Summary: Chapter XIII of Dasgupta’s Yoga as Philosophy and Religion. It divides absorptive concentration on an object (samprajnata samadhi) into four classes: savitarka, nirvitarka, savicara and nirvicara. To explain them it first shows how a thing, its concept and its name are distinct, though the mind blends them by association. The chapter goes on to the powers (vibhutis) that come from Samyama and gives a table of the objects of Samyama and the attainments that follow. Dasgupta adds that the powers have value only so far as they strengthen the faith of the Yogi in his goal.
Samprajnata samadhi (absorptive concentration in an object) may be divided into four classes, savitarka, nirvitarka, savicara and nirvicara.
To comprehend its scope we must first of all understand the relation between a thing, its concept, and the particular name with which the concept or thing is associated. It is easy to see that the thing (artha), the concept (jnana), and the name (sabda) are quite distinct. But still, by force of association, the word or name stands both for the thing and its concept the function of mind, by virtue of which despite this unreality or want of their having any real identity of connection they seem to be so much associated that the name cannot be differentiated from the thing or its idea, is called vikalpa.
Now that state of samadhi in which the mind seems to become one with the thing, together with its name and concept, is the lowest stage of samadhi called savitarka; it is the lowest stage, because here the gross object does not appear to the mind in its true reality, but only in the false illusory way in which it appears associated with the concept and the name in ordinary life. This state does not differ from ordinary conceptual states, in which the particular thing is not only associated with the concepts and their names, but also with other concepts and their various relations; thus a cow will not only appear before the mind with its concept and name, but also along with other relations and thoughts associated with cow, as for example — “This is a cow, it belongs to so and so, it has so many hairs on its body, and so forth.” This state is therefore the first stage of samadhi, in which the mind has not become steady and is not as yet beyond the range of our ordinary consciousness.
The nirvitarka stage arises from this when the mind by its steadiness can become one with its object, divested of all other associations of name and concept, so that it is in direct touch with the reality of the thing, uncontaminated by associations. The thing in this state does not appear to be an object of my consciousness, but my consciousness becoming divested of all “I” or “mine,” becomes one with the object itself; so that there is no such notion here as “I know this,” but the mind becomes one with the thing, so that the notion of subject and object drops off and the result is the one steady transformation of the mind into the object of its contemplation. This state brings home to us real knowledge of the thing, divested from other false and illusory associations, which far from explaining the real nature of the object, serves only to hide it. This samadhi knowledge or prajna is called nirvitarka. The objects of this state may be the gross material objects and the senses.
Now this state is followed by the state of savicara prajna, which dawns when the mind neglecting the grossness of the object sinks deeper and deeper into its finer constituents the appearance of the thing in its grosser aspects drops off and the mind having sunk deep, centres in and identifies itself with the subtle tanmatras, which are the constituents of the atoms, as a conglomeration of which the object appeared before our eyes in the nirvitarka state. Thus when the mind, after identifying itself with the sun in its true aspect as pure light, tends to settle on a still finer state of it, either by making the senses so steady that the outward appearance vanishes, or by seeking finer and finer stages than the grosser manifestation of light as such, it apprehends the tanmatric state of the light and knows it as such, and we have what is called the savicara stage. It has great similarities with the savitarka stage, while its differences from that stage spring from the fact that here the object is the tanmatra and not the gross bhuta. The mind in this stage holding communion with the rupa tanmatra, for example, is not coloured variously as red, blue, etc., as in the savitarka communion with gross light, for the tanmatric light or light potential has no such varieties as different kinds of colour, etc., so that there are also no such different kinds of feeling of pleasure or pain as arise from the manifold varieties of ordinary light. This is a state of feelingless representation of one uniform tanmatric state, when the object appears as a conglomeration of tanmatras of rupa, rasa or gandha, as the case might be. This state, however, is not indeterminate, as the nirvitarka stage, for this tanmatric conception is associated with the notions of time, space and causality, for the mind here feels that it sees those tanmatras which are in such a subtle state that they are not associated with pleasures and pains. They are also endowed with causality in such a way that from them and their particular collocations originate the atoms.
It must be noted here that the subtle objects of concentration in this stage are not the tanmatras alone, but also other subtle substances including the ego, the buddhi and the prakrti.
But when the mind acquires the complete habit of this state in which it becomes identified with these fine objects the tanmatras — etc., then all conceptual notions of the associations of time, space, causality, etc., spoken of in the savicara and the savitarka state vanish away and it becomes one with the fine object of its communion. These two kinds of prajna, savicara and nirvicara, arising from communion with the fine tanmatras, have been collocated under one name as vicaranugata. But when the object of communion is the senses, the samadhi is called anandanugata, and when the object of communion is the subtle cause the ego (asmita), the samadhi is known as asmitanugata.
There is a difference of opinion regarding the object of the last two varieties of samadhi, viz. anandanugata and asmitanugata, and also about the general scheme of division of the samadhis. Vacaspati thinks that Yoga-sutra I. 41 suggests the interpretation that the samprajnata samadhis may be divided into three different classes according as their objects of concentration belong to one or other of the three different planes of grahya (external objects), grahana (the senses) and grahitr (the ego). So he refers vitarka and vicara to the plane of grahya (physical objects and tanmatras), anandanugata to the plane of grahana (the senses) and asmitanugata to the plane of grahitr. Bhikshu, however, disapproves of such an interpretation. He holds that in anandanugata the object of concentration is bliss (ananda) and not the senses. When the Yogin rises to the vicaranugata stage there is a great flow of sattva which produces bliss, and at this the mind becomes one with this ananda or bliss, and this samadhi is therefore called anandanugata. Bhikshu does not think that in asmitanugata samadhi the object of concentration is the ego. He thinks that in this stage the object of concentration is the concept of self (kevalapurushakara samvit) which has only the form of ego or “I” (asmityetavanmatrakaratvadasmita).
Again according to Vacaspati in addition to the four varieties of savitarka, nirvitarka, savicara and nirvicara there are two varieties of anandanugata as sananda and nirananda and two varieties of asmitanugata as sasmita and nirasmita. This gives us eight different kinds of samadhi. With Bhikshu there are only six kinds of samadhi, for he admits only one variety as anandanugata and one variety as asmitanugata. Bhikshu’s classification of samadhis is given below in a tabular form (see Vacaspati’s Tattvavaisaradi and Yoga-varttika, I. 17, 41, 42, 43, 44).
- Samprajnata samadhi
- Sthulavishayaka (vitarkanugata) samadhi
- 1. Savitarka (with associations of name and concept of the object)
- 2. Nirvitarka (without association of name)
- Sukshma vishayaka
- Tanmatra: vicaranugata samadhi
- 3. Savicara (with association of name and concept of the tanmatras)
- 4. Nirvicara (without association of name, etc.)
- Ananda: 5. (anandanugata)
- Asmita or purusha: 6. (asmitanugata)
- Tanmatra: vicaranugata samadhi
- Sthulavishayaka (vitarkanugata) samadhi
Through the nirvicara state our minds become altogether purified and there springs the prajna or knowledge called rtambhara or true; this true knowledge is altogether different from the knowledge which is derived from the Vedas or from inferences or from ordinary perceptions; for the knowledge that it can give of Reality can never be had by any other means, by perception, inference or testimony, for their communication is only by the conceptual process of generalisations and abstractions and these can never help us to affirm anything about things as they are in themselves, which are altogether different from their illusory demonstrations in conceptual terms which only prevent us from knowing the true reality. The potency of this prajna arrests the potency of ordinary states of consciousness and thus attains stability. When, however, this prajna is also suppressed, we have what is called the state of nirvija samadhi, at the end of which comes final prajna leading to the dissolution of the citta and the absolute freedom of the purusha.
Samadhi we have seen is the mind’s becoming one with an object by a process of acute concentration upon it and a continuous repetition of it with the exclusion of all other thoughts of all kinds. We have indeed described the principal stages of the advancement of samprajnata Yoga, but it is impossible to give an exact picture of it with the symbolical expressions of our concepts; for the stages only become clear to the mental vision of the Yogin as he gradually acquires firmness in his practice. The Yogin who is practising at once comes to know them as the higher stages gradually dawn in his mind and he distinguishes them from each other; it is thus a matter of personal experience, so that no teacher can tell him whether a certain stage which follows is higher or lower, for Yoga itself is its own teacher.
Even when the mind is in the samprajnata state it is said to be in vyutthana (phenomenal) in comparison with the nirodha state, just as the ordinary conscious states are called vyutthana in comparison with the samprajnata state; the potencies of the samprajnata state become weaker and weaker, while the potencies of the nirodha state become stronger and stronger until finally the mind comes to the nirodha state and becomes stable therein; of course this contains within itself a long mental history, for the potency of the nirodha state can become stronger only when the mind practises it and remains in this suppressed condition for long intervals of time. This shows that the mind, being made up of the three gunas, is always suffering transformations and changes. Thus from the ordinary state of phenomenal consciousness it gradually becomes one-pointed and then gradually becomes transformed into the state of an object (internal or external), when it is said to be undergoing the samadhi parinama or samadhi change of the samprajnata type; next comes the change, when the mind passes from the samprajnata stage to the state of suppression (nirodha). Here also, therefore, we see that the same dharma, lakshana, avasthaparinama which we have already described at some length with regard to sensible objects apply also to the mental states. Thus the change from the vyutthana (ordinary experience) to the nirodha state is the dharmaparinama, the change as manifested in time, so that we can say that the change of vyutthana into nirodha has not yet come, or has just come, or that the vyutthana state (ordinary experience) exists no longer, the mind having transformed itself into the nirodha state. There is also here the third change of condition, when we see that the potencies of the samprajnata state become weaker and weaker, while that of the nirodha state becomes stronger and stronger. These are the three kinds of change which the mind undergoes called the dharma, lakshana and avastha change. But there is one difference between this change thus described from the changes observed in sensible objects that here the changes are not visible but are only to be inferred by the passage of the mind from one state to another.
It has been said that there are two different kinds of qualities of the mind, visible and invisible. The visible qualities whose changes can be noticed are conscious states, or thought-products, or percepts, etc. The invisible ones are seven in number and cannot be directly seen, but their existence and changes or modifications may be established by inference. These are suppression, characterisation, subconscious maintenance of experience, constant change, life, movement and power or energy.
In connection with samprajnata samadhi some miraculous attainments are described, which are said to strengthen the faith or belief of the Yogin in the processes of Yoga as the path of salvation. These are like the products or the mental experiments in the Yoga method, by which people may become convinced of the method of Yoga as being the true one. No reasons are offered as to the reason for these attainments, but they are said to happen as a result of mental union with different objects. It is best to note them here in a tabular form.
| Object of Samyama | Samyama | Attainment |
|---|---|---|
| (1) Threefold change of things as dharma, lakshana and avasthaparinama. | Samyama | |
| (2) The distinctions of name, external object and the concept which ordinarily appears united as one. | Samyama | Knowledge of the sounds of all living beings. |
| (3) Residual potencies (samskara) of the nature of dharma and adharma. | Samyama | Knowledge of previous life. |
| (4) Concepts alone (separated from the objects). | Samyama | Knowledge of other minds. |
| (5) Over the form of body. | Samyama | Disappearance (by virtue of perceptibility being checked). |
| (6) Karma of fast or slow fruition. | Samyama | Knowledge of death. |
| (7) Friendliness, sympathy, and compassion. | Samyama | Power. |
| (8) Powers of elephant. | Samyama | Power of elephant. |
| (9) Sun. | Samyama | Knowledge of the world (the geographical position of countries, etc.). |
| (10) Heavens. | Samyama | Knowledge of the heavenly systems. |
| (11) Pole star. | Samyama | Knowledge of their movements. |
| (12) Plexus of the navel. | Samyama | Knowledge of the system of the body. |
| (13) Base of the throat. | Samyama | Subdual of hunger and thirst. |
| (14) Tortoise tube. | Samyama | Steadiness. |
| (15) Coronal light. | Samyama | Vision of the perfected ones — the knowledge of the seer, or all knowledge by prescience. |
| (16) Heat. | Samyama | Knowledge of the mind. |
| (17) Purusha. | Samyama | Knowledge of purusha. |
| (18) Gross nature, subtle pervasiveness and purposefulness. | Samyama | Control over the element from which follows attenuation, perfection of the body and non-resistance by their characteristics. |
| (19) Act, substantive appearance, egoism, pervasiveness and purposefulness of sensation. | Samyama | Mastery over the senses; thence quickness of mind, unaided mental perception and mastery over the pradhana. |
These vibhutis, as they rise with the performance of the processes of Yoga, gradually deepen the faith sraddha of the Yogin in the performance of his deeds and thus help towards his main goal or ideal by always pushing or drawing him forward towards it by the greater and greater strengthening of his faith. Divested from the ideal, they have no value.
Source
S. N. Dasgupta, Yoga as Philosophy and Religion. London: Kegan Paul, Trench, Trubner & Co. Ltd.; New York: E. P. Dutton & Co., 1924. Chapter XIII (printed pages 150–158). This article is from public domain digital sources.
Disclaimer
We have made every effort to reproduce this text faithfully, but we cannot guarantee that it is free of errors. Readers who need accuracy for study or citation should check the original publication. The views and language are those of the author and his time, and e-Scriptures is not responsible for them.
Spelling and style follow the original; obvious scanning and typographical errors have been corrected. This text is believed to be in the public domain in the United States, where this website is operated. Copyright terms differ from country to country, so a text that is free of copyright in the United States may still be protected elsewhere. Readers outside the United States should check the copyright laws of their country before copying, downloading or reusing it; they are responsible for lawful use in their own country. See our Terms of Use.