Summary: A book of 1918 by Pandit Lingesh Mahabhagavat, number III in the Gaekwad Studies in Religion and Philosophy, with a Foreword and a Preface. It treats the Bhagavad-Gita as a guide in practical life. After introductory remarks on the title of the Gita, on what the Gita is, on the Yoga-sastra and on its ideal, it treats Karma-Yoga, the Yoga of action, Dhyana-Yoga, the Yoga of the mystic, Jnana-Yoga, the Yoga of knowledge, and Bhakti-Yoga, the Yoga of devotion, and ends with concluding remarks. Its notes follow each section.
Dedicated with Permission to
His Excellency the Right Honourable Lord Willingdon,
G.C.S.I., G.C.I.E., G.B.E., Governor of Bombay,
as a Token of Personal Friendship and Regard
by the Author.
Foreword
THE appearance of this work from the pen of
His Holiness, though written no doubt before his elevation to his present high and venerable position, in a language spoken of, by those whose mother-tongue it is, as the lingua franca of India, but by the contemptuous term Hoona bh*sh* by the so-called orthodox, is indeed a very notable sign of the times. It augurs most happily for the future well-being of the motherland, as showing the extremely liberal spirit which is coming to permeate even those high personages,who preside over the few wellknown centres of religion called S'S'ankaracharya Peethas ip different parts of India. Within two decades'(from now, a Swami, who was one of such heads enjoying the highest reverence at the hands of the thousands and thousands of his followers mostly in this Presidency, went the length of warning a friend of mine that any one who used English translations of Hindu scriptures, the Upanishads, etc., for the purpose of his study, was a patita or a fallen man, by reason of his resorting to books written on such subjects in other than Samskrit, the sacred language. In the light of this incident, I am sure all children of Aryavarta will agree in thinking, that the fact that one, now occupying a similar position in the hierarchy of Hindu religious teachers and guides at* the present day, has consented to the publication now of a treatise written by him, though sometime back, in the foreign tongue of the Westerns, on the greatest of Indian scriptures, the Bhagavad Geeta, marks a transition that cannot but conduce to the growth of true spirituality in the land. For, it will lead, among other things, to the recognition of the brotherhood 6f all men, including the forty millions and more of the So-called untouchables as the self-righteous castes and classes have been prone to characterise those brethren of theirs. That this view is not a piece of my imagination will be admitted if it is remembered that it was His Holiness who inspired the really remarkable movement which culminated in the All-India Anti-Untouchability Conference, held in Bombay in March last, and by bis exhortations and sympathetic letter from Delhi where he was at that time conferred on it a prestige and value that would otherwise not belong to the movement. Again, the bold appeal, made by His Holiness at a Home Rule meeting in Allahabad in a previous-month as to the duty of religious heads to come forward and work for the betterment of the people in social and civic activities also unmistakably 'points to the great change now taking place in those quarters which cannot but act profoundly on the national movement so-manifest at present.
Before leaving this preliminary matter, it may be worth calling attention to an interesting article in one of the numbers of the Samskrit journal Vidyodaya for 1897, brought to my notice by Pandit K. T. Srinivasachariar, the-able editor of the S'uddha Dharma Mandate Series, wherein, the learned writer raises a* protest against the bigotry of those who condemn writings in English on religious subjects. He opines that that language, instead of being derided, should be respected as Maha Bhasha— great language—in that it is the tongue of our rulers. He further argues for cogent reasons stated by him that, in the present circumstances-of the country, there is great necessity for making our sacred books accessible to English readers by translations and otherwise. It may be added in support of the learned writer’s argument that experience clearly establishes the' capability of this Western tongue to convey snore or lees adequately even the subtlest ideas of Samskrit philosophical and other technical terms. It stands to reason that the tongue, which the virile race of our rulers employs for manifold purposes, must and does possess a power that is great and which is getting enriched day by day as the result of the varied activities of that race all the world over.
Turning to the treatise on hand, it is scarcely necessary to say that it would be presumption on my part to enter into any criticism of the views propounded in it, even were I at all competent to undertake such a task which is not the case. I may however be permitted to remark that those views, propounded with brevity and extreme clarity, deserve the earnest attention of every student of the Geeta.
Among those views, one requires special notice, viz.) that founded on the conjunction of the phrase Yoga with such others as Sankhya, Bhakti and Karma so prominent in the scripture. Here, His Holiness touches upon what is cardinal in the Geeta, as will be seen from the edition thereof brought out by Pandit K. T. Srinivasachariar as No. 3 of the Suddha Dharma Mandate Series. The arrangement of the Scripture in that edition is essentially different from the one now in general use and which latter forms the basis XT for His Holiness’* present work. According to the former, the whole scripture, excluding certain preliminary and concluding verses is divided into four parts, each consisting of six chapters. This division rests upon the solid foundation of the ultimate analysis of human consciousness. That consciousness, so analysed, stands, as is well known, thus: (1) Jnana, (2) Iehchha, (3) Kriytt. The first may be rendered the cognising faculty of the Self in man or cognition; the second as the Self’s faculty of desire or wish which latter word apparently is derived from the same root as Ichchha; and the third as the Self’s faculty of externalising and giving effect to the other two faculties by acting upon the Not-Self or matter. The synthesis of the three constitutes that for which no better English word than consciousness is as yet forthcoming; though, having regard to what Sir John Woodroffe observes, in his recent work “Shakti and Shakta” (p. 53 et seq) in reference to the cognate term chit, consciousness is hardly a satisfactory equivalent. Now, of course, neither Jnana nor Ichchha nor Kriya should be looked on as separate component parts capable of being tied up in water-tight compartments. They are but different aspects, •each with a dominant note, of the one indivisible whole, namely, consciousness. Again, those three aspects are but reflections, in man, of the* Divine attributes chit, -ananda, and sat respectively, which in common use are referred to in a different order for obvious reasons, unnecessary to explain here. Coming back to the Suddha Dharma Mandala edition, the quadruple division referred to follows the said order and consequently the four sections are known as the Jnana, Ichchha, Kriya and the Samahara or Yoga Shatkas respectively. That this and this alone is in the fullest accord with the whole end and aim of the scripture it is impossible to doubt. For, this scripture is par excellence Yoga Shastra from the beginning to the end. No wonder therefore that in rearranging the work and making 18 chapters out of it, he, who introduced this method, found it necessary to coin such compounds as Sankhya Yoga, Bhakti Yoga, Karma Yoga and the rest. There can he no question that the division into three Shatkas was later in time than the one of four divisions. Each has its appropriate reason as GobMla, the author of a most remarkable Karika on the' Mahabharata, conclusively shows in (he extract from bis said work quoted by me in the footnote at pp. 84-37 of my Foreword to the Suddha Dharma Mandalu edition referred to above.
Were I to add nothing to what I have said so far, I feel I would not be expressing sufficiently my sense of the favour, shown to me in asking to write this Foreword. In order to discharge more fully my obligation in the matter, I avail myself of this opportunity to offer some observations from a point of view, not perhaps the least, the Geeta admits of being regarded from.
In taking such a point of view of this scripture for consideration, I am prompted solely by the feeling that if this aspect of it comes to be altogether ignored by any considerable body of students, the loss to the thinking world in general and to the mystic world in particular will be great. One more word by way of preface to what I shall presently say. And it is that in the course of what follows, I make certain, assumptions-as to the goal of human progress; as to the possible developments of human faculties and powers; and as to the existence of spiritual teachers possessed of superhuman wisdom and knowledge. All this may seem incredible to some and perhaps even to many\ and I may thereby expose myself at their hands to the criticism that I am in regard to those assumptions a victim to unwarranted beliefs, to put it mildly. This is however inevitable in b dealing with an ancient sacred book which avowedly devotes itself to the exposition of how to realise Brahman, that One Changeless Reality, from which, as the Upanishads say, mind and speech return unable to attain to It. All the more so, if my present task is to be performed without detracting in any way from the reverence due to the scripture dealing with the highest theme that can occupy one’s attention and in tune with the absolutely spiritual tone which pervades every line of it, expounding as it does the science described in one of its verses as the kingly science, most pure, righteous, easy to follow, capable of leading to direct experience, and productive of imperishable results. These words are no doubt scoffed at by the unfortunate materialist as an empty boast; but they are words that bring hope and joy to the man of faith, humility and intuition, the value of which last faculty is now being dinned into the ear of the west by some of her own great sons, Bergson, for example. /
Now taking up the point of view to be considered, it is that the Geeta is an occult work or writing. By the term occult writing is to be understood, of course, that it contains, hidden in it as it were, ideas and truths, the comprehension of which is just in proportion to the awakening of -the spiritual vision of the readers. Of the beginnings of such awakening, the one unmistakable evidence will consist of the unreserved recognition of the unity of life in the.infinite variety of forms in everything and everywhere, in minerals, vegetables, animals, men, devas and in the endless higher and higher states of existences throughout the cosmos, visible and invisible. I should not fail here to add that the view that the Geeta is an occult scripture is expressly testified to by two words which will be found in the verse cited a little above, namely, “Raja Guhyam—Koyal secret,f following “Raja-vidya” with which the verse begins.
A necessary consequence of the occult character of the scripture is that the teachings therein, taken in their merely literal sense, are often likely to be misunderstood and sometimes grossly misused. I cannot better illustrate this observation than with reference to the first out of the four maxims, which form the introduction to a similar occult priceless little book called •“Light on the Path” published more than thirty years ago in London. The maxims run: “(1) Before the rfyes can see they must be incapable of tears. (2) Before the'ear can hear, it must have lost its sensitiveness. (3) Before the voice can speak in the presence of the Masters,, it must have lost its power to wound. (4) Before the soul can stand in the presence of the Masters*
its feet must be washed in the blood of the heart.” These statements are descriptions of four of the indispensable qualifications of an aspirant' who is seeking to enter the path leading to
Moksha or Nirvana or liberation and thus wishes to become a disciple of one of those Great Teachers, who are ever ready to take in hand1 and train up all who are fit for being initiated” into the mysteries of nature, of God and the soul. For, such teachers themselves proclaim r “Those who have passed through the silence* (which marks the bloom of the soul) and felt its-peace and retained its strength they long that you shall pass through it also” {Light on the- Path, notes to rule 21, page 23). The qualifications above mentioned, expressed in the fewest' words, are true sight, true hearing, true speech and true capacity to render service—not service-to the teachers themselves, for they stand in no need of such personal attention, but to the world at large, of which they are the spiritual' guardians.
Taking now the said first maxim, nothing can be simpler than it, so far as the mere words go * but, if understood literally, the aphorism will lead to disastrous conclusions. For, it would amount ■to recommending absolute hard-heartedness, lack of sympathy and compassion. But, such an.attitude on the part of the aspirant cannot but*
on the very face of it, be an obstacle to his ardently wished for spiritual growth and not a help. To be incapable of tears with reference to the sufferings of another is the method by which the dark path is to be trodden. It is the;path of which one by-product, familiar to us all, is the Prussian super-man, who is now vigorously endeavouring to uproot all civilization. The -development of the man, treading this dark path is by contraction, leading finally to that terrible state of isolation called avichi; than which no greater calamity can befall a human Ego. What •then is the sense in which the man wishing to tread the White Path—the Path to Nirvana—is to be incapable of tears? The answer is he -should be completely above being moved even in the slightest degree by untoward happenings to himself and which would cause anguish, sorrow and mental suffering, if he were an ordinary man of the world. This is not all His soul has to become **as the ripe mango fruit as soft and sweet as its bright golden pulp for others’ woes” on the one hand, and on the other as hard '‘as that fruit’s stone for his own throes and sorrows.” Of course, this habit of keeping under complete check, man’s emotional5 nature in one particular direction while at the-same time, that nature is sustained fully alive and keen, is not easily acquired. But he, who-aspires to tread the path to the most exalted Goal before him, cannot but assiduously strive for the formation of such a faculty. Because, it is to be remembered his growth is to be by expansion of his whole nature, of his desires-and emotions, of his knowledge and the power to serve. It is when all these reach their highest pitch of perfection that he can merge himself in the Divinity whose Will is at work in the particular part of the cosmos and become a co-worker with It.
To make the present discussion complete, it remains to add that there is a very marked distinction between the sympathy with the afflictions of his fellow-men felt by a disciple and that proceeding from one who has reached liberation. In the former case, the sympathy is ever attended with regret, while in the latter, it is-otherwise. The fully illuminated soul sees and knows, as none below Its level on the evolutionary ladder can see and know, that what we call afflictions are but necessary incidents in a man’s growth, and thus within the Divine scheme of his-evolution. Consequently, the regret which was occasioned in the disciple by the absence of full comprehension of that scheme, finds no place in the mind of him, whose vision is utterly uncloud* ed and perfect. In his case, it is compassion, un-alloyed, spurring him on, to an enlightened co-operation with God’s plan by endeavours to remove that nescience, which is at the root of all the errors of the yet-developing humanity. It is not until this final stage—that of Nirvana— is reached that the regret which accompanies a disciple’s sympathy can altogether cease, though such regret will continue to diminish at each of the four great stages of the progress of the human Ego. Those stages, needless to add, are Parivrajaka, Kuteechaka, Hamsa and Parama-Hamsa, in terms of Hindu nomenclature with the corresponding Buddhistic names Shrottapatti, Sakridagamin, Anagamin and Arhat. When the four true great initiations, marking the above stages have been undergone, and the Ego attains to the superhuman fifth stage, that of the Tureeyateeta, he becomes an Asekha, (i.e.,) one who has nothing more to learn in the world system to which he belongs. It may not be out of place to point out that at the said initiations, the fortunate Ego concerned is given certain “Keys to Knowledge” and “words of power” which, among other things, enable him to progress along the path to liberation he is treading-—a path as narrow and sharp as a razor, as the Upanishad expresses it. In all this, there is no question of favour. The wonderful expansion of consciousness and soul purification, which the Ego has been able to effect by strenuous efforts birth after birth, entitle him to those keys and words as a matter of simple justice. This is never withheld from him even for a minute after it is due. Neither arbitrariness nor partiality of any sort nor delay is possible in things of such high moment to humanity, governed, as they are, by laws administered by the all wise and merciful Hierarchy, consisting of Manu, Vyasa and other less known Adhikara Purushas, under the guidance of that Mighty Being who is the spiritual King and Lord of our globe. Many are His names in the sacred books. For example, in the Mahabharata He is almost uniformly spoken of as Narayana. In the Chandogya Upanishad text beginning with the words ahnra Suddhow, His titles are Sanat-kumara and Skanda. And the words therein Tamasahparam Bars'ayati (shows the light beyond the darkness) amply justify the very apt name applied to Him in some modern English writings, namely the One Initiator.
It will be seen from what I have been explaining above that the aphorism I have commented on, though extremely simple at first sight, requires much diving into, if misconception is to be avoided. And it follows that many of the teachings of the Geeta, owing to their occult nature, stand in need of like effort on the part of the student, if their true import is to be understood.
Now, in passing, it is hardly necessary to remark that, in the hands of those, in whom there is no real yearning for spiritual growth and whose minds are not mature enough to grasp the deep significance of the teachings, the Geeta could serve no useful purpose whatever. In some few cases of this description, unmixed evil may result from some of the precepts being understood literally, as for instance, in the case of the misguided youths who have been made to believe that the injunction w O, Arjuna, fight” which occurs so often in the course of the scripture, sanctions the perpetration of the political crimes they are guilty of as part of the plot to overthrow the British Raj. How can these unwary youths be expected to realise that the battle to be fought is not as against intimate friends and near relatives as the words on their face suggest but those emotions of men, personified as such in the narrative-at the commencement of the book—emotions-which are hindrances to spiritual progress, namely, raga, dvesha, lobha, moha, mada, tnataarya and so on which have been nurtured for ages through countless births and re-births. The case of these unfortunate youths forms another illustration of the wisdom of the saying “Throw not pearls before swine.” What I have thus tried to indicate and much more,, would be found emphatically stated in the verse which lays down to what classes of persons the Geeta should not be taught. Turning now to the case of those who are more or less fit to enter upon the study of the scripture, it should be borne in mind that some of the most important precepts admit of more than one interpretation, each being legitimate from its own point of view. In support of this position, let me take for example, that crucial word which is so conspicuous in if throughout, namely, Yoga. No doubt in one view, and indeed a very essential one, it is that Samatvam which is the perfect equipoised condition which gives the man a complete mastery not only over his thoughts, emotions and activities, but also invests him with an unlimited capacity for and power of utterly selfless service.
This is certainly a consummation to be devoutly wished. But is that all the term under discussion connotes and was rpeant to connote? Is-there not a far more glorious Samatvam, necessarily implied by the word Samadhi, which is the very end and aim of all Yoga according to the very highest authorities? The answer to this-question must emphatically be in the affirmative. To hold otherwise would be tantamount to saying that the Geeta, a veritable Upanishad itself, is in this respect in direct conflict with the whole trend of Hindu sacred literature. Now, the equipoised condition, just above mentioned,, has reference to what is known as the jagrat avastha, i.e., in words intelligible to us all, the state of our waking or the ordinary brain consciousness. The existence, however, of other states of consciousness cannot be denied even by the most sceptical; as for instance,- the dream condition and that of deep undisturbed sleep svapna and sushupti known to everyone. Into the question of what the real facts of these states are, it is unnecessary to enter here. What however is relevant in the present connection is that Tureeya1 or the fourth state which is universally asserted by Hindu writers •to be the summum bonum. Nowhere is this state more accurately and tersely described than in 4hose well-known passages of the Mandukys Upanishad which begin with the words Nantakprajnam and end with sa vijneyah. In this matchless description of the subject, the S'ruti first negates that the avastha in question is any of the conditions of consciousness within the experience of ordinary men. Next, it points out that that state is incapable of being perceived by any of our senses. And it winds up with the following affirmative explanations: Ekatmadition of matter forming interpenetrating spheres in space. For example, Jagrat consciousness, has Sthula or dense matter for its field of expression; Svapna consciousness has Sulcshma or subtle matter; SusTiupti consciousness has Kd/rana or causal matter; and Tureeya consciousness has eupra-causal matter. Each plane of matter consists of four sub-divisions; of which, the types are what we know as solid, liquid, gas and ether. And consciousness peculiar to each plane has sub-modes of expression too (c.g,, Jagrat-
Jagrat; Jagrat-Svapna; Jagrat-Sushupti; Jagrat- Turttya. On the same analogy, vale, speech or sound is divided into par3—subtlest; pasyanti—less subtle; madh-yamd—still lees subtle; and vaxkhari—dense or gross. This quadruple division has its foundation in the triune aspect of Divinity, Sat, Gita, Ananda or the ‘Good, the True,.and the Beautiful’ of Plato. Here as in other instance* the sacred syllable Pranava is the symbol with its three pratyayasaram—the essence, the fount of all the-individual Selves; prapanchdpas amarn—wherein the three lower states—-jagrat, svapna and sushupti —merge and cease; santam—peace; s'ivam— where the creative preservative and disintegrating or reabsorbing forces worketh not; bliss -r advaitam—non-duality. By way of refuting the possible objection, such a state is non-existent or unknowable, the Sruti affirms, “It is the Self,. It is knowable and ought to be known— sa atma sa vijneyaha." The fact that the term Atma is in the Geeta, as well as in every other Hindu sacred book, synonymous with the all-important part of Brahman, when viewed in matras or measures and the ardhamatra or the dot over the written letter O. In spite of all such classifications, it is needless to say, states of consciousness and corresponding planes of matter are infinite in their gradations in the cosmos. The main divisions are but those with characteristics greatly and deeply well-marked and unmistakably distinguishable from each other. There is a seven-fold division, peculiar to our world system and not universal. The names of these special forms of consciousness are: Jagrat, svapna, sushupti, turseya, nirvanic, para-nirvanio, and mahapara-nirvanic with corresponding lokas or re* gions. The understanding of the facts of Nature, enumerated above, cannot but be useful to one who is intent upon self-study. For, his bodies, visible and invisible, make up a microcosm governed by the same rules and laws as the great cosmos outside him ■its divided form of Atma, Prakriti and Shakti,
must necessarily warrant the conclusion that the Tureeya state was recognised as completely by the Geeta as by the other scriptures of the highest authority. Nor is this Tureeya state a matter of Hindu teaching alone. It is the
Buddhistic Nirvana, misunderstood as utter extinction, but which is rest in Omniscience, as it has been felicitously phrased. It is the state wherein, as Christian writers would express it, the Peace that passeth the understanding abides.
The attainment of complete experience of this ineffable state is necessarily the work of ages for a human soul. But the beginnings thereof take place during the first of the great Initiations..Thenceforward conscious functioning becomes 'possible in Janaloka composed of the matter of the Vayu plane infinitely finer than that of •this dense earth. Those beginnings are described an Light on the Path from which the following few eloquent sentences are worth citing: “Then will come a calm such as comes in a tropical country after the heavy rain, when nature works so swiftly that one may see her action. Such a calm will come to the harassed spirit. And in the deep silence, the mysterious event will occur which will prove that the way has been found. Call it by what name you will, it is a voice that ■speaks where there is none to speak—it is a messenger that comes, a messenger without form or substance; or it is the flower of the soul that has opened. It cannot be described by any metaphor. But it can be felt after, looked for, and desired, even amid the raging of the storm. The silence may last a moment of time or it may last a thousand years. But it will end. Yet you will carry its strength with you. Again and again, the battle must be fought and won *' (pp. 21—23). Surely it is this final state that is reached in Samadhi which is the ultimate aim of Yoga according to all authorities. Hence, in this highest Samadhi, comprehended by the term Yoga there lies the deepest layer of the “heart of the •Geeta” to be probed and penetrated by him, who has the requisite spiritual faculty to fathom it.
In justice to the view I have ventured to put forward above, it is necessary that I should refer to one more instance supporting it, that instance however being not transcendental as the one •explained in the last paragraph. I would here invite the reader’s attention to the wellknown verse with which the dialogue concludes according to the recension, now almost universally in use. The two most important words in the verse are “mam” and “aham” Now one set of students will take both to refer to Shri Krishna, the Avatar. From their point of view, as aspirants who stand in need of a personal God to lean upon, the Avatara will’
necessarily appeal to them as what the terms stand for. But other students, who have risen above such a need and to whom, Only that which is impersonal and philosophically worthy of acceptance would appeal, must seek a different explanation of the terms. And they will find it in the incontestably right interpretation offered,, for example, in the remarkable commentary called Hamsa Yogi’s Bhashya not much known as yet but which, I hope, circumstances permitting, to get published before long. According to this illuminating commentary, “m£m” signifies that aspect of Brahman spoken of in the Geeta as Daivi prakriti, para,.prakriti, identified with the Holy Ghost of the Christian Trinity, as for instance in Swami T. Subba Row’s learned discourses on the Geeta, delivered so far back as 1886. This Daivi Prakriti is the same as the Nirupadhikam Mahachaitanyam of some of the Hindu scriptures. Infinite becoming supreme potency Bahu Bhayana Maha Sakti is one of its many apt names. The aptest of them are those used during the daily twilight prayers of the Aryan, viz., Savitri —-the World-mother; Sarasvati—the Fountainhead of Wisdom and Knowledge; Gaydtri—the Redeemer and Saviour. In short it is the One or Cosmic Life, animating all manifested existence, as indicated by the Geeta words, “Jiva bhutam mahabaho yay'edam, dharyate jagat." The purport of this part of the teaching in question, in so far as the more developed student is concerned, is that utter freedom from the heresy of separateness coupled with complete devotion2- to the Mahachaitanyam is' the way to the one Supreme Self, the atma aspect of Parabrahman Karma Yoga where it is pointed out that the aspirant who so strives reaches the supreme. The true significance of the important term Karma Yoga will be missed unless it is taken as the utilisation of all the aspirants’ faculties of Ichcha, Guana and Kriya so as to be productive of a harmonious result. It is the co-ordination of his feeling, thought and action towards helping to turn the Samsara Chakra or the evolutionary wheel, at which Ishwara is ever engaged, though He has nothing to gain by it that would constitute the practice ot Karma Yoga of the highest order.
such Yoga on the aspirant’s part, incarnation after incarnation, makes the individual life of the Yogi an integral part of the Cosmic or the One Life mam and which is no other than the manifest or energising aspect of the Supreme Self, the Aham, in the verse. Hence the emphatic declaration in another part of the Geeta “after many many births the man of wisdom enters (add Sanskrit)” Such an one becomes the possessor of wisdom by reason of his having realised that ■“all is the 8elf"—Vff8ude?as-sarvamiti.” In this context,3 connoted by the other term “aham.*' That the same doctrine is the one accepted in all true occult schools of India at least, an earnest enquirer can satisfy himself. By way of one example* reference may be made to the Prayer to be mentally offered on rising in the early morning by an aspirant undergoing the discipline in vogue among the members of the Suddha Dharma Mandala. It runs “Abhedanandam, Sat ChitramParam Brahma Veda Saha yo Avyayatma Samachitta Rangah, Daiveem Kalyana Shaktim Prapadya Sarvam Pravisati Amritoham, Ajaroham Lokebhyas Sukham Edhatetm.” Next as to the term “aham,” as already observed, it connotes for the advanced student the Paramatman, the One Self in all the cosmos and in particular residing.in every human heart. This interpretation is unquestionably warranted by what appears in many other verses of the scripture. Suffice to refer to the verse commencing with the words “Aham Atma. Gudakesa” and in which the term under consideration is explained to be the One Universal Self. It is this interpretation alone that could lead to the final truth that a man’s salvation is to be sought from the Divinity within himself and not from any external source whatsoever. That final truth is nowhere more impressively expressed than in a passage in the beautiful little book, called “Idyll of the "White Lotus,” emanating from the same source,, that gave Light on the Path to the English speaking public. In a speech purporting to be addressed by the spiritual Teacher who took part in the initiation of an advancing soul, the former said “Hear me, my brother, there are three truths which are absolute, and which cannot be lost, but yet may remain silent for lack of speech. The soul of man is immortal and its future is the future of a thing whose growth and splendour has no limit. The Principle which gives life dwells in us, and without us, is undying and eternally beneficent, is not heard or seen or smelt but is perceived by the man who desires perception. Each man is his own absolute law-giver, the dispenser of glory or gloom to himself; the decreer of his life, his reward, his punishment. These truths, which are as great as is life itself, are as simple as the simplest mind of man. Feed the hungry with them. Farewell.” (Pp. 188-184).
I trust it will be conceded on all hands that the statement with which I started the present part of the discussion to the effect that important terms in the Geeta comprehend and are intended to comprehend ideas widely differing from each other though connected by some circumstance common to them, is absolutely well-founded.
It now remains to advert to two things calculated to be helpful in a fruitful study of the scripture. As to the first of them, the one comparatively less important, that has reference to the real source of the teachings imparted in. the book. In this connection, certain material statements occurring in the Geeta or in other places in the Mahabharata, have to be taken into consideration and read between the lines, as intuitive students should always read such passages. For, statements of such description are often allegorical, or by way of parables and rarely direct matter of fact presentations of the truths intended to be conveyed. The statements to be considered are—•
(1) Sanjaya’s saying that through the grace of Vyasa, he was enabled to hear the actual delivery of the discourse by Shri Krishna.
(2) That Shri Krishna and Arjuna were no other than Narayana and Nara, the mighty Rishis ever engaged in Tapas in Badari, intent upon the welfare of the world. *
(3) That the substance of the discourse was no more than primeval teachings to humanity.
(4) That the discourse took place on the evo of what has come to be spoken of as the Kali. age. Putting these various statements together,, the student cannot but draw the following conclusions:—
(1) That the discourse, stripped of its dramatic garb, was an inspired message from the Spiritual King of our Globe, Narayana to Nara or the humanity under bis charge.
(2) That this message was called forth by the cyclic change taking place at the time when it was vouchsafed.
(3) That, that time was about the beginning of the colonisation of India by the branch of the Aryan race which came to it from their original home-in Central Asia in the neighbourhood of the sacred Shamballa, sanctified by the holy presence in it of
Narayana, though in a form invisible to mortal eyes.
If the student will bear the above facts in mind, and meditate, as a preliminary to the commencement of his study for the day, upon the mighty source from which the scripture has emanated, he will necessarily put himself en rapport with that source and will receive such inspiration as the intensity of his aspirations and hia purity entitle him to at the ever-merciful hands of the Spiritual Hierarchy, watching over our humanity. The programme for this preliminary step will be found well described in the verses, constituting*the Gita-Parayana-krama* printed at page 2 of the Suddha Dharma Mandala edition.
♦ According to the Parayanakrama referred to in the text, the student may notice that salutations have to be offered not only to Narayana and Nara and Krishna and Arjuna, but also to certain Hamsas. He may like to know who these Hamsas are. The point is worth briefly explaining, as it is one which throws light upon the general question of the origin of such scriptures as Brah-manas, Upanishads, liihasas, Puranas, etc.
The derivation of Hamsa, as pointed out in Yoga Deepika No. 2 of the Suddha Dharma Mandala series, is:1 Ha, is Ahankara or the I-concept; ‘Ma 9 is the supreme Brahman; * Sa 9 stands for the science and art which teach that all see in all things the Eternal Self of the very nature of Parabrahman and the root of every thing. In Dharma Deepika No. 4 of the said series, there are observations suggesting that, like the swan in the fable which has the faculty of separating the milk from the water, Hamsas bring out the true teachings hidden in the allegories, myths and the like, of which Hindu scriptures are so fall. There is a statement in the Mahabharata to the effect that the
Birthless One, in the form of a swan, taught Sadhyas the science and art of Brahman and established the office of Hamsa, charging those filling the office with the duty of imparting sacred instruction to the world. It will thus appear that Hamsas are members of the spiritual Hierarchy, whose functions are to supply the needs humanity in relation to the sacred science and Lastly as to the second and remaining helpful point; it consists in a firm resolve to live up Uy the teachings, and a persistent endeavour to carry them out so far as possible. Every effort to do so will not only throw light upon them but also go to show their value and utility, as bearing upon the whole life of an aspirant. Take, all knowledge in general, according to the exigencies of each age, race and the then conditions. the exact processes, by which they supply those needs, are matters upon which little is to be gathered from the scriptures accessible to us. It seems certain that Brahmanas, Upanishads, Itihasas, Puranas, etc., as we possess them, owe their origin to the inspiration of these Hamsas and that accounts for the name * Sruti’—Heard,— applied par excellence to the two former classes of Hindu scriptures. Presumably, the actual recording of what is inspired by those custodians of knowledge, is done by men who are found by the Hierarchy to be fit instruments and channels for the transmission of the instalments of knowledge, considered as needed for the time being. The persons chosen for the task, as might easily be judged, are necessarily more or less advanced souls, willing to be the channels of the Hierarchy under assumed names and to work unknown in the midst of those with whom their work lies. In some instances, such records have the name Hamsa itself applied to them, as for example, the commentary on the Geeta and numerous other works under the generic name of 4 Khandarahasya \
In these circumstances, it is not surprising that the labours of orientalists and scholars have been productive of for instance, the advice to look upon praise and blame with equal indifference, TulyanindQstuti, an advice identical in sense with the aphorism quoted frrm Light on the Path, “Before the ear can hear it must have lost its sensi-tiveness.” Any one who has meditated upon this advice and tried not to be disturbed or upset by idle gossip or malicious slanders about himself will know how free he feels from the torments he used to suffer, previously, from small results, if any, with reference to the question of the actual authorship of Hindu scriptures and their chronology, etc.
In concluding this note, attention may be invited to those very instructive passages (quoted at pp. 31-32 of my Foreword to Yoga Deepika) from Dharma Deepika regarding the genesis of the Vedic chants, spoken of as Mantras of which Brahmanas and Upanishads are explanations proceeding from the Hamsas as already stated. These Mantras themselves are held to be revelations because they are the results of the deciphering by Eisbis spoken of as Mantra Drashtdrah or Seers of Mantras. What are thus deciphered are so from the bulk of the immemorial records of all ages and climes enshrined as Dharma Deepika expresses it, in Akasic plates (Akasa phalakay). It is portions of what are thus deciphered which are banded down by Hierarchs of the highest rank, who go by the name of Vyftsas—Arrangers—to races of mankind whose special needs they are calculated to serve and are accepted under the title of Veda.
Hence, in point of authority, Mantras stand first, Srutis next, Itihasas and Puranas last; an orderly succession perfectly intelligible to all who care to try and understand such things.— such things said of him. As time goes on, he-will also find that the elation, which praise brought him, affects him no longer, he having arrived at the unalterable conviction that what really matters is not the opinion of others-about him, but the intrinsic worth of his own thoughts, words, and deeds. In short, the Geeta-is a book not, in the words of Bacon, to be merely tasted, or to be swallowed, or even to be chewed and digested but is the teaching of the Lord, whose golden precepts must be lived, verily lived.
To conclude, if this great scripture is approached by an aspirant to spiritual progress on the lines which I have humbly endeavoured to indicate, it cannot but be productive of the most beneficial results not only to the people of this country whose special inheritance it is, but also to those others who are likely to be brought into touch with it, by treatises like the one coming from the erudite pen of His Holiness. I close with saying that I esteem it an honour to have been allowed to contribute this Foreword and am most thankful for the kind consideration thus shown to me.
S. Subrahmanya Aiyar.
16th October, 1918.
1 This classification of consciousness, into four states,, has itl origin in a universal principle. Bach of these •tales finds expression in a corresponding plane or oon-
2 The statement “renouncing all dharmas surrender unto mam alone” is one requiring much explanation. Though that cannot be attempted here, a few words are necessary to guard against serious misconception on the point. The devotion contemplated by the verse is, of course, not mere: religious worship with or without rites. It is complete dedication of the whole life of the aspirant towards carrying out as far as it lies in him, the Divine Will, which is expressing itself in the evolutionary processes at work before his own eyes. The dedication necessarily involves the aspirants ceasing to be a mere pawn on a chess board as it i were moved about hither and thither by his selfish or self-centred motives. He must become a conscious coworker with that Divine Will by strenuous performance of every duty small or great devolving on him for the moment with reference to his fellow-men and the world at large. Such discharge of duty must be for the sake of the duty itself regardless of any supposed meritoriousness in the matter. This systematic and one pointed regulation of bis life directed solely towards the furtherance of God’s plan and acting without desire for the fruit will necessarily make the aspirant a willing participator in the Divine work. This is fully developed in the verses in the scripture on e
3 Vasudeva’ is but a synonymn for Atma, the Self, as i0 made to appear by the Lord’s statement “jnanee atmaiva mgmatam—my doctrine and teaching is the wise man is verily the Self. The union of the individual life with the One Life puts an end to the false notion of duality or the heresy of separateness the source of all delusions. The total cessation of that heresy results in the long longed for mOksha or liberation in fulfilment of the final promise in the Geeta u the aham or the Self will release you from all delusions, grieve not—aham tvam sarva papebhyo moksha yishyami masuchah.
Preface
PERIODS of catastrophe appear to be almost necessary at the present level of mankind to awaken men from a stagnant conservatism' in which they continue mechanically to follow their predecessors without conscious recognition-of what they aim at or should aim at finally. The situation in the West, arrived at through' ideals of national competition, dynasties and militarism, has aroused men throughout the world to a more serious and independent consideration of the meaning of life than at any time since-the Renaissance of Learning. So again, in spite of a lip service to the excellence and superiority' of its ancient wisdom, the East has imbibed too much of the scientific and critical methods of the West and caught too much its spirit of optimistic activity to feel that the traditional-expression of its philosophies of life will still suffice. The actual situation in the West is-sufficient proof that there are serious defects in its mode of life, and thus of the theories and ideals upon which it is based. The East cannot simply follow its own past, and it cannot be condemned for wishing to avoid the calamities which Western ideals have brought. All books -of a practical religious and moral character must, therefore, in our day, be tested by the help that they give in relation to these pressing problems.
The Bhagavadgita is concerned with questions so intimate and so persistent in the life of man that any honestly written book inspired by this Divine Lay may expect to find real appreciation in wide circles, especially of the Indian peoples. The Heart of the Bhagavadgita has a definitely practical aim in view: it discusses carefully the question as to the value of the Gita as a guide in practical life. The author is well-known to the Indian public as a most enlightened head of one of the monastic institutions associated with the name of the great monistic philosopher, S'ankaracharya. To Western readers he may be introduced as the first man in such a position to give to the world his reflections on this and many other subjects in a language in which they might be read in East and West. A genuine-scholar, he is also the advocate of a modern expression of the truths of Hinduism. He is an incessant worker for a multiplicity of worthy causes having the welfare of India in view- The soundness of his judgment is seen by his deliberate abstention from discussions of doubtful value in the present work and the concentration of the reader’s attention upon the practical teachings of the Gita. Western thinkers should read with interest the rule—or rather rules—of life which in a survey of an old and beloved Song, a modern Hindu proposes to a world in uncertainty as to that which belongs to its peace.
The ideal taught in this book has been recognised by all the great religions in one way or another. The expression given to it in English is “equanimity,” “evenness of mind.” Many attempts have been made by Western critics to interpret this in that sense of indifference for which nothing is worth while, or all is equally useless. It is not my intention to enquire whether or not there are good grounds for this position. What is more important is to note that the author in his teaching as in his active pursuit of worthy aims, is against such an interpretation. The hope may be expressed that Dr. Macnicol belongs to a type which is passing away, when he misrepresents the Hindu Ideal of a Holy 5Life as very largely one of a degrading indifference.* The peace of mind referred to is real; it is by nature similar to what is meant by the Christian when he talks of “that peace which the world cannot give.” It is quite another question whether Hindu thought is explicitly aware of what in Christian thought is called “Grace.” Nevertheless, in the recognition of Bhakti or devotion is an opening for the acknowledgment of that personal relationship to Jesus which is central for Christians. The correct name of the religion of Muslims is Islam, the meaning of which again •suggests peace and calm. Though the manner in which peace is supposed to come is different, through confidence and trust in submission to Allah, the thing aimed at and realised is essen-.
• See The Expositor: July 1918 tially the same. • And what is the Nirvana of the Buddhist but the state of equanimity of.mind which comes with the transcendence of the anxiety of unsatisfied desire? These and other religions contain much more than such peace and calm; but in the times in which we live equanimity is an aspect of the ideal needing to be emphasised perhaps more than any other.
That this evenness of mind is not to be interpreted as a spirit of indifference, may easily be seen from the methods by which it is to be attained. In this connection it is worthy of note that The Heart of the Bhagavadgita breathes the same broad spirit as the work around which it is written. During the course of history, and none-the-less in recent years, frequent attempts have been made to present the teaching of the •Gita in a one-sided fashion, usually in support of the special predilection of the writer. Whatever may eventually be the general verdict of scholars, here it is clear that for his definite purpose the author maintains a comprehensive and a psychological attitude: in varying degrees every man needs to make use of all the means* though for some men one path and for others other paths will lead most surely to redemption and peace. The insistence on this general type of interpretation, to the abandonment of a particularistic one, is in accordance with the tendency of modern thought in East and West.
The rendering of each of the different forms of Yoga manifests a similar width of conception. Thus, the action which is implied in Karma- Yoga is not taken, as some Western critics would like to represent it as always taken, as just the external acts, the rites and rituals of religion, and the duties of caste. Either action is to be as “unattached” to caste as to anything else. Salvation is to be found by the performance of any or all possible good actions, whenever and wherever they are possible. If the peoples of the West need to learn to appreciate more the meaning of “equanimity,” to subdue their feverish haste with a little more evenness of mind,, the people of India need to learn more deeply to understand and to apply in actual life the doctrine of non-attachment, and of Karma- Yoga in the widest sense. Only thus will the depressing fact be overcome that so many Indians will do just what the actual requirements of their vocation demand,—and nothing else, unless the State or whoever else may be concerned, “makes it worth while.” As I understand it the miserable discontent which exists so frequently in India is due very largely to the failure to recognise the equanimity, the salvation, which comes with a genuine understanding of Karma-Yoga and the doctrine of non-attachment.
Some few remarks are also needed with relation to the path of knowledge. Anyone who has seriously followed this path, even for a short period, will have experienced that freedom from care and that broadening of the outlook which come in concentrated study. There is no subject of intellectual enquiry which, with a modem interpretation, should not lead to Jnana-Yoga- The first reward of the search for knowledge is the search itself. Knowledge ought not to be conceived merely as concerned with the ultimate* the philosophy of the Absolute, or something thus metaphysical. The modern mind—as indeed, the human mind in all ages—recognises d that the world of Maya, or whatever one may call it, deserves and demands consideration, and further, that in the pursuit of the knowledge of it some of the greatest human personalities have been developed and some of the most peaceful and happy moments of even ordinary individuals are found. Again the situation in this regard in India leaves much to be desired. Engaged as we are in this direction ourselves, the almost general neglect of research amongst the very numerous body of College professors and graduates is continually impressed upon us. A widespread repetition of a statement, that the ancient rishis were omniscient, and that all necessary knowledge can be found in the ancient books, serves as a cover for those who will not take the trouble to enquire into the accuracy of the claim. Offer a high salary and many will present themselves as qualified and as yearning to carry on research—in almost any subject one may like to suggest. Here, there is a great need for an appreciation of the salvation which comes through “knowledge for its own sake,” for a genuine understanding of Jnana- Yoga and the doctrine of non-attachment.
The main aim of The Heart of the Bhagavad-gita may be considered almost entirely apart from any particular philosophical principles. The test of a practical aim must be the extent of the possibility of its achievement in practice. Yet to keep all questions of an ultimate metaphysical nature in the background is, after all, impossible even in the most practical of religious treatises. It would seem that it is in relation to the path of devotion that the importance of these principles is mostly felt, for there comes into discussion the question as to what is an adequate Object for human adoration and love. And immediately the answer is given that God alone is an adequate Object, the inevitable problem of His nature arises. This problem cannot be pursued further here, but it becomes more and more clear that the appeal of the various religions to men will differ chiefly according to the form in which God is represented in them. In relation to these different forms the manner of expression of the devotees' love will vary. In East and West the need to follow the path of devotion more assiduously can hardly be denied. The “Christian” West may eventually find that its divisions and animosities and competition can •only be overcome by making devotion to Jesus the mainspring of a life given to unselfish action and to knowledge. And the divisions and individualism of the East may only be transcended if a genuine understanding of Bhakti-Yoga in the spirit of non-attachment be related to one recognised supreme Object of devotion in a •common worship.
To me it seems that one passes into the mystical in the highest points of realisation of the life of action, of knowledge, and especially, of devotion. Mysticism is, I believe, as such beyond the scope of thought and language, so that I can say nothing concerning Dhyana-Yoga. The mystics always refer to their experiences as the highest bliss, and for the author it is •certainly a condition of equanimity, of evenness of mind. That their experiences are real few careful students of human life will deny: the author insists in this book that these experiences only come to those who dispose themselves in & suitable mode of life. The reader will learn of this disposition from the author himself.
* * *
The Heart of the Bhagavadgita was accepted by the Oriental University of Washington, U. S. A. as a thesis for the degree of Ph. D. Its aim being so closely in accord with that of the Gaekwad Studies in Religion and Philosophy—the attempt at a modern and sympathetic consideration of religious and philosophical thought for the advancement of life—the author kindly consented to its inclusion in this Series. With the exception of the Corrigenda, the Index and this Preface the book was already printed off when it came into my hands. If another edition should be called for it may be possible to bring its form and style into uniformity with the rest of the Series. The author wishes to thank Messrs. V. Subrahmanya Aiyar, B.A. and Y- Subba Rao of Bangalore for valuable assistance and suggestions in reading over the proof-sheets.
Alban G. Widgery.
Baroda, September 1918.
Introductory Remarks
IN the whole range of the world’s literature, few books can be found which can favourably compare with ‘the Bhagavadgita’ in point of interest or of influence.1 This poem of seven hundred s'lokas embodies within its short compass as will be seen from the sequel, the best philosophy and the best religious and moral principles that Ancient India could offer to the world. The charmingly simple diction and the melody of the verses in which its loftiest teachings are clothed, make it a very fascinating study. The wonderful sequence with which the teachings are presented, the thought-stimulating phrases and clauses with which the work abounds, the popular mould in which the whole is cast, and the clearness with which the most sublime truths are propounded, make this one of-the most interesting books.
It is a significant fact that from a very remote past down to our own times, this sacred book of /ndia has continued to exercise a very wide influence on not only the ordinary but also some of the most thoughtful minds. It is no wonder that it should have a great hold on the mind of the orthodox Hindu, for there is almost no traditional Indian ideal which is not here reverently handled and allotted an exalted place worthy of it. Such of the Hindu commentators as had any literary and spiritual genius, found it hard to withstand the temptation of writing a commentary on the work. But that it should meet with the admiration and praise of the modern educated Hindus, and should have compelled the attention of the thoughtful Europeans and Americans, is a feature unparalleled in the whole history of Ancient Indian literature. Countless editions of the text see the light every year and are cordially welcomed by our countrymen. There is almost no Indian vernacular2 which has not translated it, and no article or book on religion or philosophy which does not directly or indirectly draw upon its contents. Nay more, even social and political essays and articles written by patriotic Hindus of the present times may be said to often betray a strong passion for quotations from the Gita,3 Then its influence upon the Westerns is by no means little.4 The work has been translated into English,5 Greek, Latin, Italian, French and German.6 7 The practical nature of its teachings no less than the music of its language gives it a charm to the mind of the Europeans and Americans. The unusual respect paid to it by scholars reputed for their vast learning, indefatigable literary research and philosophic acumen, excited the attention of Christian Missionaries also. Some of them struck with the similarity of many of its teachings with those of the New Testament, have tried to prove that the Gita has borrowed its best ideas from the Bible.8 Thus the book has received different treatment at different hands. The orthodox Hindu considers it a revelation and tries to follow its teachings, the modern educated Hindu commends it, the European scholar admires it, while the Missionary tries to explain it away in any manner that suits his purpose.
That this little book, the very time and authorship of whose composition is yet a matter of great difference of opinion among Scholars,9 should be thus filled with unusual interest for men of different times and countries and of* varying mental calibre, and that its influence on some of the most enlightened modern minds should be of such great magnitude, is a sufficient ground for any reflecting person to pause and ask himself, “What is the value of the Gita as a guide to practical life?”
In the following pages an attempt will be made to answer this important question. Other phases of the study of the book will be subordinated to this main point, and will be dealt with only in so far as they affect it. No special research is claimed for the ideas here presented and no special school of philosophy is sought to be supported. No paragraph here will be devoted to establish or to refute the genuineness and historicity of the author, the hero and the incidents related in the book. No discussion will find a place herein which consider** the vocabulary, the age and literary value, tho inspired nature, the number of followers, the character, social position, or fame of the speaker or author of the Gita. It is not meant hete that such considerations are utterly useless. They may have their own value to the philologist, to the historian or to the theologian. But to find an answer to the question proposed above, such enquiry is obviously quite unnecessary. We are only concerned here with the simple question whether the Gita has any practical wisdom to teach, whether its philosophy or theology can offer any practical method of self-culture. The book has therefore to be studied not from the too credulous orthodox, nor from the all-admiring patriotic standpoint, much less from the fault-finding view of critics. We have to approach the book much in the same manner as ■we would a treatise on Chemistry. Just as we would verify the truths of the one by means of experiments, we should verify those of the other by an appeal to reason and experience. If reason vouchsafes the truths and if conscience approves of the ethics, we shall accept them and not otherwise.
1 Cf. “la the whole literature of the world there am few poems worthy of comparison, either in point of general interest, or of practical influence, with the Bhagavadgita. It is a philosophical work, yet fresh and readable as poetry* etc.” (Oh. I, Gita and Gospel by Rev. J. N. Farquhar, m.a.* Formerly Exhibitioner, Christ Church, Oxford).
2 “Such is the estimation in which the work is held both in Asia and Europe, that it has been translated into Hindi, Telugu, Kanarese, and other Eastern languages, and is also well-known by European translations, of which that of Sir C. Wilkins, published in London in 1785, was the first, 99 Footnote to p. 124. “Indian Wisdom,” by Sir Monier Williams.
3 “This revival of interest in Krishna and his worship is clearly part of the great national movement which has been so potent in Bengal religiously, socially and politically these last twenty years.” Appendix to Gita and Gospel, by Bev. J. N. Farquhar, m.a,
4 “The poem has also received a great deal of attention and admiring recognition from Europeans.99 Appendix to Gita and Gospel.
5 “It was the first piece of Sanskrit literature ever translated into English. This translation was by Charles Wilkins, and appeared as early as 1785, under the title of The Song of the Adorable One. Since then it has been frequently brought before the English public,” etc. Gita and Gospel, Ch, I.
6 Among the principal translations in European languages other than English maybe mentioned the Greek version of Galanos, the Latin version of Lassen, the Italian version of Stanisallo Gatti, the French version of Burnouf and the German version of Dr. Lorinser*
7 “The lofty sublimity to which it so often rises the practical character of much of its teaching, the enthusiastic devotion to the one Lord which breathes through it and the numerous resemblances it shows to the words of Christ, fill it with unusual interest for men of the West.” Gita and Gospel, Oh, I,
8 Sir Monier Williams hesitates “to concur in any theory (such as the one proposed by Dr. Lorinser, Prof. Weber and others) which explains these coincidences by supposing that the author had access to the New Testament or that he derived some of his ideas from the first propagators of Christianity.” He quotes the Rev. F. W. Farrar who in his interesting and valuable work * Seekers after God* points out “that the attempts of the Christian Fathers to make out Pythagoras a debtor to Hebraic wisdom, Plato an Atticizing Moses, Aristotle a picker up of ethics from a Jew, Seneca a correspondent of St. Paul, were due ‘in some cases to ignorance, and in some to a want of perfect honesty in controversial dealing/” and concludes that “his (Rev. Farrar’s) arguments would be even more conclusive if applied to the Bhagavadgita.” Vide p. 142, Indian Wisdom. Also see “Dr. Lorinser’s attempt (Die Bhagavadgita, uberseta and erlautert von Dr. F. Lorinser, 1869) to prove that the author of the Gita borrowed many ideas from the Bible must be pronounced a failure. Cf. Garbe, 19, 83—85; Max Muller, Natural Religion, 97—100. Hopkins R. I., 429.” Footnote to page 4, Gita and Gospel.
9 I quite agree with my friend Dewan Bahadur J. S. Chakravarti, m.a., f.k.a.s., Comptroller, Mysore Government, who in his introduction to his lamented father Rai Bahadur Bireswar Chakravarti’s translation (in Rhyme) to the Bhagavadgita, says; “There are, on the one hand, writers like Telang, who after a careful and elaborate examination of the question come to the conclusion that ‘the date at which the Gita can have been composed must be earlier than the third century b.o., though it is impossible to say how much earlier;9 on the other hand, we have scholars of the stamp of Lorinser, Weber and Lassen who hold ‘that the Bhagavadgita was not written before the third century a.o/ (Davies, p. 183). That most of the scholars who have written on the subject are men of vast scholarship, indefatigable industry and clear judgment no one oan, for a moment, doubt; but all of them cannot be said to have been altogether free from bias.”
The Title “Bhagavadgita”
The grammatical accuracy of the title “deserves some careful investigation. The word (add Sanskrit) is derived from to sing, of which it is the past passive participle. The termination (cr) might be also used in an abstract sense, in which case its gender would be neuter by Panini’s rule “tET:”. With the termination “(add Sanskrit)” another form (add Sanskrit) is also possible in the same sense. In the present case the word has taken the feminine termination (3n’) whence it becomes evident that rff is a passive participle termination and the whole word is therefore only an adjective requiring some feminine substantive to qualify. Hence the word “” by itself cannot form the full title of the work and is grammatically speaking incorrect.
This becomes more clear from an examination of the colophon at the end of each chapter which invariably runs “fief (add Sanskrit) Now when the sentence is construed it will be found that the only word which is grammatically co-ordinate with is “(add Sanskrit) the gender, number and case of both being the same, while all other words are independent in construction. Hence it is obvious-that the expression Wfiftal is only a shortened form of which is the full and correct title of the work, the plural perhaps being intended to refer to the Upanishadic doctrines propounded.1 T is a further contraction used more often and we speak of “the Bhagavadgita” or “the Gita” meaning of course “the Bhagavadgitopanishad.” This process of contraction is by no means rare in Sanskrit. Thus (add Sanskrit) is shortened into and into
1 “It is, however, styled an Upanishad or rather a series of Upanishads, because, like the Upanishade, it reveals secret and mystical doctrines.” Foot-note 4 to page 125. u Indian Wisdom,” by Sir Monier Williams. Both the singular and plural forms of the word Bhagavad-gita also seem to have been used by authoritative writers like 8'ankaracharya. (add Sanskrit) and “(add Sanskrit)
What Is the Bhagavadgita?
The main question with which this essay has started gives room to another incidental point to be settled. What is the Bhagavadgita? This has to be decided at the very outset, because on the answer to this question depends the pertinency of the main enquiry. It is a truism that no one would look for grammatical truths, in a treatise on medicine, or consult a book on Astronomy with the expectation of finding in it information on legal matters. Hence to be assured that we are justified in looking for practical ethics in the Gita, it is very essential to ascertain what the book is meant for. This question has been answered in different ways by different scholars. *Some think it a reconciliation of the warring religious sects of the times of the1 author. *Others see in it an endeavour to exalt the caste duties above all other obligations. •(•And some others hold that the Gita is meant to revive Krishnaism and emphasize the Krishnavatara. But it is curious that none of such views takes cognizance of what the author himself calls his work. In the colophon at the end of each chapter, he says: “Thus ends the chapter called so and so, of the Upanishads sung by the Lord, which are the philosophy of Brahman and the Science of Yoga, as expounded in the course of the dialogue between S'ri Krishna and Arjuna.” The author clearly intends therefore that the book must be judged as a philosophy of Brahman and a Science of Yoga.
The question now assumes another shape. What is Brahman, and what is Yoga according to •See ‘Summary of the Bhagavadgita’ in “The Religious and Moral Teaching of the Bhagavadgita examined,” by John Murdoch.
t Cf. M But the leading idea of the Gita is that Krishna is Brahma incarnate, round that all the rest of the teaching gathers” Gita and Gospel, p. 15. the Gita? “What is the Brahman you spoke of?,r is the first of the seven questions which Arjuna is made to ask S'ri Krishna at the beginning of the eighth chapter. The answer given is “Brahman is the Highest Unchangeable.” In the thirteenth chapter again, a description of this Brahman is given, “I shall now tell you what ought to be known and knowing which one attains immortality. It is the beginningless Highest Brahman.” Then follows a long description carried on by means of seemingly contradictory assertions. From these two passages, we learn that the Brahman of the Gita is the Highest Reality that knows no change. Now for the term Yoga. As in the case of the word Brahman, the author refers to this word in two places, in one of which he defines the term, while in the other he gives a general description intended to convey to the readers’ mind what is meant by the word. In the 48th verse of the second chapter, we read “” “evenness is called Yoga.” And in verses 20 to 23, chapter VI, we have the following description of Yoga. “Where the mind becomes quiescent, controlled by practice* where seeing the Self by Self one is satisfied in himself; where one experiences absolute bliss known only to the mind but ever beyond the senses; and standing where one swerves not from the truth; where no other gain is considered greater, and where placed one is not moved by the greatest pain that (state), a state in which there is the absence of all contact with misery, is to be understood by the term Yoga.”
In the whole of the Gita there is no other place where the terms Brahman and Yoga are made the subjects of discussion, and there is no Other definition or description of either term, though both the words are freely interspersed throughout the work. That in the shorter of the passages cited above, the terms are intended to be defined and that the longer extracts are meant to be explanatory to the definitions, is corroborated by the following considerations. The epithet “(add Sanskrit)” “Highest" of Brahman in the definition is recognised in the descriptive passage by the word “(add Sanskrit)” which also means Highest, and in both the contexts Brahman is considered as the great Reality to be known. This is oot the case, for instance, in the passage u” where, though the epithet * great’ is used, Brahman evidently denotes something other than the Reality. So also with Yoga. The definition identifies it with “Evenness” and the description is easily seen to refer to this “evenness”or equanimity, though the term “” primarily meaning “connection” is here used by what is called (indication by the opposite) to denote (separation) of (the contact of misery.)2 In fact, a little further on in the same chapter comes this passage which makes the assurance doubly sure. “■site: (add Sanskrit)” “This Yoga described by you as evenness, Oh, Slayer of Madhu, I cannot see how it can remain permanent, seeing that the mind is fickle,” (VI—33).
Our investigation therefore leads us to the following conclusion. Brahman is the Highest Reality or Truth and Yoga is evenness of mind in which the Truth is seen. Brahma-Vidya is thus the Philosophy of the Real and Yoga-S'astra is the science of equanimity, perfect equanimity being according to the Gita the one condition in which the mind can have access to the Real. What does the “Bhagavadgita” profess to be then? It proposes to put forth the theory of the Real, and to recommend a line of conduct which will lead us to the realization of that Reality. This means to realization, the Gita calls Yoga. Whatever leads up to this Yoga is also called Yoga by a transference of the term. Thus each -chapter of the book deals with a separate Yoga, though the ultimate aim is the Yoga properly so called, to wit, equanimity.3 Yoga has several other meanings in Sanskrit, but when we talk of the Yoga of the Gita, we had better dissociate all such meanings from this word.
1 Of. “They both (the Bhagavadgita and the Sveta-s'wataropanishad) aim at reconciling the conflicting views of different systems, and both do so by attempting to engraft the Sankhya and Yoga upon Vedanta doctrines/' “Indian Wisdom/’ p. 123. The foot-note under the same page refers to Dr. Roer for a full explanation of this view. So also Prof. Max Muller who (p. 402, Six Systems of Indian Philosophy) sees in the Bhagavadgita a reconciliation of the philosophies of Yoga and Sankhya, though unlike Sir Monier Williams, Prof. A. Macdonell and others, he holds that the word Sankhya-Yoga (S'wetas'. Up. VI. 13) denotes only one philosophy. But see page 25 of the present work. *
2 Possibly on tbe strength of this description (add Sanskrit) and professedly on the latter half of an introductory verse (g*9f *jl?T tPIT) by Bhoja in his commentary on the Yoga-Sutras, Prof. Max Muller remarks (p. 406, Six Systems of Indian Philosophy) that Yoga means not union but disunion. But Patanjali himself says in his aphorism that the term in his Science only denotes the restraint of the modifications of the mind (add Sanskrit) And the word “” (even) in the above quotation from Bhoja which the Professor has simply passed over, clearly shows that Bhoja, by no means, took M seperation” as a distinct signification of the term “Yoga.” This view is made all the stronger by the word “” (peculiar) in the first half of the same verse which runs “(add Sanskrit)”
3 It will become clear as we go on, bow this definition of “Yoga” as equanimity, equally applies to Jnana-Yoga, Karma-Yoga and other Yogas.
Yoga-S’astra
The bulk of the Gita is taken up with the Yoga S'astra rather than with Brahma Vidya, though as we have said the work itself claims to be both. Philosophical truths are adduced here more for the purpose of supporting the Yoga doctrines rather than for entering upon an intellectual discussion of philosophical problems. It is not that the intellect is given a low place in the Gita, nor that the glorious results of rational enquiry are here held up for ridicule or contempt, but the results of all philosophic enquiry are made the very basis of its chief subject, the Yoga. Philosophy is brought down to the lower level of every day experience without losing even a ray of its lustre, and its truths are here presented in such a simple manner and as it were in such a concrete form that the commonest minds can understand them and put them into daily practice. It is very often said with reference to Indian philosophy that it aims at something beyond this world and ignores the present life, that it asks us to give up life if we wish to cure the evils of life, and that it is, in short, merely an impracticable theory promising a state of perpetual happiness after death in reward for an utter neglect of the practical life. The Gita is the one standing protest to this baseless charge. Its object is to show how the highest of the Vedantic truths are at the same time the simplest •of all, how every one of them can be applied and is meant to be so applied to this very practical work-a-day world and how religion means no more than philosophy applied to every day life. The Gita as a Yoga S'astra or Science of Yoga, shows how, in whatever stations of life we may be, and whatever may be our intellectual capa- ■city, each one of us may understand and live Religion to the extent of our capability, every minute of our life. Nay more, the Yoga S'astra of the Gita is mainly intended to show that here in this very life is to be sought the highest beatitude end further to point out that there is really not so much antagonism between religion and the life of the world as is commonly fancied. This statement may be received at first with some doubt by a portion of our readers, but the sequel, it is hoped, will place it on surer foundations. For the present we may state that Yoga S'Istra tries to explain the practical part of Vedanta and to offer an ideal character to be realised.
The practicality of the Gita consists in its1 recognising the varieties of minds and inclinations. Though truth is one, and the ultimate goal must be the same, yet it cannot be insisted that all must follow the same method to reach it. Though perfect health is the goal of all his patients, a doctor would not prescribe the same course of treatment to them all. Several things would have to be taken into consideration, age, • sex, present state of health, as well as the general habits of the patient. Similarly, a religion to be practicable to a large portion of mankind should be ready to supply the needs of the various minds that seek it. This is what the Gita attempts to do. It classifies religious-aspirants into four broad divisions, the active man, the emotional man, the mystic, and the man of reason. These four classes are not mutually exclusive of one another, for all the four characteristics do actually exist in every mind to some extent or other. The classification however is based on the predominance in individual souls of one of the four natures, and though no two minds may be said to be exactly similar in all particulars, yet the Gita considers that for all practical purposes, it will be sufficient to divide human minds into these four types. And there is a Yoga for each of these types; though the goal to be attained is in each case the same.
The Ideal of the Gita
And what is this goal? This question has received several answers from the various Acharyas who have commented on the Gita. It is said by some that work is the great ideal of the Gita, Gita being sometimes called the Gospel of duties. Others say that love is regarded as the great ideal of life by the author of Gita. Some others declare that knowledge is (the goal, while yet others maintain that meditation is its ultimate aim.
Now, there are passages in the Gita, which taken by themselves confirm each of these views. Let us take “work” for instance. It is said in 11—47, “Yours is only to work.” Again in III, we have “Regularly perform your work, for action is better than inaction.” “Working without attachment, man attains the highest.” “Janaka and others attained perfection solely through work.” This view has not only the sanction of the texts such as those quoted just now, but also stands to reason; for is it not quite natural that one should work for what one wants to reach? No one but a lazy person would expect to find the goal without work. Again, take “love.” This side too, has its texts. In chapter V, we read “It is they that get absorption in Brahman, who have abscinded their doubts, who are self-controlled and who ever love all beings.” In XI, it is stated, ■“He who is free from hatred towards every being reaches Me,” In XII again, “They reach Me only, for they are ever bent on doing good to all beings/ These and other similar passages point to universal love as the ideal and reason also supports it. For, there can be really no good work except through a motive of love, and the best thinkers of all times have preached and the rest of mankind have given their assent to nothing but universal love as the means of eradicating the evils of life. Meditation or concentration of thoughts also claims the support of the Gita. “There is neither enlightenment nor religious fervour for one who has no concentration; and for one without any fervour no peace can come; whence happiness without peace?” Again, we are told in VI, " Applying himself thus constantly, the Yogin gains control over his mind and obtains-the peace and blessedness of My Estate.” The Yogin is said in the next s'loka to be greater than ascetics, greater than intellectual men, and greater than workers. This side too therefore, can make out a strong case in favour of it. Season is ready to support it. For, what do all achievements represent but degrees of mind-concentration? All knowledge is acquired by -concentration of mind, that is, by fixing the mind exclusively on the particular subject of enquiry. So, concentration may also be said to be the ideal. As for knowledge, we have numerous Gita texts in its favour too. “All action Oh! Partha, finds its culmination in knowledge.” u The Jnanin is My very Self.” And so on we find numerous other texts eulogizing knowledge; and reason has everything to say on the side of knowledge, for, reason itself is based on previous knowledge and in its turn is the accumulator of fresh knowledge. Work, love and concentration may be easily shown to lead to knowledge, and therefore on this side also, a very good position is made out, for those holding that knowledge is the ideal. Now, as we have already seen, there are four chief types of mind in this world, and it is natural that each one should have a different aim according to his particular inclination. And if we consider the other varieties of minds also for which there is ample room in this world of ours, we should be hardly surprised to find that there are numerous and different goals for which they are severally making.
And the Gita supports all these! So, we have a medley of ideals all supported by Gita texts! “Is there no way out?” “Does not the Gita then recognise the superiority of any one ideal over the others?” This is the natural question that should now possess our mind, and the answer is very simple. Each one of these ideals is called a Yoga by the Gita and the Gita is the Science of Yogas. Its very object is to reconcile all the views. And how does it effect this reconciliation? Is it by raising any one of them into distinction and allowing that Yoga to lord over others? No. In the solution of this most vital of problems lies the practicality of the Gita, which is the greatest commentary yet written on Vedanta. Persons ignorant of the true tenor of the Gita have tried to make it a sectarian treatise, and by twists and 'tortures of s'lokas, they have attempted to produce proof-texts in their favour. The Gita has been made by such men to support by turns, work and no work, love and indifference, reason and mystic practice. But there is not one of these theories which does not take only a part and neglects the rest of the work. Taken as a whole, the Gita can never be made to support any one of the theories exclusively. It supports all ideals or none. No one sectarian can claim the special sanction of the Gita in his favour. Knowledge work, love, concentration are all here commended but none at the expense of the others.1
People very often quarrel over words rather than facts. Even very intelligent men sometimes fight with one another, for the reason that some of them do not choose to set forth ideas in exactly the same words as others. An-amusing story is related of four boys who were given a coin that they might purchase and equally divide among themselves some fruit they liked best. Bach wanted to purchase the same fruit,but not knowing the language of one another,, they began to quarrel, as each boy insisted on purchasing the fruit he named. Only the names were different; but they did not know it. At last a man who knew all the four languages showed them the fruit itself and they were all equally glad and satisfied that each of them had at last carried his point. They then gave up quarrelling when they found out their mistake and saw that all the four words stood for the same fruit and not for different things as they had supposed. Somewhat similar to this is the reconciliation effected by the Gita. Truth is the fruit of all the four ideals described above. Work leads to truth, concentration leads to truths knowledge leads to truth and love leads to truth. All the four are real indeed. In fact each is an aspect of the same thing. To start with, they may appear different but they all finally converge-to one point and then it is seen that each or them involves the others.
This point of convergency is called Yoga by the Gita. To attain that state of mind is to attain Yoga. This state has been defined by the author of the Gita in a single word “evenness.** The mind has to reach a point where it is not affected by any external circumstances. As it is, the mind is subject to a thousand and one changes and the goal is to transform it into a state of “evenness.” Every change is limiting the mind, and the ideal of the Gita is to train the mind so as to transcend as far as possible all such limitations. The process may be whatever is suited to the individual and each such process is called a Yoga, because it leads to the real Yoga, which is “evenness.” No one can hope to reach this “evenness, “until he has come to combine in him the ideals of work,, concentration, knowledge and love. We have now to enter upon a more detailed study of each of these four Yogas of the Gita, in order to-understand how the real ideal is reached through them.
1 Of. (add Sanskrit) (Gita, Ch. V, 4—5). It is to be noted that the word Sankhya in the Oita stands for Jnana, but not for the system of philosophy (by Kapila) technically so called. This view is shared not only by Oriental authorities like S'rf S'ankaracharya but also by some of the occidental critics like Deussen who in his Outlines of Indian Philosophy says “The words (Sankhya and Yoga) are thus in the sense of reflection and concentration) used where they occur (add Sanskrit) the first time (S'wet, 6, 13) and it is an open question, demanding further research whether not only in the Bhagavadgita but also throughout the Mahabharatam, the words Sankhya and Yoga are not so much names of philosophical systems as general terms for the two methods of reflection and concentration.”
Karma-Yoga, or the Yoga of Action
Definition
The Yoga which we shall consider first of all’will be Karma Yoga. “” is a Sanskrit word -derived from the root “f?” to do, and the primary meaning of the word therefore is action. There are other secondary significances of the word, but in Karma-Yoga, it is action that is the subject of enquiry. Action considered as due from us to some one else is known as duty. Action performed in accordance with S'astraic injunctions is a ritual. Karma-Yoga embraces all these phases of action, and it is the science which treats of not only actions but also their motives and tendencies as well as the results.
Escape from Work Impossible
The Gita recognises that work is the order of nature. Man is incessantly changing, animals are changing, plants are changing, and even minerals are changing. Not a single second passes without producing enormous changes in nature, in the mineral, vegetable and animal kingdoms. The whole of nature is as it were work-shop of uninterrupted business. Nature knows no rest and is identical with ever-recurring work. Knowingly or unknowingly every being from a blade of grass to the highest angel is working. Now, this repeating work or change is brought about by three fundamental forces of nature according to the Sankhya philosophers. They call them Gunas. The three Gunas are Sattwam, Rajas, and Tamas.1 The English word ‘forces’ does not fully express the original idea, for Gunas are not forces as opposed to matter but are themselves the constituents of primordial matter out of which the whole of creation is evolved according to the Sankhya philosophy. The translation “quality” is 'also open to a similar objection. So far as action is concerned we may translate Sattwam as the equalising, Rajas as the differentiating, and Tamas as the deadening force. Nature is the field of competition among these fundamental forces. Thus, on one side we see the Sattwa force working to bring out harmony and equilibrium, on another, there is the Rajas predominant, showing enormous activity and giving room to numerous inequalities, while in the third place there is the Tamas stopping all action and producing nothing but inertness. These forces are at work everywhere. “q 35.fa
(XVIII—40). There is no being on the surface of the earth or even among the Gods of Heaven, who is free from these fundamental of nature. Now, it is part of the province of Karma Yoga to study the working of these forces and their effect on human character.
As said above, every one has to work. it (add Sanskrit)
” (HI—5)- “No one indeed ever stands without work even for a moment; every one is forced to work, in spite of himself, by the Gunas of nature.” Whether we will or no,' we have to march. If any one stops even for a single second, striking work, he is crushed. Man is bound to work and reap the fruits thereof. How rigorous are the laws of nature! There is not the slightest action of the body or of the mind which is not followed by reaction. Every one is working either towards equilibrium or differentiation, though for a time if he so chooses, he may also be lazy. Nevertheless, we reap the effects of laziness as well as of work. There is no escape. We may fret and fume, but there is no help for it. We may try to forget this law of nature, we may sit indifferent for a while, we may sleep for a while, we may even take drugs or other soporific thing to make us oblivious of the fact; but after all a hard knock comes and we are forced to recognise the truth, “” “The whole world is-bound by its acts’” (III—9). Now, Karma Yoga teaches that the sooner we realise this, the better for us. There is no use putting off a question which one day or other, we shall be forced to answer. So, our first duty must be to understand our real position, that we are all forced to work by nature “q f?
” “So long as one has a body, it is impossible to give up works absolutely.” (XVIII- —10).
Freedom from Work Lies through Work
Nevertheless, man is ever struggling for freedom. This is also a fact. On the one hand, Nature is forcing man to be her slave; on the other, man is fiercely fighting against her, with a deep-rooted conviction that he is sure to be the master in the end. If there is any ingrained belief in us all alike, it is the idea of freedom. If Nature ie trying to put limitations after limitations to man’spower, man is trying to transcend all such limitations if possible. Nature wants man incessantly to work and at the same time man’s heart yearns for rest. The Wheel of action is turning round incessantly and man is being carried on with if Yet he wants complete rest and complete freedom. t
Is this struggle of man in vain or is there any hope? This is a very important question. For, on the answer to this question depends the foundation of morality. If man is a mere creature of circumstances, and is forced to drudge in spite of himself, if he is no more than a wind-bound vessel in the ocean of life, his responsibility ceases, and he can neither be blamed for his evil actions nor be given credit for virtuous deeds. If, on the other hand, he is a master of his actions to any extent, and not a slave of the forces of Nature, there is hope for ethics. Man himself becomes directly responsible for his actions to the extent of his liberty. So, this question has to be put and answered. Is man free to work or is he forced to work? The Gita says, man as he is, must work in spite of himself, but it lies with him to choose the line of work. He may take a rope and hang himself or use the self-same rope to bind elephants and tigers and rule them. He may work out his own ruin or salvation. “(add Sanskrit)” “One is one’s own friend and one’s own foe.” (VI—5). To teach how to turn work to advantage and how to work out one’s own salvation is the special aim of Karma Yoga.
So then, the Oita admits that freedom is desirable and possible. But it says that this freedom lies through work and not through inaction
(III—4)‘not by non-commencement of works alone does a person get freedom of action, nor can he by mere abandonment of works attain perfection.” Victory is to be won not by deserting your post, but by bravely fighting where you are. If you want rest, you must find it in work or nowhere. Why not find rest throwing all action overboard? Simply ‘because it is impossible to do so while you live. Cessation of work means cessation of life. “(add Sanskrit)”
” (III—8). “Life itself would be impossible without work.” For, what is life but: a struggle with nature? So, this struggle is to go on to the end of life..Saints and sinners. rich and poor, young and old, all alike are sub-' ject to this struggle. Our choice therefore lies not between work and no work, but between drudgery and intelligent work, between working like a slave of nature, and working like a master. Karma Yoga teaches us the art of intelligent work.
Two Kinds of Work
“(add Sanskrit)
” (II —49). “Far removed is lower Karma (work) from the Yoga of intelligent work, Oh! wealth winner; seek refuge in this wisdom, for, pitiable are those that are led by desire of rewards.” Here S'ri Krishna wanted to emphasize the distinction between these two kinds of work, the work of a slave and the work of a master. But the laconical manner in which this is stated in the second chapter of the Gita and the concluding verses of that chapter which describe the wisdom of a Yogin without special reference to work gave room to Arjuna’s question with which the third chapter opens, “If, Oh! Janardana, you hold wisdom to be greater than work, then why do you press me to take part an this terrific war?” Evidently Arj una takes it that there is meant here a natural antithesis between wisdom and work, whereas the real contrast intended to be specially brought home isbetween lower Karma “” and higher intelligent Karma “The whole of the third and a great deal of the fourth chapter is devoted to make this point clear. S'ri Krishna points out that while it is true that there are two paths of realisation called Jnana Yoga and Karma Yoga suited to different temperaments, yet they are not mutually exclusive, nor is it true that Jnana means cessation from all work, for, as already shown it is physically impossible. The only thing to be noticed and remembered is that whereas ordinary mortals work like servants, the Karma Yogin works like a master. The three forces of nature, Sattwam, Rajas and Tamas already referred to have no control over him; for he has learnt to manipulate them without coming under their influence.2
The Three Gunas or Fundamental Forces of Nature
A knowledge of the working of these three forces is absolutely necessary for one wishing to be a Karma Yogin. A general description of them is given in the fourteenth chapter and again in the eighteenth. We shall here give the translation of three of these S'lokas(XIV—5 to 8). “Sattwam, Rajas and Tamas—the three manifest Gunas of nature bind the embodied undecaying soul. Of these, Oh! spotless Arjuna, Sattwam being pure is enlightening and purifying; it binds one with attachment to happiness as well as with attachment to knowledge. Know Rajas to be passion, the birth-place of vehement desire and fondness,• it binds the embodied being with attachment to activity. As for Tamas, know it to be born of ignorance and stupefying to all embodied beings; it binds them with negligence, indolence and drowsiness.” Thus there is constantly going on this interaction of the triple nature. Every act of ours is goaded on by one of these forces. It must not bo supposed, however, that these forces work singly each in its special field. They are simultaneously at play and mixed in different combinations produce different effects on the agents. One of these forces may be predominant in an-individual, and that may determine his choice of work. His choice and action again will have special re-action and effect on himself as well as on his surroundings.
Work without Attachment: the Chief Doctrine of Karma-Yoga
Now, Karma Yoga teaches that work by itself is quite harmless and all our miseries come from our Sanga (attachment) to the work done by the three Gunas. “
” (III-29) “Persons ignorant of the Gunas of nature, get attached to their actions.” If we just understand this aright and avoid this error, work becomes a mere play to us, instead of being a bugbear. "What is this Sanga? It is I-ness. It is a fact observed every where that the best work was produced when the doer forgot himself, or rather was wholly engrossed in the work as not. to conceive that he was working. Yet people constantly make this mistake of keeping their little personality vividly before their mind and thus spoil the whole work. The instant the idea of “I” comes, we lose sight of our work. As an aid to this practice of non-attachment, and as another factor in making ourselves masters of our actions, the Gita recommends that we should renounce the fruits 'of work also. It is only when we work without attachment and without desire for fruit, that we can become real Karma Yogins. “5
& TP? (XVIII-6) “But my verdict in the matter is this, Oh’ Partha, these Karmas ought to be done without attachment and without desire of reward.”
This simple doctrine of “action without attachment” seems to have offered unexpected difficulties in certain quarters. The Gita inculcates it as the one key to success in life and as containing all the essentials of ethics. Yet certain critics are disposed to think that it is the most poisonous doctrine in the book. The Rev. J. Lazarus, b.a., for instance, thus comments on the doctrine, “To act without attachment is to act without motive or purpose, to experience in the act itself neither pain nor pleasure, and to think nothing whatever of its future fruit or result. Action, then, without the three concomitants of motive, feeling and effect is action without attachment. Men are to be mere animals or living automata, acting as they are moved by instinct. The moment that any one of these attachments is formed the actions become sinful. For a rational being such as man is, it is utterly impossible to act without attachment so called unless he becomes mad or delirious. The moral element, not to speak of the physical, would be utterly wanting in it; no such action would be possible. How was Arjuna as a human being and a kinsman to dismiss all feelings of pity and mercy for the foes against whom he was aiming his deadly darts? Action without attachment is a convenient loop-hole for the commission of any crime however horrible or foul. The murderer of Mr. Rand walked up to the gallows with the Gita in his hand. I am afraid this is the most poisonous doctrine in the hook.”3 (Vide Lectures on the Bhagavadgita, by Eev. J. Lazarus, pp. 11, 12).
Now, one peculiar feature of this extraordinary piece of criticism is that it takes immense pains to father upon the author of the Oita a doctrine which he never taught and then passes the severe judgment on the Gita that it propounds a “poisonous” doctrine. We have therefore only to explain the real doctrine in order to show that the criticism stands self refuted. Action without attachment does not mean “to act without motive or purpose and to think nothing whatever of its future fruit or result.” Action without any motive is a. physical impossibility even for a mad man, for,, even he has some fancied motive for his conduct. All action is motion *and as such necessarily requires a motive. Even inaction is, strangely enough, due to some motive. This the Gita recognises fully and says that in this sense, inaction may be also spoken of as a species of action (IV-18). By action without attachment again, is never meant an action without feeling. For, man, as he is, is a bundle of feelings and every action is sure to bring about a necessary feeling in the agent. Thus to touch fire and not to expect a feeling of burning sensation would be possible only for the most obtuse-minded person. Nor does action without attachment mean “thinking nothing whatever of its future fruit or effect.” Though such an action is possible, none but a mad person or an infatuated murderer would stoop to it. What the Gita has to say on an action without any concern for results will be clear from the following: (XVIII—25). “Regardless of its future effects,, of what it costs, of the trouble it involves and of the capacity required for its execution'—an action undertaken without regard to any of these is said to be Tamasic (of the lowest type).” The best action on the other hand, is described in the Gita in the following words: “(add Sanskrit)” (XVIII—23). “That action which, as a rule, is done without attachment, which is the outcome of neither love nor hatred, and which is performed with a view to no personal gain, is said to be Satwic (of the best type).” Karma Yoga, therefore does not ask us to become mere animals and to act as we are “moved by the instinct.” It does not mean an action “without the three concomitants of motive, feeling and effect.” It only asks us to have the highest of motives, the best of feelings and always to undertake actions calculated to bring about the greatest amount of good while it costs the least trouble either to ourselves or to others.
The reader will have by this time pretty clearly understood what is meant by the expression “(add Sanskrit)” “action without attachment.” Being acted upon by the three fundamental Gunas afore-mentioned, man has the curious knack of attaching himself to their acts and as it were, becoming a mere appendage to them. He says to himself “I am doing this, this is to be done by me now.” (XVI—13). The moment this thought occurs in his mind, this Ahankara or egoistic tendency destroys much of his energy. According to the Gita, there is a higher mood in which man can place himself and in which alone his actions are at their best. All the great men of the world have consciously or unconsciously put themselves in this mood when they achieved the greatest of their performances. Now, the Gita says that it is the Sanga or the clinging to the “I” that obstructs our passing to this mood. If we are consciously to get this higher state, we have to give up this clinging to our little self; in plain words we are to give up selfishness. This doctrine is the very basis of Hindu or for that matter universal ethics. All ethics preaches nothing but the destruction of this lower “I.”" The lower self or Ahankara is to be destroyed this is the one theme of all religion. Till this lower self is gone, there is no hope of the higher being attained. As the poet says—
“Unless above himself he can
Erect himself, how mean a thing is man!”
And what is “” Renunciation of fruits? It is not to be regardless of the consequences of an action, but to forget our individual gain or loss, nor to think of what return we are to get for the deed. We are required to see that our energies are not frittered away by thinking of little temporary gains. For, it is only action done by a man expecting no personal gain that is calculated to produce a lasting effect. It is this renunciation of fruit, for instance, that displayed itself in the founders of all religions; Had they thought of the fruit or the result to accrue to themselves by their actions, they would have never become great men and their names would have been buried in oblivion like those of a thousand other persons.
Thus the doctrine of “giving up attachment and fruit of action” is neither impossible nor -absurd. It is not meant for mad and delirious persons but for brave souls who can work for the good of the world without expecting any reward. There is thus no “want” or absence of the moral or any other element in actions without attachment and without desire for fruit, for only in such actions do morality and physical energy find the widest field for their fullest play.
But it must be borne in mind that the Gita does not depreciate other actions, for, according to this book, even selfish actions are not necessarily sinful. Though unselfish action ought to be the goal, yet it is not possible for us all. Bo, we may work with selfish motives if we cannot help -it. Indeed to work with some motive (including a selfish one) is preferable to indolence. “Work is better than no work” —8). To give up laziness, the first step is to take up some work. A great many of us find it impossible to go beyond this stage. We are •doing some work, with some motive. Some are •working for money, and they would not be content even were they to amass the wealth of Kubera himself. Even if a portion of this wealth should be diminished by chance they would break their heart over it, like that millionaire of Rome who finding one day that he had only a million pounds left, is said to have died in intense sorrow. Then there are those who work for power. In their eyes nothing is all right unless it has power. Even God Himself is no God if He is not All powerful. They set value on things in terms of power. Thus, “knowledge is power, money is power, time is power.” Knowledge, money and time are valuable to them only as conducing to power. So, they work for power. But others work for knowledge. They are quite dissatisfied with those who work for any other ideal. How beautiful, how excellent is knowledge I All money, all power is nothing before knowledge. Others again work for name, fame and honour. There are various other motives too numerous to mention. Suffice it to say that the Gita condemns none. No work done with one, or even more selfish motives is sinful in itself. You may work for enjoyment either here or hereafter, the Gita has no quarrel with you. Avoid' inaction by all means. “(add Sanskrit) (III-8)-
Always work” that is all it has to say.
But a rational being should eventually see that there are higher motives also. To work for wealth, power or fame is good, but to work because it is our duty to work is better. To work because it does good to the world is a still higher stage. To work for the sake of work is a yet higher motive; to work not because it brings us enjoyment, not because it is our duty to some one else, not because we wish to do good to the world and to improve it, but because intelligent good work is in itself an ideal, is the highest stage that man can reach in the present world. To be always doing good and to be always loving good is in itself a state of blessedness for which no other enjoyment can be a match. To taste of this eternal fountain of joy, discovered by never-ceasing and selfless work is the highest of motives with which man can be actuated.
A word more is necessary about another “concomitant of action” as it has been aptly termed by our Reverend critic. We have now fairly done with motive and effect of actions t there remains ‘feeling.’ -By what feeling are we to be actuated in our actions? The definition of Satwic Karma already quoted says “
Our work must not be the result of love or hatred. Very often we imagine that unless we are excited by some passion we cannot work. It is true that feeling is a necessary concomitant of work, but it does not necessarily follow that we should feel the passions as vehemently as we do generally. Indeed our feelings spoil the work rather than help it. The one feeling that we should possess is unruffled calmness. It is only when the mind is very calm and collected that it can accomplish anything great. Hence it is that the Gita says, “(add Sanskrit)
(II-48). “Do your actions,_taking stand in Yoga, giving up all attachment, being undisturbed in mind, either by success or failure.” And what is this Yoga in which we should place ourselves. (II-48). “Evenness is called Yoga.”
This evenness, this equipoise of mind, is the higher mood in which every one should try to place himself while at work. It is not the man given to love or hatred or anger or any other passion that can do real and useful work, but only a person who commands a calm and well-balanced mind.4 This evenness or undisturbed balance of mind is the secret of success. A man swayed by passion is always iu a hurry, for, before he has in one mood determined what to do, he is carried away by another passion. How can masterly work be possible to one who is ever a slave to his passions? On the other hand, “a mind of equanimity” is always at leisure. It can well weigh its motives and tendencies. It can think rightly, determine rightly and choose rightly, (add Sanskrit) (II-50). 44 Therefore apply yourself to this Yoga, for, in actions Yoga (balance of mind) is the skill.”t All clever and intelligent work is the outcome of this balance of mind.
The Gita on Duty
Now, it becomes easy to understand why Krishna calls Arjuna a coward when he refuses to fight. “Whence at this juncture comes upon thee, Oh, Arjuna, this despair, un-Aryan, disgraceful and obstructing the heavenward path 1 Yield not to cowardice, Oh { Partha, it -doth not become thee; cast off this mean weakness of the heart, and arise, Oh! vexer of thy foes.” (II-2). Arjuna as a human being and al kinsman, naturally felt for his foes. He was, as any other ordinary mortal would have been, overwhelmed with mercy and pity for them and refused to fight. But this was just the time t Prof. Max Muller translates this half of the verse thus:—“Therefore devote yourself to Yoga. Yoga is success in (all) actions” (six systems of Philosophy). 'This, if taken as defining Yoga as success in all actions, would be against the context. For a further elucidation of the complete verse, see the concluding remarks of the present book. I-when he ought not to have sold himself to i these passions. He came to fight and goaded by his warrior spirit was sure to fight, but meanwhile came this weakness of heart in the garb of pity and love for his kinsmen. Thus he was first subject to a heroic passion and then to the passions of pity and worldly love and in a. ' moment more, perhaps he would have changed his mind again, and reminded of the wrongs-done to him and his brothers by those enemies, he would have certainly made ready to aim his ■deadly darts at them. This is what S'ri Krishna /■warned him against. fare: r ir 1 (XVIII-59-60). “You think egoistically that you are not going to fight, but this determination will be in vain, for your inborn spirit will compel you (to fight); nature-bidden and predestined by your own action, that which you do not Relish to do (now), you will do in spite of yourself.” This giving way to the passions and to be readily acted on by feelings as they come,, is what is rightly denounced as cowardice by S'ri Krishna. Instead of fighting like a hero, Arjuna chose to fight like a slave spurred on by passion. This was the true situation of Arjuna though he declared to the contrary. From a prudential point of view, it was a decided loss to him not to fight, for, he was losing one of the rarest opportunities, which being embraced would lead him on to fortune, fame and honour. From a moral point of view, he was shirking his duty as a king, for, it was his duty as well as his interest to enter into a righteous war but for which a great calamity would have befallen his country. The war between Pandavas and Kauravas was no mere party strife but really a fight between right and wrong. By giving up this fight purely on sentimental grounds, therefore, Arjuna was committing a great moral blunder, (II-33), Looked at from the standpoint of philosophy, Arjuna’s refusal to fight amounted to a spiritual self-degradation. It was nothing short of limiting the One Infinite, Unborn, Undecaying Atman. Arjuna was in fact immersed in sorrow for want of real Vedantic knowledge. A truly enlightened person neither avoids ft piece of work as bad nor unnecessarily courts another thinking it good, (XVIII-10) but ever does the duty nearest to him without losing hie own balance of mind by thinking of its consequences to him. But Arjuna immersed in sorrow has no time to think over such matters. S'ri Krishna therefore considers Arjuna a coward. Arjuna according to Krishna is a coward not because he refuses to fight but because he yields to passions, because he is committing a moral sin by giving up his duty, and finally because he does not know and has not the courage to face the truth of philosophy and religion, though he argues all the same like one well-versed in both.
Thus the Gita does not propound a philosophy of fighting, as has been erroneously thought by some superficial students. Nor does it support in any way the commission of heinous crimes as has been insinuated by persons who do not know what they say. The Karma Yoga of the Gita asks us not to be over-ridden by passions, not to give up the duties next to us, nay more, to rise even above the idea of duty if possible and to work in a calm and undisturbed manner. In whatever sphere of life we may be, we are to learn to work without passion, faithfully and disinterestedly to discharge our duties, and to work for work’s sake. The refrain “therefore fight” found in various places of the Oita in various forms of expression if interpreted in this spirit, justifies the claim of the Gita as a guide' in practical life. To a lover of peace no less than to a lover of righteous war, to the poor no less than to the rich, to the subject no less than to the King, the Gita offers this one piece of advice: *' In whatever station of life you may be placed, do your duty not like a slave but like a hero.” Perfection is possible for all in this way alone. “Engaged in his own duty man attains perfection.” (XVIII-45).
How are we to know our duty? The Gita says “(add Sanskrit)” (XVII- 24.) “The S'astras are your authority in determining what is or is not duty.” We are not to depend on mere speculation in this matter, for, if we do, there will be no end to our doubts. What is considered right in one country and at a particular time, becomes wrong in another country and at another time. Different ideas, indeed, of right and wrong prevail among men even of the same country and time, and men placed in the same condition. The ethics of any individual or society therefore, represents the degree of perfection to which that individual or society has developed its conscience. But it may be contended, does it not follow, that for this very reason morality should depend upon conscience and not upon scripture or authority? The answer is that it does follow. The Gita does not recommend any atrophy of the conscience, but only teaches that we should be guided by a sense of duty rather than of interest. Self-interest understood in the highest sense of the word; does not really clash with a sense of duty (Cf. VII-11). But in the limited sphere in which interest usually functions in most of us, it will be necessary to be cautioned against it. When left to himself, man is apt to choose the temporarily pleasurable to the what is eventually and eternally beneficial to him. But if instead of his personal speculation, he submits himself to the guidance of Scripture, which is •only another name for expert opinion, he is not likely to go wrong. Many of us have not the presence of mind to choose the right even if it should go in the teeth of our interest. Hence the Gita says, “(add Sanskrit) (XVII-23). “He who rejects the injunctions of ethical science and acts ever impelled by desires he never attains perfection, he gets to neither happiness, nor the highest goal.”
Now, the ethical demands of any particular time depend as remarked above, on the degree of perfection which conscience has attained, and 1 therefore ethical science can only indicate the general lines of conduct, while the particulars will have always to be worked according to the needs of the times. For instance, at the time of the Gita, caste was a well-ordered institution, and the author of the Gita therefore, very often applies the general laws of ethics to caste, just to show their practical bearing on life. But though caste confusion has more or less taken place in India in our own times, the Oita not only continues to take a bold on the minds of the Hindus, but influences non-Hindus-also to a great extent. This suffices to show that the basement of the vast superstructure of the ethics of the Gita is not-caste, as has been alleged by some. Its teachings are general enough to be applicable to any society whether with or without caste. The teachings of Karma Yoga, in particular,, admit of application to-day as they were thousands of years ago. The Most Important Principles of Conduct,
The Most Important Principles of Conduct Required by Karma-Yoga
Though we have already alluded to the general principles of conduct recommended by Karma Yoga, we shall now state the most important of’them in brief. (add Sanskrit) OTTER” (III-9) “Except in the case of an action done for the sake of sacrifice, the world is action-bound; for, that (sacrifice) do thou, Oh! son of Kunti, perform action.” This is the first principle of work. But for sacrifice, we become bound to our actions. What is sacrifice? Several kinds of sacrifices are spoken of in the Gita (Ch. IV) “sacrifice to the Gods, sacrifice to Brahman, sacrifice through asceticism, sacrifice through concentration, sacrifice through Study and knowledge.” The one idea that pervades all these is killing selfishness. The idea of Me and Mine which vitiates our life is to be removed. It is difficult to enumerate all actions which are always right, but as a general rule it may be said, that which tends to unselfishness is right, while that which makes us selfish is wrong. Though the world is bound through work, self-sacrifice cuts through the bonds of Karma. Indeed, Karma becomes no Karma— in so far as its evil effects are concerned—to a person of self-sacrifice. SJHT
(tV"-23), “For him who works for sacrifice, all action disappears (in its evil aspects).”. Self-sacrifice is the first principle of conduct.
The second principle is cheerfulness,
(III-84). “Every sense.organ has its established love or hatred towards sense-objects; but one-should not yield to these (passions); for, they are his foes.” We have already dwelt upon this principle at length; a person should not be.guided by strong passions in his actions, for, the more he can dissociate himself from passions and assume a calm attitude, the greater will be the success he can command.
The third principle is Faithful discharge of’ duty. ‘ftrpn sfcr::” (III-35). “Better is one’s own duty though lacking in some quality, than another’s duty well performed; better face death in one’s own duty, for, another’s duty is full of danger.” It has been already remarked that the Gita often applies principles of ethics to caste. One of the objects of S'ri Krishna was to show that Arjuna was wrong in proposing to give up his duty as a Kshatriya. Some persons misunderstand this teaching and are led to think that the Gita exalts caste duties above all other •obligations. But those who are willing to make friends with the context, can easily see that the real point at issue is not caste but duty depen-deut upon birth and position in life.* We are-apt to see others through our own eyes and to-judge all customs by our own standpoint. The-main teaching of the Gita on duty is intended to show that this is an error. Though duty as a; general idea exists in all our minds, we see that; duty as manifested in life changes with environments. Karma Yoga requires us all to be cheerful in discharging our duty by birth as well as those by our position in (add Sanskrit) If one satis-- factorily performs his own duties however humble, nature selects him for higher duties.. We should not neglect our own duty imagining that we are better qualified to do another duty. We are to show our fitness to higher duties by the proper discharge of our duty in the position we are placed in.
The fourth principle of Karma Yoga is that
♦Of. “Tbe burden of bis (Krishna’s) teaching is that the zealous performance of his duty is a man’s most important task to whatever caste he may belong” (Page 405, History of Sanskrit Literature by Prof. A. Macdonell.)
t Of. “We do not choose our own parts in life and have nothing to do with these parts. Our simple duty is confined to playing them well” Epictetus. we should ever keep ourselves enlightened with knowledge so as not to be deceived by the three forces of nature “(add Sanskrit) “But the knower of the real nature of distinguishing Gunas and their works, Oh strong-armed Arjuna, thinks that it is only Gunas acting on Gunas and is (therefore) unattached” The Gunas have been treated of already. A true knowledge of the several ways in which they work enables us to be out of their trammels. Thieves break into only an unguarded house. While we keep the light of truth, we cannot be taken in by the Gunas. S'ri Krishna therefore advises Arjuna thus i -- a “(add Sanskrit)
(add Sanskrit)” (III—45). “The Vedas are for those who are attached to the three Gunas; but go thou, beyond these Gunas; free from opposites ever taking stand in Satwa, be free from a sense of possessing every thing, and be self-controlled.” Of the three Gunas, the influence of Tamas is to be overcome by Rajas, and Rajas with the aid of Satwam, for, while one Guna is predominant, the other two are necessarily powerless(XIV—10.) When one learns the habit of being always ia ■Satwam, he gets gradually beyond all three, for it has to be noticed here that pure Satwam is ■quite different in its effects from the Satwam mixed with Rajas and Tamas. It is for * this reason that one who ever engages himself in purely Satwic Actions, is said to be a “(add Sanskrit)” (one who has got beyond the influence of the three Gunas). „ A description of such an ideal person is given at the conclusion of the fourteenth chapter.
From the advice that one should go beyond all the three Gunas and then take one’s stand in Satwam, another principle can be inferred and deserves to be noted here. As shown above we have to shake ourselves off Tamas and Rajas before we get to the pure Satwam, all the seeds of evils such as Kama and Krodha being the outcome of Rajas (VI—3T). This is in effect the same as saying that even if we cannot do good ■deeds all at once, our first duty must be to give up bad ones. This is expressly taught in the Satasamhita by saying “(add Sanskrit)
(though one cannot fulfil the duty enjoined in Sutras, one should give up the prohibited act.) In the Gita also S'ri Krishna says to Arjuna “(add Sanskrit)” (therefore Oh best of the descendants of Bharata, kill first of all this sinful (enemy born of Rajas) distroyer of knowledge and realization, having controlled the senses.) The application of this principle is very simple. It. only requires us, for instance, to desist at least from hurling vindictive language against a poor beggar even if we do not give him any alms.
Meekness of spirit is the next principle of Karma Yoga “(add Sanskrit)
(add Sanskrit) Through body, mind, and even by the senses, Yogins work giving up attachment for the sake of self-j purity.” There is great spiritual danger in thinking that the world is in need of our help. In spite of our working, the world will always be the same on the whole. The world ' in fact neither makes towards infinite progress nor is it going awfully backwards. It will be just ■where it is, and will go on without us. To think that the world is bad and is waiting for our help is absurd. God has created it for a purpose and it is perfectly well adapted for that purpose* It does in no way stand in need of us. But we-should think it a privilege to be allowed to-work here. Our unselfish work eventually helps us most. It is for “(add Sanskrit)” self-purification, rather than for the good of the world that we work. This meekness of spirit is an important principle of Karma Yoga.
We now come to the last though by nn means the least important principle of Karma Yoga. “How are we to be self-less? How are we to free ourselves from passions? itow are we to discharge our duty without attachment? How are we to get beyond the Gunas? And how are we to rise above the pride that we are helping others while we do the right?” It is indeed very hard to do all these. Unless we have a method to pursue in this respect. Karma Yoga will be a mere talk. Now, those that do not believe in God are left to themselves. They have somehow to get at this ideal. By sheer force of their will, they have to rise above all actions and become free. They have no other resource except their own determination to get unattached. A person who asks “How can I do it?” already confesses ignorance as well as weakness, and a willingness likewise to be instructed and guided. To such persons. Karma Yoga offers the method of renunciation of work to God. S'ri Krishna says to Arjuna
{111-30). “Having renounced all work unto Me with a holy mind—without desires and without the idea of mine, fight thou, freed from sorrow." Giving up all works unto God is the safest method. All our duties are really His. We are all doing His will here. We are merely His instruments, and all fruits of action go to Him. Ours is only to serve. Let us try to do the duty allotted to us as best as we can, but let us claim no praise for it. For, it is all God’s. This renunciation of the lower self to God must go on ceaselessly till we get into the habit of doing so unconsciously. “Whatever one does by nature in deed, word, mind, senses or intellect, all that must be given up to the great Lord.” This self-renunciation to the Lord makes us free. The idea of duty will no longer be a bugbear of life, but it will be the pleasantest cause to do the bidding of the Lord. “ felt (add Sanskrit)” (XVIII-46). “Worshipping God with bis duty, man attains perfection.’' We work not because it is our duty to work, but because it is our privilege to work. We are not -slaves to duty, but free servants of the Lord. Never thinking either of rewards or punishments5 we work out His will. This constant thinking of God is the secret of non-attachment. “(add Sanskrit)” (XVIII-58). “Minded in Me, you can surmount all difficulties” says Sri Krishna.
Such are the general principles of Karma Yoga. This Yoga solves the problem of life through self-less work. The true Karma Yogin does not shirk work, for, he has realised the most important truth that intense self-less work is the real rest and that mere laziness or wilful giving up of work is really work that binds the soul (IV-18). True rest, true actlessness is to ■work always disinterestedly for the good of the world. Real rest, indeed, does not depend upon working or not working. It is merely a certain state of the mind. Eternal rest is attainable only by those that have reached the true Yoga of “Evenness of mind.” He who can be busy always and yet can enjoy such complete rest is the ideal Karma Yogin.
1 Though the terminology of the Sankhya philosophy (Sattwam, Rajas, Tamas, Prakruti, etc.) is used throughout the.Gita,'the work it will be seen is pre-eminently Vedantic. This process of making Vedanta a superstructure on the Sankhya phraseology is by no means uncommon in religio-philosophic writings. Moreover no terminology can be considered peculiarly Vedantic or (add Sanskrit) as it sometimes done. See page 338 of Six Systems of Indian Philosophy where Prof. Max Muller says “There are certain technical terms such as Purusha, Buddhi, Gunas, etc., which are looked upon as the peculiar property of the Sankhya and others auch as Atman, Brahman, Avidyar Maya, etc., which remind us at once of the Vedanta-philosophy; but even these terms are used far more freely in the Brahmanas and the (add Sanskrit) than in the Dars'anasr nor are they always used in the same sense or in the same order by earlier and later authorities,”
2 Cf. S'ankara’s commentary on the above verse where “(add Sanskrit)” is interpreted as making it a Bahuvrihi compound adjective qualifying “(add Sanskrit)” understood.”
3 What a strange piece of argument is this, to infer from the sinful action of a murderer that danger lurks in one of the righteous doctrine inculcated in the G-ita, a most well known ethical work, and to make it responsible for heinous crimes! If this book really supported crimes, the millions of people in India that reverently read it every day, should have by this time sunk to the lowest depths of immorality. But as Miss E. Waldo says “In the statistics of crime for the whole civilized world, the percentage of India is the lowest. The high system of ethics that has been inculcated there for ages has its effects and to-day it is still manifest/* How the Gita provides the sorest foundation of morality so well recognized by Western scholars like Dr. Paul Deussen, will become clear from the concluding remarks of this book.
4 Cf. “Emotions should be servants, not masters; or a* least not tyrants. The secret lies in the will. The personality should reside there as in a castle."—Rev. Robert Hugh Benson.
5 This is the connecting link between Karma Yoga and Bhakti Yoga, and as such will be dealt with at length later on when we shall take up Bhakti Yoga.
Dhyana-Yoga, or the Yoga of the Mystic1
What is mysticism? This word is sometimes contemptuously applied to the belief of those that claim to apprehend certain sights and sounds in states called ecstatic and who dogmatically put forth their experiences as the ultimate truth. The word as used here, however, is a synonym for Dhyana. There are many in this world who are of a contemplative turn of mind, who do not rely much on argument, but are given to constant reflection and brooding till they are convinced of the truth. It is not meant that they never reason or work or do anything else.But self-reflection is their guiding principle of life. They love to examine themselves, to concentrate* their mind upon themselves,and to meditate upon what they see in themselves. This method of self-examination and contemplation is known as Dhyana Yoga, or the Yoga of mysticism. It is very necessary therefore, to be forewarned that the mysticism here meant has nothing to do with mysteries. Dhyana Yoga should on no account be connected with anything secret. It has no connection whatever, with that branch of speculation which deals with secret-communion or intercourse with angels, spirits or devils or any other imaginary beings. Indeed Dhyana Yoga neither asserts nor denies the existence of such beings or the possibility of human dealings with them. The world of such Beings is beyond the range of enquiry of Dhyana Yoga. The word mystic in foreign countries is said to denote and include a mind which claims that direct experience of truth is possible and which strives to have such experience. Now, it is in this sense only that we call Dhyana Yoga by the name of mysticism, and with reference to no mystery whatever. Yet in a way, Dhyana Yoga may be said to be a Yoga of secret also. Self-examination is, strange to say, a great mystery to the majority of mankind, and while many show inclination and curiosity to know external nature, they live almost in complete ignorance of their own self. For such, therefore, the subject and method of Dhyana Yoga will ever remain a supreme secret “(add Sanskrit) But for all others, who are not satisfied with the surface, but want to probe deeper, the Yoga remains to say the least, an open secret. At all events, nothing secret is ever hinted at in the whole of the Gita.
Reason and Realisation
In the consideration of Dhyana Yoga, some' • persons are confronted in the very beginning ■with a serious difficulty. These persons are bred into the belief that all knowledge is founded upon reason and therefore naturally ask themselves “I may get to believe or even realise something in a particular state, but where is the proof that what I experience is the truth?,r Now, this is really an important matter and has to be settled definitely. This is the so-called point of difference between philosophers and mystics. The philosopher thinks that the mystic merely realises without being able to ad-duce proof, and therefore such knowledge is an assumption at best, till proved; the mystic, on the other hand, wonders how the philosopher can assert that he knows on the mere strength of reasoning. In order to clear up this difficulty, we have to note that all reasoning finally rests on previous experience, for, reason never, proceeds except on facts observed and ascertained j to be true, and these premises of reasoning are either assumed to be true on the strength of j experience or else reasoned from other premises'; so assumed. Hence even the philosopher must admit that he realises first and then reasons- But this can be no excuse for the mystic, however, to demand others to believe on the strength of his own realisation. If be wants to convince others, he must be able to give reasons for his statements when demanded. For, no realisation can contradict reason. The fact is that every one adopts only one method to ascertain truth —to wit concentration, and when he wants to convince others of his experience, he argues or suggests it in various other ways to them till they take up the suggestion and following the hint are led up to a state where they realise a fact. Hence realisation is the highest proof available and therefore there can be no demand there again for a proof. But, realisation is not against reason; it fulfils reason. It covers a vaster field than reason but always includes reason in its range. The test of true realisation is that the fact realised is under no circumstance contradicted. Again, it must be verifiable by all capable and willing minds. No one can claim special realisation, for which others are eternally ■disqualified. To be brief, the doctrine of realisation is nothing strange or peculiar. It only; assumes that all knowledge is ultimately founded upon universal experience and whatever contradicts such experience is not truth.
Sense Pleasures Really Sources of Misery
Dhyana Yoga as already remarked is the act of attaining that state of flue perception of mind in which it can introspect or look into itself. It is plain that to perform this introspection successfully, one must first cease looking outwards. The majority of people, therefore, are •quite unqualified to enter upon this study, since they are ever engaged in extracting pleasure from the outside objects. To help such people, the Gita starts by warning them against the senses “(add Sanskrit)
gu:” II (V-22). “All enjoyments arising from the contact of senses and sense-objects are really sources of misery, these (sense-enjoyments) have a beginning and an end, a wise man, therefore does not delight in them.” This is the great warning of Dhyana Yoga, External nature is really grand and the senses are the gate-ways of our knowledge ■of that nature. But what do the senses reveal? They seem every moment to prove that all external nature is change and quite undeserving, of being relied upon. The senses extract all the pleasures they can from the external world and. then conclude “This is all we can give you.”' Even if one is unwise enough to wish to repeat the same monotonous enjoyment of the senses,, he is soon disappointed. The senses themselves cannot continue in their vigour for ever. The duration of the power of the senses, bears as it were, an inverse ratio to the enjoyment they can give us. Now, this is a sufficient ground for a wise man not to take delight in external enjoyments, which invariably depends upon a particular relation being set up between the self-exhausting senses and the ever changing material nature outside. Thus this pleasure of the senses is not only impermanent but also disappointing, being in reality misery in the making in as much as it begets attachment. For, if we get the sense-enjoyment we desire, we become impatient for more and thus make ourselves miserable; but if we do not get the enjoyment, we have to suffer from disappointment. A person who is thus convinced of the utter hollowness of the sense-pleasures, and who is suffering from a mental indigestion of sense-enjoyment though hungering all the same for happiness, naturally turns inward to see what he can find there. As the Katbdpanishad puts it “(add Sanskrit)
”...“Outward the self-existent one projected the senses and therefore man looks outward and not within himself. The heroic man only rarely met with desiring immortality, with inverted senses examines himself.” This wise man who wants to observe and generalise the laws of his internal nature is the person qualified for the pursuit of Dhyana Yoga.
The Use of Self-Study
What is the use of such study or practice? The best reward for all study is knowledge and there can be no question of utility in the matter. Ignorance is itself a loss which no gain compensates except knowledge. But yet there is utility also here. (add Sanskrit) (V-21). “One whose mind is unattached to the external sense-pleasure,.gets in himself what is (really) happiness; with his mind attached to Brahma Yoga, he gets the highest happiness.” All misery comes through fear. When we depend upon senses there is no end to our fears. First there is the fear that the sense-objects, the supposed seats of pleasure, may be themselves destroyed, or they may be lost or else so altered,in their nature as to become objects of positive hatred instead of being desirable. There is no depending upon these ever-changing sense-objects. And then the senses themselves are so delusive, they sometimes become diseased and give us false reports of nature or even fail sometimes, to do their proper functions. We can never depend upon these senses, which have developed themselves into their present state almost from being nothing, and they are sure in the long run to lose themselves in nothing. And then the mind!
(add Sanskrit)
II” (II-67). “When the mind is directed to follow the senses, it. drives off one’s power of judgment, as a wind drives before it a vessel in the waters.” There-can be really no end to the fears and miseries of a man, therefore, who depends-upon such a fickle mind, which in its turn depends upon the changing senses and the-changing matter, for happiness. At best, happiness to the men of the world means nothing more than avoidance of disappointment and danger. But it is only avoiding Scylla to fall into Charibdis. A worldly man is taken on and on from misery to misery and has no time to enjoy the one real happiness. To understand what real happiness consists in, one must turn to himself. The highest bliss is to be attained only when we can learn by self-analysis that-there is something immortal and perfect in us. Only then can we cease to fear death and to be i troubled by vain desires. It is only then that j life becomes bearable and even pleasant. This then is the utility of Dhyana Yoga, to point out to us the way of escape from misery and to vouchsafe perfect bliss even in this life.
The Need of Purification to the Worldly Mind
But the mind in its ordinary state is useless for the pursuit of this Yoga. The mind’s purity has been dimmed by external dirt. The subtle workings going on in the internal world cannot be reflected in such an opaque mind. Now, man becomes thick-headed mainly through his fault. The Yoga-Vasishtha thus describes the thickening process which a worldling’s mind undergoes. “By mistaking the not-self for self, by constant brooding over the body, by an inordinate selfish attachment to wife, children and other relations, the mind gets dull. By giving way to the egotistic spirit, by the free play of the dirty idea of * mine’ and by constant brooding over things with a sense of exclusive possession, dullness of mind sets in.” Again the mind has as it were, a natural out-going tendency and therefore finds it comparatively easier to study 'external nature. But when it has to turn back and study itself, the method becomes extremely difficult. It cannot be made to concentrate on itself, for, it is usually so fickle. Arjuna says in'the Gita “(add Sanskrit)
(add Sanskrit)” (VI-34). “Fickle indeed is the mind, Oh, Krishna, tormenting, strong and firm, I consider its control to be as difficult as that of the wind.” In order to fit the mind therefore for self-study it is necessary not only to subject it to a thorough cleansing process but also to concentrate its powers till they are thrown on itself. This double process constitutes the chief part of Dhyana Yoga.
Like any other thing in nature the human mind usually consists of Satwam, Rajas and Tamas. According to a theory of Dhyana Yoga, the substance of the mind in itself is made of pure Satwam, while the Rajas and the Tamas are merely accidents or supports. Rajas is the cause of its restlessness and Tamas makes the mind muddy and dull. As the extraneous Rajas and Tamas are removed, the mind returns more and more to its natural purity and the more Satwic it becomes, the more is it illumined with correct knowledge. This removal of Rajas and Tamas is known as Atma Vis'uddhi (self-purification)..
Two Steps in Purification
There are accordingly two steps in the method of this Yoga. First, Tamas has to be overcome,, and then Rajas. Rajas being a higher force must be utilised to conquer Tamas and Rajas will have to be controlled by Satwam. The aspirant of the Yoga is called (desirous of ascending) or “arre:” (having ascended) according as he is in the first or second stage. In the first stage, the mind is muddy and not clear it is inert and has to be roused to action. When it has learnt to be active enough, it is time for it to take to the second step. This is the tranquillising process. “(add Sanskrit)” (VI-3.) “For the sage wishing to ascend the Yoga of Meditation work is the means; to the same person when he has ascended the Yoga, tranquillisation is said to be the means.”* I * In this verse the word Karma is restricted to rituals by some. Even then the S'loka should be understood to mean that rites and rituals are intended as a preliminary fitep to rouse the soul, but real religion begins only with feeling of spiritual calmness. This is in effect the same assaying that Tamas is to be renounced before Rajas.
Karma or the Preliminary Stage
What are the characteristics of this early training called Karma? All measures taken here should have one object and that is sense-control. To select such actions as will tend to put a check on the ever active senses to keep the intensity of sense-desire and sense-hatred within proper bounds must be our sole aim. We should try to take up the Satwic action described in Karma Yoga. Unless the senses are properly trained in Karma Yoga, it is impossible to control them. It is possible to stop all sense-work but that will be useless, for a mind not qualified for the higher stage will ever keep thinking of sense-pleasures. (add Sanskrit)
(add Sanskrit) farmer ll*” (III—6-7.) “Whosoever restrains the organs of action but keeps thinking of sense-pleasures in his mind, that foolish person is said to be of a hypocritical conduct. But he who mentally restrains his senses and in a spirit of non-attachment undertakes Karma Yoga with the organs of action, is far better (than the other).” Work ■without attachment therefore, must be our rule of conduct at this stage. When by patient striving we attain the second stage, the next, method may be taken up.
There is a test which should be applied when the aspirant wants to know, whether he may profitably take to the second step, “qqT q l II” VI-4). “When one does not get attached to works for the sake of sense-pleasures, and haft given up all interested motives, one is said to be ft Yogarudha.” It is no doubt a long and difficult process, but unless a person has learnt to undervalue sense-pleasures, spiritual life has not begun for him. People often ask for a comfortable religion, a religion that reconciles a life of sensuality with spirituality, but it is only fair to say that there is no such religion. All great teachers have taught that the religious aspirant should never sell himself to the senses. On oof moral culture, on our purity, and on our capacity to free ourselves from the power of the senses, depends the attainment of spiritual bliss.,
Dhyana Yoga lays down that we ourselves make or mar oar life to a great extent. It is not that some malicious aad infinitely powerful being has control over us and finds pleasure iif subjugating us to the fluctuations of pleasure and pain, but that we in our foolishness make ourselves miserable, “(add Sanskrit)” (VI-5). “One should raise and should not hurl down himself; for, it is the self that is the friend of self and it is the self which is foe to self.” Man would be his own friend, if he controlled himself, and he would be his own enemy if he did not (VI—4). We should, therefore, try to raise ourselves by self-effort, that is by having recourse to Satwic actions, and then we shall.have done justice to the self within us. Company of the pious, the reading of books and the hearing of sermons, may quicken the birth of ■religious yearning in our heart, but the growth of spirituality entirely depends on the individual. A theological objection is sometimes raised against this position by saying that it precludes Divine Mercy. But the objectors forget that if God’s Mercy be unconditional, it makes the [Most Supreme Being partial. Why should not- His Grace descend to the saint and the sinner alike? The idea of Divine Mercy should not be so degraded as to lay the axe at the very root of righteousness. God’s Mercy depends entirely -on the moral perfection of the soul; for, He has no blood-money. So, even to vindicate God’s Mercy we have to admit individual liberty, for. Heaven helps those who help themselves. This doctrine of self-help inculcated by the Dhyana Yoga, has the additional advantage of removing all weakness. For, when we are sure that we are the effect of our own past actions and have it in our own power to shape our future, we are never cast down by failures, or disappointments, but learn the glorious lesson of trying to rise every time we fall.
We should therefore prove ourselves our own friends by conquering our self. Self-conquest is the most glorious that can be achieved by man, but it is not to be accomplished by marching Cohorts to shed human blood. This must be •the harmless war of the spirit against the flesh, the war of our higher nature carried on against •our lower nature. When our lower self is finally vanquished, our own highest self is gained. This is the greatest gain that can accrue to-rational beings. “q ■5RK” (VI-22). “After gaining which no other gain is considered greater.” For, in the words of Jesus, “What is a man profited if he shall gain the whole world and lose his own soul?”
The Second Stage or S’ama
When by Satwic conduct, a person has so far •conquered himself, as to realise that there is something higher than the sense-plane, he may enter upon the second course of Dhyana Yoga, to, ‘sot:’ or tranquillisation of mind. In all of us thought and action are acting and reacting. Our thoughts influence our acts as much as our acts influence the thoughts. Action is as it were the more concrete and better known of tbe two, and therefore we first begin by regulating our actions. But this necessarily implies a change in our thoughts, and a man who attends to his actions will soon learn to attend to his thoughts. The study and conscious manipulation of thoughts, is the second step of Dhyana Yoga. It must not be understood that henceforth the student of this Yoga,, gives up all actions and converts himself into a recluse, meditator. He only now gives more importance to his mind than to his external behaviour. A child first learns to walk and it masters this movement of the body after repeated trials. But it does not give up walking when it has thoroughly learnt it. It performs the movement most gracefully but instinctively and now can attend to some other business without caring how it walks. Thus, while a child has to-attend a good deal to its mode of walking for fear of falling, the same child as a boy performs that function properly and can afford to devote its thoughts to some higher work. In a similar manner, the Yogin who has learnt to manipulate actions successfully does it almost unconsciously and can without difficulty study the subtler act- ©f thought control.
Renunciation and Practice
Ihe grasping of the mind by itself is a most difficult step to take. It is something like a pair of tongs trying to turn round and catch it*- Self. Tet this apparently difficult feat has to be performed. The mind has already the power of acting reflexively on itself and this faculty has to be trained and developed. The object of such training must be to make the mind invulnerable. “(add Sanskrit)
" (VI-B3). “No doubt, Ob, strong-armed Arjuna, the mind is hard of control and restless, but through practice, Oh, son of Kunti, and through dispassion it is conquered.” In the first place practice is absolutely necessary. Reli- gion is not for those who want to have it for \ mere fashion. The majority of us are content to consider religion as merely one of the accomplishments. We just make a show of religion,— observe certain rites and rituals, say our prayers, read the holy books and then rest satisfied for ever. But one who wants to be a Dhyana Yogin, should be patient and persevering. He must probe more deeply into himself and be prepared to patiently investigate the self. Mere curiosity will be of no use. A close and constant application is needed. In the second place, freedom from worldly desires is also necessary. Man is being dragged hither and thither by a thousand vain desires, and never knows the calm necessary for self-study. So long as he is not dissatisfied, with the senses, he cqnnot taste of higher happiness,
What Is Renunciation?
This is the place for a little more detailed consideration of renunciation. Two words are used in the Gita to express this idea. They (add Sanskrit)” and “(add Sanskrit)” Sannyasa means giving up and Vairagya is desirelessness. There have been a certain order of monks technically called Sannyasins and because of the ascetic like practices of some of them, it has been the custom with some to suppose that the essentials of Sannyasa are asceticism. The word Virakta (dispassionate) likewise has been often misapplied to persons who are averse to the stern duties of life. Now, this strange notion seems to have been as old as the time of the Gita for, the author remarks “(add Sanskrit)2 the man who is merely without the household fire, nor the man who has given up all work.” Now, this S'loka does by no means disparage the order of Sannyasins, but only points out what constitutes the essential Sannyasa or renunciation. True renunciation does not depend upon one’s position, or rank, it does not depend on one’s food, dress or ways of living. It is nothing more than giving up of selfish acts •(XVTII-2). Vairagya is simply rising above desires, Man, as he is, is hampered by numerous desires which clash against one another. When he rises above them and lets them alone, they will fructify one after another leisurely.
In so many places have we spoken of giving up the senses, of freedom from worldly attachment and of rising above worldly desires, that an explanation seems due here. The Dhyana Yoga is not pessimistic. It does not say that the world is a mass of evil. At the same tim® it is not optimistic, for it does not think that the world is all-sufficient in its present conditions. The world is according to this view neither a charming heaven nor a hideous hell. It is a mixture of both. Dhyana Yoga says that what the world is to us, depends upon ourselves. So long as we sell ourselves to the senses and sub*- ject ourselves to numerous passions, there is no hope of happiness for us in this world. But when we cease to send piteous petitions to the senses, when we have learnt to be our own masters, we find that misery never was. “4'l*wter-
(add Sanskrit)
(V-26). “For persons free from desire or hatred, for the persons who have controlled their mind, and who have realised the self, everywhere is found the bliss of Brahman.” Renunciation of\ sense-pleasures therefore, should not be understood to mean asceticism and total abstinence from sense-pleasures; it is only keeping the senses under due control. Renunciation of the sense world-means that we should not allow ourselves to be enslaved by passionate sense-desires, but should ever remain masters of those desires. “The person who constantly broods over objects of sense, gets attached to them, from attachment arises desire, and from desire, hatred; from hatred proceeds indiscrimination and from indiscrimination comes loss of the recollection of truth; from such loss of memory*, the intellect is destroyed and one’s ruin is thus complete.” (add Sanskrit) “But enjoying the worldly things with senses free from desire or hatred and under due control, the self-controlled person attains calmness.” (II-64). It is no sin to enjoy the sense-objects, and it is by no means advisable that all sense-enjoyment is to be absolutely forsaken, for abandoning all sense-actions would be tantamount to reducing oneself to a clod of earth or a block of stone. The only thing necessary is non-attachment and control of the senses. This is just the doctrine which the Upanishad preaches, when it says “(add Sanskrit)” (Is'a.) “Therefore enjoy with renunciation.”
This gives the lie direct to the accusation sometimes brought against the Indian idea of renunciation, that it severs every tie, not only those of covetousness and evil passion but those likewise of duty and right affection. The Reverend N. Macnicol, for instance, holds this view of renunciation. He compares the method of renunciation with that of the religion of ‘Christ and says “The goal of the one method of deliverance is Samadhi, Nirvana, cessation of moral movement, silence attained by passing to the great home of silence which is Brahman. The goal of the other is fullness of life and moral activity in unimpeded fellowship with the source of life—harmony, joy and peace in the perfect fulfilment of function, in the freedom and the blessedness of love gladly rendered to the Lord of Love.”* Now, to show that the idea of Nirvana is fundamentally ill-conceived here, we have but to turn our attention to a single S'loka of the Gita (add Sanskrit)” (V-25). “It is they that reach the Nirvana of Brahman—those seers who are free from impurity, who have cut asunder their doubts, who are self-controlled and ever at work for the good of all beings.” The S'loka speaks for itself. It says Nirvana is neither cessation of moral activity nor
* The Religion of Jesus, by the Reverend Macnicol, M.A.,.page 6. severance of the ties of affection, but the very-opposite. Renunciation is not a severe frost killing the fair flower of right affection, but a warm sunshine to it. Renunciation does not sever brotherly ties but only nips in the bud selfish ties. On the other hand, it opens the gates of the human heart as wide as not humanity above all but creation. Persons who have renounced selfishness are the only ones that can love God’s children with any sincerity. The man of renunciation has indeed reached the home of solemn silence—the Brahman—he has indeed, attained the peace that passeth all understanding VI-15)—but his actions ever utter forth a glorious voice in reason’s ears. Every single action of his preaches the glory of the Divine Essence in unmistakeable language to a sequacious mind.
There is however a pseudo-renunciation which is justly to be condemned. It appears in many forms. In some it becomes laziness, and they assert that the giving up of activity is renunciation; in others, it takes the form of sense-hatred and they say that fleeing from the world to some secluded place is renunciation; in yet a third kind of people it assumes the form of ambition or greed and they want to give up their duty to try that of another, and to cover their mistake under the cloak of renunciation. Now, all such states of mind are the results of ignorance and not of enlightenment. On the other hand true renunciation proceeds from wisdom. It does not shun activity, much less moral activity. It does not hate the world of senses, though it does not lust after it. It does not give up duty, but feels unlimited joy, in discharging properly though disinterestedly whatever duties may devolve on it, on account of position in life.
Practice
So much for Vairagya or renunciation. We now turn to Abhyasa or practice. This practice is partly physical and partly mental. Physical practice will be the preliminary part, but the advanced and more important exercise will have to be mainly mental. Before beginning, the would-be Dhyana Yogin should first adjust his external life and regulate his food •dress and hab'its. He will have to eat good food, wear plain dress and observe moderation in his habits. The Gita does not attach much importance to these questions, for minute rules in such particulars are of no practical utility. It only states the. principle pp-
(add Sanskrit) (VI-17) For one who is moderate in eating and walking, who is moderate in his actions, and moderate in his sleep and wakefulness, Yoga becomes pleasant.” In brief, all extremes should be avoided; after the first preparations one may begin practising.
He must select a clean spot, say a room set apart for the purpose and there sitting in some •convenient posture practise Yoga. First, he must learn to sit in a firm, erect posture. Then he must regulate his breaths. He must keep. his eyes and other senses in their proper places so as not to allow them to wander away. This is all the physical portion of the practice. Now, the student may devote himself to the mind, (VI-11, 12, 13).
Now comes the concentration of mind. This is the most difficult part. It cannot be achieved all at once. 3TIR- JR: fRT II” (VI-25). “Slowly and steadily, should one recede with a courageous mind; having made the mind to stand in Self, we should stop thinking of anything else.” The outgoing tendency of the mind, is to be perseveringly checked. At first, it will be very difficult not to think: of something outside, but as we go on separating ourselves, as it were, from the mind and what it is doing, the waves in the mental ocean begin gradually to subside. The mind when it becomes an object of continued observation has the * trick’ of becoming quite calm in time.
Spiritual Bliss
When this calmness of mind is secured, we can realise ourselves as we are. Only then can we taste of real happiness, for all happiness is really inside, not outside. Just as in a flickering dim light a precious stone cannot be well examined and its worth correctly estimated, the true measure of happiness in a person cannot be seen by him of a wandering mind. But when lie has attained tranquillity, be knows what happiness means. He then sees that absolute happiness is beyond the senses, to be enjoyed by a spiritual mind alone (VI-21). Even in the case of sense-pleasures, it is the mind that enables one to enjoy, for, if the mind be detached from the sense, the sense-perception will be of no avail. Now, there are several faculties in the mind, and these are at work in various fields busily digging out happiness. Thus one faculty gives us intellectual happiness while another confers upon us the moral pleasures. The pleasures of thought are finer than those of the senses and moral happiness is infinitely finer than both of them. But the faculty of self-concentration in its highly developed state gives us a feeling which is called not pleasure or happiness, but spiritual bliss. It is evident that no subtlety of thought could secure us the experience of such bliss. Just as the eye can only, discern form but can say nothing about sound, the intellectual faculty is no judge in matters of spiritual bliss. There is a special faculty in ear mind which wishes to know what is bliss and this faculty works only when the mind has attained the power of self-concentration.
How do we know that this bliss is real and not an hallucination? Because once we begin to enjoy it, its destruction can never be conceived. When we do taste of it, our reason tells us that we always had this bliss in us and that we were never separated from it. If there were no such bliss already no exercise, spiritual or otherwise, could create it. This mine of felicity therefore is always within us. Happiness is ours by birth-right, but we have not had the good luck to use it. With infinite wealth hoard-ed at home we have gone out of ourselves to beg at the door of the five poverty-stricken senses.
When a man has realised true happiness or blessedness in himself, he sees happiness everywhere else, “(add Sanskrit) “To persons who have known the Self, the bliss of Brahman lies everywhere.” As a person is so he sees the world. Our notions of the world are derived from our own mind. So this Yogin having realised happiness in himself, sees happiness in every one else. In fact he sees the whole •world to be one’ Boundless Ocean of Bliss, of*' which the individuals represent so many waves* great or small. Each one represents to him. but the degree to which this Infinite Happiness has been manifested. Then it will be no mere intellectual assent with \im to say that God. indwells all beings, for, he never loses sight of •God, being in eternal communion with Him, (add Sanskrit)” (VI-30). “He who sees Me everywhere and sees every thing in Me, to him I do not become invisible nor is he away from Me.” Such a Yogi’s attitude may be best described, thus:—
“Happiness is the only good.
The time to be happy is now.1
The place to be happy is here.
The way to be happy is to make others so.’*
Secluded Life and Service to Humanity
There is a consideration by the way. This.Abhyasa or practice of Yoga necessarily implies frequent and sometimes prolonged retirement irom not only bad society but also good. First* *k will be necessary to associate with good persons and to avoid the company of persons whose ideas disturb the mind. Then it will be found more convenient to be alone, to think and meditate alone. (add Sanskrit)
(add Sanskrit)” (VI-10). " The Yogin should always practise in privacy, alone-and with the senses and mind controlled, with no desire or sense of possession.” This recommendation of practice in solitude has led some to think that the Gita is self-contradictory in as much as it recommends service to humanity and retirement from society at once.. But this is an obvious misconception. The practice refers to a preparatory stage, while the service to a later. The Yogin practising in seclusion can no more be blamed for his uselessness to the world than a student who goes for a time to the University to develop further his mental powers and to fit himself the better for life. The retirement of the Yogin will never take him to an utter blank wiped of all ideas of the universe, but it will bring him to this busy universe a richer and a wiser man offering the best fruits of his labours to all his brethren alike. The object of the Yogi’s practice is not aimless thought but a solemn preparation for useful life. All self-made men walked alone first and expected no others either to lead them or to accompany them in the noble and difficult path they chalked out for themselves. And then came the free mixing with society and ceaseless self-sacrifice. Ever in intimate touch with Reality (add Sanskrit) they could help mankind to enjoy a similar bliss
Indeed, it is the person who has by steady and 'persevering practice of devotion has realised the noble truth that the same Divine Essence lives in all beings, that can undertake with any sincerity and conscientiousness the task of benefiting humanity. A dark ray of selfishness will have stolen into the heart of the noblest person who has not realised any such link connecting, as it were, all humanity into one living chain. "The man of realisation, on the other band, has reached a state in which he can have equal regard for all beings. He has attained to the highest State of * Evenness of mind.’ “(add Sanskrit)” (VI-7, 8). In spite of heat or cold, pleasures or pains, praise or blame, the person who finding satisfaction in his knowledge and Anubhava remains immovable like the mountain and has conquered his senses is a Yogin that is perfect, to whom a lump of earth, a block of stone, or a nugget of gold is the same.” He has so far conquered’ his selfishness that nothing outside can influence him. And as for his behaviour, it is the same to all;
(VI-9). “He who has equal regard for benefactors, friends, foes, indifferent men,, well-wishers, persons deserving of hatred, relatives, saints and sinners—he is the best Yogin.” How does the Yogin show equal regard for all these? By wishing and doing good to all alike. Whatever may be the action and attitude of the public towards him he himself remains the same* He always lives a life of sacrifice. He calls upon all alike to do good, not by precept but by example. He makes himself one with his brethren and his universal sympathy attracts all towards him. He feels compassion for all groaning under suffering, sorrow and sin. He feels with the righteous their delight and satisfaction in spiritual life. He is ever ready to minister to the sick, to instruct the ignorant, to help the weak, to guide the intelligent, and to lead spiritual aspirants to self-realisation. He, in fact, bridges the gulf between the man of the world and the Highest God. Such is the ideally perfect Yogin,
“But what if we are not perfect in this life? Are we not losers either way?” This is an objection raised by the philosophy of utility. “The sense enjoyments have been renounced by the Yogin and the higher bliss is not attained, what then?” Now, this objection assumes that sense enjoyments are sure and the Yogin has forsaken them, and further that spiritual bliss is not guaranteed and therefore not worth striving for. The hollowness of both these assumptions will be dear to any one who has seen from the preceding pages that the Yogin does not in reality re? nounce' all sense enjoyment but only keeps the senses under control, and that the blissful nature of the human soul is an undoubted fact, which has only to be discovered, as it were, to be enjoyed. But the Gita gives another reply to this question just to meet the objector on his own ground. “The man who has failed in Yoga is born in rich and noble families or still better he is born in the family of wise Yogins themselves. A birth like this is indeed very difficult attain. In that life, the man gets the same Yogic ideas that he had in his former body, and again strives for perfection. For, in spite of himself he is carried away by the instinctive past habit. Even an ordinary student, who studies Yoga experimentally gets beyond the ritualistic fruits, but the Yogin who exerts with energy becomes purified and attaining perfection after many births reaches the highest goal.” (VI—41 to 44).
Reincarnation
The Gita does not attach much importance to the explanation of the much controverted question of Reincarnation but contents itself with giving some illustrations. It says that just as a person changes his old clothes for new ones, and just as the same man passes through different stages of life from childhood to old age, a person goes from body to body. We may conclude, therefore, that at the time of the Gita, as at present, the theory •of re-incarnation was' a settled doctrine with the Hindus3. Besides the Hindus, many other people have accepted the doctrine. In the scientific world, however, the belief in the doctrine is by no means universal. A great many scientists have written against it, while others equally illustrious have made assertions of their faith in the doctrine. Re-incarnation, on the whole, cannot be said to be a hopelessly -absurd doctrine, for, after all that is said against it, there are still many good features about it. We shall here give a few extracts from some of the most well-known writers of the West to show _ how these features are appreciated by them also;—
Prof. Max Muller says: “The popular mind of India seems never to have doubted the fact that every good or every evil thought or deed will grow and bear fruit, and that no one can ever escape from the consequences of his own acts and thoughts. Whether such a belief is right or wrong is not the question, but it produced at all events a deep sense of responsibility. Instead of complaints about the injustice and cruelty of God, people were taught that what seemed undeserved misfortunes, were fully deserved, were, in fact, the natural consequences of previous acts, and in one respect the safest means of paying off all debts. Philosophy at the same time held out a hope that in the end this net of consequences might be broken through, and the self, enlightened by true knowledge, might return to whence it came, return to himself and be himself; that is, be again the Universal Self, free for ever from the chains and pains of this transient episode of life on earth.”— (Page 511, Six Systems of Indian Philosophy).
Prof. A. A. Macdonell remarks: •*' The immovable hold it acquired on Indian thought is doubtless due to the satisfactory explanation it offered of the misfortune or prosperity which is-often clearly caused by no action done in this life. Indeed the Indian doctrine of transmigration, fantastic though it may appear to us, has the two-fold merit o.i satisfying the requirements of justice in the moral government of the worlds and at the same time in inculcating a valuable ethical principle which makes every man the architect of his own fate.”—(History of Sanskrit literature, page 388).
Miss S. E. Waldo writes: “Reincarnation and Karma are inseparably connected together and these two great laws rightly and completely understood show man that he alone is the Arbiter of his destiny, that he can no longer attribute his sorrows and sufferings to a mysterious Providence, that he can no longer trust to forms and creeds, but must arouse himself and set himself to correct past errors and learn to-inow his true nature.”
It would not be difficult to cite many other similar quotations. But it is only necessary fcere to point out that so far as the study of Dhyana Yoga is concerned, it is immaterial whether we accept the theory or not. Its practice and results concern the living present;and not a doubtful future. Its one important purpose is to show men how to keep up the balance of mind so as to be inured against out- influences. It does not entail belief in any theory whatever. The Yoga only proposes to point to a higher form of happiness than that obtained through the senses and says that happiness is subjective and not objective. To secure 4his bliss or rather to realise tbe blissful nature which is the permanent privilege of the soul, the -one means that Dhyana Yoga proposes is self-concentration aided by moral culture.
The Excellence of Dhyana-Yoga
The Gita has warm commendations of this Yoga.
(add Sanskrit)” (VI-46). “The Yogin is greater than the ascetic, he ia held to be greater than even persons distinguish- for intelligence, the Yogin is greater than the-worker, therefore be thou a Yogin, Oh, Arjuna.” We shall consider these statements in order. First the Yoga is better than asceticism. Asceticism in the sense of self-torture, is not only no pass-port to spirituality, but is also directly opposed to it. We have already quoted a s'loka which recptamends the avoidance of'
' extremes in habits, as a qualification for the Yoga. Here is another Gita text which directly condemns it. * * (XVII-5, 6).. “Those men who practise unscriptural hard asceticism, coupled with hypocrisy and vanity,, guided by lust of power and passion, know such people, to be of a demoniacal resolution, for they are tormenting the aggregate of beings, in the body, as also Me who am seated in the heart” (XVII-5, 6)..Asceticism is comparatively easy •of accomplishment. The most toilsome pilgrimages and the most painful penances are far easier and require infinitely less exertion than concentration of mind, and a moral life. It is only fair, however, to note here that all external, religious practice does not deserve a wholesale -condemnation. External forms, symbols, and practices are very often great helps to quicken the birth of spiritual life; and it is for this reason that forms and ceremonies have found a place in many religions of the world. That the concrete suggests the abstract and helps quicker perception of the same is now almost a truism. The man who would have people take only the real spirit of religion and mercilessly reject all outward practices, is comparable to one who wishes that the cocoa palm should bear fruit consisting of the kernel only, to the exclusion of the husk- The outward husk is not less useful merely because it is outside, for, it serves the important purpose -of protecting the precious internal kernel. So, -ascetic practices have worth of their own. But Yoga is their very kernel. Again, Yoga is higher than intellectual attainment. Reason, no-doubt, has its importance in the ascertainment of truth. But what is of much more importance to a man is that he actually realizes the truth he believes instead of being able to merely theorise. Now, such an immediate perception is possible only to the Yogin or a person who has learnt to control and focus his mind on that which he wishes to ascertain. Merely reading books on religion, hearing intelligent lectures, and even reasoning on them, though in themselves valuable enough, will be of no avail, if we do not exercise the feelings in accordance with the conclusions of reascja. Lastly, Yoga is greater than Karma. If Karma is understood to mean ritual the sentence needs no further explanation, after what has been said above about Tapas. But if we interpret the word to mean work, a remark is necessary. All work is but the perience of thought, and the best deeds of the great man of the world represent but a fraction of their greatness represented by their thoughts. Mmd-control is therefore vastly superior to works which are but the outward symbols of it. The world’s greatest men are always calm, silent and unknown. Even when they do not work they are not lazy, for, their noble thoughts spread with -infectious rapidity and influence thousands of good men who are thus stimulated to ceaseless activity. Thus the Dhyana Yogin is superior to the ascetic, superior to the philosopher, and superior to the man of work. As Emerson says “All men are commanded by the saint*” He is the master of the Universe. “Therefore become a Yogin” exhorts S'ri Krishna.
What is this Yoga? tl sir? “Evenness of mind is Yoga.” The Karma Yogin tries to control the thought-world by control of action, while the Dhyana Yogin controls his actions by thought control. Both are equally noble, for, thought and action are inseparably connected with each other. Really speaking therefore, nobody can be a perfect Karma Yogin, unless he has learnt the secret of control* and no one can get control over his mind, unless he has become a perfect Karma Yogin. Thought and action therefore have to be developed in parallel lines, the ideal of both being evenness or equanimity. This state is also called Samadhi which is a Sanskrit word meaning adjustment of the mind. All ordinary men have experience of two states known as the conscious and the unconscious respectively, the conscious being a higher state than the uncon- 8cious. In the unconscious state the functions of the mind are as it* were dormant, stupefied or stunted, and in the conscious state they are all working. By exercises of deep contemplation and devotion, the Yogin claims that the mind can be developed into a still higher state, where the mental faculties reach such a fineness, that the mind knows without reasoning, feels without passion and wills without egoism. This state is samadhi and he whose self-control has resulted in this supreme state of mind is called samahita (well-poised), Yukta (attuned to Yoga) and a Paramayogin (the best of Yogins).
1 From a consideration of S'lokas 10 to 17 of VI Chapter, which is expressly named DhyaDa Yoga, it will be clear that this Yoga might be called (add Sanskrit)” as generally known. But we have preserved the name ‘Dhyana Yoga’ not only because the other word is nowhere used in the Gita, but also because of the eight steps to Yoga {.Baja Yoga) the first five are considered the external (or secondary) in contradistinction to those beginning with. Dhyana which are internal (or primary).
2 (add Sanskrit) “He who does his duty not depending upon results, he is the real Sannyasin, he is the real Yogin,
3 Of. “The theory that every individual passes after death into a series of new existences in heaven or hell or in the bodies of men and animals or in plants on earth where it is rewarded or punished for all deeds committed in a former life, was already so fairly established in the 6th century b.o. that Buddha received it without question*”—(Page 386, History of Sanskrit Literature, by Prof. A, A. Macdonell.)
Jnana-Yoga, or the Yoga of Knowledge
Jnana (knowledge) in the Vedanta philosophy plays a part which neither work nor love nor yet meditation does. The Upanishads are never tired of praising knowledge, and they make it the non of salvation. The Bhagavad-gita as the best) symposium of all genuine Upanishadic doctrines is no less warm in its encomiumsion Jnana. “Even if thou be the most sinful of all sinners all sin thou shalt cross •over with the aid of the boat of knowledge alone.” {IY-36). “Knowing which you will be free from all evil.” “Knowing which all' sages Attained supreme perfection.” (XIV-1).“Knowing which one reaches immortality.”• These sdokas bear testimony to the very high place which the author of the Gita accords to Jnana.
Knowledge Is Not Mere Speculation
But what is this Jnana? Some have thought that it is no more than a speculative process and the relation that man enters into with God or the Highest Truth whatever that may be, is often declared to be non-moral. Jnana, in fact, is erroneously identified with vain enjoyments and conjectures of reason to the exclusion of all moral sympathy and affection. That the exposition of the philosophy of Jnana Yoga necessarily requires the exercise of reason just as much as other Yogas do or even a little more, is admitted. It is to the credit of this Yoga that it uses the best instrument yet known to man for the ascertainment of the truth. The dizzy heights to which reason ascends in this Yoga does, it is conceded, prove too much for undeveloped intellects. But to say that It* ignores morality or is opposed to it, is, to be mild, an untruth. Philosophy opposed to religion and morality is unknown to Vedantic works in general and to the Gita in particular. The -Juana of the Gita is not merely reasoned belief, though this knowledge is by no means against the use of the intellectual faculty. This Jnana.is nothing short of the realisation of the one truth worthy of knowing, and living up to the conclusions of practical reason.
Qualifications for Jnana
Knowledge as properly understood is the accumulation of information—a collection of all past experience of men. But real knowledge is a reference to ourselves. Original knowledge is possible only when we turn away from books, teachers, and instructors and literally educate ourselves (draw forth our wisdom). All great men whether of religion, philosophy or science, discovered knowledge not in books or other outside helps but in themselves. Of course tha vast store of knowledge handed down by our forefathers deserves respect and is worth careful study. Certainly guides and teachers are necessary to suggest methods. The Gita in full recognition of this says, “(add Sanskrit)
(add Sanskrit)” (IV-34). “Know that this knowledge is got by reverence,, enquiry, with humility and personal service rendered unto teachers. These knowers who have seen the truth will initiate you into knowledge.” But unless the aspirant exerts himself with the necessary qualifications, nothing results from mere outside helps. A teacher can suggest methods and remove obstructions, and there his business ends. If you wish that I should share with you the enjoyment of a beautiful picture, all that you can do, is to show me that picture, and to commend it to me. But if I have not the eyefor beauty, can you help? Andifl happen to be short-sighted, bow could you help? You may give me a pair of glasses, and thus assist me a little, that is all. But the innate defect cannot be cured. So unless there are the requisite qualifications, the student is not fit for Jnana Yoga. These qualifications are enumerated in the following sloka “” (IV-39). “The man of faith who is persevering and has controlled the sense* attains knowledge.” To a person working with these requisites, knowledge unfailingly shines forth of itself.
Let us now examine these three pre-requisites. In the first pla?e, faith is necessary. Nothing was ever achieved without faith. In Carlyle’s words, “Faith is great, life giving.” Religion without faith, philosophy without faith, is dry as dust. Faith is not blind belief or a mere mental assent to a doctrine. It is an innate faculty of man, through which we work out and find the truth. When looking at a certain obvious set of phenomena in external nature or in the mind, we leap to the conclusion that there must be a more complicated set behind them, we exercise faith. To find out the.purpose of a new machine, which we never saw before, we exercise our faith and find it out. Finding out the true significance of letters and words of a forgotten ancient language requires the exercise of faith. This faith is quite necessary for the student of Jnana Yoga. The person 'who studies nature as a whole and sees in it an Infinite series of shifting scenes is forced to ask himself “Is this real? If not, what is the real His heart becomes possessed of the one strong belief that there must be something permanent behind this constantly changing nature and he strives accordingly to find it out. First, he has-the faith in himself. He is fully convinced that he has the instrument and capacity required for the search. Secondly he is as fully persuaded that there is a Reality in this changing Universe and is worth knowing, a reality in fact, “Knowing which nothing remains to be known.” (VII-2). It is this intense faith that saves a man. “(add Sanskrit) (IV—40).. “The person who without knowledge and without faith indulges in doubt, destroys himself; for the sceptic there is neither this world nor the other, nor is there happiness for him.” There is of course a wise harmless scepticism’ which is quite necessary for every one. We should all weigh well, and consider well before we believe. But the sceptic whose creed is-made of denial and doubt, a person whose motto is universal unbelief is dangerous to himself as well as to society. No happiness material or spiritual can exist for him. For all progress, at least a tentative faith is necessary, and there is no where else so much need for this as in religion. This, faith as distinguished from assumption and superstitious belief is the first qualification for Jnana Yoga.
In the second place, persistence is required ' for such a student. Enlightenment does not come in a moment. First, the truth has to be heard. Heading of good books and listening to expositions of wise men is the very first step. Many have neither the inclination nor the capacity for enjoying abstract thoughts. Well has the Kathopanishad declared that “Many cannot hope even to hear of God.” “;r This hearing presupposes a dissatisfaction with the existing state of things and an intense desire to find something more trustworthy. The ordinary man knows that the world is an awful mixture of good and evil and snatches what pleasures he can. He wants to make the best of it. He receives harder and harder blows but does not awaken. When after hard experience, he learns that it is difficult to enjoy without suffering, and that he must go beyond the world of sense enjoyment to get the infinite peace of mind, he exercises his faith, His heart then tells him that behind the pair of opposites (add Sanskrit) there is something very permanent. It is then he begins to hear about Ood and other things of the sort. This hearing is the first step. The second step is to think over what has been heard. Mere hearing would be of no avail if we never bestowed any after-thought on the matter. We should think it out day and night, till it becomes a habit with us. As a philosopher says,
” “The whole time up to sleep, the whole period of life up to death if necessary, is to be spent in thinking on truth.” This thinking occupies a most important part of Jnana Yoga. Reason is to be pushed to its utmost limit and legitimate conclusion here. No church or creed, no book or doctrine, no authority of how-so-ever reputed an infallibility, should be deemed suffi-dent to form a belief unless reason is satisfied in the matter. To follow right reason where-so-ever it may lead us, and cheerfully to take the consequences with undaunted courage, must be the spirit with which the student of Jnana Yoga works. After this thinking comes the profound meditation of the truths so thought out. Reasoning by itself is not sufficient. It can wipe off superstitions and it can dispel doubts. The truth to which reason points should be meditated upon, felt and made the very essence of practical life. When we are convinced of what is the truth, our business must be to live the truth. To feel truth intensely till we are identified with it as it were, is the third and last step. It is then that realisation is complete and one becomes a Jnana Yogin. To be willing to have this dogged persistence throughout, to patiently hear, think, and to feel till we realise the truth is the second qualification required of the student of Jnana Yoga.
Finally, the control of the senses, is an absolutely necessary qualification of the would-be Jnana Yogin. For, many temptations come in his way. The first temptation will be to think that it is foolish to try to transcend the senses. The sense-pleasures are so dazzling that they sometimes induce us to think with the Old Charvakas (Materialists of Ancient India) that all religion and philosophy is the concoction of fools or cheats. To think that life is well enough and that we need not bother ourselves at all about anything beyond, will be the first temptation. Again, love of sensuality may tempt us to imagine an eternal future world or a future state in which we shall have all play and no work, all good and no evil, where we shall eat, drink and make merry but never suffer. But the student of Jnana Yoga has to see clearly that this cannot be. He should.be perfectly satisfied as to the hollowness and destructible nature of all sensual pleasure either here or hereafter. We may accumulate as much as we like of the means to sense-enjoyment, we may get the patronage of Kings or even Gods to assist us in such accumulation, but at the end of such enjoyment, we are certain to be miserable. ft 5W forrs foorfor” (IX.—21)- “Having enjoyed the vast world of pleasure,- they then at the end of their good fortune enter the world of mortals.”1 Sense-indulgence ends in death and destruction, but control of the senses-leads God ward; knowing this one should constantly exercise sense-control. This is the third: qualification for Jq’ana Yoga.
The Knowledge of Kshetra and Kshetrajna Spoken of as “The Knowledge” in Jnana-Yoga
Which is the knowledge to be gained by such a student? It is the knowledge of matter and soul and their distinguishing properties. What knowledge is more important than that which -concerns our ownselves, and our relations to our surroundings? That part of philosophy that with the essence of ultimate truths, the reality in us a9 well as in other things around us, is justly regarded as the Crown of philosophy. S'ri Krishna accordingly says “wsrra mm" (XIII—3)*. “The knowledge of Kshetra and Kshetrajna is that which is deemed by Me as the best knowledge.” Now, Kshetrajna and Kshetra are in modern philosophy known as subject and object respectively, and we may use these terms in connection with the Gita also if we keep in mind the following description:—
We shall first consider the teaching of the Gita about the kshetra (the object) (add Sanskrit)
(add Sanskrit)
(XIII—6-7). “The great elements, Ahankara, Buddhi and the Avyakta, the ten
*This numbering of the verses in the thirteenth chapter, assumes that the first a’loka begins i( JPf An....-..99 etc., which is omitted in certain editions. senses and the one miDd and the five objects-of the sense; desire and hatred, pleasure and pain, the aggregate, intelligence, firmness,. —this here described in brief, is the kshetra with its modifications.” To put this in more intelligible or rather modern language—the senses together with their objects (whether forming our own bodies iVr objects outside) which constitute gross matter, and the mind with all its modifications, known to eastern philosophy as subtle matter, are the kshetra ('object). That the gross body and the gross things around us are objects of knowledge and as such depend on a subject is almost self-evident to any one. But that the mind is no less an object—though finer and subtler than other objects—is a little difficult to understand. But this will be clear on a little reflection. Desiring or hating, feeling happy or miserable and performing other similar functions, the mind is itself subject to constant fluctuations; for, it grows, develops and decays. These changes of the mind no less than those of the body, are the object of the knowledge of a something which i must be itself changeless*. The changes of the mind and the changes of the body act and react on each other, but stand ever separate from their cogniser. All these changes, gross and subtle, of the body as well as of the mind, form the kshetra.
Let us now turn to kshetrajna. “He who knows this kshetra is called kshetrajna by the knowers of these (the subject and the object).” The body has no intelligence of its own. It cannot be self-conscious. Nor can the mind, if -we take mind to mean that which desires, hates, wills, imagines, remembers, doubts, reflects, thinks and performs various other functions. But that which subsists all the changes of the mind, and recognises all such changes as a witness ■ unaffected by them, must be itself changeless ' and this enduring aspect of ourselves is what is known as Atman and kshetrajna.
Subject and Object Presupposed in Every Knowledge
Before entering into a detailed examination kshetrajna, it will be necessary to consider one important point. All knowledge presupposes subject and object or kshetra and kshetrajna as the Gita calls them. We cannot therefore conceive of the beginning or cause of •either the subject or the object, for even that conception should have to presuppose-subject and object. Hence the Gita says “(add Sanskrit) (XIII—20). “Know that Prakriti and Purusha are both beginningless.” This Prakriti is'f-he same as kshetra, for, the next half of the same S'ioka says “(add Sanskrit) Know that the modifications and the Gunas (Satwam, Rajas, and Tamas) are born of Prakriti.” We have already referred to the Gunas while discussing Karma Yoga. All the changes brought about by the forces of nature whether these changes be gross or subtle are in Prakriti or kshetra. Kshetrajna is also known as Purusha or Person. The Gita thus defines the Prakriti and the Purusha “(add Sanskrit) That which is the occasion of cause and effect and agency, is called Prakriti; the perceiver of pleasure and pain, is said to be Purusha.” Here we must notice that causality is possible only in time and space. Therefore I that which philosophers call “(cf. S'ankar Bhashya on sutras I, 1-1-2) or space,, time and causality is included in Prakriti. That which, so to speak, senses or feels, is the Purusha. All human knowledge is based upon this distinction and opposition of Purusha and Prakriti, of kshetra and kshetrajna or as we may now express it, of subject and object.
(add Sanskrit)” (XIII—27). “Whatever is born, whether unmoving or moving, know that to be from a commingling of kshetra and kshetrajna. Oh,, the best of Bharata’s race!”
The Natural Purity of the Soul
We have already seen that the essence of kshetra is to be changing. We have also seen that kshetrajna to be the perceiver of this change must itself be changeless. But it is within our experience that kshetrajna or Purusha has also the knack of identifying himself with pleasure, paiD, or with some one modification of the mind. This double aspect of kshetrajna it is important to remember, for, from this circumstance, Jnana Yoga deduces a valuable corollary. According to Jnana Yoga, the soul is "by nature pure and happy, but gets into sorrow and suffering by its identification with Prakriti or change. “(add Sanskrit)
ipreift SST”(XIIT —22). “The Purusha experiences the Gunas of nature by identification with Prakriti; the cause of such experience (of sq al) in good or bad life, is its attachment to the Gunas.*’ This self-identification with Prakriti is Ajnana (ignorance) and the consequent experience of alternating pleasure and pain is Samsara (circling round) as popularly called by Vedantic philosophers.
Ignorance
Jnana Yoga therefore preaches that the self is always free, and bondage is nothing but this ignorance or identification with Prakriti. “(add Sanskrit) “Knowledge is enveloped in ignorance, it is hence that beings befool themselves.” This is the most logical position about the self or soul, for the soul cannot be both free and bound at the same time. If it is bound, that is, if its nature is to sow and reap sweet and bitter fruits, if this be its essential nature then nothing can make it free. For, as the great Sures'- waracharya says “(add Sanskrit)” “If the Atman is of the nature of a doer, etc., then do not hope for freedom therefrom; for the nature of things cannot be removed just as for instance, the heat of the sun (cannot be removed).” If it is our nature to be subject to fluctuations of pleasure and pain, what is the good of trying to alter it? If on the other hand, the self is pure and free, by nature, it is impossible for anything outside to influence it or make it bound. Hence the ancient philosophers of India contended that the soul is by nature free, and that the only real bondage is ignorance. “W* srst:” “As’ there can be no alternative, (we have to admit that) indiscrimination is the only bondage,” says the Sankhya Sutra (VI—16). “(add Sanskrit)
* * “Ignorance is the productive field of the following (four pain-bearing obstructions) whether these be dormant, attenuated, overpowered or expanded,” says the Yoga Sutra (II—4). •*RKWWIW*f: •” “Misery, birth, activity (with attachment), sin, false knowledge, of these those following in succession being removed, the immediately preceding in each case is removed and the result is freedom,” says the Nyaya Sutra (I-1.2).
Hence it fallows that the experience of the 1 pleasures and pains of this world is only while ignorance lasts. It is only apparent, but the real nature of the soul is freedom. All great men have preached this idea and all religions preach that the apparent life of man is an empty dream,2 and misery and weakness are not the essential nature of the soul- The individual soul vu originally pure and perfect, and this purity and perfection is to be regained once more. This is a universal idea. The Mahabharata says that at first, all men were righteous. And then error began to assail their hearts. This clouded their perception and they became covetous. Covetousness gave rise to further confusion and then the Vedas disappeared. (*rrcf 3 m 3 1
4—10) the notion, so prominent in the later system, that the material world is all illusion, is first met with. The world is here explained as an illusion produced by Brahman as a conjurer. This notion is, however, inherent even in the oldest Upanishads. It is virtually identical with the teaching of Plata that the things of experience are only the shadows of the real thing and with the teaching of Kant that they are only phenomena of the thing in itself.” (p. 221, History of Sanskrit Literature, by Prof. A. A. Macdonell).
“To his (Mahomed’s) eyes it is forever clear that this world wholly is miraculous. He said what all great think* era, the rude Scandinavians themselves, in one way or the other, have contrived to see, that this so solid-looking material world is, at bottom, in very deed, Nothing, is a visual and tactual Manifestation of Hod’s power and presence, m shadow hung-out by Him on the bosom of the void Infinite;, nothing more.”—(Carlyle: on Heroes, Lecture II). The story of Adam’s fall by Satan’s influence has a similar meaning behind it. According to Zoroastrianism, man’s deterioration is due to Ahriman’s influence. The Buddhistic theory of Nirvana also implies this doctrine. All religious accounts of man’s downfall agree in this, that the downfall ' has been due to man’s own lolly. This fault is no other than ignorance. For, how else could a pure soul degrade itself? Therefore only the wise man who has attained knowledge realises this freedom. “smi
(V—16). “To those however, whose ignorance has been dispelled by enlightenment, knowledge like the bright sun reveals the Highest.” It is only a wise man that knows that Kshetrajna is eternally free and changeless, and as such the only reality.
The Gita on the Real
We have stated at the commencement of this book that the Bhagavadgita is Brahma-Vidya, the philosophy of the Real and Yoga-S'astra the science of Yoga or Equanimity.3 This is a fit occasion to consider what the Gita has to say on the question of the Beal since in Jnana Yoga the knowledge of Brahman or the Beal and the means to the realization thereof overlap each other. The Gita says “tmrpfr
(add Sanskrit) (II-16).
Of the unreal there is no existence, and of the Beal there is no non-existence,—the true nature of both (the Beal and the unreal) has been found out by seers of truth.” According to this definition, therefore, that which ceases to be at any time cannot claim to be regarded as Beal. Applying this definition, we find that no one thing in the world satisfies this test except Universal consciousness or as the Gita with the Upanishads calls it the Brahman.
About Brahman, the teachings of the Gita present the condensed essence of all the Upanishads. In fact, the word Brahman, denoting the ultimate reality, and the various epithets rahasya, construes the expression (add Sanskrit) as being equivalent to It will be shown, in the concluding remarks of the present work, that Mr. Tilak’s interpretation is not correct. applied to Brahman in the Gita are all directly from the Upanishads themselves. As if to confirm this view, the author calls his book, itself an Upanishad, though according to tradition the Gita has been generally regarded as a Smriti in contra-distinction to S'ruti under which head the Upanishads are always classed. The full title of the work j'4 “Bhagavadgitopanishad” as has been already pointed out and this clearly shows that the author intended the work to be an essence* of
It is obvious that in its present form the Gita does not pretend to be more than the essence of the Upanishads. Swapnes'wara, the commentator on S'andilya Bhakti Sutras, however, makes the further claim that the Gita being the direct utterance of the Lord is in truth a part of the Veda. His contention loses much of its force when he says that the very verses came forth from the lips of Sri Krishna and were subsequently embodied by Vyasa in his great epic. Even the quotation on the sole authority of which he founds hie argument, simply states that the Gita escaped from the lips of S'ri Krishna but lends no support to the supposition that the phraseology as well as the thought is Krishna's.
Prof. Hopkins has a theory that the Gita was originally an Upanishad and that it was subsequently re-written as a Vaishnavic poem, and once more re-arranged so as to include elements of Krishnaism. This theory has not however, commanded universal acceptance, as it has no convincing evidence to support it. the Upanishads. The view is endorsed by the verse “(add Sanskrit) All the Upanishads are kine, Krishna is the milkman, Arjuna is the calf, and wise men the enjoyers of the ambrosia Gita, which is thus milked.”/
Now, the central doctrine of the Upanishads is that while the objective world is ever changing, the subject, the soul, never changes and is therefore the only reality The Gita refers to this important Upanishadic doctrine, when it says “Of the real there is no non-existence.” According to Jnana Yoga, then, this reality being our own self there is no fear of its ever dying. For, reality is that which never changes or dies.. That which witnesses all changes must be itself changeless, and therefore, says the Gita, for the person who has realised his true self there can be no more misery, fear or any other imperfection. The Kshetrajna is, in fact, perfect; but through ignorance he is thought imperfect. He is the One changeless Reality, but trembles in fear of misery and death. To put it in Emerson’s language “Every man is God playing the fool.”
A thick veil of ignorance envelopes us. Error has assailed us according to the Mahabharata. The sin of Adam has descended unto us according to the Christians. The temptations erf Mara have enticed us according to the Buddhists. It is the same fact, put in different language. “(add Sanskrit) Knowledge is enveloped in ignorance.” We have to overcome this ignorance, we have to take off this veil for then there will be no more fear, no more misery, no more death. The person who has realised the real self sees that misery never was, but all misery came through identification with Prakriti and her acts. “(add Sanskrit)
ScR q qrq sfer *” (II—19). “He who considers him to be the killer, and he who thinks killed, both of these know not; for he neither killeth nor is killed.” “(add Sanskrit) (II—20) “He is neither born nor does be ever die; nor will he having existed cease to exist again; unborn, ever-lasting, unchangeable, and prime-j val, he is never killed when the body is killed •”
Jnani’s Actlessness—What It Means
This view of the purity and actlessness of the soul has sometimes evoked undeserved criticism. Bishop Caldwell for instance, thus remarks on the Gita doctrine.—“A man accused of murder neither denies his guilt nor pleads that he committed the act in self defence but addresses the Court in the language of Krishna. ‘It is needless/ he says ‘to trouble yourselves about the enquiry any further, for it is impossible that any murder can have taken place. The soul can neither kill, nor be killed. It is eternal and indestructible. When driven from one body it passes into another. Death is inevitable, and another birth is equally inevitable. It is not the part, therefore, of wise men like Judges of this Court to trouble themselves about such things.’ Would the Judges regard this defence as conclusive? Certainly not. Nor would it be regarded as a conclusive defence by the friends of the murdered person or by the world at large? The criminal might borrow from the Gita as many sound nothings as he liked, but the moral sense of the community would continue to regard his murder as a crime.” Now, the Judges of the Court if they had any humour at all to pay this supposed murderer in the same coin, could easily give him the following reply.. “Please note that the soul neither enquires nor sentences you to punishment. Besides, no harm can be done to your soul by punishment, for really it is beyond all punishment, being eternal and indestructible. But your body and mind disregarded the purity of the soul, and paid no respect to the pure soul enshrined in the body; so they will have tobe punished.” The impure mind of a murderer can have no conception of the purity of the soul. There is no reason whatever, therefore, to suppose that the ideas of freedom and purity of the soul preached to the world would produce any difficulty in practical life. On the other hand, there is every hope that it will prove a sure foundation for moral life. If one is made to believe that he is pure and free by nature and that this purity has to be manifested, he would know that to commit anything wrong is self-degradation while to do anything right is a step towards the re-attainment of self-purity. Hence any fear that this doctrine might prove dangerous to practical life should be con- ■sidered entirely groundless.
“But,” it may be asked, “what about the doctrine of the soul’s being inactive,—the theory that it never acts nor is acted upon? Does it not lead men to laziness and indifference?” This objection woefully misunderstands the teaching. The soul is according to Jnana Yoga certainly beyond work, that is, work can produce no effect on it. In this sense the soul is no doubt actless, “rwrq: 1
(XIII—31) ‘This undecaying supreme soul, being beginningless and void of Gunas, though seated in body, Oh, son of Kunti, neither acts nor is defiled (by acts).” But this does not mean that the soul identifies itself with Tamas and becomes inactive. Inactivity or indifference is the lowest manifestation of Prakriti, whereas the real soul is not only above Tamas and Rajas but also above Satwam. Hence its nearest approach is Satwam, and Satwic action is in reality actlessness. The Jnana Yogin, indeed, is compelled by no necessity to work, for he has realised his pure nature which is beyond work or duty. Jrrcsri I W
(add (III—17-18). “He who rejoices in the self and is satisfied in the self only, for him there is nothing to do; for him there is no interest either in what is done or what;',s not done here, nor is tb*-re in all beings anything on which he has to depend.” He is beyond all selfishness and selfish work is therefore impossible for him. But for this reason it cannot be argued that Jnanin is precluded from doing any action. He works for the well-being of the world not by any selfish desire or by a sense of duty, but because it has become his habit to work selflessly. “Hrur: faacisl vtrcti
(HI—25). “A wise man desirous of effecting Loka Sangraha.without attachment should also work, Oh, descendant of Bharata, just as the ignorant do with attachment to action” Loka Sangraha is harmony, or welding hearts together. This working for harmony is the very characteristic of the ideal Jnana Yogin, for it is-only in such work that the actless Brahman is realised. Hence it is stated elsewhere, “
(add Sanskrit) A wise one should work here. Oh, tormentor of foes; those that are inactive are the inanimate things but not human beings.” Therefore when a Jnanin is said to be actless, it should never be understood that he leads a lazy life. Every man works for himself. But the idea of ordinary men about the self is very narrow. The Jnanin also works for the self, but the self in his case is identified with the Real Self of all the universe. Hence his work is for Loka-Sangraha4 which literally means ‘embracing the whole world He never works for a single body, he works for all bodies. He never works for a single mind, he works for all minds. His activity is therefore the most intense. Only he has realised that all selfish action is foolish and also that the Real Self being beyond Prakriti (time, space and causation) is in reality beyond action.
The Nature of Kshetrajna
But to pursue our enquiry into the nature of Kshetrajna. We have seen that Kshetrajna is really pure and perfect, being ever beyond all limitations, time, space and causality. Having no limitations therefore Kshetrajna must be really infinite, and as we cannot conceive of two infinites, it f( Hows that the reality behind all phenomena is one and the same. This is what Sri Krishna declares “(add Sanskrit)” (XIII—3). “Know Kshetrajna to be Me, In all kshetras, Oh, descendant of Bharata.” Thus Kshetrajna is in reality no other than Brahman. Now, another fact remains to be considered. This unchanging universal consciousness or Brahman, which is the self of things is the only Reality, for it satisfies the definition “Of the real there is no non-existence.” It never ceases to exist. The objective tilings not satisfying this test of reality are therefore unreal. The objects being finreal, the subjectivity of Kshetrajna is also seen to be unreal; for the subject is inconceivable without an object. From the highest standpoint of philosophy; therefore, the Brahman or supreme self i neither subject nor object though it is the reality behind both. Hence the Gita calls both Kshetra and Kshetrajna, manifestations of the supreme soul “(add Sanskrit) (VIII—4-5). “Earth, water, fire, air and ether, manas, Buddhi and Ahankara thus eightfold is My manifestation. This is the lower, but other than this, know My higher manifestation which has become the Jiva, Oh, strong-armed, by which (manifestation) this world is upheld.” From this it follows that while all manifestations in the universe may be looked upon, from one standpoint of view as proceeding from the supreme soul without which they have no independent existence, these manifestations cannot be said to be a permanent property of that Being inasmuch as they da not always exist in it. This is expressed by S'ri Krishna in the following apparently paradoxical statements. “All beings dwell in Me, and I do not dwell in them; nor dp being a dwell in Me, behold My divine Yoga * (IX-4, 5). Though this universal soul or Brahman is the only reality from a philosophic point of view, the word “real” cannot be said to fully describe it, for in common parlance we apply the term “real” to things that have a permanent existence in the wakeful state. If that which persists in the wakeful state is real, that which persists through all states of consciousness should be more than real. Of course unreal would be an evident misnomer for Brahman. Hence the Gita says “q” (XIII-13). “It is said to be neither real nor unreal.”
The Brahman
In considering the nature of Kshetrajna, we are thus necessarily dragged to the consideration of the Brahman. Five s'lokas of the thirteenth chapter of the Gita give a description of the Brahman. We have merely referred to this passage in the introductory chapter. It is now necessary to consider it at some length, This passage contains many assertions of apparently contradictory epithets and we shall here give a free translation of it, adding any explanatory words or phrases that may be necessary. “Though it has no form in truth, yet there is no form which appears independently of it. Hence it is described as having hands and feet on all sides, eyes, ears, and faces everywhere. Indeed though nothing can be predicated of it, yet whatever we predicate of anything, can never exist separate from Brahman. In this sense, therefore it may be said to possess all properties. Being beyond space it cannot be located in any particular place, but yet whatever we see inside or outside exists only in Brahman, and so we might also say that it is, in essence, everywhere. Being the subtlest part of our selves, it can never be said to be knowable; so it is very distant from the knowledge of the ignorant, but being our very Self, it is nearer than the nearest and it is the only existence of which we can be emphatically confident. It is the one undivided reality in all beings, though owing to extraneous forms of an unreal nature, it seems to be many and distinct. As nothing in the universe has an existence independent of Brahman, and is finally seen to be unreal when compared to it, the whole of the universe may be said to proceed from Brahman, exist in Brahman and return to Brahman. It is the light of lights, for neither the sun nor the moon nor the stars could shine -of themselves without Brahman, while Brahman is self-luminous. Therefore it M beyond all darkness, for what darkness can ever enter j'lto that which is ever-luminous? In a
I’ word, what we call the means of knowledge is this Brahman, what we call the knowable is also this Brahman in truth, and what we call knowledge, the result of knowing, is also really this Brahman. This Brahman is seated and can be realised in the heart of every one that wishes to do so.” Such is the Brahman, as described in the thirteenth chapter.
The Use of This Knowledge
We shall now consider the use of this knowledge. The first use will be that we shall get a sure basis of morality. It is often taught by religions that we should love-our neighbour like ourselves. But why should we do so? This can be explained only in Jnana Yoga TO (XIII*29). “Seeing the same residing everywhere, one does not injure •elf by self, and therefore reaches the highest goal.” When man realises that his neighbour is his own self, how can he hate him? “forr-
(add Sanskrit)
(V-18). “The wise regard with equal impartiality, a learned and well-behaved Brahmin, a cow, an elephant, a dog and an out-caste.”5' This universal love exercised equally towards all beings will be the direct effect of knowledge. Knowledge supplies a good criterion of right and wrong. Whatever tends to unite beings to harmony, to Loka Sangraha as the Gita puts it, is right. Whatever separates beings and tends to create discord is wrong. Jnana again enables a person to be inured to all external influences. Having learnt to identify himself with the Great Reality beyond the three Gunas constituting Prakriti, the Jnanin is secure against the influence of Gunas. (add Sanskrit)
(add Sanskrit)” (V—20)1 " The firm minded and ever watchful knower of Brahman taking stand in Brahman as he does, would not be puffed up with prosperity nor cast down by ill-fortune.” Not that he avoids the world and its doings. He may mis with society how much-so-ever he likes, he may undertake the most fatiguing work, he will yet never lose sight of the one reality with which he has identified himself. He ever maintains Yoga or evenness of mind, in virtue of which he is never disturbed. ‘‘ft *£or (add Sanskrit) (V—8-9). “The knower of truth would consider himself as not acting at all in reality, though apparently he is seeing, hearing, touching, smelling, eating, going, sleeping, breathing, weeping, leaving, taking, opening or shutting the eyes, ever noting that it is the senses that act on the sense objects.” The Jnana Yogin alone can work best because he gets never attached to his work, and by his identification with the universal con- •ewufiness, has acquired the power of doing tmimpassioned work. He incessantly works for harmony and at the same time ever keeps in view the principle that consciousness which is his real self, is above all actions. He is, in a word, in the World but not of it. \j
The Necessity of Religious Practice to Attain Jnana
Before we leave Jnana Yoga, it is necessary to sound a note of warning. It is quite easy for every one to say “I am by nature pure and blessed and above action,” but to show this in practical life is very difficult. The Gita says
(add Sanskrit)” (II—29),
One man looks on this self as a marvel and so also another talks of it as a marvel, while a third man listens with equal wonder, but no one even having heard, knows this (Atman) aright.’' The purity, blessedness and actlessness which are undoubtedly the birth-right of all, are in most of us, dimmed ot enveloped in darkness. We have by a series of self-hypnotic acts made ourselves impure, wretched, and action-bound.
First we have forgotten the purity and self-effulgence of our real self, and then goaded on by all sorts of vain desires, we have converted ourselves into miserable worldlings. i (III—-38). “A fire is enveloped in smoke, as a mirror is covered with dirt, as an embryo is covered with caul, so is this (knowledge) covered with that (desire).” So this knowledge though inherent in us, has to be discovered as it were afresh. Unless we'get rid of the smoke, the scorching light of knowledge cannot shine forth; unless we polish the mirror and get rid of the accumulated dirt, knowledge cannot be reflected in our mind. Hence the necessity for religious practices. These practices are not for creating anything new, but for polishing the mind. Merely reading books or hearing lectures or even sharp reasoning will be of no use unless we polish the mirror first. As the Vivekachudamani says
(add Sanskrit)
Eloquence of speech, different ways of throwing words, as well as the learning of philosophies is for enjoyment not for freedom." Tke one thing necessary for freedom is self-culture/or conquest of all selfishness. *(
(III—41). “Therefore do thou first control the senses and then, Oh, best of Bharata’s descendants, get rid of this evil of selfish desire which i the destroyer of wisdom theoretical and practical.”
Hence the Gita enumerates a number of prerequisites of Jnana Yoga and concludes the list with the remark “This is true wisdom and what is other than this is ignorance.” The list includes the following:—
“Humbleness, sincerity, non-injury, forbearance, rectitude, reverence for the teacher, purity, constancy, self-control, contempt of sense pleasures, self-sacrifice, thinking over the evils of birth, death, age, disease and suffering, non-attachment, absence of extreme attachment to children, wife, house and such things, an ever tranquil heart in fortunes good and fortunes evil; exclusive and faithful devotion to God, frequenting a quiet place for meditation, dissatisfaction with vulgar society persevering study of the science of Self and pondering over the knowledge of the Ultimate Reality.” These requisites have been condensed into three by the Gita under the name ■S'raddha (faith), Tatparata (perseverance), and Samyatendriyata (control of the senses). We havf already dwelt on these qualifications at the beginning of Jnana Yoga. It may be noticed here that the same qualifications are sometimes classed under four heads, by some Vedantic philosophers, ■“discrimination, renunciation, moral life, and burning desire for freedom.” Of the fourfold means we have already had occasion to remark elsewhere on renunciation at some length. Discrimination is ascertaining with the aid of right reason the real as distinguished from the unreal. This is in fact the knowledge of Kshetra and Kshetrajna, which has been the subject of the present section. Morality is the very life of religion. It will be noticed that these three requisites are not exclusive of one another and each can be well pursued only along with others. Indeed they may be said to be different aspects of the same thing. Again, these are not merely the means of knowledge, but they are the chief distinguishing marks of a perfect Jnana Yogin. They are not a sort of initial ordeal to be gone through for the sake of knowledge, but they are the permanent features of the perfectly illumined soul (Jnana-Nishtha).6 In fact, discrimination, renunciation, and morality reach their culmination only in such an ideal person. Hence no one can have too much of these indispensable spiritual qualifications. But none of these three are possible for a person without a genuine aspiration. Until this aspiration is born in our heart, religion has not begun for us. No one is fit to become a Jnanin until he is literally a philosopher, the lover of wisdom. This sentiment is voiced forth by S ri Krishna when he says “3T?r feri (add Sanskrit) “If you are unable to fix your mind exclusively on Me then desire to reach Me through the Yoga of practice. Oh, wealth-winner.”
We shall take leave of this aspect of Yoga with a paradoxical quotation from the Gita. “(add Sanskrit) What is darkness to all other beings, in that the self-controlled is wide awake and that in which beings are awake is darkness to the seeing sage.” If we classify persons into two classes, worldly and spiritual, we may say, that the worldly know nothing of the Ultimate Reality; they are quite in the dark so far as the truth of things is concerned. The spiritual person similarly lives in utter oblivion of the world known to the vulgar,, for his world is the world of truth. But a spiritual soul cannot be rightly said to know nothing of-the ordinary world, for, he sees the-utter hollowness of the world. By living oblivious of the world is not meant, retiring to a forest or cave, or to live away from society in some other manner. The Jnanin is ever present in society, looking at the eternal play of, the
Lord going on in the world and helps as far at he can to add to the merriment. In all he sees or does, however, he sees nothing but Brahman.
“(add Sanskrit)
(IV—24). “The offering is Brahman, the oblation is Brahman, in the fire which is Brahman is it poured by Brahman. Thus he whose instruments of Karma are all Brahman, must, of necessity reach Brahman alone.” Thus the Jnanin sees not only Brahman in all beings, he not only realises that the same reality indwells all beings in the world but also realizes Brahman in his divine ecstatic vision, in all feelings, actions, persons, in short, to him the whole creation becomes deified. He in fact sees nothing but Brahman. To such a person, therefore, Yoga is an accomplished fact. For, what is Yoga? “far” Equanimity is Yoga. A Jnanin being one who sees Brahman everywhere, nothing can possibly upset his mind. The Jnanin displaces as it were all disturbing elements in nature by one homogeneous principle “equanimity “faf far (add Sanskrit)” (V—19). “Even in thb-life is nature conquered by those whose mind is firmly fixed on evenness, for Brahman is pure-and everywhere the same, hence they live in Brahman.”
1 From these and similar passages iu the Gita some have concluded that the date of the Gita must be very recent since, according to those critics, the Veda is slighted and sneered at in these s'lokas. Such attack on the authority-of the Vedas, they say, could not be possible iu very recent times. But what is actually discouraged, however, in the Gita is easily seen to be giving undue importance to rituals and neglecting spiritual culture. In this respect it only echoes the teachings of the earlier scriptures. Of. “(add Sanskrit)” (Tait. Brab. 3—10—4—1).
2 Of. Dr. Paul Deussen: “The life a dream! This has been the thought of many wise men from Pindar and Sophocles to Shakspere and Calderon de la Barca, but no body has better explained the idea than S'ankara” (The Philosophy of the Vedanta, an address delivered before the Bombay Branch of the Royal Asiatic Society on 25-2-1893). “You see the concordance of Indian, Greek and German metaphysics; the world is Maya, is illusion, says S'aokara; —it is a world of shadows, not of realities, says Plato; —it is “appearance only, not the thine: in itself/’ says Kant. In one of the later Upanishads, the
3 Mr. Bal Gangadhar Tilak, in his recently published Marathi treatise on the Bhagavad Gita called Bhagavad-gita-
4 Of. S'Sakara Bhashya, Bhagavad-Gita, (III—20) preventing people from going astray from the right path.)
5 Of course it would be ridiculous to interpret this verse literally, for no man, not to speak of a wise man, would' think of making his external behaviour the same to all men and beasts alike* Our external behaviour should certainly differ according to the being we have to deal with. But the feeling behind each of such behaviours would be the same, vir,, unbounded love.
6 “Cf. Where you find unbroken gentleness, enduring patience, sublime lowliness, graciousness of speech, self-control, self-forgetfulness and deep and abounding sympathy, look there for the highest wisdom, seek the company of such a one, for he has realized the divine, be lives with the Eternal, he has become one with the Infinite” (Cb. XII, From Poverty to Power by James Allen).
Bhakti-Yoga, or the Yoga of Devotion
Man’s Search after Happiness
In treating of Jnana Yoga we had occasion to remark that man’s soul is originally pure and tree and religion is the struggle to regain that freedom. We shall in the present section take up a special aspect of this freedom, viz., freedom from 'misery. Every being in the world shows by its activity the wish to reach a higher state,, a dissatisfaction with the present. Man is vividly conscious of a well-defined limitation to his powers of obtaining knowledge and enjoyment. The vast achievements of man from an immemorial past to the present day serve only to leave him impressed with the idea of an infinite region not yet conquered. This certainty of the possession of power, knowledge, and enjoyment is confined to a very.narrow circle while doubt and darkness prevail as regards the outer skirts of that boundary. This knowledge of his own limitations in every way is the chief source •of misery and all attempts of mankind may be described as conscious or unconscious trials in right or wrong directions to go beyond this boundary. In a word, man wants to reach eternal happiness and to avoid all misery.
The Way out of Misery Lies through God-Love or Bhakti
There'have been two solutions of this problem of misery. One as propounded by a school of thinkers is that no doubt evil exists in this world but this evil is irremediable. So the best thing to do, is to make the best of it. To live as mewily as we can, to snatch what pleasures we •can and then to succumb to fate, this is the solution. This was the philosophy of the •Charvakas of Ancient India, who said that all the Vedas were the invention of fools and cheats. Even in our own times it is sometimes asserted that we ought to take the good and forget the evil as there is no help for it. But this is a piece of impracticable advice. Pleasures and pains make themselves felt in spite of efforts to ignore them. The world is a mixture of both. He lives in a fool’s paradise, who thinks of making merry while conscious of unending misery. Thus we see that this solution is not very satisfactory. There is another solution of misery. This is the solution of religion. Religion says that we can take heart and march on. If we can only forget our little joys and artificial remedies of evil, we can go beyond this misery. “q
” “The removal of this three-fold misery” is not possible by artificial means, for, even after repression its recurrence is experienced,” says the Sankhya sutra. (I—2). Religion therefore says that the way out of misery is not through artificial means. It lies through the help of a being who is eternally blissful, pure and free. We have seen how in man is implanted the double instinct of misery and happiness. Man is conscious of his misery—of his limited knowledge, existence and enjoyment—but at the same time, there is in him the never to be extin* gtiished idea of lasting bliss. All men from the-lowest savage to the most civilised person, are full of this belief in a something which is infinite knowledge, infinite existence and infinite bliss. This ingrained belief of man in the existence of the Infinite is undeniable. This ideal infinite is the God of religion. This belief may be explained away in some manner, but there it exists. The belief in God is not peculiar to the masses. Men illustrious in every field of scientific enquiry have affirmed their faith in this Being. Our purpose here is not to discuss the propriety of the belief, but to note that the belief exists in a very large proportion of mankind. Some people while they disclaim the belief, yet postulate an existence and give it pet names of their own. We shall here include all these under the term God, God being the most comprehensive term as conveying all the different ideas. The absolute (Avyakta), the unchangeable (Akshara), the moral law (Dharma),. the ultimate truth (Tattwa), existence (Sat),. the beyond (Para), matter (Sdra), ideal Unity (Eka), are some of the names. We have here noted against each name, a Sanskrit approximate translation, these terms being all taken out of the Gita and the Upanishads which apply all of them to God. Now, religion says that the way out of misery is through the help of this pure and perfect Supreme Being. Or rather this Being is perfect blist and learning to lore thif God is the way out of misery. The Yoga which lays down principles of the art of developing and cultivating this love is called the Bhakti Yoga.
God According to Bhakti-Yoga
So far as the Gita teachings are concerned it should be noted this God is not a mere conjecture, but the Highest Reality. For, God is the same as the Brahman we saw in Jnana Yoga. We there learnt how Brahman is the only Reality and also how everything in this world may be looked upon as a manifestation of Brahman. Now, God is the highest manifestation of Brahman, the highest reading of that Brahman by the human intellect. “snpft
(XIV.) “I am indeed the abiding place of Brahman” says S'ri Krishna. It is true also that other beings are manifestations but they are as it were only fractional manifestations, comparatively very low manifestations. “(add Sanskrit)” (XV—7). “My own part is manifested as the eternal Jiva in this world.” To take a simile from Swami Vivekananda “The clay mouse can never become a clay elephant, because as manifestations, form alone makes them what they are, though as unformed clay they are all one.” As manifested beings then we are God’s eternal slaves and worshippers. Through his worship, we are to go beyond this misery of life.
UM wq,” “As you have got into this transient and miserable life, worship Me” (IX— 33).
The God of Bhakti Yoga, then is not different from the God or Brahman of the Jnana Yoga. It is the same God seen through the spectacles of love. Jnana Yoga says that God in his essence is beyond all predicates and hence to describe Him, it employs a negative language, (add Sanskrit) “It is neither real nor unreal’' and so on. But Bhakti Yoga gives positive definitions of God. It is true that God is really infinitely more than the highest attributes known to human language; it is true that all attributes only delimit Him. But since all our words at best indicate or suggest this. great reality, but can never directly and exactly signify it, is it not best to apply the best.tributes our language can command? Our language is necessarily inaccurate, but why refrain from using the best expressions we have? The heart of man is ever declaring that there is a Being which is the embodiment of all knowledge, existence and bliss. This is supported by reason, which establishes that God is the highest manifestation of Brahman. And therefore Bhakti Yoga unhesitatingly applies the positive language “(add Sanskrit) (XI—38). “Thou art the Primeval Lord, the Ancient Person; thou art the great Hidden Treasure of the Universe; thou art the All-knowing and then art the One ta be known; (thou art) the highest abode, by thee is the universe pervaded, Oh, Omniformed One.” (add Sanskrit) (XI—43). “Thou art the father of this world animate and inanimate; thou art the One worthy of worship by this world; thou art the Great Teacher; there is not in all the triple world any one equal to thee,—whence a greater?—incomparably mighty One as thou art.”
The Crossing of Maya or Spiritual Realisation
Bhakti Yoga as we have said is the search after the infinite bliss or God through love. All men are engaged in an unwearied search after an eternal object of love, a something which they can depend upon. All attempts are baffled but man continues in his endeavours. Is this not a sure sign that all are certain of finding it sooner or later, if there be bliss at all in this universe? S’ri Krishna vouchsafes in the following s'loka that man’s hope is not at all a dream, and going beyond misery is possible. “Jim (VII—14), “This My Divine Maya made of Gunas, is difficult to cross; whosoever seek refuge with Me alone, they cross this Maya." When a person hearkens to this advice, and consciously strives to take refuge with the Lord, he has begun to tread the field of Bhakti Yoga. Maya in this s'loka refers to nature where the interplay of the three Gunas is manifested. God can properly call Maya “Mine” for He is ever the master of the three Gunas and keeps them under control. But for other souls* Maya is like a boundless ocean, very difficult to cross without an aid. Trusting ourselves to the Great Pilot, we can safely find ourselves on the other side of the deep. There is another beautiful metaphorical representation of the idea, in the Bhagavadgita “fafa I
(add Sanskrit) “The Lord is seated in the heart of all beings. Oh* Arjuna, turning round by means of Maya all beings who are mounted on the merry-go-round world.” There is a reference here to the merry-go-round which consists of painted horses and other animals (of wood) moved round by a mechanical contrivance. Persons are seated on these artificial animals and are allowed to wheel, a number of rounds of this mock-ride. This world, says the Gita, is a huge magir cal mechanism [of this kind. God is the Manager* our bodies aud possessions are the animals on ■which we ride. As the machine is turned round and round, the animals fly in the air, faster and faster at various heights. One is' high and another is low, and the fun goes on. But to enjoy this fun it is necessary to seat ourselves firm and to keep up the balance aright so that we may not fall. Sometimes we forget that we are merely playing, and taking it seriously we are sometimes tempted to think with pride “How high I have risen above my neighbour!” This very pride and carelessness, however, is the cause of our downfall and takes away the pleasure of the whole play. Pride goeth before a fall, as the proverb says; to avoid this foolish pride and to learn to take pleasure consciously it is necessary to keep up the balance. This balance is possible only when we hit upon the centre of gravity, which is God. We cannot enjoy the fun unless we seek refuge with the Lord of the play.
It is necessary here, to meet an objection which is sometimes taken about the theory of.Maya and Sport. It is thought a low and unworthy conception of the Deity to have a Maya in which souls get entangled. The view degrades the Supreme Being, which makes Him “moved by such a sportive and unmeaning impulse” * as creation. This view of creation, that it is a mere sport, is considered to militate against the claim of Theism that the creation is due to a motive on the part of Brahman that moves Him to reveal Himself.” Leaving aside all philosophical views of creation for a while one is yet unable to conceive how it is derogatory to Godhead to have arranged for an eternal game of merriment and to have expected the souls to participate in the joy thereof. If it is admitted that it is the essence of God to reveal himself, and if it is taken for granted, likewise that this desire of seif-communication, is the motive for creation (these two being postulates of all cosmological theories of theology), then in what manner should we expect the Deity to manifest Himself? In a way to be understood, loved and enjoyed by souls or in a way to be feared, estranged from all hearts and
* Tbe Religion of Jesus, p. 35, by the Rev. N. Macnicol. hated by all? To make the creation a playground or to make it a hell? It is no sin, therefore, to hold that the creation is a kind of play. Even games are regularly planned and carried out. A play would be no play if it were not played according to fixed rules. God in his infinite mercy, has arranged this play for us. God is not making fun of our vain struggles and desires. The struggles and desires are obstacles to the play thrown by ourselves. Whether we go high or low, as we ride on our mock-horses, we should neither feel proud nor be cast down, for that would destroy the fun. We should only enjoy the play. “If you are poor enjoy that as fun; if you are rich enjoy the fun of being rich; if dangers come, treat them also as fun; if happiness comes, there is more good fun.”* So much for the sport of divine creation. As for Maya it is no black magic wrought by a jealous being to entice human souls into misery. It has been observed that the s'loka just quoted says it is made up of Gunas. Maya is another name of Prakriti or nature, and nature is, as we
* Swami Vivekananda. have elsewhere remarked, neither good nor bad. It is a mixture of good and bad, and these terms good and bad are only relative so that no one thing in nature can be said to be good or bad in itself. To make the world or Maya, good or bad, depends entirely on ourselves.1 The ■Gita says Maya can be thus mastered and the;World converted into a beautiful heaven of bliss. •“They who resort to Me alone cross this Maya,” says S'ri Krishna.
The Importance of the Education of the Heart
The s'olka we last quoted says that the Lord is seated in the heart of all beings and we are asked to take refuge in the Lord. We should understand this to meaD that the cultivation of the heart is the most necessary step for spiritual realisation. There is no religion in the world," which does not advocate the proper training of that part of the human mind which is properly known as the heart. Intellectual investigations are most necessary to clear the understanding, and to make our beliefs firm. But it should not be forgotten, that intellect by itself achieves nothing. It is like a lame person who talks from where he is seated. The work of the intellect is always negative, for it can only remove errors and false beliefs. On the other hand, what are called our emotions and feelings are more daring. There is no region which they have not the curiosity to explore. But the heart by itself is like a half blind person, who by wilfully walking where he lists, falls times without number into ditches and is miserably bruised. But by mutual help, intellect and feelings may be so combined as to produce the. most beneficent results and avoid all unnecessary pit-falls and dangers. It is this happy combination in a more or less degree that has produced the world’s great men. Speaking from a religious point of view, however, one is inclined to think, that on the whole it is far better to have a little feeling even without a good intellect rather than to have a highly developed head without heart* It is through feelings that one will see the Lord, and the training of feelings in the right way isthe special province of Bhakti Yoga. Hence, who is qualified to enter upon a course of Bhakti F It is the man of feelings. Bhakti Yoga does* not impose conditions of birth, sex, occupation, wealth, power or learning. S'ri Krishna says ft qr*r Tamas: (add Sanskrit)
TRT Td (IX—32). “Those that depend on Me even if they be of ignoble birth,—women, Vais'yas (merchants) or S'udras (laborers), even they will attain the highest goal.” The one and only pre-requisite is feeling and a desire to* improve feeling. The Transformation of Ordinary Love into
The Transformation of Ordinary Love into Bhakti or God-Love
Of course every one has feelings and emotions but they are generally in a most neglected condition, being least developed and exercised always in the wrong direction. Still no one need despair, how deplorable so ever the condition of his heart may be. “
(add Sanskrit)
(add Sanskrit) Even if a highly impious person loves Me exclusively, he must be deemed a good man, for he is wisely resolved; soon he becomes a virtuous soul and attains eternal peace. You may be sure. Oh, son of Kunti, My [devotee is not ruined” (IX—30,31) says Bhagavan. Once with a desire to self-improvement we begin to attend to our feelings, we soon get Bhakti. In fact, our feelings developed, regulated and properly directed, become Bhakti.
Bhakti Yoga then chiefly aims at converting ordinary love into Bhakti or God love. To find the Lord through love is the most natural method as we have already remarked,for man is miserable and wants happiness. We find misery in objects of hatred and pleasure, in objects of love, and there it follows that infinite happiness must be in that which is the eternal object of the highest love. The problem of the religious aspirant is. According to the view, therefore reduced to the simple one of the finding such an object. Among All the means to salvation, accordingly, Bhakti Yoga holds love in the fore-front rank. “?mr
(add Sanskrit)” (XI—53). “Sri Krishna
'O says “Neither by Vedas nor by asceticism, neither by charity nor by sacrifice is it possible to see Me in the manner thou hast done, but by exclusive devotion, it is possible to-know Me like this, to see Me in truth and be assimilated into Me." In the study of Bhakti Yoga, it is therefore important to note that-higher (Para) Bhakti or God love is but the-same feeling as the lower (Gouni) love with a difference of direction. Just as by judicious manipulation harmful refuse and filth may be converted into useful manure for the orchard, just as useless and foul smelling parts of animals can be dexterously manufactured into useful articles of daily use, and just as even poisons by scientific compounding can be turned not only into harmless but. also into potent medicines, so by Bhakti Yoga* a process is offered by means of which all our lower passions are made to work out our salvation. It is in this that the naturalness of Bhakti Yoga lies.
Love in Its Lower Forms
To study how this method works, we should ■consider love from its lowest stage up to the stage when it becomes Bhakti. In its lowest form, love is called Kama or desire and lust. It is then the greatest impediment to spiritual progress. All religions have preached against covetousness and evil passion, and.the Gita is no less vehement in its condemnation of these feelings. When Arjuna asked S'ri Krishna who it was that moved the soul to sin, he perhaps implied that God or some supernatural Being was compelling man to go wrong. He said “3T*I
(add Sanskrit)
” (III-36). “But by whom induced does this man commit sin, Oh, descendant of Vrishni, being urged on, as it were by force even against his will?” S'ri Krishna to show emphatically that man is not compelled by any external force and that evil is his own free choice, replied in the following words tpi
” (III-37). This is desire, this is wrath, born of the primal Guna of Rajas greatly voracious and immensely harmful, know this to be the foe here.” What is called sio, therefore, is the direct outcome of such desire or lust. This low desire disappointed becomes anger, and when fulfilled results in fond attachment and miserliness. Hence the Gita elsewhere says “(add Sanskrit)
3TTWTIRR: (XVI—21, 22). “Three fold is this doorway to hell, which destroys the soul; (it is made up of) desire, anger, and miserliness, and therefore one should avoid these three. A man free from these three gets to darkness, Oh, son of Kunti, acts for his good and therefore reaches the highest goal.” In the view of the Gita, therefore, the one original source of all errors of the human mind, is this love in its lowest form called desire. Desire takes a number of forms. The Brihadaranyakopanishad says, (add Sanskrit)
Desire, will, doubt, faith, disbelief, firmness, frailty, modesty, thinking, fear, all such are verily the mind.” From the standpoint under consideration, all these functions of the mind may be looked upon as aspects of love in various degree* and stages of development. The lowest stage-is, as said above, desire or sensuality. Desire, then, is the result of ignorant non-use or conscious misuse of love. The misuse of love makes man of a demonaical nature. The sixteenth chapter of the Gita gives in about a dozen couplets an illustrative description of this-m nature, there called Asuri Savipat (wealth of demons)- One thing that is made prominent throughout the description is an inordinate love of body and a selfish love of wealth, wife and children. Love in this stage besides being called Kama (desire) sometimes also receives the name of Sanga (attachment). The difference in significance between the two words is this, that while Kama is desire for objects not attained, Sanga-is attachment to things in possession. Now, in desire and attachment, men instead of giving as much room a* possible for the free play of love, try to concentrate it on trivial and frivolous objects. This is the very reason of the soul’s misery. By desiring various objects which are to be obtained only with great difficulty and which if obtained are sure soon to perish, man becomes the slave of his desires. His peace of mind is always disturbed by desires, and he can never know any thing of real happiness. Again by extreme attachment to the body and possessions, man loses his independence and becomes a mere appendage to his belongings. Thus instead of the body belonging to the man, the man belongs to the body. Desire and attachment are the real bondage, for man totally surrenders his independence when he becomes subject to these feelings. On the other hand infinite peace belongs to him who can help himself above desires and attachment. “(add Sanskrit)
(add Sanskrit) As the streams enter the sea which is constantly filled on all sides and yet stands unmoved, so into whom-so-ever enter all desires (without affecting him) he attains peace and not the man who has all sorts of desires.” So long, therefore, as we cherish this desire or abnormal love, we can never know anything of spiritual rest. Trending misery is the lot of all selfish persons. Hence to taste of spiritual bliss, it is absolutely necessary to give up this-demon-like habit and to cultivate the divine accomplishment. “urn.” “Godliness makes for freedom, but for bondage is the demonaical held to be.”
The Principle of the Renunciation of Low Desires
But how are we to give up this selfish habit which has become, as it were, our second nature? It is easy to say “Give up desire and attachment” but to bring this into practice is extremely difficult. The Gita states a principle which offers the best solution here. “(add Sanskrit) WISEST rsjr former.” “Objects are removed from the embodied being who does not take them in (through the senses), but not so the love of objects; even love is removed after having seen the highest {love)." Love of one object can be removed only when we have placed our love on something else. We are all trying to fix our love on something permanent, but do not succeed. For a moment we love an object and when we to attach undue importance to it, when we think that there is no other object worthy of our love, the object is suddenly removed from us. Then we direct our love to something else. Or •even while the object remains, we may take to Another object as more worthy of our attention. This shifting of love from object to object is the very force that moves all beings to action. In the words of Manu, “
“Whatever a being does, that is the work of love.” All beings are in a blind-1 fold race, as it were, towards some object on which they want to fix their love permanently. We give up the lower love when we realise the higher love, for the quality and permanence of happiness depends both upon the sort of love and the objects loved. In the animals love is fixed on the grossest of pleasures. Love of sense-pleasures of the grossest type predominates in these beings. But as man becomes more and more civilised even the sense pleasures become more and more refined and at last man finds out a higher love. Love is now placed in intellectual pleasures and lower pleasures lose their attraction. Love of morality is still a higher stage. Therefore, we may say greater and greater happiness is realised, as love becomes finer and finer. The finer love is taken up in preference to the grosser, and the latter naturally disappears. Therefore, says the Gitar when the highest love is reached, all other forms of love are thrown into the shade and discarded.
God Is Love
And what is the object of the highest love? It is a little peculiar that the line which man’s selfishness takes should point out this object, to the utter annihilation of selfishness itself. Man loves things external to himself less than himself. The nearer the object of love to him, the more be loves. This principle stretched to its utmost limit leads us to the conclusion that nothing is more loveable than that which is the very self of us all; for, what can be nearer to us than our self? So we see that the search of love takes the same direction as the direction of knowledge. In fact, knowledge itself is impossible without love, for the knowledge of a thing increases with the love of knowing it. It follows therefore, that the highest knowledge of the Lord comes to those that cherish the highest love for the Lord. In Jnana Yoga it was said that knowledge reaches its acme, when, it realises the one supreme reality in all. Now, love is the best means of realising this, for whatever object we intensely love, we become identified with it for the time being. Thus when we love the body, the body is our self and for the lover of body there is no truth higher than it. When we love the mind,mind is our self,and there is nothing higher than it. In every case, every thing else exists in and through the self and every thing is loveable for the sake of the self, whatever we take the self to be for the time being. Love therefore always makes for the realisation of unity. When love learns by experience that no object can satisfy it, that no object can permanently engage it, it at last transforms itself, as it were, and turns back on its own real self. This is no doubt a yet 'difficult feat, but when performed, permanent bliss is reached. It is then found that the reality which is in all the world is one and the same and its nature is perfect Love• The essence, the reality,, of love is love, and hence love can never hate love. All misery being the result of hatred, disappears when love reaches this stage. Thus after a weary search man finds that there is no object worthy of his love greater than the Lord, the Love seated in the heart of all. He then understands the meaning of the Narada Sutra
“The nature of love is inexpressible.” After one has seen this Paramarasa (Highest Love), all his lower love vanishes like a mirage.
For one reason Love is the greatest name that could be devised to indicate the Great Self- We have seen in the last section that one definition of Kshetrajna is “The knower of kshetra.” And that the kshetra includes not only the external body but also the mind and all its functions such as desire and hatred. We have observed again in the present chapter thatthe chief functions of the mind such as desire may be considered to be different phases of love. Now, the mind is the nearest to the self, And the more it is purified, the more shines through it the self behind. Indeed, the mind and the self are so intimately connected that the mind is very often mistaken for the self. S'ri S'ankaracharya speaking of this confounding the self with the mind says “The mind is the illuminated and the light of the self is the illuminator like the ordinary light. Not distinguishing the illuminator and the illuminated is very common. For, being pure, light seems similar to the illuminated object. Thus while illuminating a red thing it seems similar to the red thing and assumes a red form. And illuminating green, black or brown things, the light becomes similar to them. In the same way the self illuminating the mind, illuminates the whole of Kshetra through the mind.” (Brih. Bha.) The Gita expresses this idea in the following text: “(add Sanskrit)
” (XIII). “Just as the one sun illiminates the whole of this world, so also the whole of Kshetra the Kshetrin illuminates, Oh, descendant of Bharata.”The mind therefore being the nearest, catches as it were, the best reflection of the self. Since as we have said above, the supreme self is seen the more clearly, the more the mind i8 purified, it follows that the self as it is, can be seen only by the most purified mind. Now, the mind is most purified when all its lower passions are tansformed into divine love or Bhakti. Since the highest truth shines forth only in the highest mind of love, is it not most appropriate to call it by the unique name of Love? Hence the Upanishad declares “(add Sanskrit)” (Tait. 11*7). “He is verily sweet Love. Having got this Love alone, indeed, this soul becomes blissful.”
Preparatory Bhakti
But until the mind is thoroughly purified, this Supreme Love is not realised. “H
(add Sanskrit)” (VII-15). “The sinful, the ignorant, the lowest of men do not come to me, for their knowledge is removed through Maya, and they have taken to the demonaical life.” Till supreme Bhakti is attained, therefore, a preparation towards that stage is necessary. The Gita divides seekers after truth into four classes. “uj srt: si*\ arrnf” (VII—16.) “Righteous persons of four sorts worship Me, Oh, Arjuna; (they are) the afflicted, the enquiring, the interested, and the enlightened.” These four classes are again brought under two main heads “(add Sanskrit)” (VII—17-18). “Of these the best is the enlightened person whose mind is constantly applied and exclusively devoted to Me; for I am greatly beloved of the enlightened man, and he is also my beloved. All these are noble, indeed, but the enlightened man, is My very self, for by constant attachment, be holds on to Me as the highest goal.” It is ■clear from these texts that the three classes of Bhaktas other than the Jnanin, are in the preparatory stage of Bhakti. But even preparatory Bhakti is not easily got, for they are qualified.as the righteous (add Sanskrit) in contradistinction to the vicious or demonaical persons.
The Gita does not explain which of the three preparatory devotees is the best, but in Narada Bhakti Sutra, it is said that of the three each is preferable to the one immediately following it *(in the above enumeration), whence it follows that according to this view the best preparatory* approximation to the highest form of Bhakti is- A Arta Bhakti or to become conscious of the misery of Samsara and to resort to the Lord with whole-heartedness to be relieved of thie distress. This is supported by the sloka already quoted from the Gita “Those who resort to Me alone, they cross the Maya.” Initiatory to this stage are all other endeavours to purify the mind. J
Purification of the Mind
Means of mind purification are three-fold according to the Gita. “(add Sanskrit) XVIII-5) “Sacrifice, charity and asceticism are the purifiers.” Sacrifice is of different kinds varying from the grossest worship with various materials (add Sanskrit) to the highest worship in spirit and truth (strait:). Sacrifice is described at length in the fourth chapter. The best sacrifice is, according to the Gita, that which is done for its own sake (XVII—11). The best charity is thus defined “(add Sanskrit)” (XVII—20). “Charity given, just because it ought to be given, given. without expectation of any return, in the right place, at the right time, and to the right persons —that charity is considered to be the best.” As for Tapas or asceticism the Gita divides it into three classes, physical, verbal, and mental. “Worship of God, the spiritual teacher and the wise man, purity, rectitude, chastity, harmless-ness are said to be bodily Tapas. Unwounding,, true, pleasant and agreeable speaking, and study of holy books, are said to be Tapas of speech; clearness of mind, gentleness, studied silence, self-control, purity of heart—this is said to be the Tapas of the mind (XVII—14,15,16).” These three-fold exercises done with intense faith and without expectation of reward constitute the best asceticism according to the Gita (XVIII—6, 7).
In this preparatory Bhakti, which has been called Gouni by ancient writers, all such forms and symbols as are conducive to speedy realisation of divine love may be advantageously used. Some people are disposed to think that the use of symbols, forms, or other concrete helps is useless and even dangerous, inasmuch as these concrete things turn away the seeker’s attention* from God. They say that to recommend their use is to recommend a conscious alliance with falsehood and direct propagation of lies. But the ‘Gita does not agree with such men. It is assumed here that just as the use of formulae and symbols in science tends to only greater dearness of understanding, the use of symbols and forms is of great use in helping young minds to realise the true nature of worship. All great religions of the world having made use of symbols and forms to some extent at least, the Gita does not stand alone in the recommendation of such helps. S'ri Krishna says i cpft agrregr
(add Sanskrit)” (VII-21). “Whatever devotee wishes to worship whatever form with faith I confirm his faith in the same.” These forms and symbols must be worshipped not for their own sake but for the Lord. When used as a suggestion of God, they are not only beneficial but also necessary for all who are in the preparatory stage. But when the image, form or symbol is worshipped for its own sake,.that is when it represents a saint or an angel or some being other than God, the worship has-merits of its own, but cannot directly lead to real Bhakti (devotion to God) or Mukti (freedom). Hence the Gita says of such kinds of worship “(add Sanskrit)” (VII—23). “But
'O perishable is their reward, and it comes only to small wits.” But even this little perishable result comes from the Lord. “ i (ix— 23). “Even the devotees of the other Devatas who? worship with faith, they are really worshipping Me in an indirect manner.” Therefore to take the assistance of symbols and forms, and consciously worship the one Lord in them, is highly beneficial and recommendable. Such substitutes or suggestions as it were, of God are stated at length in the tenth chapter of the Gita under the name of Vibhutis. It is interesting to observe how the Gita makes such Vibhutis, the stepping-stones to the realisation of Bhakti or the love of one God. To begin with S'ri Krishna states “rwi (X—20). “I am the self. Oh, self-controlled, seated heart of all beings, I am the beginning, the middle and the end of beings.” Then for such as may not understand this grand ideal, several approximations are given and again at the end of the enumeration, a general statement is made 1 ‘
(X— 41). “Whatever is magnificent,abundant aud vigorous, know thou, that that is born of a part of My own glory.” Thus whatever is awe-inspiring, wonderful and admirable in nature and whoever represents goodness, greatness and wisdom are here recommended to be revered in order that the heart may be gradually led to a sense of the One Infinite Being. From curiosity to fear, from fear to wonder, from wonder to admiration, and from admiration to reverence and love, these are the various steps that the soul will take in its onward progress, and this progress will be speedy and well-directed just to the extent to which it can draw inspiration from the divine Vibhutis. Here we have to speak in particular of three Vibhutis, viz., the Vedas, the Guru and the Avataras. The Bhagavadgita in its enumeration of Vibhutis is only illustrative and is by no means exhaustive, for S'rf Krishna says, (add Sanskrit)” (X—40). “There is no eDd to My divine Vibhutis, Oh, tormentor of foes, but this list of Vibhutis, has been given by Me just in illustration.” If, the Gita names certain books, certain teachers,! and certain incarnations, it is merely because they were the best known to India of those times If Krishna were to teach a modern world, wei should not be surprised to hear him include the! Dhammapada, the Bible, the Koran and the, Zend-Avesta among sacred books, and Jesus,j Mohamad, Zoroaster and Buddha among persons, to be revered as-manifestations. The perfectly general character of the teachings in the book warrants this supposition. S'ri Krishna says (add Sanskrit)” (IV—11). “Whoever takes refuge with Me in whatever form, I take them into My service in that form; men follow My path. Oh, son of Pritha, by all means.” The Bhagavadgita therefore, cannot be justly held to advocate reverence to a particular book, teacher or divine incarnation. The book simply refers to the principle of Vibhutis and stops there, "With these preliminary remarks, we shall now turn to a consideration of what the Gita has to say on each of these three Vibhutis. First of all, sacred books if rightly used are a great aid to the cultivation of religious feeling. Hence the Gita says “OTM
(XVI—24). “Therefore the scriptures are your authority in distinguishing right and wrong.” But it is necessary here to observe that we are not here given over to books bound hand and foot, for in a subsequent chapter, it is said that even persons without a scriptural authority are to be considered Satwicas if they work in good faith. As for teachers, the Gita gives them two epithets “Possessed of knowledge” and “seers of truth.” This is but a paraphrase of the Upanishad which says that the Guru must be S'rotriya and Brahmanishtha (Mundaka, 1-2-12.) The sure test of a genuine teacher is when knowledge is kindled and all confusion is vanished in the disciple’s soul (IV—35). The effect of the teaching must enable the taught to conquer all sin, to burn all evil tendencies, and to attain purity of spirit (IV—36, 37). Now, for the Avataras. The Gita says that there will be Avataras again and again. “(add Sanskrit)” (IV—8). “Age after age I incarnate Myself for the establishment of religion” says Sri Krishna. Whenever religion subsides and irreligion prevails, there will be an Avatara (IV-?). Besides showing that the purpose of Avatara is always moral, the Gita says that Avatara necessitates no limitations to
* God’s self-sufficiency. “Though without birth and of an undecaying nature, and the Lord of beings, I, controlling My Prakriti, manifest Myself through My Maya” (IV—6). Hence the Gita never attaches too much importance to any particular Avatara, for it declares that all Avataras are for the upholding of religion. This is quite enough we think as a refutation of the theory that has been advanced by some, that the Gita is intended to revive the Krishnavatara, and to advocate Krishna worship. In the whole of the Gita there is not a single text betraying any jealousy of the worship of any other incarnation. On the other hand, all forms of worship are positively commended and given their right position in the ladder of spiritual progress. The Gita manifestly rests on the foundations of religion not on the infallibility of a book, nor on the authority of a person, nor yet on any particular forms and ceremonies, but on the right exercise of reason and righteousness of conduct and on universal love, joy and peace. But at the same time the Gita is never antagonistic to any form, ceremony, book, or person that may help souls in their onward march to spirituality. They are Vibhutis and may be justly revered. The Gita only wants to advise that instead of taking the Vibhuti for itself, it is infinitely more beneficial to take it as a symbol or suggestion of the Lord who is revealed in it. That this is the obje6t of the enumeration of Vibhutis is clear from the following concluding verse (add Sanskrit)
fatr wni” (X—42) “Or, what is the good to you of knowing all this detail, Oh, Arjuna? Pervading the whole universe I stand revealed therein in part.” ThusVibhntiworship is meant to gradually take the soul upward and widen the aspirant’s heart more and •more till it embraces the whole creation. The ■realisation will be complete, when the seeker has actualised that the Lord in His glory is infinitely more besides what part of Him we find revealed in the universe.
The Methods of Bhakti-Yoga (in Brief)
Before we proceed further it seems necessary, for clearness of understanding, to recapitulate the methods of Bhakti Yoga we have here and there alluded to in the preceding pages. First, the special aim of Bhakti Yoga being spiritual realisation, it does not at all attach much importance to speculation, though right reasoning is not excluded from its sphere. Secondly, the education of the heart is its chief business, and its central secret is to give a nobler and a higher direction to our feelings and to transform them all into one intense religious feeling of supreme love. Thirdly, in its preparatory stage, Bhakti allows the use of forms, symbols and other helps to worship. Fourthly, all this must be made subservient to the one object of the realise-tion of the Lord who is manifested in the universe and who in His essence is infinitely more besides. Lastly, we note that in Bhakti Yoga, it is the personal aspect of God, that is chosen. The-soul is here advised to escape from misery through the help of Is'wara or personal God. The impersonal aspect is not denied, but the personal alone is preferred for worship as being natural and easy of access. While Jnana-; Yoga takes up the impersonal and tries to tackle the problem of life mainly through philosophy, Bhakti-Yoga.recognises that the majority of mankind are unable to guide their lives by philosophy. Men often thinking themselves to be capable of scaling the heights of philosophy, suffer from great falls. To avoid this Bhakti- Yoga offers a natural, smooth and gentle path. S'ri Krishna says wr trt i trarcr ft gwwr mn:” (XII—2) “Those who concentrating their mind on Me' worship Me with eternal constancy and with the highest faith, they are, in my opinion, the best Yogins.” That this refers to the personal aspect of GodfcWill be evident from the next three s'lokaa •where S'ri Krishna says “Bat those that worship the Unchangeable, the Indescribable, the Un-manifested, the Omnipresent, the Unthinkable, the All-comprehending, the Immoveable and the Eternal, by controlling all their senses and having the conviction of equanimity with regard to all things, they also come to Me, as they are engaged in doing good to all beings. But the difficulty is greater for those whose minds are devoted to the Unmanifested, for the path of the Unmanifested, is trodden indeed with great difficulty by embodied beings.” Here the description is clearly with reference to the impersonal aspect. Hence the first one must be the personal God of Bhakti-Yoga. Bhakti then is best developed when it is directed to the personal aspect of God.
In the above quotation, a statement calls for some remark. It is said there that the way to the unmanifested is beset with difficulty for the ■embodied. Since all human beings have a body, does this mean that no man can worship the Absolute? This conclusion being plainly repugnant, the word embodied is better interpreted when - it is made to mean those who are too much attached to the body. Many of us find it difficult to shake off the body idea. People often make the body everything. For such beings, evidently, it is extremely difficult to go at once to the path of the highest philosophy which says that the-world including the body is unreal. For all ordinary men, therefore, the worship of the personal is the only thing that is recommendable.
It must not be supposed, however, that the manifested God is a low existence, the worship of which is meant only for beginners as being easy enough. That would be the greatest mistake to commit about the Gita teaching in the matter. For, St} Krishna describes the worshippers of the manifested God, thus,
(add Sanskrit) stmt (add Sanskrit)
” (IX—13, 14). “But high souls, having a Godlike nature worship Me with, minds of exclusive attachment, knowing Me to be undecaying and the origin of all beings. Ever repeating My names, practising with firm resolution, saluting Me with devotion, they worship Me with eternal constancy.” At the end of the Gita, after the whole teaching is wound up S'ri Krishna says “Hear again My greatest advice, the greatest of all secrets; since you are My sure devotee, I will tell you your own good. Be minded in Me, be devoted to Me, worship Me, salute Me, you will reach Me alone, I assure you, as you are My dearest.” (XVIII—64, 65).* The Gita therefore holds it of the utmost importance that the aspirant should take to the adoration of the personal God in the most reverent attitude possible. In this connection, we cannot resist the temptation of quoting another Gita text on the point with the commentary of S'ri S'ankaracharya,himself one of’ the staunchest advocates of Nirguna Brahman or Unmanifested God. f (XI—55). “He who does my work, regards me as the highest, is without' attachment and is without enmity towards all beings, he reaches me, Oh, Pandava.” S'ri S'S'ankaracharya introduces the s'loka in his commentary thus: “Now, the essential point of the whole scripture of the Gita, meant for salvation ia here given out in a nut-shell for practice.” Then the commentary runs thus:—“Matkarmakrit, He who does My work; Action for My sake is My work. Matparamah, the servant does the work of his master but never takes the master for the highest to be reached after his death, but this man does My work and considers Me the highest goal, hence he is Matparamah (to whom I am the highest goal); so Madbhaktah, he worships Me by all means, in all forms and with all heart hence he is My Bhakta (devotee); Sangavarjitah without Sanga that is without fondness for and attachment to the enjoyments of wealth, children, friends, wife and relations. Nirvairah sarvabhuteshu without enmity in all beings, without the'feelings of enmity even towards those who are engaged in doing the greatest evil to him; he who is like this, he reaches Me. I and nothing else will be his destination. This is My teaching to you. Oh, Pandava.”
Spiritual Realisation Resulting from Bhakti
To the Bhakta thus devoted realisation will become the easiest of things. S'ri Krishna say8 elsewhere in the Gita “fof
(add Sanskrit)
*rram” (X—10, 11). “To them who are earnestly attached to Me, and worship Me with love, I give that direction of will by which they come to Me. Out of mercy to such alone, I seated in their heart destroy the darkness born of ignorance by means of a brilliant spiritual illumination.” Thus it remains finally true that while the head knows the Lord, the heart it is which enters the innermost sanctuary and enjoys the sight of the Lord. S'ri Krishna says “(add Sanskrit)
(add Sanskrit) eras! (add Sanskrit) faster (add Sanskrit)” (XVIII—55)“Through Bhakti he recognises how great I am; actually knowing Me through that Bhakti, he is assimilated into Me who am not far from him.” This is the state of the devotee when Paru Bhakti or supreme devotion is reached.
Human Representations of Divine Love
It is indeed impossible to express in human language the burning love which the Bhakta feels for God. J ust by way of suggestion. however, human relations are given in comparison to the love. Thus Arjuna says “You will please forgive me. Oh Lord, as a father would forgive his son, or a friend his companion, or a lover his beloved.” Addressing God as father has been a universal practice among religions, but to denote the intensity of divine love, even an intimate friend’s love has been thought insufficient by Bhaktas. Religious men have exhausted the list of human relations of love in representing God love. For, God has been represented not only as father, but also as mother, grand-father, friend, protector. Creator, King, guardian, teacher, etc., as we can see from the Gita(IX—17,18, XI—43).These however are merely suggestions and can never exactly represent the intense love that Bhaktas feel for the Lord. Their state is thus described by S'ri Krishna “(add Sanskrit)
(X—y). “Ever minded in Me, holding life for Me, teaching one another and ever relating My glory, they please themselves and make merry.” Thus respect for the Lord, joy in His presence, misery in feeling separate from Him, distaste for worldly things, complete dependence on the Lord and perfect self-surrender are the chief characteristics of the Bhaktas. Out of the fulness of their hearts, they have frequently given expression to their feelings. They feel the presence of the beloved God so near that they call him Lord, master, father, friend, nay more the Self. They feel and most confidently assert “I and my Lord are one.” They are filled with God to such an extent that they would not like to hear of the slightest; separation from Him. It is this view that S'ri Krishna endorses when he says “(add Sanskrit)
(IX—29).” “I am the same to all beings and there is none hated or loved of Me; but as for them that worship Me with devotion they eternally live in Me, and I in them.” Again, S'ri Krishna spys elsewhere “The enlightened Bhakta is My very self.” (VII—18).
The Ideal of Para Bhakti
When this supreme state of blessedness is) reached, all forms and ceremonies become useless; promise or threat of S'astras loses its force alike; the misery due to the Gunas of Mays vanishes for ever and in its place comes eternal unbounded bliss.- Such a Bhakta would say with the Gita ftg: 1
(add Sanskrit) “The Lord neither takes away vice nor accepts a meritorious action of any souls; true knowledge being covered up with ignorance, beings befool themselves.” It must'not be concluded from this that the ideal Bhakta is reckless and wilful in his ways, being quite unmindful of the S'astras. The s'loka just quoted only means that Bhakta has so far overcome all interested motives, that he does good not because of S'astric injunctions, not because he expects a reward or desires to escape some punishment, but because it has become a habit with him to do good. He has realised the maxim “It is only noble to be good.”In discussing this point, the famous Sures'- warftcharya says “When the Atman is realised, will humbleness and other self-less activities vanish along with interested activities, (both being the result of ignorance) or will the former not disappear? We reply, they will not. What is the reason? Because the supreme Atman is of his own nature unopposed to injunctions of self-less activities. But (this non-removal of good qualities is) not because of the injunction. How else then? Listen. To the person in whose vv the realisation of the Atman has been born, non-hatred and other qualities (Cf. Gita etc. XII—13 to 19) will be a habit requiring no effort, but no longer will they be virtues to be acquired by conscious exertion.” (Naishkarmyasidhi IV—69). To such an ideal Bhakta with whom it has become a habit to do good, it is immaterial whether pleasure or pain falls to his lot, whether people accord him praise or blame. In spite of the changing external environment he remains for ever undisturbed, because he has found the source of eternal bliss. He has realised that the ideal of • love, the essence of all love, is itself bliss. His unbounded love reveals to him the truth that the whole universe is one ocean of bliss. He sees that all beings are only waves great or small in that ocean. He has, in fact, understood the true' meaning of the Upanishadic statements “
(add Sanskrit)” (Tait. Ill—6). “From bliss only, indeed, are these beings born, being born they live in bliss, and it is bliss that they finally approach and are there-into assimilated.” And when one has identified oneself with this ocean*of bliss, how can there be dissatisfaction or disturbance? This ideal person therefore may be said to have realised the true Yoga- For, what is Yoga? “him “Evenness is Yoga.”
The Relation between Bhakti-Yoga and Jnana-Yoga
In Par3 Bhakti, we have a point of conver-gency where both Juana Yoga and Bhakti Yoga meet. Different though they might appear at first sight, the two Yogas are really closely interrelated as already shown, and at this stage they again commingle into one. When a Jnana Yogin attains to that ripe condition of knowledge, called “Jnana Nishtha” or firm adherence to knowledge (XVIII—50), his realization becomes absolutely indistinguishable from Parft Bhakti. In fact S'ri Krishna calls Jnanin his highest devotee (VII—17) and when knowledge coupled with all its ripening aids and free from antagonistic influences developes into supreme realization of the Atman, it is called “Nishtha.” And it is this Jnana, Nishtha or fully developed Jnana that is identical with Para Bhakti.2 It is this Bhakti that Vaman Pandit the famous mediaeval Sadhu and poet of the Maharashtra so much extols in his commentary on the Bhagavadgita called the “Yathartha Dipika.” Thus while the preparatory Bhakti (itH) leads to the knowledge of Brahman (add Sanskrit) the supreme Bhakti (to (add Sanskrit) is the final consummation of Jnana generally known as Brahma- Nishtha. This fact that Para Bhakti is the fulfilment of Jnana, accounts for the position accorded to Bhakti Yoga after Jnana Yoga in the present treatment.
1 Of. “What makes life worth living is not what you and] in it but what you are ready to put into it by your.ideal interpretation of the meaning that, as you insist, it shall for you William James.
2 Of. S'ankaracharya’s Commentary on XVIII—55 (add Sanskrit) to (add Sanskrit)”
Concluding Remarks
It now remains for us to briefly recapitulate •what has been said in the preceding pages in order to enable ourselves to frame an answer to the question, with which the present book began.
We have seen that the Bhagavadgita is a treatise on Brahmavidya, and Yogas'astra1 and that Yoga is the one indispensable condition in which Brahma Vidya or the knowledge of Brahman is attained. That this is so is borne out not only from the contents of the Gita in almost every chapter of which the knowledge of Brahman is spoken of, and the means of attaining it is set forth as Yoga, but also from the express statement “(add Sanskrit)” (standing where one never swerves from the Truth). Here we are told directly that Yoga is that frame of mind in which one never loses sight of the Truth or Brahmam.
It has also been seen that the Yoga intended as a means to Brahma Vidya is defined in the Gita itself as “equanimity/’ A good many commentaries both on ancient ahd modern lines have attempted to solve what this Yoga means and what the essence of the Gita is in their own way. Thus S'ankaracharya, whose commentary is the oldest available, says that S'ri Krishna taught Arjuna the twofold Vedic religion, of works (add Sanskrit) and renunciation and according to that commentator Supreme Bliss or Moksha is attainable by Jnana Yoga. According to Ramanujacharya, the next commentator, the Gita intends to set forth the Bhakti Yoga supported by knowledge as well as works. The system of Nimbarkacharya is slightly different from that of Ramanuja, but still it may be put down as recognizing Bhakti Yoga as the essence of the Gita. Madhvacharya also teaches Bhakti though according to him knowledge Buddhi Yoga is the primary meaning of “Yoga” and the essential •condition of Moksha. According to Vallabhacharya who is a Vaishnava commentator like Eamanuja or Madhva, but the expounder of a modified Advaitism unlike either, the Gita expounds chiefly Bhakti as calculated to bring on Divine grace. In later times the famous Jnaneshwara of the Maharashtra wrote a learned commentary in Marathi, on the Gita very much in accord with the views of S'ankara but specializing the importance of Bhakti. Of the modern writers Dr. Thibaut2 thought that Bhagavata system was chiefly represented in the Gita. Dr. Sir E. G. Bhandarkar according to whom the Gita represents a theistic reaction against antagonistic influences,3 passes over the definition of Yoga in the text and simply says “The condition of mind in the Yoga mode is a determined will." Though Pandit Sitanath Tattvabhushan of Calcutta refers to the Gita definition of Yoga in his book called “Krishna and the Oita” (p. 177), he does not seem to attach much importance to it, for he seems or less identify it with Dhyana Yoga (p. 183, ibid), and later on with Bhakti, though he thinks the philosophy of the Gita is Bhedabheda Yada utterly opposed to Maya Yada, (p. 249, ibid). Prof. M. Rangacharya of Madras has recently published his class lectures on the Bhagavad Gita in which he gives prominence to ethics as is evident from the very name of the disquisition “The Hindu Philosophy of Conduct.” Mr. Bal Gangadhar Tilak of Poona thinks that Karma Yoga is the Yoga meant to be taught in the Oita and according to him that a Jnanin ought to work for the good of the world is the central doctrine of the work. He accordingly styles the Gita as Karma-Yoga-S'astra.4 This scholar also has revived a controversy as to the true position of Karma in the Gita, besides adding a new tenet of his own, unlike all other commentators, that the Gita teaching is meant for Jnanins and not for aspirants only.
It is not necessary, however, for us to pursue here the enquiry as to the exact position of Karma in the Gita, for the real point at issue is what the Yoga of the Gita is and in the preceding pages we have shown that it is * equanimity r and that this definition applies equally to Karma, Dhyana, Jnana and Bhakti. Accordingly S'ri Krishna says “(add Sanskrit)
(add Sanskrit) (XIII
Nos. 23,25). By concentration some behold the self in the self by self, others by Sankhya-Yoga, and others by Karma Yoga. Yet others, not knowing this, worship, having heard from others; they too cross beyond death, adhering to what they heard.” Here Dhyana Yoga and Karma Yoga are recognised expressly by their own name, Jnana Yoga is also recognised by its alternative title Sankhya Yoga, for it has been stated to be expressly meant for Sankhyas in an earlier chapter (II—3). The word “worship” (TRr) clearly refers to Bhakti coupled with faith. Thus all the four lead to the realisation of the Atman, that is, are the to means Brahma Vidya. Each of these four leads to equanimity” the real Yoga and thus to the realization of Brahman. Hence there can be little doubt that the Gita as Yoga S'astra lays special stress on Yoga as equanimity. Some of the modern writers5, however are disposed to think that Yoga has an alternative definition, “(add Sanskrit)
'Fteran” and according to them this means “Skill in actions is called Yoga,” but this view ignores the context altogether. The passage in which the verse occurs runs thus (add Sanskrit)
(add Sanskrit) Steadfast im Yoga do thy works, O, Dhanaojaya, casting off attachment, being the same in success and fail-- lire. Equanimity is called Yoga. Far removed is lower Karma, from the Yoga of intelligent ■work; 0 wealth-winner, seek refuge in this wisdom, for pitiable are those that are led by desire of rewards. He who is endowed with the wisdom leaves behind both the good and the bad, wherefore apply thyself to Yoga. In regard to actions, Yoga is the skill.” Obviously S'ri Krishna is here pointing to Arjuna, how actions should be performed in order that they may not be binding. He says that they must be performed with Yoga (or equanimity), without being perturbed in mind by success or failure; he then contrasts this sort of work with Yoga with selfish work and condemning the latter, praises the former as a great power, inasmuch as actions which are of a binding Nature lose that nature when done with evenness of mind. Then Karma Yoga is concluded with the words: “Therefore apply thyself to Yoga.” Some* have thought that “gfc” in
*Prof. Max Muller seems to be one of these for he translates the present verse “He who is devoted to knowledge leaves behind both good and evil deeds, therefore devote yourself to Yoga, Yoga is success in (all) actions.” (Six flys. 406). the last verse refers to knowledge as contrasted with work, apparently on the ground that it is only for the Jnanin that leaving both the good and the bad is possible. But the conclusion “Therefore apply yourself to Yoga” is a sufficient guarantee that Buddhi is really ‘‘”, Though it is true that actions are not binding oU a Jnanin, we may be sure that we are here concerned with the fruits of actions only, for the next verse says: “For men of wisdom cast off the fruit of action, possessed of knowledge, (and) released from the bond of birth, they attain the state where there is no evil” (II—51). In any case it must be more than clear that “equanimity”* is the one Yoga thought of in the Gita.
We have shown in the preceding pages how all the four Yogas lead to this ideal Yoga and how as such they are not really so many distinct paths, but are really inter-related. This explains why the Gita begins with Jnana and introduces Karma Yoga and finally concludes with Dhyana Yoga in one place, while it begins with Karma Yoga and treating of the other two
* Cf. the Stoic ideal in Greek Philosophy. Yogas concludes with the Jnana Yoga in another place. We may select here a passage in the last chapter of the Gita, where this interrelation is more clearly suggested than elsewhere in the work. Devoted each to his own duty, man attains perfection; how devoted to one's own duty one attains success, that do thou hear. Him from whom is the evolution of all beings, by whom all this is pervaded, by worshipping Him with his proper duty, man attains perfection (XVIII—45-46). This shows how Karma Yoga and Bhakti Yoga are related, how actions performed as worship become a means of perfection. Again “He whose mind is free from attachment everywhere, whose self is subdued, from whom desire has fled, he by renunciation attains that supreme state of freedom from action.” (XVIIL—49). Here is indicated the relation between Karma Yoga and Jnana Yoga, how actlessness of the self is realised through unselfish work. Take these verses now. “Endowed with a pure mind, controlling the self with firmness, leaving aside objects like: sound, giving up love and hatred, resorting to & sequestered spot, eating but little, speech and body and mind subdued, always engaged in meditation and concentration, taking refuge in dispassion, having abandoned egotism, strength, arrogance, desire, enmity, property, free from the notion of mine and peaceful, he becomes fit for becoming Brahman.” (XVIII—51-53), We are told in these s'iokas how Dhyana Yoga leads to Brahma Vidya or realisation of Brahman. Thus it is quite possible to conceive of how Karma Yoga necessarily involves Bhakti Yoga and Jnana Yoga and through Dhyana Yoga leads to realisation of the Brahman. And we might quote other similar passages to establish similar sequences of Yoga in a different order. This should be enough, therefore to show not only that the Gita does not consider the Yogas as mutually exclusive, but also that it implies the necessity of a certain order of discipline to be followed. But still the fact remains, that according to the temperament of the religious aspirant he would be called a Yogin in accordance with the method preferred by him.
It is this peculiarity of the Gita that has baffled many a commentator, who started with a preconceived theory that the Gita wanted to establish a particular Yoga as supreme. As it is not the purpose of the present attempt to* critically examine any of these theories, we may simply repeat here again the observation made in the introductory remarks that none of these exclusive theories can find any support in the Gita. According to the Gita, we may repeat,, the ideal Yoga is equanimity and whatever leads up to that Yoga is itself a Yoga.
It is now time to formulate an answer to the main question with which we started the present discussion. “What is the value of the Gita as a guide to practical life?” If by practicality we mean a teaching to be reconciled to our present life which merely sanctions the way in which we live in the world, however gross may be its defects, then the Gita, to be plain, is absolutely of no value as a guide. For* the teachings are antagonistic to most of our conceptions of life. People of the ordinary frame of mind are, it is to be feared, mostly opposed in their trend of thought to the doctrines of the Gita. They believe in competition, in the theory that might is right, that the pleasurable is necessarily the eternal destiny of mankind and that one’s interest is identical with one’s duty. If this be the practical life,, it may be confessed at once, the Gita is at best indifferent to it, but is certainly no guide to those that wish to lead such a life. But there is another kind of practical life. Instead of trying to reconcile the ideal with our present life, we might try to gradually improve ourselves till we approach the ideal. This ideal, however high it may be, must not be an impossible one. In this sense the ideal of the Gita is quite practical. Brahma-Vidya is its ideal, the realisation that Brahman or the Absolute is the self of us all. As observed elsewhere in the course of our discussion, every one is consciously or unconsciously striving to attain the Highest Truth or Brahman. Owing to our not having an exact conception of what this ideal is are caused the different courses of action we take towards the realisation of it. Every man is therefore really following the path of Brahman, whatever course of conduct he may have chosen for himself and he is in the long run destined to take up deliberately the path of Brahman (IV—11). Hence the realisation of Brahman becomes the ultimate
* goal of every one of us. Yoga or perfect equanimity is the one condition of actualising it.
It goes without saying, therefore, that the teachings of the Gita offer the surest foundation for morality. "While moral principles are only recommended in other sacred books without offering any philosophical basis for the same, the Gita is not only pre-eminently ethical in its nature, but supports it on the surest foundation of Brahma- Vidya. We have had already occasion to note this in connection with Jnana Yoga (p. 147). And it is this feature of'the Vedanta that has been specially appreciated by foreign admirers like Dr. Paul Deussen. This scholar says “People have often reproached the Vedanta with being defective in morals and indeed the Indian genius is too contemplative to speak much of works, but the fact is, nevertheless, that the highest and purest morality is the immediate consequence of the Vedanta. The Gospels fix quite correctly as the highest law of morality, ‘.Love your neighbour as yourselves.’ But why should I do so, since by the order of nature I feel pain and pleasure only in myself, not in my neighbour. The answer is not in the Bible (this venerable book being not yet quite free of Semitic realism) but it is in the Vedas,, is in the great formula “(add Sanskrit)” which gives in three words metaphysics and morals together. You shall love your neighbour, as yourselves because you are your neighbour and mere illusion makes you believe that your neighbour is something different from yourselves. Or in the words of the Bhagavadgita, he who knows himself in everything and everything in himself will not injure himself by himself “iVa hinasti ntmana atmanam.” This is the sum and tenour of all morality and this is the standpoint of a man knowing himself as Brahman.”6
If we remember the circumstances that led to the teaching of the Gita, how Arjuna, a •fighting king, was taught these things by S'ri Krishna also a Kshatriya, in a battlefield, and how Arjuna is exhorted at every stage not to neglect his duty and how at the same time the highest philosophical truths are taught him as the one panacea for all evils of this world, we can measure the extent of practicality of the philosophy and religion of the Gita. According to the Gita there are not two worlds—one of practical life and another of religious life—but there is one undivided life, and the truths of philosophy and religion are to be felt and realized here or nowhere. Accordingly it says 4 ‘qqf feci” (V—19.) “Even in this life is nature conquered by those whose mind rests on evenness.” This verse occurring as it does after another which declares that “the wise see the same in a Brahmin endowed with wisdom and humility, in a cow, in an elephant, as also in a dog and in a dog-eating outcast” clearly points out the practical nature of the Yoga of equanimity. This Yoga of equanimity is not to be attained by taking refuge in a jungle from the vicissitudes of life and doing nothing useful. It needs, no doubt, speaking from the standpoint of Dhyana Yoga, retirement into solitude not with an aimless discontentment, but with the express object of investigating the most important problems of life. Then again after the realization the ideal wiseman is described throughout as in the above verses as spending his life in the very midst of the world. Whether they come in contact with the spiritually regenerated or with the worldly minded or even with the purely Tamasic souls who are not yet sufficiently developed to be fit for the busy concerns of life, they see in all the one and the same pure Brahman. Their very presence inspires other less-gifted souls, and their living personality is no small help to those that wish to keep up their balance of mind but are constantly tossed up and down by the waves of worldly life. Here is a very practical ideal, for every one of the thoughtful people on earth wants to get at a method whereby he can improve himself and be of some use to society. The Gita says to achieve this you must gain tranquillity of mind, perfect balance of mind. Avoiding the extremes of inactivity (add Sanskrit) an & activity with passioM (fNn?), we should ever strive after intense activity, but in the midst of it, eternal calmness. Try to see the same Brahman in all, have before your mind constantly those great souls who are ever inspired with the Divine Atman, full of the Divine Atman and Atman alone (V—17), and who see the same Divine Atman everywhere in this world of variety (V—18), and you will have a great help to secure this calm, forgiving, equable, all-loving mind which is the condition of success in life.
And this practice does not require any extraordinary special qualifications reserved only for a few. For S'ri Krishna says “(add Sanskrit) (XVIII—67). “This is not to be taught to one who is devoid of austerities; never to one wha is not devoted; nor should it be taught to one who is not obedient, nor yet to one who is jealous of Me.” These are the only con-7 ditions. One must undergo training of thought, word and deed. What this training is, is explained in the seventeenth chapter, “Worship, purity, straightforwardness, continence and abstinence from injury, speech which causes no excitement and is true, pleasant and beneficial, reading of the scriptures, serenity of mind, good-heartedness, silence, self-control and purity of nature” (XVII—14 to 16). Practice of these constitutes Tapas. He must be devoted to God and willing to obey the injunctions. In a word, no special qualification is demanded except a sincere wish to improve oneself. Provided with this qualification one may practise the discipline from where he is placed by nature. (add Sanskrit)” (XVIII-45.) tl Engaged in his own duty man attains perfection.”
Thus the Gita is of the highest practical value to those who wish to get over difficulties in this life—difficulties which are the results of wickedness and evil,—and to those who wish to improve themselves as well as their environment. We might with perhaps even more propriety quote the very expressions which have been applied to European mysticism and say “its teachings hold just as good in the family, in the market, in the Senate, in the study, aye in the battlefield itself, and teach (man) the way to lead, in whatever station of life he may be placed a truly man-like because a truly God-like life.”
1 Mr. Bal Gangadhar Tilak’s interpretation of the colophon “nifomi” as meaning “” (Yogas'astra included in Brahma Vidya) has to supply an unnecessary ellipsis. The trend of the Gita teaching as a whole clearly shows that all the locatives here individually refer to the Gita itself without any interrelation among themselves.
2 See introduction to his translation of the Vedanta Sutras.
3 See page 29, Vaishnavism, S'aivism and Minor Religious systems. Encyclopedia of Indo-Aryan Research (Vol. III* Part 6). P. 14, ibid.
4 His commentary itself, however, is called, “(add Sanskrit)” though we should have liked it to be named “” or (add Sanskrit)” meaning that Kama Yoga is the essence of the Bhagavadgita or that Bhagavadgita i* a treatise on Karma Yoga.
5 Pandit Sitanath Tattvabhushan (Krishna and the Oita, p. 176-177) Mr. B. G. Tilak (Gitarahasya, p. 67) etc.
6 The Philosophy of the Vedanta, by Dr. Paul Deussen.
7 Of. (add Sanskrit)”
Source
Pandit Lingesh Mahabhagavat, of Kurtkoti, Ph.D. (now His Holiness Sri Vidya Shankar Bharati Swami, Jagadguru Shankaracharya of Karvir and Sankeshwar), The Heart of the Bhagavad-Gita. The Gaekwad Studies in Religion and Philosophy, III. Baroda: Professor A. G. Widgery, The College; printed at Madras by Srinivasa Varadachari & Co., 1918. This text is from public domain digital sources.
Disclaimer
We have made every effort to reproduce this text faithfully, but we cannot guarantee that it is free of errors. Readers who need accuracy for study or citation should check the original publication. The views and language are those of the author and his time, and e-Scriptures is not responsible for them.
Spelling and style follow the original; obvious scanning and typographical errors have been corrected. This text is believed to be in the public domain in the United States, where this website is operated. Copyright terms differ from country to country, so a text that is free of copyright in the United States may still be protected elsewhere. Readers outside the United States should check the copyright laws of their country before copying, downloading or reusing it; they are responsible for lawful use in their own country. See our Terms of Use.