Summary: Henry Eastman Bennett describes emotion as the affective element of experience intensified, with a physical basis that is much like the other. He explains the biological function of the emotions and how they come from earlier stages of evolution, why conflicting tendencies block one another, and the Lange-James theory. He then treats the control and the transformation of emotions, their use and abuse, emotion in drama and literature, and moods and dispositions, and says that self-mastery is the prime mark of higher manhood and womanhood.
Affective element intensified
Sometimes the affective element is not merely a gentle stimulating or retarding tone of an intellectual process. It is often a great flood of neural energy surging through the nervous system with an intensity which wholly obscures the mental process which gave rise to it. We are provided in our “fearfully and wonderfully made” organisms not only with the local centers of interest and the mildly invigorating centers of affective stimulation but with tremendous reservoirs of that nervous energy which, when once the floodgates have been loosed, sweeps away in its resistless current all judgment, reasoning,and normal mental associations. Such general disturbances commonly occur as reactions to particular stimuli. Some object or idea, which might under normal conditions start a calm intellectual process more or less affectively toned, seems to tap some mighty reservoir and turn loose the overwhelming flood which breaks down all ordinary controls, upsets normal balances and safeguards, arouses violent physical activity, and often leaves the entire mind and body exhausted, confused, and out of adjustment. These violent upheavals are known as emotions. Some emotional states, to be sure, may be relatively mild, but they are emotional to just the degree that they are disturbances.
Physical basis of emotion
The physiological background of emotion is obviously similar to that of the affective element, only much intensified. The pathways into which energy flows with such violent force must be those which are deep-laid in our inherited connections or which have been established by intense and vivid experiences. The reservoirs are more than the mild centers of interest. The so-called “sympathetic nerve system” seems to serve in large part as a store of excess energy which is released on occasion of these emotional upheavals. The release of this energy not only floods the specific connections involved in responding to the particular stimulus, but overflows violently through the whole nervous organization.
Biological function of emotions
Emotions, like every other natural tendency, physical or mental, serve a valuable purpose somewhere in the development and life of the creatures in which they occur. To understand this function we must again glance back to the primitive existence of men and of animals in a low order of existence. There are situations in the life of a savage or of a wild animal when their embryonic intelligence is wholly inadequate to determine the necessary line of action or to set it effectively in motion. When confronted with a serious danger which one is incapable of understanding or intelligently combating, some powerful impulse is necessary to get the legs in motion for effective flight or to get the lungs in motion to utter a useful call for help or to frighten the enemy. One must run or scream before he can think. Slow-acting thought is ineffective in the face of an energetic enemy, and the fighting force of blind rage is the only means of safety or victory. The very preservation of the primitive race depends upon a sexual attraction and mother love which does not wait for the feeble reason or intellectual purpose. The presence of a serpent, indicated by a characteristic slight movement or gentle hiss, is a matter of too vital concern in primitive life to trust to any reasoned response. Action instant and vigorous is imperative, and the inherited instinctive machinery insures that this slight stimulus shall release a powerful response to the exclusion of all other interests. Thus nature has provided in emotions a means of instant and effective action which functions in many situations of most vital concern to the creature.
Emotions and evolution
But the tendency to inherit these deep-laid instinctive pathways persists long after the changed conditions of civilized life have removed the necessity for them and when the developed intelligence has become a safer guide. Although the milder and more elevated emotions serve an important purpose in even the highest levels of rational life, the more violent forms often become as dangerous to a civilized being as they were necessary in primitive existence. Uncontrolled fear, anger, jealousy, or passionate animal love have no place in a law-abiding, intelligent life. Those who give way to them will find themselves in constant trouble—if not in jail. The primitive impulse to fight means an appeal to teeth and fists, but civilized conflict must be in organized armies, courts of law, or organization of competitive industries. The savage impelled by fear must run, scream, or hide; modern man appeals to the police. The savage type of reaction to a rushing elephant is quite ineffective as a means for a pedestrian to avoid an automobile. Knowledge has largely eliminated blind fear and unreasoning rage. The prevalence of firearms and the resistless organization of government render primitive emotions helpless to accomplish their original purposes.
Conflicting emotional tendencies
Although in a primitive unreasoning existence the instinctive emotional action affords the best and perhaps the only means of preservation, even there it often proves woefully inadequate. Under some circumstances safety lies in flight, in the face of danger of another sort the only protection is in hiding, under other circumstances in screaming or shouting, at other times in keeping perfectly still, again in climbing a tree, or perhaps in turning and fighting. Instinct has coupled each response with the situation for which it is adapted. But confronted with some new sort of danger, the creature often is helpless to choose one form of reaction to the exclusion of others, and the resulting emotional conflict produces a shaking of knees, a chattering of teeth, hair standing on end, cold sweat, an utterly helpless collapse, with no effective or useful action whatever. Instinctive emotions have not kept pace with the changes of modern life, so that some such pitiful confusion and helplessness is the frequent outcome of the surrender to emotion of a civilized being. Indeed, it is precisely the uselessness of such simple and direct forms of instinctive response in the utterly changed conditions of our civilized life that gives rise to our most intense emotional disturbances. So long as the sudden discharge of energy can find an outlet in effective action, the result is practically the same as though equally vigorous action had been directed by intelligence; but when the conflicting impulses are pulling in contrary directions they block each other, and unless intelligence can get control and direct an effective form of action, the pent-up emotions increase the confusion and helplessness. A human being is never quite so contemptible or seems so unworthy of being an intelligent creature as when in blind rage, uncontrolled fear, or helpless embarrassment, he writhes and flounders in miserable futility.
Lange-James theory
From the preceding discussion it will be seen that an emotion is an automatic, more or less instinctive, response to a definite stimulus which sets it off. We do not see a lion, decide that it is dangerous, and become disturbed as a result of that judgment. The disturbance is immediate and follows directly from the original stimulus. Any judgment in the matter comes afterward, if at all. Ordinarily if we could but suppress the emotion until we can reason upon the situation, the emotion would never arise, certainly not the conflicting, paralyzing sort of emotional disturbance. As James has said, we do not cry because we are sorry, but we are sorry because we cry. We do not scream and tremble because we are frightened; we are frightened because we scream and tremble. The physical reaction (that is, the crying, screaming, and trembling) is immediate and automatic, like the action of a nickel-in-the-slot machine, and we become conscious of our own disturbed state and of the cause of it at practically the same instant. This is better appreciated when we recall our own embarrassment after we have given way to a startled scream, a fit of anger, or unseemly laughter. Sometimes we are heartily ashamed of ourselves and wonder why we did it. The reason is, we did not do it; it did itself. The scream, the jump, the weeping, or other display of emotion had got under way before thinking started.
Control of emotions
Our practical problem—as it is with all instinctive tendencies, with habits, and with the mildly emotional affective element—is to make our emotions our helpful servants and to keep them from getting the mastery. They are subject to training through the supremacy of the intelligence. The habit of acting from intelligence rather than from emotion is the chief distinguishing mark of a civilized and developed being. Self-mastery is the prime mark of higher manhood and womanhood. “He that ruleth himself is greater than he that taketh a city.” The conquest of anger, hatred, prejudice, passion, and selfishness is the essence of Christian spirit. An American statesman has defined civilization as the progressive conquest of fear. The method of accomplishing this mastery of the primitive self through the higher gifts of our guiding intelligence is simply the method of all habit formation. We must first set clearly before our minds the desirability of acting from thought, principle, and purpose rather than from impulse; then we must practice it persistently, faithfully, and without exception. We must train ourselves to “think before we act.”
Their transformation
But control of the emotions should by no means result in a hard, cold, or unfeeling personality. Much of the brightness, sweetness, and richness of life would be lost if we were to become wholly unemotional. A life that is altogether cold and calculating may be more efficient for some purposes, but it is joyless and hardly worth the living. The ideal is to “sublimate” the emotional impulses; that is, to refine and elevate them. Instead of mere physical responses to definite situations we must encourage those fine impulses, abiding purposes, and high ideals which impel men and women to the best things of life. It is not desirable to crush out the emotion entirely, but to redirect it into higher and better channels, to transform it into an inspiration to noble living. One should not cease to hate, but he should learn to hate evil, filth, and meanness. Fear, instead of being a mean, cowardly trait, may be elevated to a beautiful spirit of respect for things worthy, deference to superior wisdom and worth, reverence for things pure and holy, a fear to do evil, “the fear of God.” The fighting impulse is as much needed in modern civilized life as in the primitive, but the higher need is for this fighting impulse to overcome obstacles, to conquer one’s own evil tendencies, to vanquish difficulties in the way of wise and useful progress. It is a savage, childish thing to be ever ready to fight one’s playmates, to quarrel with one’s companions, to resort to fists to settle differences; it is a noble thing to use all one’s skill and intelligence, all the resources of government and science, to fight the physical, moral, and social diseases which afflict a people. A student has use for all his fighting energy in conquering the problems of his daily work. The sex impulses when they descend to a primitive form in a civilized community bring in their train untold sin, sorrow, and suffering but, sublimated to fit the higher relations which civilization affords, they become the inspiration of chivalry, courtesy, all that is loveliest in home life, and much that is finest in music, literature, and art.
Use and abuse of emotions
The function of emotions being to bring about action, the most common and usually the most effective means of arousing people to action is by means of an appeal to emotions. The cold intellectual decision as to what ought to be done does not by any means get it done. The emotional energizing force is ordinarily a large factor in the actual results. On the other hand, under the influence of too great emotional stimulation people do many things they would never consent to do under the direction of calm intelligence. In the “heat of argument” the attitude of contention looses emotional energy; and as this grows stronger it supplants judgment and reason, it arouses a corresponding emotional attitude in the antagonist, and instead of an appeal to reason, which is the essence of argument, the whole becomes a mere conflict of blind impulses and leads to nothing more than sheer antagonism. Shrewd boxers and prize-fighters know that if one can madden his opponent he is an easy winner, and the basest means are sometimes resorted to to make blind wrath supplant the antagonist’s intelligence. In all sorts of contests “a cool head” is an asset no less important than great skill. Every baseball “fan” knows the disastrous results of getting the pitcher “rattled.” “Whom the gods would destroy they first make mad.” The really “good fighter” in any race for victory is one who can intensely desire success, who never entertains discouragement or other enfeebling emotions, and who never for a moment loses the supremacy of his judgment. Because emotions get action rather than judgment, political arguments are commonly addressed to prejudices and the intense feelings. Just here is the great strength of the social and industrial “agitator.” The untrained mind does not easily follow complex reasoning, but emotions are readily aroused in even the very ignorant. From what has been said it should by no means be concluded that an emotional appeal is in itself bad or undesirable. Like other primitive forms of mental activity, emotions are neither good nor bad: they are forces which may be utilized either for good or for bad. Intelligence must determine in what direction and how far they shall have sway. The noblest purposes as well as the basest are made effective by appeal to the emotions. It was the appeal to patriotism, loyalty, and sympathy for the oppressed that aroused the American people to give freely of their means and to make all manner of sacrifices during the World War and after it. The great “drives” for funds for various splendid causes have owed their success to the emotional character of the appeal. The power of the religious revivalist is in the fact that he is skillful in reaching the emotions of his hearers. His purpose is to bring them to a point of decision, and hence the emotional appeal is the effective one. But even these exalted emotions may be excessive and actually injurious if not supported and restrained by judgment. Religious enthusiasm has led to emotional excesses, to insanity, and to other psychological results as far as possible from the true religious aim and character. Patriotism may be aroused to fanatical partisanship and bitter hatred.
Emotional drama and literature
Normally, then, the emotions are a means to an end. They should result in conduct. Few things are more hurtful to strength of character and the power of achievement than the constant stimulation of emotional states which lead to nothing. Emotional literature and the drama (including motion pictures) are valued because of their power to arouse these emotional states. Within certain limits the mere pleasure of this stimulation is adequate justification for it. Whatever adds to the richness and joy of living is to that extent good and worth while. But the stirring up of one’s anger against the villain, admiration for the courage and honor of the hero, sympathy for the wronged and oppressed, should leave its traces in the nervous system in such form that when like conditions arise in real life, there will be a greater readiness for and capacity for doing something to defend the right or to suppress the wrong. Not only is fact often stranger than fiction, but, as Aristotle pointed out centuries before the time of Christ, good drama is truer than history. By this he meant that drama should depict the natural and normal effects of conditions, impulses, and traits of character as they would be if allowed to work out to their logical and natural conclusions; while in history, accidents and influences which could not be foreseen constantly intrude to upset the normal effects of the causes which we attempt to trace. Good drama and fiction, then, untangle the confused threads of actual life and seek to arouse in the reader or hearer the right emotional attitude toward the moral and social conditions which are affecting society, to the end that he may react intelligently and effectively toward these conditions. In so doing they are educative in the highest and best sense. But drama and fiction may be bad. They may stir up emotions or they may associate them in ways which have no place in clean and efficient character. Much that appears upon the stage or is published as literature is wholly untrue to psychological or social fact. Much of it is merely an overemphasizing of the most unwholesome aspects of life and society. To allow oneself to be stirred by the foul and morbid when no helpful constructive action is to result is just to destroy the purity and beauty of life without any compensating advantage. Even to arouse good motives incessantly, with no reaction but sighing, crying, wishing, and dreaming, is to make one’s character sickly sentimental. It is not a thing to be ashamed of, but rather to be proud of, that one is tender-hearted, easily moved to tears, indignation, or laughter, provided that on occasion one is also moved to effective conduct; but deliberately or weakly to permit the endless arousing of emotions, only to let them dissipate into useless sighing, is to destroy one’s power of decisive action, and this should be as much a matter of shame as the hardest callousness.
Moods and dispositions
Some persons are too much swayed and dominated by their emotions. They are emotional people. Others are always seeking the superficial tickling of their emotions for the pleasure of shallow thrills, but with no effective outlet to useful action. They are merely sentimental. Others easily become affected by certain emotions for longer periods of time. For example, one becomes angry, and instead of the anger working itself out on its legitimate original object, it takes possession of him and finds expression in everything he does. He “takes it out” on anything and everything. Again, he is sad, and for a time all his world is dark and dreary. Something pleases him, and immediately everything affords him joy. These are moody people, and the mood of the day colors every experience while it lasts. All of us doubtless are more or less emotional, more or less sentimental, and more or less moody. Our judgment is given us to control these more primitive impulses, and the wisely ordered life keeps a careful check and balance on these emotional states. A slave to emotions is the helpless tool and plaything of whosoever chooses to play upon him; he is driven about by the winds and waves of chance; he is sorely buffeted by adversity and whirled off his feet by good fortune. He is not the master of himself. Whenever one mood is permitted to hold sway for a very long time, it tends to become habitual. It becomes one’s permanent and perhaps unchangeable emotional character; it becomes a disposition. We all know many people of many dispositions —“grouchy,” suspicious, selfish, sullen, quarrelsome, gentle, kindly, friendly, brave, generous, happy. As each of us controls his own moods, so he can determine his disposition—not easily, perhaps, but certainly subject to his own choice, provided he chooses early and exerts enough of will and determination in smothering the emotions he would not have dominate and in acting upon those he would crystallize into his disposition.
Source
Henry Eastman Bennett, Psychology and Self-Development. Boston: Ginn and Company, 1923. Chapter “Emotions” (printed pages 229–239). This article is from public domain digital sources.
Disclaimer
We have made every effort to reproduce this text faithfully, but we cannot guarantee that it is free of errors. Readers who need accuracy for study or citation should check the original publication. The views and language are those of the author and his time, and e-Scriptures is not responsible for them.
Spelling and style follow the original; obvious scanning and typographical errors have been corrected. This text is believed to be in the public domain in the United States, where this website is operated. Copyright terms differ from country to country, so a text that is free of copyright in the United States may still be protected elsewhere. Readers outside the United States should check the copyright laws of their country before copying, downloading or reusing it; they are responsible for lawful use in their own country. See our Terms of Use.
This chapter comes from a psychology textbook of 1923. Its psychology and physiology reflect the knowledge of that time and have since been revised.