Skip to content

Memory

by Henry Eastman Bennett, from Psychology and Self-Development (1923)

Summary: Henry Eastman Bennett describes a good memory as the ability to keep nerve connections and bring them into action when needed, and says that health is the largest physical factor. He sets out the conditions of permanence (vividness, primacy, recency and contrast, and repetition at increasing intervals) and the methods of learning by wholes, by meanings and through associations. The chapter also covers mnemonic devices, learning a speech, remembering names and faces, the price of a good memory, the memorizing of empty forms and, last, forgetting.

The problem

Cortical connections and mental associations would be useless achievements if they were not retained. If they disappeared like tracks made in water, not only intelligence but habit and instinct would be impossible. Without some considerable degree of permanency all the processes we have been studying would be in vain. Our next problem is to examine the manner in which the experiences and connections of the past are made available for the present and future. Where is a habit or an instinctive tendency when it is not in use? What becomes of an idea? How does it remain with us when it is not in mind, so that it may be recalled at will for service in our thinking? What is a thought when we are not thinking it? We do not and we could not think all the time about all the things that we know. When we turn to another idea, the one we have been working with seems to “go out” like the flame of a candle when it is extinguished. Does it cease to exist? Or where does it go?

Retracing synaptic paths

Though our direct and positive knowledge in such matters is decidedly limited, there can be no doubt that the retention of all such attainments depends on their persistence as synaptic pathways in the nervous system. The idea “goes out” not like a candle, but like an electric light, by the turning off of the current of energy which caused it to shine, leaving the bulb and the connections all ready to function as soon as the current is turned on again. The habit machine or the instinct system of equipment go into or out of action simply by the turning on or off of the actuating current. The special cortical connections involved in seeing, smelling, and handling a rose are doubtless the same (barring only the afferent, or incoming, currents from the sense organs) as are involved in seeing, smelling, and feeling it again in memory. The first process is set in action by the physical stimulus from the senses, and the other by some internal or related process that “gets on the line” and retraces the pathway of the former activity.

Permanence of pathways

A good memory, then, consists of a large ability to retain synaptic connections and to get them into action when we need them. The permanency of neural connections per se is something over which we have no direct control. We have no way of getting into our brains, picking out the connections we desire to have permanent, and treating them with any sort of preservative. It is possible that the durability of such connections is to some extent a matter of inherited physical structure. Some brains seem to be quick to receive impressions and some very slow. Some are perhaps more fluid in character and some more dense and solid. If the one is the more easily impressed, the other has the advantage of greater retentiveness. If the latter requires more effort to get the impression established, it is probable that the former requires more repetitions to keep it there. Whatever may or may not be true as to differing native permeability and retentiveness, it is certain that each of us is concerned primarily with making the best of what he has, and in this there is no difference of principle or procedure.

Health and memory

The largest physiological factor in both receptivity and retentivity is vigorous health. Disease, drug effects, excessive fatigue, irritation, worry, excitement, strain,—these are the things which interfere with the normal efficiency of the nervous system. Sound and vigorous health, regular habits, moderate eating, clean red blood, rest, poise, calm, together with fixed purpose and intense activity, are the conditions most favorable to power of memory as to all other powers dependent on an effective nerve system.

Conditions of permanence

Further than maintaining the most favorable general conditions of this sort, our control of the permanency of neural pathways, and hence of the mental and physical powers dependent upon them, depends wholly on our method of making them. In making the connections our control is limited only by our control of the experiences, the thinking, the mental work and physical activity by which they come into being. The strength of one’s memory lies entirely in his memorizing. Three fundamental conditions in the establishing of memory pathways determine their permanency and usefulness: (1) the vividness of the original impression, (2) the frequency of its repetition, and (3) the efficiency of associations in which it is established. We shall discuss these in order.

Vividness: (1) By violence

The more vigorously an experience is recorded in the nervous system, other things being equal, the more permanent the record it makes. An intense flow of energy brings about greater results in its pathway than a feeble flow. A violent event, like a train accident, a burning building, an explosion, is more likely to be recalled than an ordinary occurrence. The big, loud, striking thing forces itself upon our observation and our recollection. ,Circus day and the Fourth of July, by their very vividness, stand out among the days of the year; the giant among men, the elephant among animals, the brilliant cardinal among birds, the shouted sentence in a quiet sermon, the italics, capitals, and black-face type on the pages of a book.

(2) By primacy

But vividness of the impression may arise from other causes than mere violence of the sense stimulation. The first day in college, the first day of a trip to the city or country, the first money earned, the first meeting with a now familiar friend, stand out more prominently and abide more durably in memory than subsequent events otherwise like them. This is the principle of primacy, an important factor of vividness.

(3) By recency

Then, too, vividness may be due to the recency of the experience. Yesterday’s events are more vivid than otherwise similar ones of a week or a month ago, and these stand out better than like ones of a year ago. That which has but recently occurred has not yet had time to fade into oblivion.

(4) By contrast

Sometimes vividness is due to the very slightness of the impression. A quiet day at home in the midst of a bustling life; a moment of absolute silence in a boiler factory: a sudden hush in a crowd; the whispered or scarcely audible sentence which an orator introduces in the midst of his loud discourse,—these things are remembered when their much more violent surroundings are forgotten. Vividness, then, is rather a matter of differentness than of mere force. The mind readily adapts itself to violent stimuli, if long continued, so that they become the commonplace and ordinary. The deafening clatter of an elevated railroad is not heard by those who work on or near it. Bright lights, strong smells, cold weather, soon go unnoticed. Were it not so we should continue to be unable to perceive or remember anything else while in their presence. Contrast becomes the key to vividness and durability of impression. Any sort of stimulus becomes monotonous and ineffective if too long continued.

Repetition

The most familiar mode of fixing ideas in memory is that of simple repetition. Sufficiently numerous repetitions of any neural process render it automatic and inerasable. This is exactly the principle of habit formation. It is the simple, primitive, unreflective mode of any learning.

But mere dull repetition, without discretion as to emphasis or method, is probably the most wasteful and laborious way possible of committing ideas to one’s memory, requiring the largest expenditure of effort and time for the results in available remembered material. Intelligence has discovered means of greatly economizing in these repetitions. The following principles of economy in learning by repetitions should be clearly understood and constantly practiced:

(1) increasing intervals, (2) learning by wholes, (3) selective emphasis, (4) learning by content rather than form.

Economy by increasing intervals

The principle of increasing intervals is based on the physiological fact that the longer a cortical pathway has been established, the longer it will last without being exercised; or, stated conversely, the newer the pathway, the more quickly it fades into uselessness unless exercised. To make sure that a particular connection will be ready for use when needed, repetitions must be more frequent while it is young than after it has been long established. Therefore to secure the greatest permanence in memory at the cost of the fewest repetitions, these repetitions should be arranged with the intervals of time between them increasing in geometrical progression. For example, one has memorized a quotation by means of just enough repetitions to be barely able to recall it without prompting. After an hour it will have faded to a point just below the ability to repeat it. If neglected for a longer time it will be still more difficult to recall. But if at the end of the hour it is relearned, with just enough repetitions to fix it as clearly as at the end of the first learning, several hours will pass before it has faded away as much as it did during the first hour. If at the end of this time, say six hours, it is again just barely relearned, it will endure as well for a day or two as it did for the first hour or during the six hours.

Being once more just barely relearned, it will last as well for a week or two: then for some months; and if retained for a year or more by this next relearning, it will probably not be forgotten in any reasonable length of time. If, however, all the repetitions required for relearning these five or six times had been added at the time of the original learning, it would have lasted but slightly longer than without them. For practical purposes, of course, one would not expect the memory to fade away at any time. Instead, one would do his re-learning before instead of after he has forgotten the former learning. The practical rule is this: Instead of attempting all at one time to drill in a lot of dates, facts, or principles so that they can never be forgotten, learn them just far enough to be clearly able to repeat them. After a reasonable time, perhaps at the end of that study hour, go over them again until you can just repeat them clearly—perhaps once will be enough. At the end of a day repeat them again just to the same point of efficiency, and again after a week or so, after a month, and at the end of the term. No special importance should be attached to the precise divisions of time just mentioned. There is no objection, except the waste of effort, to an excess of repetitions at any time. A slight excess is always desirable for the sake of greater surety. But no amount of repetition in the first hour or the first day can possibly make a difficult piece of learning permanent without the further repetitions at later times.

Learning by wholes

Another principle of economy in memorizing by repetitions is that of learning by wholes rather than by fragmentary parts. It is the tendency of untrained minds, in committing a poem to memory, for example, to learn each couplet or stanza separately and with automatic thoroughness before passing on to the next one.

Much psychological experiment has proved this to be unwise.

It is better to read the whole selection over and over until some degree of success is attained in repeating it as a whole; then, with special attention to and repetition of parts of special difficulty, continue to deal with it as a whole. This principle is due to the fact that fragments learned separately are stored in the brain as a long series of “cortical islands” with little or no connection between them. The power to recall rests not so much in the depth of separate impressions as in the coherence of the whole; not so much in the thoroughness of minute parts as in the effectiveness of the connections among them. The whole must constitute an integral system of connections, each fragment leading on unfailingly to the next. If the entire selection to be learned is too large to be dealt with in this manner,—a matter of many pages, for example,—it is best to separate it into two or three large natural divisions, each being a logical and natural whole in itself. These units should be so large and important that no one of them could be overlooked or its relations to the others confused.

Emphasis on strategic points

A third important principle of economy in learning by repetitions is the value of constantly selecting the points of special difficulty for particular attention and extra drill. In all kinds of learning there is a wasteful tendency on the part of students to “go over and over” the lesson dully, to spread out attention and effort evenly over all parts of it as they come. This inevitably means that some parts of the task will be quite imperfectly done, while a great deal of time and effort is wasted in continuing to learn the others after they are mastered. For various reasons some portions of a particular task are more difficult for any particular learner than are others. Because they are not clear the unintelligent learner tends to slur over these very points while increasing the emphasis on those that are easier and more attractive and agreeable. The result is a mixture of overlearned and under-learned fragments. Intelligent, economical learning will consist largely in selecting the points of difficulty and in special drill upon these. Dead-level work is always wasteful in the field of learning.

Learning by meanings

A fourth principle of economy, and it is inseparable from the two preceding principles, is that of learning by meanings instead of by words. The useless waste and lifeless grind of drilling in words, words, ‘ words, is perhaps the saddest and most inexcusable folly of the student’s work. It is foolish for two reasons: first, because so much useless energy is required to learn in this way and, second, because so much stuff thus learned is useless.

The most difficult material to hold in memory is a string of nonsense syllables, for the simple reason that they utilize no cortical tracts except those involved in producing the sounds. Words are normally symbols of ideas. In connected discourse these ideas lead on from one to another in a natural sequence, making a connected and well-integrated whole.

A mere string of words is like a rope of sand, with no binding force to hold the parts together. The more nearly a passage is learned as a mere sequence of words, the more difficult it is to establish the connections in memory; while the more perfectly it is learned as a unit of intelligent presentation of thoughts, the more easily it is retained. But because at any given moment it is easier to run over a series of sounds than it is to analyze them into their meanings, lazy minds keep on drilling over the sounds and postponing the vigorous analysis. It is the same lazy and shiftless tendency that causes one to keep on doing a thing badly and with enormous labor all his life instead of stopping once for all to form a habit which will do it better and automatically; or that results in an ignorant person’s spending his life on mechanical tasks which would be done better and far more easily by a machine if he had the energy and foresight to install it. Not only are the methods of such learning wasteful, but the results are practically worthless. It is safe to say that nothing would be lost if students never memorized any lessons by words without their meanings. Always the meaning is the vital thing and the words incidental. Even in “memory gems,” quotations of particular beauty or force, songs, recitations, and the like, it is the meaning which is important. The exact words may be very desirable, but only as an attractive embodiment of the thought. Getting the words without the thought not only gives the student nothing of intellectual value but develops a habit of accepting empty symbols which is ruinous to effective study. Furthermore, the precise words of a quotation are more economically learned by first mastering the exact thought expressed by them. The words cling to the thought incidentally because they exactly fit it. If the thought has been thoroughly mastered in a passage of particularly effective wording, very little additional effort is necessary to give it expression through the same identical form.

Memory through associations

Besides the force of the original impression and the number and quality of the repetitions, a large factor in the efficiency of memory is the associative connections with which the impressions are bound together with each other and with the particular things in company with which they are later to be recalled. ‘This problem of useful associations is inseparable from those just discussed.

Recognition

Not uncommonly an idea appears in mind as a memory of something, but such that it makes us ask, “Did that really occur or did I dream it?” As a thought fragment it is vivid enough, but somehow it does not fit in with other circumstances. It seems that it could not have happened. For practical thinking it is not enough that an idea should simply be in memory. We must know that it is a reliable reproduction of the thing it purports to be. We must be able to identify it, to know positively that it is not some contorted, exaggerated, dreamed, or imagined thing. This can be done only by means of the associated ideas and memories. To recognize a person we must not merely feel vaguely that we have seen the face before, but we must know where and when, in what environment and in whose presence, or what we did before and afterwards. An idea is fully recognized when we know the settings and circumstances in which we knew it before. An isolated idea, coming one knows not whence or how, unrecognized and unidentified, can no more be trusted in our serious business of thinking than an unknown stranger could be trusted in our business affairs. Recognition is often largely a matter of feeling, a sort of comfortable “at-home-ness,” or an’ “old-shoe sense of fitness.” But this feeling of recognition, obviously due to the ease with which nerve currents retrace familiar paths, is not always reliable as a basis of sound reasoning upon the facts given by memory. It should be supplemented by an examination of the actual associations whenever there is the slightest doubt of identity. However, we are not so much concerned with how to identify doubtful ideas as with the more practical problem of how to learn ideas so that they will not be doubtful. Any idea that is very definitely and positively committed to the memory in clear and forceful connection with the associated ideas with which *it should function will be as clearly and positively recognized when recalled. This is the first essential of practically useful association connections.

Availability

The value of memory depends upon our ability to recall an idea when we need it, “I didn’t think of it” is an excuse which is used to cover a multitude of failures. Our afterthoughts are prone to prove much richer than our forethoughts or the thoughts which arise at the instant when they are needed. The things we think of afterwards and wish we had said might as well not have been known. The fine stock of illustrations and anecdotes, the telling arguments and impressive facts, the stores of information, which give some men the power to think, entertain, and convince, are only those which are so related in the stores of memory that they are available for instant use in the connections in which they can function. Every practical capacity to deal with people and with situations as they arise depends upon the availability of one’s store of knowledge. This is wholly a matter of association and organization of the material required. Unlimited inaccessible knowledge is no more valuable than none at all. Hence a fundamental principle of effective memorizing is that each thing musi be learned in the connections in which it is to be used. Only those things will be recalled together which have been associated together in the learning. “7 × 6” should not mean the table of 7’s, but should mean 42 instantly, and for it to do so it must be learned in just this one connection. Tenebant does not mean tenebam, tenebas, tenebat, etc., but means “they were holding” and should be so learned. The rule for extracting cube root is not something to say, but is a way of doing something. It should be learned by doing, not by saying. The vital question in all profitable memorizing is, In what connections will this have its value? The task of learning it is primarily one of thinking it into those connections. A roadway is useful not primarily because of the excellence of the paving, but because of where it leads. The best road is waste if it is inaccessible and leads nowhere. So with the pathways of the mind.

Mnemonic devices

Many ingenious devices are advertised for “improving the memory.” Aside from such general principles as we have indicated, these depend on more or less artificial schemes of association. These “mnemonic devices” are capable of infinite variation and elaboration. For example, to remember some unusual name you are told to discover some easily remembered trait or association and establish a connection between the name and the trait. You meet a Mr. Parmenter, who happens to be a stockbroker. You think of stocks at par, and this syllable gives you a key to his name. If he were a minister or judge you would associate the latter part of his name with his occupation as mentor. For remembering numbers you devise a key in which each digit is represented by a letter; as, for example, the phrase “I don’t shave,” in which I stands for 1, d for 2, o for 3, and so on to e for 0. Your watch number is 8824302, represented by the letters aadnoed. This “word” is somehow pronounceable and easy to remember; or, better yet, by throwing in letters not belonging to the key, a phrase is constructed, “am badly knocked.” The date 1693 could be remembered by the word “misvote,” the last two letters being rejected easily because a date could have but four figures. Some associative relation would be sought between the remembered words and the original idea, as between the watch and the fact that it should not be or possibly has been badly knocked. Fantastic as this may seem as a memory device, some of the widely known systems are decidedly more so. One may readily become extremely skillful in devising relations based on similarity of sounds, on puns, on contrasts, and other wholly superficial and unnatural relations. It is possible by such means to learn long lists of names, dates, or numbers. Those who choose to devote much time to such exercise can give memory exhibitions little short of marvelous to the uninitiated. But for the average person a memorandum book and a twenty-five cent “compendium of useful facts and figures” are more economical. There is little more use in making the mind a statistical reference book than for making it a phonograph record. Real, meaningful relations between ideas, such as can be used in practical and profitable thinking, is incomparably the best system of mnemonics yet devised. For special purposes there may be occasional applications of these artificial devices which will prove economical. At best any one of them must be a scaffolding, to be utilized only until the permanent structure can stand alone. The sooner it is dispensed with, the better the mind-training.

Learning a speech

A well-known device is the following:

In learning an address which he is to deliver, the speaker thinks of himself as entering and passing through a familiar building. He may actually pass through the building, learning as he goes, to make the associations the more vivid. His introductory sentences are associated with the steps and entrance; the first paragraph, with the first room to the right; the opening of it, with the door; and other sentences in order are connected in his mind with the pieces of furniture, pictures, etc. as they appear. If now each sentence is sufficiently well associated with its respective object, he can in imagination make the circuit of the building as he speaks and be pretty sure to find each sentence in its proper place.

Cues or key words which will start him off on each paragraph are put into particularly vivid relations with the prompting objects. However successful such a scheme may be in practical use, one cannot help wondering if it is fair to an audience to address them while one’s mind is rambling around the speaker’s house. Has one a right to occupy the time of his hearers if his words do not mean enough to himself to stay with him until they are spoken? How infinitely more effective is the speaker whose ideas are so clear and forceful that each inevitably brings its successor. It is unfortunately and awkwardly true that sometimes one “has to say something” when it is not true that he “has something to say.” The only successful way of meeting such a situation is to select an idea about which rich associations of meaning have already been stored, and going from idea to idea let each find its expression in the plainest words that can tell his thought. In other words, if you have to say something, say what you have. It is richness and beauty of thought that make for eloquence. For the learner, then, we inevitably return from every consideration of memory devices to the same conclusion: Learn all things through their meanings and make these associations of meanings as complete as possible, ramifying from each important center to all useful and pertinent relations.

Learning through appropriate channels

A waste of effort in memorizing is often due to attempting to make associations through channels which are not used in practical application. Spelling is commonly learned through the eye and oral drill, while in use it is almost exclusively applied through the hand. Much greater results are secured from the same effort by learning through the hand in writing words instead of spelling them orally. That the spelling memory is actually located in the nerves controlling the hand is shown by the fact that one can often write words without hesitation or error when he is unable without confusion to tell another how to spell them. A typist’s hands know the keyboard of his machine perfectly, although he probably could not without much delay and error arrange the letters in the order they appear on the keyboard. Diacritical marks learned and recited as a list will have little or no value in looking up words in the dictionary until they have been relearned in precisely that connection. Grammatical rules, so long as they have been learned only as statements in the book, do not function at all in correcting daily speech. They must be learned as correct forms of utterance precisely through the actual process of uttering. The free use and quick recognition of conversational forms of French cannot be learned through grammar lessons and written exercises. They must be made familiar through actual hearing and speaking. The wise student will do well to keep in mind always in his memorizing the sort of use he will have for that which he is learning, and to learn it in the connection and form of activity in which he will apply it.

Practical application

A few illustrations applying the foregoing principles will complete our discussion of this topic. Unfortunately neither pronunciation nor the principles of word formation go far toward giving us reliable associative connections for remembering the spelling of English words. A few rules are helpful to know, but their exceptions are hard to remember. A knowledge of classical stems is valuable, if we have it, but even classical words are often orthographical outlaws. For rare and infrequent words it is perhaps wise to rely somewhat on the dictionary. It is much better to use a dictionary than to try to be one. But there are a thousand or so very common words which we dare not misspell and yet cannot look up every time we have need of them. Even though they can be spelled by rule we cannot afford to interrupt our thought to find and apply the rule.

These words must be spelled instantly and automatically, independently of all associations, derivations, and phonic relations. They must be learned in this independent, unrelated way. But this skill is not attained by monotonous drilling through the spelling-books. The worst speller the writer has ever known among college students had spent more time drilling from spelling-books than anyone else he has ever known. Words should be selected for study as they are needed for use. Only those need special attention which give special difficulty. Of these, only the particular syllables and letters which give trouble should be given attention. These treacherous elements should be impressed so vividly and in such striking associations that they cannot be confused or forgotten. Troublesome words should be drilled upon as they are to be used; that is, through the hand. They must be reviewed at increasing intervals. Once learned, in accordance with the principles of habit formation, it is vital that a word shall never thereafter be misspelled. It is surprising how very few words, if misspelled and often used, give one’s writing the stamp of ignorance. Almost any student who knows enough English to get into college, however poor his spelling, could become practically perfect as a speller by discovering and permanently correcting one word a day for a month or two. The same principles apply to one’s grammar, punctuation, pronunciation, penmanship, accuracy in calculation, methods of study, and all the arts of doing the little things which make the difference between failure and success in student life.

Remembering names and faces

That very valuable and happy faculty of remembering the names and faces of people and other matters of interest relating to them can be developed just as far as one is willing to put himself to the trouble of making vivid impressions and associations at the time of getting acquainted and of vigorously renewing them by repetitions at increasing intervals. Leaders of men often owe much of their success to the popularity which comes from being able to recall people instantly by name and to remember their interests and concerns. On being introduced to a Mr. Blank one immediately addresses him by name, uses the name as often as possible in the conversation, inquires if he is related to the Blanks of Blankville, tells of the various Blanks he has known, and in every practicable way impresses and associates the name while impressing the face on his mind. He may resort to some mnemonic device, such as noting that the gentleman has a blank face, or the contrary. Meantime he is gathering data regarding Mrs. Blank and all the little Blanks, the town from which Blank comes, his business, his friends and relatives, his opinions on leading questions, and whatever is valuable to know about the new acquaintance or which may serve as a channel for future approach. At the first convenient time one recalls the name, face, and related things he has learned. Later he recalls them again in reviewing the various persons he has met during the day. Day by day, week by week, he recalls and organizes the knowledge thus acquired. Perhaps he uses a memorandum book to impress and preserve the facts further. It is told of the celebrated politician Boss Tweed that he suffered from an atrociously bad memory for names until he deliberately decided to cure the defect by telling to his wife at the end of every day and every week the names, appearance, and all related matters regarding every person whom he had met or had dealings with during the day or week. A few months of training of this sort resulted in a most remarkable development of the faculty for remembering people. It was an invaluable power for him, and he was willing to pay the price of effort to attain it.

The price of “a good memory.”

There is no such thing as “a poor memory,” for the simple reason that there is no such thing as “a memory.” One’s memory is not an original power, gift, or faculty. It is precisely the sum of the effective brain pathways one has made by his energetic impressions and associations and has made permanent and available by vigorous renewal and organization. No one has “a good memory” for all sorts of things, for the reason that he has not been interested in giving equally vigorous attention to learning all things well. Many a student with “a poor memory for dates” can recall football scores and batting averages with remarkable accuracy; while his professor, with a prodigious fund of perfectly remembered knowledge of history, cannot recall the simplest errands for his wife. Any normal person can attain any degree of memory power in any field of knowledge—if he is willing to pay the price. You may develop a phenomenal memory for names and faces, for dates, for formulas, for numbers, for poems or addresses, for business details, for the spelling of words, for languages, for anything that is of sufficient importance and interest for you to give it the effort. All the widely advertised schemes for learning “how to remember and never forget” rest upon the principles given in this chapter. They plan detailed methods of applying these principles to various learning tasks and give exercises to make those methods habitual. Some of them are doubtless of much practical value for just this reason. What really constitutes “a good memory” is a good habit of committing things to memory. The essentials of this valuable habit may be summed up in the three principles: (1) make the original impression vivid, (2) make many and useful associations, (3) repeat and review faithfully at ever-increasing intervals. Discretion must be used in selecting the modes and channels of impression that will make the most effective cortical record; in repeating, special attention must be given to points of difficulty; in associating, care must be used to make connections which will be serviceable for ready recall; and all these must be made habit. This is the price of a good memory. Anyone can have it for the price and no one can have it without.

Memorizing empty forms

Rules, definitions, and formulas are the sort of things which students often attempt to learn by the method of drilling in words while neglecting the precise thought which they express. It should be clear to any intelligent person that it is the idea and not the words which are of value. Once the thought is fully mastered, the exact words may serve to give it more permanence and definiteness. Learned in this manner—the thought first—they are usually valuable in abbreviating the thinking necessary to apply them. But when learned as a group of words of imperfectly understood import, a trifling change in the sound may render the whole absurd and the learner helpless. Used thus they are a snare to the student and ruinous to successful habits of study. The boy who wrote the following definitions on examination would better not have learned them at all:

“The imperative mood expresses a command or a treaty.”

“A partisikle does not insert action or being but expresses it in such a way as to mollify a noun or pronoun.”

He had gained nothing whatever of value and was prevented from successful study by the deplorable tendency to accept sounds instead of clear knowledge. In delivering a speech or recitation which has been committed to memory, if the reciter has first fully mastered the thought he is attempting to express he is able to put genuine expression into his delivery and can, if perchance some words should slip his memory, fill the gap impromptu in some way. On the other hand, the horrible mockery which is so often perpetrated as a “recitation,” in which the reciter rattles or singsongs through a long series of words to which he gives no expression or meaning, is perhaps the thing most offensive to good sense that ever occurs in school life. Giving true expression to interesting thoughts—whether in the words of the speaker or of some author—is valuable exercise for the speaker and attractive to the listeners, but nothing can well be more uninteresting to listeners or more harmful to habits of mind development than for a creature possessing a brain to attempt to turn that brain into a phonograph record.

Forgetting

Our last word in this chapter on remembering is a brief one on forgetting. We have already said that nature has provided no directly controlled means of unlearning. We can make connections at will through our control of our actions, but we cannot reverse the process. The only way to break a habit is never to use it. The only way to forget an idea is to cease to think it. But this is a hard thing to control. The disagreeable things we would forget come unbidden to mind and stay with no welcome or urging. The more we seek to drive them out by force, the more they stick. Physiologically it is obvious that we do not close a pathway by keeping the energy going over it, even though we are wishing it would not do so. There is but one way to keep nerve energy out of forbidden channels; that is, to keep it busy in other channels. If you would not think of some thing, think intently of something else. Let there never be an exception. Whenever the unbidden idea seems about to present itself proceed calmly to busy yourself with things worth while. The devil finds works for idle brains, as well as hands, to do, and the only means of escaping the devil’s work is by being fully preoccupied otherwise.


Source

Henry Eastman Bennett, Psychology and Self-Development. Boston: Ginn and Company, 1923. Chapter “Memory” (printed pages 160–180). This article is from public domain digital sources.

Disclaimer

We have made every effort to reproduce this text faithfully, but we cannot guarantee that it is free of errors. Readers who need accuracy for study or citation should check the original publication. The views and language are those of the author and his time, and e-Scriptures is not responsible for them.

Spelling and style follow the original; obvious scanning and typographical errors have been corrected. This text is believed to be in the public domain in the United States, where this website is operated. Copyright terms differ from country to country, so a text that is free of copyright in the United States may still be protected elsewhere. Readers outside the United States should check the copyright laws of their country before copying, downloading or reusing it; they are responsible for lawful use in their own country. See our Terms of Use.

This chapter comes from a psychology textbook of 1923. Its psychology and physiology reflect the knowledge of that time and have since been revised.

Our books

Translate This Page

Search This Site