Skip to content

Yoga and Indian Thought: Yoga Cosmology

by Surendranath Dasgupta, from Yoga Philosophy in Relation to Other Systems of Indian Thought (1930)

Summary: Chapter VI of Dasgupta’s study of Yoga against the background of other Indian systems. It explains how the three gunas (sattva, rajas and tamas) rest in equipoise in Prakrti, in a movement that only maintains the balance, and how evolution begins when sattva comes to dominate and a connection with the Purusha is made. It follows the development from the buddhi-tattva into a series of subject and a series of object experience, and on to the subtle potentials and the atoms of earth, water, fire, air and ether. The notes point to Brajendranath Seal and P. C. Ray for related accounts.

We have seen that in order that a connection should be established between the prakrti and the purusha the sattva type of Reals must completely dominate the other two constituents— the rajas and tamas. But the prakrti is acknowledged to be the state in which these three gunas are in such a state of equipoise that all their individual characteristics are in a state of absolute potentiality. The gunas are of course in motion even then, but in this movement they are in a kind of inner oscillation against one another so that the movement is confined to the unified whole and only serves to maintain equilibrium and stability. This kind of movement which serves to maintain the state of equipoise) is called sadrsa parinama as distinguished from that which breaks the equipoise and sets the three gunas rolling on in the road of development, called the visadrsa parinama.

We must assume (phalabalat kalpyah) that the first step in the development is a state of sattva predominance, for otherwise it is difficult to explain the connection of the three gunas with the purushas in the earliest stage. If the connection with the purusha is not admitted as the initial state, then such a transformation, being out of touch with the purusha, would be meaningless and the general teleological attitude that the developments of prakrti are for the experience of the purushas has to be sacrificed.

But the question is how and why the prakrti should of its own accord change its type of inner movement in a state of equipoise, so as to accept the other movement which produced the transformations. Prakrti is non-intelligent and it cannot have any desire of its own to follow any particular course and change its own movement of itself. The difficulty is enhanced when we consider that the Samkhya-Yoga in common with other Indian systems believed in the doctrine of dissolution—a state in which the world returns back into the original state in the prakrti and again comes forth after a time as it existed before, through gradual transformations. The connection of buddhi with purusha cannot therefore be regarded as beginningless or anadi as it is taking place anew at each new creation after dissolution, and is broken up again at the time of every new dissolution (pralaya). Thus the question arises as to how or why the prakrti should disturb its original equilibrium in order to form the first modification as represented by a state of predominance of the sattva? Why after it is once cut off from connection with any particular purusha should the buddhi again strive to find him and again become connected? If it be a matter of accident, then the buddhi might as well accidentally entrammel an emancipated purusha. Moreover the emancipation also would be no emancipation, for even after emancipation the buddhi might equally well again entrammel purusha. This question brings us to the difference between the state of dissolution and the state of emancipation. The state of dissolution, pralaya (apiti), is like the state of deep sleep for the purushas, for just as when we go to sleep we lose all consciousness, feelings and experiences of the awakened state, but get them back again when the sleep is broken, so also in the pralaya, the purushas remain for a time in themselves, only to be again associated with old experiences at the time of the new creation. Pralaya is not a state of emancipation but almost a state of samsara. Prakrti has two movements, forward (anuloma) and backward (pratilama). It is then the karmas of all purushas which come to such a state of harmony that they by their united force demand a state of temporary cessation from the bonds of prakrti and the prakrti takes its backward movement and retraces the stages through which it developed. The state of pralaya is also a state which has been as much earned as samsara by the purushas owing to their karmas or deeds. We have remarked in the last chapter that the purusha is pure intelligence without any movement of any kind, knowledge, feelings, desires, actions all belong to the prakrti; so all karmas also belong to the prakrti and there cannot be any karma at all in the true sense for the purusha. But as we have said, the purusha experiences and takes the experiences as his own, on account of the reflection of the buddhi in the purusha, or merely owing to proximity. It is this false identification and false knowledge that constitutes the ignorance of the purusha. The prakrti is impure and changing and it is when the purusha identifies this prakrti with himself as pure and unchanging that the samsara begins. It is a wrong or false knowledge, this taking that for the self what is not the self, that is called ignorance (avidya), and emancipation only comes when avidya is destroyed by the rise of a pure state of modification in the buddhi, which closely resembles the pure purusha (sattvapurushayoh suddhisamye kaivalyam). When such a state comes, the purusha experiences its true state through the states of buddhi which shows to it that all the modifications of the prakrti, the objective physical states, as well as the mental states do not belong to it, and the result is that the buddhi returns back to the prakrti once for all and cannot again serve to bind that purusha; and like a dancing girl, the prakrti retires from the stage when its performance is over.1

There is however a technical difference between the Samkhya and the Yoga avidya, for while the Yoga holds that it is a positive knowledge opposed to the right knowledge, the Samkhya takes it to be a mere non-distinction (aviveka) between the nature of the purusha and that of the prakrti and calls this the avidya, cause of the samsara (anyathakhyati). But without entering into details as to the significance of this difference we see that from the Yoga point of view it is the taking of the buddhi as the purusha, that is the cause of the bondage of the purusha. This avidya however exists in the buddhi and manifests itself in diverse ways in the diverse modifications of the buddhi. At the time of dissolution when everything returns to the potential state, this also as a mere potential tendency returns back to the prakrti. When the time of new creation comes, the transcendental influence of the purusha acts, and Isvara removes the barrier of the prakrti in accordance with the potency of the avidyas of the buddhis which had returned back into the prakrti. The barriers being removed the prakrti by the transcendental influence of the purushas acting like a magnet, moves on for the realisation of the experiences of the purushas. These potential avidya tendencies (avidya-vija) serve to bring the peculiar modifications suited to the realisation of their potency into actuality and to show them again to their respective purushas, as their separate buddhis. These buddhis are but inherent parts of the stuff of consciousness called the mahat tattva, for at the time of the retirement of these avidyas into the prakrti, their potencies had in them the peculiarities which were inherent in them by being in association from beginningless time with the particular purushas. Samkhya finds a difficulty here, for the theory of nondistinction (aviveka) has no positive content in the avidya of Yoga. For non-distinction can only take place so long as the buddhi and the purusha are present and it cannot be said to exist in the prakrti when there is no buddhi; consequently, it is difficult to discover the agent which could modify the prakrti as the buddhi of a particular purusha in the Samkhya system. Bhikshu is therefore forced to admit that this aviveka is not a mere negative phenomenon of non-distinction, but has a positive stuff of existence or potency which resides in the buddhi and serve the same purpose as the Yoga avidya. Moreover the Samkhya does not think that the interposition of an Isvara is necessary for removing the barriers of the prakrti; though non-intelligent the prakrti by its own inherent teleology under the magnet-like influence of the purushas, can bring about the order of development necessary and suitable for the experience of the respective purushas.

Considering the different kinds of evolutes that come out from the prakrti, we find that these are classified as the aviseshas and the viseshas. The former (slightly modified evolutes) are those which being modifications or products themselves are capable of originating other products like themselves. The viseshas (thoroughly modified evolutes) are themselves the products of some causes but cannot themselves be the cause of the origination of other existence like themselves. Thus the five tanmatras and asmitamitra (ahamkara) are called the six aviseshas ; the eleven senses and the atoms of the five mahabhutas are called the visesha. Mahat itself, called also sattamatra, is properly speaking an avisesha, for it has been produced from the prakrti and is the mother of all other aviseshas, but still as it has got its special name linga, it is not generally included under the aviseshas. The production of these aviseshas and the viseshas are called tattvantaraparinama, as distinguished from the changes that take place among the viseshas themselves. Thus for example when the tanmatras are produced from ahamkara, the state of being involved in the tanmatras, is altogether different from the state of being of ahamkara. It is not merely a mere change of quality but a change of existence or state of being. Thus though the tanmatras are derived from mahat through ahamkara, the traces of ahamkara cannot be easily found in them. This derivation is not such that the ahamkara remains principally unchanged and there is only a change of quality of the ahamkara, but it is a different existence altogether, and has properties which differ widely from that of ahamkara. So it is tattvantaraparinama, i.e., evolution of the different categories of existence. The evolution of the senses and the five gross elements cannot be of this nature, for they are the viseshas which have been too much specialised to allow the evolution of any other substance of a grade of existence different from themselves. With them there is an end of all emanations and the changes or modifications that they suffer are brought under the dharma, lakshana and avastha-parinama. Thus mahat, ahamkara and the five tanmatras are themselves emanations as well as the source of other emanations. The mahat has been called the linga (sign or ground of influence) as it is the basis from which the existence of the prakrti and purusha can be inferred. Prakrti from which no other primal state is inferrible is called the alinga, or that which is not a sign for the existence of any other primal and more unspecialised state. In one sense all the emanations can with justice be called the lingas or states of existence standing as the sign, by which the causes from which they have emanated can be directly inferred. Thus the five gross elements may be called linga of the tanmatras, and they again of the ego (ahamkara) and that again of the mahat, for the unspecialised ones are inferred from their specialised modifications. But this technical name linga is reserved for the mahat from which the alinga prakrti can be inferred. Prakrti is the eternal state which is not an emanation itself but the basis and source of all other emanations.

Thus the first stage in the onward course of the development of prakrti is the mahat which comprises the knowable, the empirical universe, cosmic matter or stuff of consciousness, the intelligible essence of the cosmos evolved by differentiation and integration within the formless, characterless, inconceivable prakrti.

The relation of this stage to the individual buddhis is that they are only the parts of this universal, first great stage of being. There is however according to Samkhya-Yoga no ultimate difference between a whole and its parts, but yet it is to be understood that if the creation had been from the individual buddhis then each person would have his own separate creation and there would be no stability of the objective world as the common field of experience for all persons. It is probable that such a view was held by the primary (Maulika) Samkhya school mentioned by Gunaratna, who for the sake of consistency held that there were separate prakrtis for each individual. The reduction of the many prakrtis to one in the Uttara Samkhya school naturally necessitated the joining together of the buddhis as one tattva which in its aspect as whole was the cause of the cosmic world, and as individual parts of the separate buddhis at the disposal of each purusha, the cause of his experiences.

This consciousness-stuff is described as “sattamatra”—having no other determination than the pure being, and it is this pure being, which is at once the one and the same mindstuff and the matter-stuff. It is a state of pure sattva where the rajas and the tamas elements are extremely subordinated. The confusion in understanding the system comes in when according to popular conception the buddhi is thought of as being of the nature of individual intelligence or idea, and as a result of that the world is thought of as having sprung from individual ideas, ego-hood or “ego.” It is therefore to be pointed out again that the buddhitattva is the universal consciousness-stuff of matter from which on one side the mental and on the other the physical take their origin.

The next stage of development from the buddhitattva is a non-individuated indeterminate stuff which bifurcates into two series, the subject experience and the object experience. It comprises on the one hand the indeterminate unity of apperception or the empirical ego, as the co-ordinating principle of the subject series ; (asmita) and on the other hand the indeterminate material potencies, the subtile vehicles of potential energy (sukshmabhuta tanmatra), the ultimate subtile constituents of the object-series of the external world. The genesis of the bhutas from the tanmatras and the tanmatras from the ahamkara (ego) and the ahamkara (ego) from the buddhitattva has sometimes misled some scholars to suppose that according to the Samkhya philosophy matter has been derived from thoughts and ideas. Thus Mr. J. C. Chatterjee says in the introduction of his Hindu Realism—“There has been much confusion in the West as to the exact nature of this standard. It derives the material from the mental and the psychical, that is to say from things which are of the nature of thoughts, ideas and feelings. But in spite of this fact Prof. Garbe has yet taken it to be a form of materialism ; so much so that he has seen no place for psychology in this standard and has substituted a physiology in its stead. This is indeed strange not only because it is absolutely against the universal tradition of the Hindus, but also because it is absurd to call a system of philosophy materialistic which derives matter from thoughts and ideas.” From the description of the genesis as generally found in the Samkhya treatises such an idealistic explanation may apparently appear to be justifiable at first sight. But if we look at it in connection with the most important passage on the subject in the Vyasa Bhashya— “lingamatram alingasya pratyasannam tatra tatsamsrshtam vivicyate kramanativrtteh, etc.,” the whole system assumes such a position that it can neither be called altogether materialistic nor idealistic in the ordinary sense of the terms. For here it is said that the separation, evolution or determination of mahat as such takes place in such a way that it remains itself integrated with the prakrti all the while. Mahat is therefore not posited in opposition to the prakrti as its differentiated evolute, but what we find here is rather differentiation in integration. Mahat is no doubt differentiated from prakrti, but is at the same time integrated with it (samsrshta vivicyante). The course of evolution here described points out that in each stage, it is the prakrti itself which becomes more and more differentiated, determinate and coherent. The evolution of mahat means that the absolute homogeneity of the prakrti being negated and broken, there is the predominance of the sattva which justifies its christening with the new name mahat, sattva, liga, or sattamatra. This differentiation, however marked it may appear, cannot be thought of differently from the aspect of its integration with prakrti. As Dr. Seal points out, “increasing differentiation goes on hand in hand with increasing integration within the evolving whole, and by this double process, what was an incoherent, indeterminate homogeneous whole becomes coherent, heterogeneous and determinate.” Mahat can never be regarded as a product of prakrti outside of it but it is the prakrti which has been differentiated within itself in order to be more integrated within itself ; there is viveka, differentiation in samsrshti or integration. Integrated with the mahat we find that the ahamkara and the five tanmatras are differentiated, in a like manner. It is said no doubt that the five tanmatras are evolved from the ego or ahamkara ; but this evolution cannot be regarded as being of the same kind as the evolution of the bhutas from the tanmatras.

With the evolution of the stage of mahat, there is an oscillation consequent upon the liberation of rajas, which takes three different courses according to the predominance of sattva, rajas or tamas. The transformation which mahat undergoes by this liberation of rajas gives at one moment a shake to sattva and tamas and asserts its own predominance, and thus the differentiation which is the product of this liberation of rajas, though associated with integration, represents the root of the development of this stage in three distinct directions. Thus according to these three phases, the ego is called sattvika, rajasika and tamasika. These different phases represent the disturbance caused in the three constituent entities or gunas of mahat which will lead the ego to develop in three distinct directions. The ego however in spite of its differentiation from mahat is however integrated with it all the while, for it is mahat itself which by an element of differentiation within itself has become more determinate and coherent in the form of ego and has thus become integrated with itself in a new form. But it is said that the five tanmatras together with the ego are evolved from the mahat—“tatha shadavisesha lingamatre samsrshta vivicyante parinamakramaniyamat.”2 To understand this passage clearly we must remember that the tanmatras are generated with successive accretions from the bhutadi (tamasa ahamkara); thus from bhutadi the rudiment matter by the action of rajas, the sabdatanmatra or sound potential being generated, there is an accretion of bhutadi, and by the action of rajas, the touch potential is produced and so on; each new tanmatra is generated at each successive accretion. We must also remember that though bhutadi or the tamas side of ahamkara is regarded as being one with the conception of the ego or ahamkara, it being a preponderance of tamas is essentially different in nature from the sattva side of ahamkara. Its inclusion in ahamkara with the other two phases is due to the fact that all the three of them are associated and taken up in the very first moment of the oscillatory movement in the mahat. The successive accretions of tanmatras for the formation of the tanmatras are made from the mahat through the bhutadi; or rather the bhutadi represents the tamas side of mahat which is in a state of activity by the inherent rajas for the formation of the tanmatras. Bhutadi is the tamas or rudiment matter, mass, just when we conceive it to be unmoved by rajas for the formation of the tanmatras by successive collocations of gradual accretions and their definite combinations. It is the transitional state through which differentiation and determinations of tamas take place with the help of rajas in the very body of the mahat with which they are integrated. The being of these determinations and differentiations cannot be conceived in any way as being outside of mahat.3 In the production of the atoms however from the tanmatras the differentiation and integration take place in the tanmatras and not in the mahat. Those tattvas or categories, the genesis of which depends directly upon the differentiation and integration of the mahat are classed as aviseshas. Though the tanmatras are derived from ahamkara yet the very fact that the basis of their originating collocations lies directly in the mahat makes an idealistic explanation of the Patanjala-Samkhya doctrine an impossibility. The ahamkara also, it should be remembered, is not a mere idea of “I” or “mine” as is sometimes understood, for it is also a substance, an egostuff. Thus Bhikshu says, “ahamkarasca abhimanavrttikam antahkaranadravyam.”

The confusion that has arisen on this point is, I imagine, due to the confusion which was probably caused owing to the transition of the idealistic school of the Maulika Samkhya to the Uttara Samkhya. For the idealistic explanation of deriving the tanmatras purely from the ego could well have been defended if the ego of any individual person created his own matter, and if the matter and the prakrti vanished altogether at his emancipation ; but here in the Uttara Samkhya, with the world as one common reality and ground of objective experience for all persons, such an explanation becomes wholly untenable. But the divergence is due, as I have just pointed out, to the difference of view which naturally arose at the time of the modification of the idealistic Samkhya to the realistic Samkhya. Here is the lacuna of an imperfect modification. But that the Yoga view, as I have explained, was also a genuine Samkhya doctrine is suggested by the inconsistency pointed out by Sankara in his refutation of the Samkhya doctrine “tatha kvacit mahatastanmatramupadisanti kvacidahamkarat.” Vacaspati being a Vedantist himself seems to be inclined to explain the genesis from an idealistic point of view, which could certainly be traced in it owing to the original idealistic form of the school from which the realistic one grew up. Thus Vacaspati says, “I am, mine are the objects, no one but I myself am entitled to do it; this is the abhimana and its functioning is the ahamkara ; and feeding on this the buddhi decides or posits itself for the creation in the two series, and hence the twofold creation—the subject series and the object series.”

The bearing of this doctrine on Yoga ethics and psychology will be dealt with later on.

The three stages of bhutadi, tanmatra and the atoms have thus been described by Dr. B. N. Seal. “The ultimate condition of matter is a question of the profoundest interest in the Samkhya-Patanjala system.4 These stages clearly stand out in the genesis of matter : (1) the original infinite units of mass or inertia absolutely homogeneous and ubiquitous on which energy does work, when the original equilibrium comes to an end (bhutadi, tamasahamkara) ; (2) the infra-atomic unit potentials, charged with different kinds of energy, which results from the action of energy on the original units of mass (tanmatra); and (3) the five different classes of atoms, the minutest divisions of which gross matter is capable, but which are themselves complex tanmatric systems. The first stadium bhutadi is absolutely homogeneous and absolutely inert, being devoid of all physical and chemical characters (rupadibhih asamyutam) except quantum or mass (paricchinnatva parimana); and this admits neither of addition nor of subtraction, can neither be created nor destroyed. The second stadium tanmatra represents subtile matter, vibrating, impinged, radiant, instinct with potential energy. These potentials arise from the unequal aggregation of the original mass units in different proportions and collocations with an unequal distribution of the original energy (rajas)—“tanmatrarupadeh kim karanam iti cet sa karanadravyanam nyunadhikabhavena anyonyam pratisamyogavisesha eva svajatiyopashtambhadina vrddhihrasadikam ca yuktam.” The tanmatras possess something more than quantum of mass and energy. They possess physical characters, some of them penetrability (avakasadana), others powers of impact, others radiant heat, others again capability of viscous and cohesive attraction. In intimate relation to these physical characters they also possess the potentials of the energies represented by sound, touch, colour, taste and smell, but being subtile matter they are devoid of the peculiar forms (visesha) which these potentials assume in particles of gross matter, like the atoms and their aggregates. In other words the potentials lodged in subtile matter must undergo peculiar transformations by new groupings and collocations to be classed among sensory stimuli, gross matter being supposed to be matter endowed with properties of the class of sensory stimuli, though in the minutest particles thereof, the sensory stimuli may be infra-sensible (atindriya but not anudbhuta): “tasmin tasmimstu tanmatrah te ca aviseshinah te ca padarthah santaghoramudhakhyaih sthulagatasabdadivisesha-sunya ekarupatvat, tatha ca santadivisesasunyasabdadimattvameva bhutanam sabdaditanmatratvam.”5

“The tanmatras then are infra-atomic particles charged with specific potential energies ; first, the potential of the sound stimulus is lodged in one class of particles, tanmatras, which possess the physical energy of vibration (parispanda) and serve to perform the radicle of the ether atom (akasa-paramanu) ; then the potential of the tactile stimulus is lodged in another class of tanmatras, particles which possess the physical energy of impact or mechanical pressure, in addition to that of vibration, and serve to form the radicle of the gas atom (vayu paramanu) ; next the potential of the colour stimulus is lodged in a third class of tanmatras, particles which are charged with the energy of radiant heat and light in addition to those of impact and vibration, and serve to form the nucleus of the light and heat corpuscles; then the potential of the taste stimulus is lodged in other tanmatras particles which possess the energy of viscous attraction in addition to those of heat, impact, and vibration, and which afterwards develop into the atom of water, and lastly the potential of the smell stimulus is lodged in a further class of tanmatras, particles which are charged with the energy of cohesive attraction in addition to those of viscous attraction, heat, impact and vibration and which serve to form the radicle of the earth-atom.”

A very wide divergence of views is however found about the genesis of the tanmatras ; thus according to Vishnupurana bhutadi in conjunction with mahat, the sound potential, and this in conjunction with bhutadi produced the akasa paramanu. This akasa paramanu in conjunction with bhutadi produces the touch potential, and that in conjunction with bhutadi produces the vayu atom. Parasara again says that the sabdatanmatra is produced from bhutadi ; and from the sabdatanmatra is produced the sparsatanmatra and from it the rasatanmatra and so on. From sabdatanmatra as centre surrounded by bhutadi the akasa paramanu is formed; from sabdatanmatra as centre surrounded by sparsatanmatra and the akasa paramanu, the vayu paramanu is generated and so on.

According to Yoga-varttika on Vyasabhashya however we find that it is the bhutadi or the tamasa ahamkara, the rudiment mass which being acted on by the rajas (or rajasi ahamkara) produces the sound potential or vibration potential. This subtle sound potential with a further accretion from bhutadi generates the touch potential (impact potential) which is impingent and oscillating. This touch potential with a further accretion from bhutadi generates the rupatanmatra or the light-heat-potential. From this again in a similar manner comes the taste-potential and from that again in a similar manner with a further accretion the smell-potential.

Coming to the production of atoms we find that the sound potential forms the akasa-paramanu with an accretion from the bhutadi. The touch potential combines with the sound potential to produce the Vayu atom. The light-heat potentials combine with the two previous tanmatras of touch and sound and produce the tejas atom. Thus in the same way by the combination of the first three tanmatras, the ap atom and of the first four tanmatras with kshiti tanmatra, the earth atom is generated.

The akasa atom possesses penetrability, the vayu atom impact, the tejas atom heat and light, the ap atom viscous attraction and the earth atom cohesive attraction.6

There is a characteristic difference between the tanmatras and their respective paramanus, such that though the former are sufficiently modified to be classed as kshiti, ap, tejas, marut, and vayu, yet they are not in themselves sensible, but are rather the rudiments by the peculiar combination of which the atoms or the sensible, elements are produced. Thus Bhikshu says :— tanmatranyaviseshani avisesastato hi te na santa napi ghoraste na mudhascaviseshinah The atoms of the Samkhya-Yoga system are not partless (niravayava) like that of the Vaiseshikas, but have parts (savayava) or what is called mahat parimana. The gunas alone are here taken to be partless or (niravayava) and can be compared in that sense with the atoms of the Vaiseshikas. Thus Bhikshu says, “vaiseshikokta paramanavah api asmabhih abhyupagamyante, te ca asmaddarsane gunasabdavacya ityeva visesha, Yoga-varttika, iii. 52.” But even the gunas themselves are not wholly of an infinitesimal nature, for then the all-pervasive nature of the prakrti has to be abandoned. It is therefore to be admitted that those gunas from which the partless antahkarana and akasa are produced are to be regarded as pervasive; if they were wholly ubiquitous, then the contact necessary for the first movement of the prakrti would be inexplainable. But these atomic gunas have of course no differentiation as earth, water, etc., as in the case of the Vaiseshika atoms. But these questions were not probably solved in the older Samkhya-Yoga speculation, so the Vyasa-bhashya7 is also almost practically silent on these points. Bhikshu however in his Yoga-varttika comes to these conclusions on the supposition that the opinions of other schools could be accepted so far as they did not run counter to their own conclusions. In other places however Bhikshu himself has said that the gunas stand for all the eight substances of the Vaiseshikas, and it is these which are the permanent causes of the creation as the modifications of mahat, etc., which vary in various creations after the final dissolution (pralaya).

Turning to the development of the eleven senses we find that these are produced from the sattvika side of ahamkara with the help of the rajas. The internal organs are therefore buddhi, ahamkara, manas and the five cognitive and the conative senses. Of these the first three form together the three inner mental organs, and hold good for all experiences, past, present or future, whereas the other senses hold good only in taking the objects at the present time. Now to take a review. When at the outset of the last pralaya the gunas had taken their backward movement, and all the aviseshas had returned into the mahat, which with all the ignorance-stuff (avidya) of the purushas inherent in it had returned back into the prakrti, there came the pralaya. Prakrti is now in a state of equilibrium consisting in a uniform diffusion of the reals. The tendencies to conscious manifestation as well as the powers of doing work are exactly counterbalanced by the resistance of the mass (tamas). The process of evolutionary creation is at rest. The transcendental (non-mechanical) influence of the purusha, whether it be contact (samyoga) or mere passive attraction of proximity, puts an end to the state of arrest and the equilibrium is disturbed. But how the actionless purushas can by their influence disturb the state of equilibrium of prakrti is a point which Samkhya cannot properly explain. The Yoga has tried to solve the difficulty by admitting that the disturbance is directly effected by the removal of obstacles by Isvara. When once the disturbance is set afoot, the affinity comes into play and leads to unequal aggregation, and therefore to the relative preponderance of one or more of the gunas, and the process of formative combination (arambhakasamyoga) commences. It has to be imagined that the first stadium of evolution is a state in which the sattva or intelligence stuff, the principles of manifestation, should preponderate, for, otherwise the mutual reflection with the purusha becomes inexplicable. This stadium is the stage in which out of prakrti a development has come which holds the first germs of all things as the stuff of consciousness. When we speak of such a development, it does not mean that the whole of prakrti bas been transformed into the mahat, but it only means that some portions of it has been transformed into it. Just as portions of the ocean are transformed into foam while still the great ocean lies within itself, or just as a tree grows up knot by knot, so this universal pure being as stuff of consciousness contains within itself as inherent in it many separate buddhis or individual conscious planes which form its part. These buddhis, though they have been treated as new, contain within themselves the particular and peculiar avidyas or ignorance-stuff with which the buddhis of a former creation had returned into the prakrti at the pralaya. It is also in accordance with or for the realisation of the function of these buddhis that Isvara had disturbed the prakrti. When once the disturbance was set up, the old avidyavijas or ignorance potencies prevailed and that stadium evolved, in which new buddhis with old avidya potencies could find scope and bind their respective purushas by mutual reflection. If the potencies had been absolutely burnt by true knowledge of any purusha then that purusha could no longer be bound again, for the potency being lost no separate buddhi would evolve for him. This stadium is then on one hand the first stage through which prakrti would evolve itself towards the creation of material objects, and on another the whole in which the individual buddhis were held up in one plane. Thus from these two aspects there is a twofold creation. For the first movement or undulation of this mahat creates a strife amongst the three different gunas, and this state being a new differentiation as integrated in the mahat is called the three different ahamkaras. The sattvika ahamkara which expresses itself as “I,” “mine,” is the co-ordinating principle of the subject series which with the help of the rajasa ahamkara produced the eleven senses. So this sattvika ahamkara is one product of the mahat whereas the other product is the tanmatras by the action of the tamasa ahamkara. The sattvika ahamkara is as much a new kind of consciousness-stuff as the tanmatras with this difference that the latter charged with the predominance of tamas is ultimately reduced into the matter-stuff by a further accretion of tamas. So all these actions up to the production of the tanmatras and the asmita go on in the mahat and through it in the prakrti herself. The tanmatras are therefore not a product of asmita but of mahat directly, while they along with asmita were still in a state of differentiation as integrated in the mahat. It should again be noted that when mahat transforms itself into its evolutes it is not wholly transformed, but as some forms of it are evolving onwards, it is being fed by the fresh formations of mahat-stuff from the prakrti. Thus it is that we find that by a peculiar transformation, the gunas (comparable to Vaiseshika atoms) through the stage of a stadium as cosmic matter of experience of the predominance of sattva-stuff bifurcate into two lines, the subjective series through asmita, and the world or gross matter through the tanmatras. Every transformation is nothing but a new state of existence generated by the groupings in of the guna particles in varying proportions with the predominance of a particular type of gunas; sattva, rajas or tamas are but names to denote the classes of gunas giving their own peculiar types of manifestation, actualisation, or existence. The names sattva, rajas and tamas only serve to differentiate the characteristic differences of the gunas as are seen in the state of their development.

Notes

  1. Samkhyakarika, 59-61.
  2. Vyasa-bhashya, II. 19.
  3. This interpretation is based on Dr. Seal's interpretation of the evolution of Samkhya categories in his “Positive Sciences of the Ancient Hindus.”
  4. Vacaspati's commentary on Samkhya-karika, 24.
  5. The Positive Sciences of the Ancient Hindus, p. 25.
  6. Many other views regarding the genesis of tanmatras and atoms have been elaborately discussed in Dr. Seal's most erudite introduction to Dr. P. C. Ray's Hindu Chemistry and need not therefore be repeated here unnecessarily.
  7. Yoga-varttika, III. 52 and II. 18.

Source

S. N. Dasgupta, Yoga Philosophy in Relation to Other Systems of Indian Thought. Calcutta: University of Calcutta, 1930. Chapter VI (printed pages 172–199). This article is from public domain digital sources.

Disclaimer

We have made every effort to reproduce this text faithfully, but we cannot guarantee that it is free of errors. Readers who need accuracy for study or citation should check the original publication. The views and language are those of the author and his time, and e-Scriptures is not responsible for them.

Spelling and style follow the original; obvious scanning and typographical errors have been corrected. This text is believed to be in the public domain in the United States, where this website is operated. Copyright terms differ from country to country, so a text that is free of copyright in the United States may still be protected elsewhere. Readers outside the United States should check the copyright laws of their country before copying, downloading or reusing it; they are responsible for lawful use in their own country. See our Terms of Use.

Our books

Translate This Page

Search This Site