Summary: Henry Eastman Bennett explains attention as the focus of consciousness, with its range and function, and separates the primitive attention caused by strong stimuli from the intelligent, purposive attention a student must cultivate. He treats the control of attention (the surroundings, the bodily attitude, habits of attention and the building of mental momentum), plans and schedules, and fatigue and second wind. He ends by saying that purpose is the key: the mind attends only where it has work to do.
What is attention?
From our earliest days in school we were told to pay attention or to give attention. We soon found that it is impossible to learn without attention. If our minds were wandering away from our lessons to something of more interest, we missed what was said, read without grasping what it was we were reading, and all because we failed to pay attention. Our attention had a way of wandering from the tasks in hand, which was very unprofitable for us—but usually quite pleasant. This thing, attention, was forever running away, and we had to bring it back. It liked the things we liked and avoided those we would have liked to avoid, but somehow we were unable to learn things when it was absent. After all these years of giving it and paying it, of capturing it in all its wanderings and putting it on our work, have we yet a clear idea of what it is? When we examine it, it seems to be just our thought—our reasoning, thinking, remembering.. When we are attentive to any given thing, we are simply thinking about that thing; when we are inattentive to it, we are thinking about some other thing. And that is all there is of it. It is no new power of the mind, different from those we have been studying. To give attention to a thing simply means to think about that instead of something else. The mind is always more or less active. That upon which it is acting is that to which it is giving attention. Attention is the point of greatest activity in the mind.
The focus of consciousness
At any given instant in our waking lives our senses are being assailed by countless different stimuli. Light waves from every object within the range of our vision are playing upon the retinas of our eyes. Sounds of many sorts are almost continually entering our ears. There is usually some sort of odor in the atmosphere and some taste in our mouths. Some appreciable degree of warmth or coldness is affecting the temperature sense in the skin, and practically every inch of the surface of the body is being subjected to some pressure from our clothing, the things we are touching, currents of air, etc. Yet with all these and other sense processes going on, we are quite unconscious of most of them and are definitely noticing just one or a very few things. We are looking at some object, and for the time being the others which are in the range of sight have scarcely any more existence in our minds than if they were entirely out of sight. We are listening to one thing, and the others are not heard so far as we are aware. If, however, something else attracts our attention, we look at or listen to that, and it is the former thing that passes out of our minds. As we said, in discussing memory, an idea seems to “so out” when the current is turned off. As we saw in that connection, the countless things that we know are all lost in oblivion when we are not thinking about them. Of the - innumerable experiences which you could be thinking about at this instant, of the whole range of ideas that you might be working with, all are out of existence for the time except just this that we are discussing. The connections are still in the brain, but the current is not turned on. Unlike an electric illuminating current, the current of nervous energy can be turned on in full force at only one point in consciousness at a time. While one part of the mind is active the others are inactive; while we are attending to one idea we are inattentive to all others. Or, to use another figure, attention may be likened to a searchlight, and the “mind” to the whole area over which it may throw its beams. It may be turned at will from one point to another; it may “pick up” a moving object and follow it; it may be held to one point, while all the other points in its field are in darkness. But it cannot be spread out over the whole field at once. This is the nature of the mind, it is focal; that is, its activity is always focused upon a single point.
The range of attention
The single thing we are looking at may be one bird or a flock of birds, it may be one tree or one leaf of a tree or a whole forest; we may listen to a single note of the violin or we may be attending to the whole composite music of the orchestra; we may be observing a letter or a word or a sentence; we may be thinking of an individual thing or of any group or class of things; but in any case what we are attending to is a single idea, a single unit of thought. It is a single mental object. Our feet and many muscles may be engaged in walking (a habit which has become mechanical), our hands may be doing something else, while the mind is on yet another thing. Or the mind may be shifting with lightning rapidity about a group of more or less related separate things, or it may be wandering aimlessly about without much intensity of application to anything. But a careful analysis seems to indicate that at any instant only one thing can be in the focus of attention. Usually there is a more or less definite fringe of objects or ideas which are almost in focus, of which we are vaguely aware, which seem to be crowding into the edge of the focused area and demanding our attention, but they are just outside. Just before or after some especially exciting or interesting event it seems to stay very close to the focus: at any instant we are apt to find ourselves thinking about it; it tones or affects our thoughts of every other thing; we “cannot get it out of our minds”; it makes it hard for us to divert our attention to other things. But the mind is actually working on just one mental object at a time, however often that object may change.1
The function of attention
This limiting of the mind’s activity to one thing at a time may sometimes seem unfortunate, just as at times we may wish we could be in several places at once. Be this as it may, it is a marvelously wise provision that we can concentrate all the mental light we have, all our power of intellect, on each or any one point in its whole range at such time as we have need to do something with that particular idea. The true value of any mental power (or physical power) is to be found in the way it aids us to react most advantageously to the situations in which we find ourselves. For this purpose the concentration of our whole mental force on one point at a time, together with the ability instantly to transfer it to some other point when needed, is unquestionably the most efficient scheme of which we can think. Attention thus not only focuses the whole power of the mind so as to attain the greatest intensity of efficient activity, but it is a selective process which is constantly choosing out from the whole world of sense material and ideas those which are of particular concern for our present purposes.
Primitive attention
This tendency of the mind to act only at a focal point is, of course, a natural or instinctive characteristic. It is the only way the mind does act. We “pay attention” more or less vigorously whether we intend to or not. To do so purposely means that we select according to our purpose the thing to which we shall be attentive and hold the mind with more or less effort to that thing. In primitive life, where intelligence and reflective thought are at a minimum, attention is valuable in the proportion in which it automatically turns the mind to the thing in one’s physical environment which “needs attention”; that is, to which one has need to react. If a thorn is pressing its way into the flesh of a savage, the consequent pain demands and insures his prompt attention and such adjustment as will remove the danger. If he hears a sound or sees a movement in the bushes, however slight the stimulus itself which indicates to him the presence of some mortal foe, his attention is immediately fixed upon this danger signal, and all less urgent matters must be put aside while he reacts according to his habit or intelligence. In more civilized life this primitive instinct still functions when pain, unusual or striking objects, loud, insistent or peculiar sounds, or an unexpected touch as of a slimy or furry surface which suggests some noxious animal, intrude themselves on our sense perception.
1 Surprising exhibitions are given of writing quite distinct matter with each of the two hands simultaneously while answering questions, performing mental calculations, etc. This can probably be explained as a remarkably rapid shifting of attention, together with unusual automatization of some of the processes. If such cases are truly instances of multiple focusing of attention, they are so abnormal as not to affect our statement regarding normal attention.
Any sense phenomenon which by its very force or by its suggestion of importance to our welfare strikes in upon our conscious lives demands and gets attention. Psychologists speak of attention thus externally directed as involuntary attention or, because it is done to us rather than by us, as passive attention.
Intelligent or purposive attention
But in the intelligent life it is necessary to hold our minds to abstract things and to those which are uninteresting to a primitive mental organization. It becomes necessary to pay attention to lessons even in spite of the countless things that are appealing to our instinctive involuntary attention. This purposive focusing of the mind is called voluntary or active attention.
Obviously all study, all mind training, all ability to think of things other than those which are from moment to moment present to the senses, or to select those subtle qualities of things with which a primitive mind would not be occupied, are dependent upon this power of voluntary attention. Just as experience teaches the savage that the faint hiss of a serpent is of much more immediate concern to him than the loud roaring of the wind or the continuous thundering of the waves, so it is not the clanging of the trolley car nor the roar of a neighboring mill that concerns us so much as the problem of mathematics which we are solving or the abstract discussions of psychology which is our task for the time being. The increasing development of the thought life more and more involves the power of attending to ideas regardless of their sense appeal or inherent interest. This power of voluntary attention is the key to self-control and to mental mastery.
Effective, enduring attention
But the turning of the mind to a subject or object is quite a different matter from holding it there while a difficult thought process is going on. The fact that the thinking is hard ordinarily means that the cortical connections involved are obscure, difficult to make, and require genuine effort. Opposed to this effort to hold the attentive center of the mind in difficult paths are the persuasive attractions of all the objects and ideas which clamor for the involuntary attention. Our ability to hold to the matter in hand depends upon our ability to get a hearing for it, to connect with some beaten or established pathways through which the energy will flow freely to the new connections we are seeking to follow. Once this has been done the new associations seem to develop their own energy, which works its way step by step along the line of thought. We may compare it in this respect to a fire which is started slowly and with difficulty; but, once under way, it generates its own heat, which prepares the adjacent material to catch, and this in turn starts the next, and so it continues to gather force and headway. By voluntary effort we may bring the attention to bear upon a lesson problem, but involuntary attention will call it away again unless we can get into the subject sufficiently to generate this continuing sort of attention which holds itself to the subject by its own activity. We apply the torch of active or voluntary attention only to start the fire of mental activity which will work its way through the problem. This continuing attention is sometimes called by psychologists nonvoluntary or secondary passive attention. These names are applied because of the fact that no effort is required to hold the mind to the subject in which it is once actively engaged, and that while it is passive in this sense, the process becomes so only after it has been well started by either the voluntary or the involuntary directing of the mind to the subject. A circus parade, for example, attracts the focus of mental activity by passive attention, and then because of its natural interest holds it by the secondary passive sort. A novel may require an effort of the will, active attention, to get the process started, but we are soon absorbed in it because of this secondary passive attention. This continuing attention, then, is the sort by which mental work is done, the mental motor power for which the others are merely starters.
Control of attention
The practical problem we are concerned with in this whole matter is how to keep the mind at work where we want it to work. The simple savage or untrained mind is forever at the mercy of the senses, is at the beck and call of the easy or striking things which command involuntary attention. The trained mind, on the other hand, through voluntary attention, directs its efforts where it will and gets the “secondary passive” activity at work upon those problems which the higher intelligence indicates are of the most consequence. We all know that it is not always easy to pay attention just when and where we should, and yet it is precisely upon one’s ability to do so that the power of his mind depends. Easy or hard, it must be done if our minds are to do work, to solve problems, to overcome difficulties. It would be very gratifying if we could suggest some simple trick by which this could be done, but there is none. Sheer determination alone can accomplish it. If at first we don’t succeed we must try, try again. The task is made much easier by removing the distractions of involuntary attention as far as possible. It is well to turn our backs to the window so that passing vehicles will not attract the eyes; to seek a quiet place or insist upon silence in our study room that attention may not be switched to frequent sounds; to make provision for proper lighting and temperature; to be comfortably seated and clothed; to have our pencils well sharpened and to provide good paper, pen, and ink or whatever tools we are working with, so that none of these things may unnecessarily intrude themselves into our thought processes once they get under way. Annoying worries and distracting thoughts of pleasure make it hard to hold one’s mind to its task. If they intrude despite us we must determinedly recall our minds from them and focus on the task in hand until we have got the continuing attention under way and have lost ourselves in the active solution of our problem. The only way to keep the wrong thing out of mind is to keep busy on the right one. The only way to keep thinking of right things is simply not to think of wrong ones. The physical world cannot be wholly prevented from sending messages to our eyes and ears, though we can to some extent remove ourselves from them. Effective concentration, however, is not in fleeing from disturbances, but in training ourselves to ignore them, to inhibit distracting ideas, and to focus and absorb our mental energy so completely in one problem at a time that others have no distracting force. “What can’t be cured must be endured!”
Bodily attitudes
If one is very attentively watching something, there is a tendency to lean forward as though to get a closer view, although he may not thereby aid vision in the slightest. If one is listening intently, he tends tc strain toward the source of the sound as though he could thus hear better. As one watches a race or a football game in which he is deeply interested, every muscle is strained and taut as though somehow he could thus help his team. A speaker often expresses his thought and feeling as much with his face and gestures as he does by his words. All this indicates something of the close relation there is between the activity of the mind and that of the body. Much can be done toward making a given mental activity more easy or more effective by assuming a bodily position in correspondence with it, by establishing a harmony between bodily and mental attitude. An alert, forward-leaning, aggressive position of the body is favorable to the vigorous conquest of mental problems. The schoolboy fighting hard with a troublesome task takes an aggressive position and supplements it with a frown, clenched teeth and fists, and a tension of the muscles of all the body. In studying a particularly difficult passage a good student finds much assistance in reading it aloud with all the expression possible and with emphatic gestures such as he would use in explaining the passage to another. To enjoy a humorous article thoroughly we should encourage the smiles and chuckles; the suppression of them suppresses the enjoyment. An experienced teacher or public speaker is constantly reading the minds of his pupils or auditors through their facial expression. He knows which are actively at work and which are mentally idle, which are sympathetic and which are hostile. The posture and expression of the auditor not only aid but are actually a part of the hearing and understanding. Some writers regard this physical tension as the essential character of attention.
Habits of attention
The greatest aid in the control of attention is in making that control a habit. Habit, as we know, makes any form of activity easy, reliable, and automatic. The key to large powers of intellectual application and achievement is the habit of getting quickly into a subject, of immediately and effectively eliminating all other matters from the mind, of ignoring all sorts of distractions, of applying ourselves with all the intensity of concentration of which we are capable. Such habits, like all others, are attained by getting a clear idea of just what it is we wish to do and then doing it intensely, repeatedly, constantly, accurately and permitting ourselves no lapsing back into careless and ineffective ways. Not only are our powers tremendously increased in this way, but the joy of work is greater by the elimination of the constant conflict of annoying distractions. We have more time for equally complete relaxation and for enjoyment of well-earned pleasures. Too much stress cannot be laid on the value of habits of intense concentration as a means to an efficient, successful, and happy life. These habits are within the control of each student and are limited only by his determination.
Concentration and mental momentum
When we consider (1) that mental activity goes on at only one point at a time, (2) that real effort and energy are required to focus it on any difficult task, (3) that continued concentration is required to generate the energy necessary to solve any difficult mental problem, (4) that the mental momentum is largely lost whenever one’s mind is withdrawn from one problem and directed upon another, it must be obvious that fluctuating attention is enormously wasteful of mental energy. It is as though a burning-glass focused the rays of the sun upon a point which one is seeking to set afire. Just as the smoke begins to rise, the rays are turned elsewhere for a moment. Again they are focused upon the point desired, but now it has cooled off, and the process must begin again from the start. So, again and again, nearly all that has been accomplished is lost because the cumulative effect of the heat is wasted. And thus great attainment in mental work is dependent largely on momentum, and this upon continuous, unrelaxed pressure. Long periods of intense application absolutely free from physical distractions or mental fluctuations is the price we must pay for thinking things through. Trains of thought, like trains of cars, consume more energy in frequently starting, stopping, and starting again over a short distance than they do in continuous running for a long distance. It is the momentum that counts in covering distances and in getting large results from power expended. Don’t waste your mental momentum on trivial distractions.
Plans and schedules
Many an earnest, hardworking, and faithful student wastes much of his energy and meets with constant discouragement for the lack of a very simple device. His trouble is that in his conscientious zeal to do many things he permits his attention continuously to be distracted from one to another. He plunges into some absorbing task, and about as soon as his attention has become fully effective for doing the work in hand to advantage, something reminds him of another task undone. He feels that he is neglecting it. He drops the one thing and takes up the other. Presently he feels that he ought to have completed the first before leaving it. Then he hesitates about taking up a third, and to whichever he applies himself, or however hard he works at it, his attention is more or less wandering to the other things he thinks he ought to be doing. Concentration under such conditions is impossible, and hence efficient work cannot be done. If, now, he should list in advance all the tasks he has to do; assign to each the due proportion of time that it should receive, allowing ample time for rest, recreation, and other things necessary or worth while; arrange a schedule showing just what he proposes to do in each of the twenty-four hours; check over the schedule until he is satisfied that it is as he wants it, then follow it without question or hesitation,—he will immediately be relieved of all anxiety and distraction as to the use of his time. Then when any task is taken up he knows that during the time given to it on the schedule, nothing else is of any concern to him. In this simple manner the hardest workers may often more than double their mental efficiency without increase of effort. A train of thought, to maintain its momentum, must have a clear track. Form the habit of working by schedule. Before starting a task that requires concentration decide that it is the one thing you want to do at that time. Then forget everything else.
Fatigue and second wind
To those who make it a habit the power of concentration is capable of surprising development. The only limit fixed is that of physical exhaustion. Nerve energy is consumed in continued mental exertion to the point where it is no longer capable of sustaining attention or doing work effectively. Everyone knows the effect on mental work of being tired either mentally or physically. Ideas simply will not come at our call. The mind wanders and trails off into sleepiness. So far as work is done at all it is likely to be full of errors. Things have lost their interest. The work does not seem worth while. We find ourselves staring at a page, and utterly oblivious of what we are reading about. Under such conditions concentration, intensity, and hence effective work are impossible. It is usually not worth while working when the mind is fatigued. Genuine fatigue is due to the presence in the system of a toxin caused by the combustion of nerve and muscle tissue as a result of their activity. This poison is removed automatically by respiration, circulation, and other vital processes. More fatigue is caused in the life of the average person by the failure of these elimination processes to remove effectively the poison than by the work that produces it. Then, too, it is produced as much or more by irritation, worry, distraction, eyestrain, indigestion, and countless other unwholesome mental and physical conditions than by actual work. Abundant fresh air, vigorous exercise, deep sleep, avoidance of rich and excessive food, regular habits, calm, poise, freedom from worry, laughter,—vigorous, healthy, happy living,—these are the best preventives of fatigue and hence the best means of increasing the power of sustained profitable work. Insured by these healthful conditions, one need fear no danger of mental overwork. A healthy person has vast resources of reserve energy—stored probably in the sympathetic nerve system— upon which he seldom draws, The renewed power which one gets with his “second wind” is due to the first tapping of this reserve store. Under hypnotic conditions and under the stress of some powerful stimulus which causes one to forget himself for the time, one discloses a capacity for both physical and mental endurance he would not have dreamed possible for his ordinary self. This is not some new sort of power acquired. It is merely reserve energy released. There is probably no danger in such unusual display of energy so long as the normal physical conditions and processes are not interfered with. Certainly in the humdrum activity of study there is no chance of overexertion. Tired nature will invariably put us to sleep long before the system is endangered— provided always that we are not artificially stimulated by drugs of any kind and that we exercise vigorously, eat heartily, and sleep soundly. “Overstudy” is almost invariably physical disorder of some sort, due perhaps to worry, irregularity in sleep and eating, unnatural stimulations, lack of exercise, etc. It is probable that no one has found the absolute limit of possibility for mental exertion. If you are ambitious to accomplish great things, make sure that your physical condition is sound and vigorous and then don’t be afraid of “overstudy.” The efficiency of work, however, is measured rather by the intensity than by the length of the period of study. Although under the stress of emergency one may work many hours under intense pressure, a regular program of study will achieve better results if divided into periods of an hour or two followed by a short, complete relaxation or perhaps a change in the character of work. Many executives whose work requires a very high order of concentrated attention find that they can accomplish more in a four-hour to six-hour day than in a day of eight or ten hours. The ideal schedule will vary with the individual and with the character of work to be done, but it should always be planned with a view to working under high pressure. This habit of intensity of attention is the means of continuously increasing one’s capacity for effective work. One can acquire no increase in muscular power except by exerting to the limit the power he already has. The same is true of mental power. Mental work to the point of genuine fatigue is part of the price of greater mental capacity.
Purpose the key to attention
Perhaps chief among the conditions which determine one’s ability to concentrate his attention upon a given idea is the attitude or “set” of his mind toward that idea. This will be discussed in the following chapter on interest and in the chapter on the will. The knowledge that one has of a subject and his interest in it are among the factors that limit his capacity to hold his attention to it, but the principal factor is one’s purpose. Without a definite purpose, without a problem to solve or a recognized situation to meet by means of his mental activity, attention wanders aimlessly from sense stimulus to sense stimulus. With a clear, positive purpose thinking becomes reasoning, judgments progress directly from data to conclusion, knowledge is organized and ordered to a definite end.
For such thinking only is attention definitely and continuously available. Attention is the place where the mind is at work. It works only where it has a purpose in view, where it has work to do.
Source
Henry Eastman Bennett, Psychology and Self-Development. Boston: Ginn and Company, 1923. Chapter XIII, “Attention” (printed pages 194–209). This article is from public domain digital sources.
Disclaimer
We have made every effort to reproduce this text faithfully, but we cannot guarantee that it is free of errors. Readers who need accuracy for study or citation should check the original publication. The views and language are those of the author and his time, and e-Scriptures is not responsible for them.
Spelling and style follow the original; obvious scanning and typographical errors have been corrected. This text is believed to be in the public domain in the United States, where this website is operated. Copyright terms differ from country to country, so a text that is free of copyright in the United States may still be protected elsewhere. Readers outside the United States should check the copyright laws of their country before copying, downloading or reusing it; they are responsible for lawful use in their own country. See our Terms of Use.
This chapter comes from a psychology textbook of 1923. Its psychology and physiology reflect the knowledge of that time and have since been revised.