Summary: The closing chapter of Henry Eastman Bennett’s Psychology and Self-Development takes up the old question of formal discipline: whether the study of one subject strengthens the mind for others. He sets aside the older faculty psychology, which treated memory, reason and the will as separate parts, and explains transfer of training through ideals of method, in work and in thought. He ends by saying that books and teachers can only suggest, and that a person gains superior ability through his own careful and faithful work.
The problem of formal discipline
During the past quarter century there has been extensive discussion among educational psychologists, sometimes with considerable heat of controversy, on the problem of what is known as “formal discipline” or the “transfer of training.” The question at issue was how skill or ability acquired by a learner in one field of study is made available for application in other and different fields. For example, mathematics has been taught in the high schools primarily in the belief that it develops “the reasoning faculty”; history has been studied “to improve the memory” or “to develop the imagination”; and other subjects have been defended on the ground that they give the learner accuracy, thoroughness, and similar qualities. In reply to the commendable inquiries of the earnest student as to why he is required to study certain subjects of the curriculum he has been told in general that they train the mind. It would hardly be fair to him to close this book on mind training without giving a more definite indication of how he - + is expected to accomplish this training through the medium of his school and college studies.
The discredited faculty psychology
In times past it was thought that one’s mind was made up of a number of distinct “faculties” which were called the memory, the reason, the imagination, the attention, the perception, the will, and such. Each of these was regarded as a separate part capable of distinct development. Phrenologists claimed to have located these so-called faculties, and such traits as reverence and combativeness, in the brain and to be able to determine their respective development by the bumps on one’s skull. Educational discussions indicated that psychologists thought of these faculties almost as if they were distinct organs which could be developed by special exercise like so many muscles. Just this comparison was often made. Studying geometry was said to develop one’s reason precisely as chopping wood develops the muscles of his arms. Learning history was said to strengthen the memory exactly as walking strengthens the leg muscles. Mathematics was supposed to develop accuracy as singing develops the voice. It was asserted that any sort of work develops the will if only it is hard enough. And each faculty or ability so developed was assumed to be immediately available for use in any work to which it could be applied, just as strength acquired in lifting weights could be applied to digging ditches or pitching hay. With the rise of a more scientific psychology and an understanding of the neural processes involved, such theories became entirely untenable. “The dogma of formal discipline,” as the old idea was called, became the object of merciless attack. No longer could educators justify the requirement of subjects of study solely on the ground of their “disciplinary values,” by which was meant the separate development of these supposed faculties. If there are no such faculties, it was argued, there can be no such values in studying these subjects. Many went so far as to say that no subject should be taught in the schools which could not be defended on the ground of the practical value of the knowledge it afforded.
The problem restated
But tradition often serves to balance the extreme tendencies of changing theory; and before the curriculum was radically revised educators recognized that, whatever the explanation, the study of mathematics, the classics, logic, and some other subjects does quite commonly leave disciplinary values which count tremendously for success in life even long after the subject matter in which they were attained has been forgotten. True, some sought to explain the evident connection between the pursuit of these “hard” subjects and the superior abilities manifested by saying that only pupils of superior ability succeeded in the hard subjects, that the studies selected the students of unusual capacity rather than developed them. Furthermore, observation and more or less scientific investigation show conclusively that many who study the “disciplinary subjects” do not acquire those qualities of accuracy, good judgment, reasoning power, good memory, and the like which they are assumed to develop. On the other hand, the accumulated evidence is too convincing to be lightly dismissed that just such superior abilities are acquired by a considerable proportion of students concurrently with, and apparently as a result of, the study of subjects which are characterized by much hard work and relatively little information of a practically useful sort. Hence much thought and investigation have been devoted to the problem which may be stated thus: If the formal discipline theory is untenable, exactly what effects of a permanently valuable sort can be retained from studies, aside from the practical knowledge acquired, and just how are these values assured and made available in other activities of life?
The transfer of training
Out of the many theories and explanations there have been sifted these conclusions which are of immense importance to the student who is ambitious to make the most of his capacities. First: Some of the so-called general abilities are merely the sum total of a great many specific abilities. These are not acquired in mass or by some general trick of learning, but by patiently accumulating the specific abilities one by one. For example, ability in multiplication is not a single thing but is automatic accuracy in / each of forty-five or more distinct combinations. A good vocabulary in a native or foreign language is the sum of a large number of different words separately learned. Spelling ability is several thousand distinct items of spelling knowledge. Scientific knowledge is knowledge of many scientific facts. Such cumulative knowledge is so widely useful and enters into the solution of so many varied problems that it appears to be some distinct unitary power. Second: Many bits of knowledge and of skill acquired in the complex processes of study are required in the efficient performance of other very different complex processes of life work. These elements are simply carried over in practically their original form and applied in such very different connections as tq lose their identity except under most careful analysis. This is known as the transfer of training by identical elements.
Third: Methods or habits of work acquired in one field of activity may be transferred to other specific fields or they may be generalized and become the characteristics of one’s work in many or all kinds of activity. While each of these three views has been offered as a general explanation of all transfer of training, it now seems that there is no conflict among them; that all are true and that they supplement each other perfectly. All seem equally sound from our knowledge of neural conditions and the principles of association of ideas.
All are equally necessary to explain the facts
The first emphasizes the necessity of patient accumulation of much material from many sources. The second stresses the importance of clearness and thoroughness in detail as well as the value of selecting those details of fact and method which have the widest usefulness. Neither of these two is really discipline or transfer in the same sense as is the third, which is more complex and will be discussed separately.
Transfer by ideals of method
In our chapter on memory ‘we found that what is known as a “good memory” is really a good method of memorizing. We showed there how one may deliberately attain any desired degree of ability to remember the names, faces, and other facts regarding people—if he is willing to pay the price in persistent effort—by adopting a method of securing vivid impressions and frequent recall and by making that method habitual. A method habit so acquired may with slight modifications be applied with equal success to learning the names and characteristics of plants, animals, facts of history, numbers, vocabularies, or any other things which one may wish to remember. But merely because one has acquired such methods in connection with persons it does not follow that he will use it in the other connections. It might possibly be transferred in some degree by chance, but to become a certainty it must be purposely and positively transferred by deliberate effort. (1) The method itself must be studied and become an ideal of procedure; (2) this ideal must be consciously adapted to the new field of application; and (3) the application in this new field must in turn be made a habit. Even then it will presumably function only in the two specific fields, the one from which it was abstracted and the one to which it has been definitely applied. But now it will be possible and very much easier to apply it to a third appropriate sort of things, and then still easier to apply it to a fourth, and so on until the application of this ideal of method in every field becomes itself a habit. This method of committing to memory has then become truly generalized—is a characteristic of the individual himself as well as of his learning in any particular connection. He then has indeed a good memory in the fullest sense of the term. Probably no one -will ever perfect his ability to memorize in connection with all sorts of things. It is not desirable that he should. But so far as his training in one connection transfers and is made available in others, it is by means of this more or less effortful transfer and habituation of an ideal of method. What has > — been illustrated here by the method of memorizing is equally true of methods of problem solving, of reasoning, of controlling attention, of imagination, of perception, of any habits of work (or of neglecting work), or of such qualities as accuracy, precision, promptness, or thoroughness.
Transfer of methods of work
Some methods of thought and work are necessarily quite complex and difficult to isolate from their connections. Others are very definite and simple. To illustrate the latter, let us suppose that one finds that he has a habit of procrastination. Little matters are postponed from hour to hour and from day to day, awaiting “a more convenient season.” The result is that many things are never done, and others accumulate until they must be disposed of hurriedly at a more inconvenient season. Now, one learns through some disciplinary training of the schools, or perhaps from the harder school of practical experience, that the habit of keeping little things cleaned up promptly as he goes along avoids confusion and tremendously increases efficiency. He adopts that invaluable slogan “Do it now” as applicable to his correspondence and gets delightfully satisfactory results. He readily sees how it applies equally to keeping his desk, table, room, or class notes in shape, and with some effort of persistence forms the habit of promptness and regularity in these matters. The ideal is very simple, though extending the habit may at times require a deal of determination. He soon finds that he is developing a notably increased power of dispatch and executive ability. In like manner he finds that uncertainty and inexactness are hampering his efficiency in the study of Latin. He adopts the watchword “Be exact” with gratifying results. The fact that the ideal is so clearly and so simply expressed makes it easy to transfer to his study of mathematics and other subjects, to the keeping of his records, to his observations and drawings in science, and later to all his professional and business observations and transactions. “Be prompt,” “Never give it up,” “What is worth doing at all is worth doing well,’ ‘A stitch in times saves nine,” are other slogans which sum up ideals discovered in some particular line of activity, which are readily applied elsewhere and may in time become quite general traits of one’s work and character.
Transfer of methods of thought
Methods of logical analysis and of problem solving are more subtle and complex. It is more difficult to determine precisely wherein lies the particular key to efficiency. But the necessity is therefore even greater for getting the ideal of method clear and then for positively transferring it by deliberate effort and patience to any lines of activity in which it is to be used. For example, one learns in mathematical studies the necessity of first stating his problem clearly, of formulating definitely just what it is he is trying to find out or to prove; next, of listing the pertinent facts or data with which he must work; then, of selecting from his previous knowledge the principle or rule by which such data may be combined to bear upon the problem; then, of performing the combinations indicated and finding the desired result; and finally, of testing or proving the result. He will find that the problems of the physician, engineer, lawyer, teacher, merchant, banker, farmer, and housewife are subject to practically the same kind of analysis and solution. Whether his study of mathematics will in any degree increase his efficiency in solving these problems of life depends on whether he actually does form efficient method habits of solving his problems in mathematics, whether he becomes definitely conscious of just what these efficient habits consist in, whether these methods become his ideal of procedure in the more practical problems of life, and whether this ideal is adequately adapted to the new situations and applied until it becomes habitual therein.
Ideals of method as the aim of this book
It will be recalled that our first chapter set up as the primary aim of our study the attainment of more effective methods and habits of learning. From chapter to chapter we have followed our analysis of the several processes of mental life with discussion of the ideals and methods of controlling them effectively. We have frequently illustrated the ideals from the problems of the work of the student. The exercises at the end of each 4 chapter were formulated to bring into clearer relief in the student’s mind the precise nature of these methods of control and to afford some practice in using them. If the instructions and suggestions given have been faithfully followed, the: student will have already attained no small amount of the mind-training discussed in this chapter. If he has applied to this text and to all his work so far as they are applicable the principles of economical learning outlined in the first chapter, he will appreciate the purpose of this chapter and will have attained that purpose in large measure.
The price of mental power
In any case the reader must realize that books and teachers can but suggest and guide; that the attainment of superior ability in the solution of the problems of life depends on the faithfulness of the individual in attaining through conscientious painstaking the best methods of work in all his study, in deliberately applying these best methods in whatever other work he may undertake, and in utilizing all the principles of habit formation to the end of making these supremely important methods his most natural and automatic form of procedure. Regardless of differences in inherited endowment, each individual is concerned with the problem of making the most of himself, of all his mental powers, and the price of this attainment is persistent determination in the strenuous task of continuously increasing his equipment of knowledge, high ideals, and habits of doing all things worth while in the best possible way.
Source
Henry Eastman Bennett, Psychology and Self-Development. Boston: Ginn and Company, 1923. Chapter “The Powers of a Trained Mind” (printed pages 277–284). This article is from public domain digital sources.
Disclaimer
We have made every effort to reproduce this text faithfully, but we cannot guarantee that it is free of errors. Readers who need accuracy for study or citation should check the original publication. The views and language are those of the author and his time, and e-Scriptures is not responsible for them.
Spelling and style follow the original; obvious scanning and typographical errors have been corrected. This text is believed to be in the public domain in the United States, where this website is operated. Copyright terms differ from country to country, so a text that is free of copyright in the United States may still be protected elsewhere. Readers outside the United States should check the copyright laws of their country before copying, downloading or reusing it; they are responsible for lawful use in their own country. See our Terms of Use.
This chapter comes from a psychology textbook of 1923. Its psychology and physiology reflect the knowledge of that time and have since been revised.