Summary: Henry Eastman Bennett treats habit as the machinery of the mind. He describes it as a set of nerve connections made firm enough by repetition that an act follows its cue automatically, and compares it to a machine that saves effort so long as what it does is worth doing. Practice does not make perfect unless it is right practice, he says, and he explains how to form good habits by selective drill, attention to the hard points and thoroughness, how to break bad ones, and how to choose the habits worth forming.
The outlet of instinct to action
Instinct is blind. We have already noted that it knows not the right or wrong, neither can it see to direct its force in any effective way. Intelligence must furnish the guidance both as to ultimate values and as to practical working. The one is a matter of moral purpose, the other a problem of skill. At present we are concerned with the latter. We must find how these vague forces of life can be connected up with the practical work they are to do. The winds and streams, the energy buried in coal, petroleum, or gasoline, are comparable to the unharnessed forces of instinct. The engines and machines by which these forces are made to do the work useful to man serve the same sort of function as the skills and habits of action which are set up through our learning.
Necessity of automatic processes
All our practical processes, muscular or mental, involve more or less of elements which must function in a purely mechanical and automatic fashion. Such, for instance, are the strokes used in swimming, the skillful swinging of an ax, the formation of the letters in a written word, the spelling of common words, the combinations in addition and multiplication, the grammatical structure of ordinary sentences. One has no time to consider the case of a pronoun to be used when he is speaking if he desires to have interested listeners, to recall the formation of a letter or its place on the keyboard of his typewriter if he is to write his thoughts efficiently, or to think up the product of six times seven if he is to use multiplication in a practical way. Neither can he consider how he is to maintain his balance or to turn the handle bars when riding a bicycle, nor how to manipulate the clutch or steering gear when driving an automobile. These things must be absolutely automatic. One merely thinks what he wants to say or to write, where he wants to turn, to speed up, or to stop, and his well-formed habits do the rest. Skill in speaking, in writing, or in driving a car, or in anything else whatever, consists precisely in a series of thoroughly automatic acts so coordinated as to secure the desired results with the least expenditure of time and energy. These automatic processes are what we know as habits.
Physiology of habits
From our understanding of the nervous system it is easy to see that a habit consists in a set of synapses so definitely established that under a given stimulus a perfectly certain and definite muscular response will take place. The synaptic pathway is established by doing with effort just the thing we wish to do by habit, and by repeating the doing of it until the successive performances, each leaving an increased strength in the synapses involved, have formed a neural pathway so strong that it is reasonably certain to function just as intended without effort to direct.
Habits and machines
A habit is quite like a machine in that it is the most economical and reliable means of doing a perfectly definite thing in precisely the same way a great many times. Whenever there is sufficient demand to justify its installation, a good machine will produce its precise single sort of product with a rapidity, ease, and accuracy far beyond the possibility of piece production. The machine utilizes the cheaper and more reliable forms of power and enables the intelligence of one worker to accomplish what perhaps ten or a hundred were required to accomplish by the slow, laborious methods of hand production. The tremendous capacity of modern industry is due to this accuracy and economy of machine production. So a useful and well-established habit accomplishes its special task with a certainty, speed, and definiteness which is impossible in any process which must be directed at every step by attentive thought. Then, too, it utilizes mere muscular power, leaving the thought processes and attention free to direct other matters at the same time. When the bicycling, piano-playing, typewriting, or other much-used sorts of activities get to the point where they “do themselves” with mechanical ease and accuracy, one’s mind is free to busy itself with other matters while these go on automatically; one can enjoy the scenery and converse on quite foreign topics while he pedals his wheel or guides his automobile more safely than if he were thinking only of what his hands and feet are doing, or he may give his attention to the thoughts and feelings he would express in music or writing instead of forgetting these in the fingering of his keys or pen.
Habits invaluable
The value of our equipment of habits is often not appreciated because they serve us so perfectly and unobtrusively that we are ordinarily no more conscious of them than we are of the operations of a right-functioning heart or stomach. Habits may become so completely a part of our organism that we are not aware of their existence. If we should imagine our helplessness without some of these, or if we were deprived of them through some unhappy paralysis, we should become keenly conscious of the vital part they play in our life economies. If we had to learn to walk anew every time we have to go about, if all our attention had to be focused on the lacing of our shoes and the buttoning of our garments as when we first attempted them, if we had to handle knife and fork each time with the concentration and effort required when they were new to us, if every thought had to be expressed with the laborious struggle involved in using an unfamiliar language, it requires little imagination to realize that we should not get far in an ordinary day’s work. Every simplest act would involve the strain and tedium of a child expressing his thoughts in his first written letter.
Extravagance of useless habits
But a machine is an expensive and difficult thing to install and would be most extravagant to employ for products which are not to be used in large numbers. So the establishing of a reliable habit which will insure one’s doing a given thing with the least thought and effort and with the greatest rapidity and accuracy is a most expensive educational process. It involves more expenditure of learning effort than the learning of the same thing on any other plane. Therefore it is of primary importance that care should be taken in determining which activities should be made habitual. Do not install a machine to do what you will seldom have occasion to do. It is tremendously wasteful. Yet this is precisely what a student is doing who laboriously “learns by heart” a lesson which he can never use again in that form except in the recitation following. There may be some elements in any lesson which will be constantly needed to serve in an automatic way thereafter, but it is certain that an overwhelmingly large part of what we get from books has no such value.
Waste through imperfect habits
It must be equally evident that a machine which does its work incorrectly is more certain to waste its materials and to produce unsatisfactory results than if the same work were to be done by hand. The more easily and frequently it operates, the greater its waste. The machine has no choice as to its product and no discretion as to the value of it. It simply does what it is formed to do, good, bad, or indifferent. Adjusted to turn out a bad product it will be absolutely sure never to turn out a good one. You cannot improve its product by speeding it up nor by working it longer hours. Yet many a child is seeking to improve his penmanship simply by writing more, or his ability to study simply by studying more, or his spelling ability by spelling more. Repetition secures ease and rapidity in doing exactly the thing which is repeated and in nothing else, certainly in nothing better. If a written character is poorly formed, the more often it is so formed the more certain that it will continue to be poorly formed, and the more difficult it will be ever to correct the form of it. If composition work is carelessly prepared, the more often it is done the more improbable that it will ever be done differently. In the nervous system it is by the very doing of a thing that the synaptic machinery for doing it is formed; the way in which it is done determines the quality of the habit.
Does practice make perfect?
“Practice makes perfect” —only if the practice is perfect. Just as truly it has been said, “Practice makes imperfect” —if the practice is of that sort. Practice merely fixes its own character. Let us revise the old saw to read Only perfect practice makes perfect.
How to form right habits
When it has been decided to construct a machine, much thought must be given to experimenting, adjusting, correcting, readjusting, improving, until exactly the correct product is attained, and the simplest, surest way of getting it with the least cost and waste. Then constant watchfulness is necessary until it is certain that the machine is so adjusted that it will continue to perform precisely and without variation. Not until then can it be trusted to be self-acting without further adjustment. Habit machines are no different from other machines in these particulars. So long as a thing needs to be learned, it is by that fact incapable of being done correctly without careful attention. Merely to repeat the imperfectly learned process is to fix it at its present stage of imperfection. What is necessary is that at each repetition the effort be carefully studied and compared with the ideal, its imperfections noted, and the next effort devoted to correcting them. Each repetition is a determined effort consciously directed toward more nearly attaining the ideal. One correct performance cannot be expected to outweigh the influence of the many incorrect ones leading up to it, so that further continued attention is needed after perfection is mastered to make sure that there is no backsliding. Such will be the history of the attainment of any difficult bit of skill. Happily most of our learning is much simpler. Whether a single repetition be needed, as in spelling a simple word, or many thousands, as in pitching a curved ball with accuracy, the fundamental law laid down in the nervous structure is the same—attentive and corrective effort toward the ideal at each repetition alone can insure correct habit formation. One need have no fear of continuing the attention and correction too long, for it is an inevitable condition of our make-up that when attention brings no changes it wanders to other things and the process quickly becomes automatic. In other words, if attention is accomplishing nothing it will not stay.
Primitive learning
Mere repetition is the most primitive sort of learning. Where intelligence plays no part at all, some chance or necessity starts the process, each act influences the next one to follow its own model, and this blind repetition fixes permanently that chance form. If the process happens to be a good one, the creature profits thereby; if it prove injurious, the creature is ultimately destroyed by the very fact of the irresistible tendency to continue in the ruinous practice. This is simply the story of the “survival of the fittest,” the law of evolution. Development goes on more or less blindly without foresight of its trend. If the development chance to be a fortunate one, success and survival attend the individual and its race; if it chance to be harmful, the species is exposed to its enemies or is helpless to overcome its prey and ceases to exist. Only the pleasure which may attend the satisfaction of its needs or the pain which may accompany its injury affords any guidance for the unthinking creature to direct it toward its welfare rather than to its destruction.
Unguided learning is primitive
A child set to the task of learning, without guidance as to how that learning is to be done, will inevitably follow the primitive, natural way of mere repetition. In the abstract sort of learning required for school lessons it is seldom that the pleasure-pain index of the success or failure of his efforts will be sufficiently definite to correct his procedure. Quite commonly he is wholly incapable of knowing whether he is making any progress. At best he can only know that he is or is not succeeding in the mechanizing process which he is attempting. Whether it should be mechanized at all, or to what extent, is entirely beyond his knowledge. However persistently and conscientiously he may apply himself to the task, he cannot be expected to have foresight of the future uses of the material he is working on or to be able to analyze it into the elements which should be made automatic and those which should not. Nor can he without guidance know when his repetitions are constantly approaching the ideal and when they are merely fixing in habit the errors with which he first approached the learning task. As the pupil matures and assumes more and more the direction of his own learning processes, it is this analysis and guidance of his learning efforts that he must ever keep before his mind. He must know that effective learning is not by means of sheer persistence in stupid repetition, but by increasing the intelligence of his efforts.
Selective drill
The particular name applied to this learning by repetition with the aim of forming habits is drill. It is important to notice not only the particular things which should be mastered by drill but also the particular parts of them upon which drill is necessary for that mastery. Most habits are rather complex and involve some elements which are difficult to acquire along with others which are quite easy. Great economy results from intelligent analysis and concentration of one’s effort upon the points of difficulty. Some familiar examples may be drawn from our primary-school experiences. In learning multiplication there were a few combinations—mainly of sevens and zeros—which caused probably nine tenths of all the blunders we made. It would have been a small matter, if we had been so guided, to have detected these troublesome points and, by concentrating our drill upon them, to have perfected the whole process. Some of us, however, were so unfortunate as to spend our energies on trying to learn to multiply correctly by drilling on multiplication in general or by continuing to “oo over” the tables in general. The result was that so much time was expended in continuing to “learn” the combinations we already knew perfectly that we continued to get wrong those which we missed in spite of much discouraging drudgery. In spelling there were a few “demon” words so constantly recurring and so commonly misspelled as to give one the hopeless feeling of being a “naturally poor speller.” Some of these were which, there and their, whether, written, grammar, and separate. Possibly some of us are yet pursued by these unconquered demons. In each there are not more than one or two letters which could possibly give us trouble. In some it is the problem of doubling a consonant, in others an elusive unaccented vowel. By focusing drill intensely on one difficult word at a time, and strictly upon the danger point in that, good spelling becomes a habit in a surprisingly short time. In learning a foreign language there are a few idiomatic expressions, a few adverbs and particles, which cause a very large proportion of our difficulty. To spread the drill evenly over all parts of the vocabulary invariably means that an enormous amount of energy is wasted on elements already known or on those too little used to justify drill, while the real keys to mastery escape us. To “go over every word of the lesson ten times” means that a great deal of work will be done which is not worth doing, much will continue to be done which is already done, and usually the thing that most needs to be done remains undone. It is quite probable, too, that in this blind way one may be expending his energy in drilling in the very errors that he is supposed to be drilling out.
Habits in and out of their setting
An important part of every habit is the connection in which it is to serve. It may be possible to practice a good swimming-stroke on the floor, but it is useless unless it will serve automatically in the water. Penmanship which is good in a copy book but careless or illegible elsewhere is not good penmanship. A word learned correctly in a spelling-class but misspelled elsewhere is not learned. It is hardly worth while to use correct English forms in the grammar class if they are not used out of it. Classes exist only that the things learned in them may be used out of them. Not only should the habits supposed to be formed during one’s study be applied afterward, but much waste in learning will be avoided if that which is learned is learned in the connections in which it is to be used. The synapses formed by learning a word in a spelling-list or in spelling it orally are probably quite different from those required to spell it automatically with a pen. There may be some value in learning the declensions and conjugations of a foreign language, but the associations thus formed have very little in common with connecting the mode, tense, number, and person ideas with the forms which represent them in reading or speaking the language. To be useful the associations must be learned in the sort of connections in which they are to be used. Why should amant be learned in connection with amo, amas, amat, amamus, amatis, when it never means these nor is ever used in association with these except in a grammar class? Why should “six times seven are forty-two” be learned in association with the “table of sixes,” since it can never be used in that connection except in recitation and since the knowledge of it as it is in the table does not by any means insure a knowledge of it as it is practically needed? Some values there may be in forming lists of dates, rulers, capitals, etc., for comparison, but only those things should be reduced to habit which are to be frequently used and then only in the sort of connection in which they are to be used. Students even go to such absurd lengths of study waste as to “learn by heart” (that is, reduce to automatic habit) the very words of a history, a geometry, or other lesson. They are setting up at cost of great effort habit-machines to do a thing that will never have to be done but once, if at all, and by so doing they inevitably miss the real educative benefits to be attained from the lesson.
Overdrilling and thoroughness
There is danger also of much waste of energy and often of actual retardation of the learning by means of overdrilling. A false idea of “thoroughness” is commonly responsible for this fault. It is much as though one should seek to build up a sound physique by developing one muscle at a time. Suppose he should attempt to develop the right biceps to full size and strength before beginning on the left biceps, and only when this, in turn, is “completed,” he should start on some other muscle or organ. This is scarcely more absurd than the effort to “complete” nouns before “taking up” verbs, to “finish” equations before “leaving” them, to get one lesson “perfectly” before starting the next. Nature has not provided us with that sort of an organism in either the nervous system or the muscular system. A biceps can be developed thoroughly only along with and in coordination with other muscles and organs. After undue exercise the biceps “goes stale” and must have rest while some other exercise is going on. So in any physical or mental drill, thoroughness does not consist in learning the one thing to completion before taking up the next, but in continuing the one so long as satisfactory progress continues; then passing on to the next related task which applies and tests the former; then, as defects in the former are discovered, correcting them and drilling them, returning again and again to strengthen the weak points until perfection is attained. Thoroughness is not in doing a task of habit formation all at once, but in never abandoning the task until it is done. One must never forget that habit-forming is a growing process. Nerve tissues must be built up, and this takes time. It goes on as truly in the period of rest after exercise as during the exercise itself. When the nerves have built up and restored themselves after one period of drilling they are ready to profit by further drilling. Then, too, the learning connections are formed as truly by the use of them in the work that involves them as by the separated drill. Many skills can be acquired only in the connections in which they are practically used, others need to be taken out of their setting for special drill and then relearned in their true association, but any of them are fully and thoroughly learned only when they function easily just as they are to be used.
Rate of learning
Progress in the learning of any special skill does not often go on at a uniform rate. After a period of encouraging success there will usually be an “off day,” perhaps several of them. Not only is there little or no apparent increase of ability, but there may be an actual decrease. This fact stands out clearly in practically all “curves” or graphs showing the rate of improvement in typewriting, telegraphing, the tossing of balls, and other carefully measured results of drilling. It is not certain whether these “plateaus,” or periods of retardation in growth, are due to defects in the method of learning or to necessary reorganizations in the nerve system. It may be that an ideal training could avoid them entirely, or it may be that they are like the temporary interruption of traffic while improvements are being made in the roadway. In any case they are to be expected. There is no occasion for discouragement or for slackening of effort when these times of no apparent progress occur. Only over-drilling and excessive fatigue are to be avoided. The next spurt of improvement may come very suddenly and unexpectedly, and it is likely to be particularly rapid after an unusual period of retardation. Besides faithful practice the only things needful are careful analysis of the process and more intelligence in adjusting and improving the mode of learning.
Habit-breaking
We have been discussing those habits which are difficult to acquire, which require effort and intelligence to form effectively. Our natural habit-forming tendency, however, causes us to form countless habits unintentionally and even unconsciously. Many of these are absolutely necessary to our welfare, but all of us know only too well that many habits get themselves fastened upon us which it is quite essential to our welfare that we break away from. If good habits are a priceless equipment for success and happiness, bad habits are an equally certain means of unhappiness and failure. Bad habits are relentless enemies harbored within us. It would seem to be common sense at least to insist that the habits we keep should be our friends. We have seen in an earlier chapter that there is no direct way of disconnecting neural pathways already formed. There is no way of unforming habits by direct effort and attention. It can be done only by letting them disintegrate through disuse. This is the sort of thing which cannot be speeded up or hurried. Watchfulness and persistency, not hurry or intensity, are the means of getting rid of habits. We may sometimes long for an operation or an amputation which would, however violently, get rid of them once for all. But this is no more possible than getting into the brain to make the connections we desire. We make a habit only by repeatedly doing the thing that the habit is to do; we break it only by never doing the thing it does. Once a neural pathway is well formed an occasional repetition of the act involved at long intervals is sufficient to keep it in full force and vigor.
If we seek to destroy it, these occasional repetitions, at however long intervals, must not occur. As James forcibly expressed the situation:
The drunken Rip Van Winkle, in Jefferson’s play, excuses himself for every fresh dereliction by saying, “I won’t count this time!” Well! He may not count it, and a kind Heaven may not count it; but it is being counted none the less. Down among his nerve-cells and fibers the molecules are counting it, registering it, and storing it up to be used against him when the next temptation comes.
The fact that one repetition after a long period of inactivity is sufficient to restore the efficiency of a habit is most encouraging when we are seeking to retain habits of value to us. It seems most discouraging when we long to rid ourselves forever of those which have enshackled us. It emphasizes what we have said about nature’s laws and those of the nervous system being entirely neutral morally. They do not necessarily make for either good or bad. They are merely facts which we may use either for or against ourselves. Intelligence is given us that we may learn these laws, just as we may learn the laws of any other science, and make sure that we use them only for our good. The simple, cold fact is that if we would break a harmful habit we must cease at once to permit it to function and never permit an exception.
If we find that at any time we have slipped, there is nothing to be gained by blaming fate or luck or an unkind providence,—they have nothing to do with it,—but get another grip and hold on all the tighter. One other important thing we can do to loose the grip of habit. Get busy at something else. As we shall see in subsequent chapters, the idea of an act tends to produce it. Therefore, do not think of the thing you desire not to do. Think of the thing that ought to be done, and do it. When temptation is strong to do the thing we have resolved to quit, we must concentrate our energies upon the things we have resolved to do.
The choice of habits
Successful learning, then, in the field of habit formation consists first of all in a wise selection of the habits which are formed. The student owes it to himself to see that all his habits are his friends. He should early form the basic habit of determining for himself what habits shall count in his life and character instead of having them selected by mere chance. In his study he should decide intelligently which portions of his assigned lessons are of a sort that should be made mechanical and which are not. Because it is wise or necessary to know a thing is no reason for forming it into a habit. It is wise to mechanize only those acts which are to be much used, and these only in the form and connections in which they are to be used. The inventory of one’s habits should show first of all those which make for health and vigor,—habits of posture, breathing, eating, cleanliness, exercise, and rest. There should be habits of promptness, regularity, and concentration in daily routine. There are a vast number of special movements whose accuracy and ease make the difference between success and failure, between ease and awkwardness, between certainty and uncertainty in all our work and play--whether it be milking a cow, sweeping a floor, throwing a ball, playing a piano, or wielding a pen. There is usually one best way of doing each, and that should be made habitual. Muscular skill is one measure of success in every trade. Very important to a student are correct language habits, the right pronunciation and spelling of words commonly used. Fundamental processes in mathematics should be mechanized: the use of the decimal point, commonly used types of calculation, the basic processes in algebra, and a few constantly used formulas in the sciences. Beyond these and others already suggested in this chapter there are few things in ordinary book study which need to be completely mechanized. Always it is a consideration of the extent to which an ability is to be used and the connections in which it is to be used that should guide the student in the selection of the habits which he is to form.
The degree of habituation
We have followed the custom of speaking of habits as though each were a distinct entity, or thing in itself. The habit aspect is rather a quality, like the hardness or smoothness of a road, which may be attained, by sufficient expenditure of energy, in any degree desired for any neural pathway. The synaptic path underlying a habit differs from any other only in the greater degree of mechanization, or automatization, to which it has been subjected. The wise student or teacher will consider every act of learning, mental or motor, not only as to whether it should be habituated but as to the degree in which it should be habituated. Any thought or act may become a habit, and any kind of thinking or acting become as mechanical as may be desired. Intelligence must decide whether one will gain or lose thereby.
Source
Henry Eastman Bennett, Psychology and Self-Development. Boston: Ginn and Company, 1923. Chapter “Setting Up the Machinery—Habit” (printed pages 45–61). This article is from public domain digital sources.
Disclaimer
We have made every effort to reproduce this text faithfully, but we cannot guarantee that it is free of errors. Readers who need accuracy for study or citation should check the original publication. The views and language are those of the author and his time, and e-Scriptures is not responsible for them.
Spelling and style follow the original; obvious scanning and typographical errors have been corrected. This text is believed to be in the public domain in the United States, where this website is operated. Copyright terms differ from country to country, so a text that is free of copyright in the United States may still be protected elsewhere. Readers outside the United States should check the copyright laws of their country before copying, downloading or reusing it; they are responsible for lawful use in their own country. See our Terms of Use.
This chapter comes from a psychology textbook of 1923. Its psychology and physiology reflect the knowledge of that time and have since been revised.