Summary: The part of the section on the Three Jewels in Jaini’s Outlines of Jainism that deals with right knowledge. It explains how right knowledge follows right conviction and must be free from doubt, and describes the five kinds of knowledge, with sections on false knowledge and on full knowledge. It ends by showing which kinds of knowledge a soul can have at one time.
B. Right Knowledge (68–77)
Right conviction makes us perceive the reality of life and the seriousness of our object in life. It saves us from the soul-emptying, puzzling void of scepticism. It brings us nearer to the feeling and touch of the solid, substantial reality of our own and other souls, as also of the matter in union, with which the soul gives rise to the phenomena of life.
Right knowledge makes us examine in detail the matter brought into the mind by right conviction. Of course, both are mental processes; the difference is in degree. I see a nurse taking a boy on the pavement outside. This is perception. I have the right conviction that there are a woman and a boy out there. I also perceive that the woman is a nurse. But I do not know the details—who they are, where they live, why they are in this particular locality, and so forth. If I saw or heard or read about them, I should gain right knowledge.
This knowledge must be free from doubt, i.e. it must be retained steadily and based on firm conviction.
Error is also recognized in Jainism. It reminds one somewhat of the ignorance (avidya) of the Vedanta, the want of discrimination (aviveka) of the Samkhya, and the illusion (maya) of the Buddhist systems of philosophy. Jainism insists that right knowledge cannot be attained, unless belief of any kind in its opposite (i.e. in wrong knowledge) is banished (69).
The soul of man is indivisible, and our intellect cannot really consent, even temporarily, to what our faith has not grasped; and our conduct cannot but be coloured by our intellect, from which it springs. Faith and knowledge leading to right conduct are at once the process and the goal; for right faith dispels weak doubt, right knowledge preserves us from ignorance, indifference, and laziness, and right conduct enables us to create the best life of which we are capable.
Right knowledge is of five kinds (70)—
Mati-jnana: knowledge which is acquired by means of the five senses, or by means of the mind of man (71)
Sruta-jnana: knowledge in which on the basis of mati-jnana one acquires knowledge about things other than those to which the mati-jnana relates (72).
The difference between the two is thus stated Mati-jnana deals with substances which exist now and, having come into existence, are not destroyed sruta-jnana deals with all things now existing, and also with those which were in the past or may be in the future, e.g., an eclipse to-day may be known by mati-jnana, but one in the time of Alexander, or one to happen next year, can now only be known by sruta-jnana. Even a mineral or plant soul with one sense only can have sruta-jnana.
Avadhi-jnana: knowledge of the remote or past. It is possessed always by celestial and infernal souls; ascetics also sometimes acquire it by austerities (74).
Manahparyaya-jnana: knowledge of the thoughts and feelings of others. It is possessed by Samyamins only, i.e. by persons who are masters of self-control and who have practised the restraint of body, mind, and speech (75).
Kevala-jnana: full or perfect knowledge, which is the soul’s characteristic in its pure and undefiled condition (76).
False Knowledge
The first three kinds of knowledge, i.e. sense-knowledge, study-knowledge, and knowledge of the past, may also be perverted or false. The senses may deceive us; our studies may be incomplete or erroneous; and the angel’s vision of the remote or past may not be perfect in detail or clearness (77).
But mind-knowing cannot be false. We cannot have it, unless we can have knowledge of the exact thought or feeling in another’s mind.
Full or perfect knowledge obviously cannot be false.
Before we take up the five forms of knowledge separately, it is interesting to compare them with the five “bodies” in Jainism (supra, pp. 42–5).
The five kinds of bodies, we remember, are: audarika, or the physical body; vaikriyika, or the angelic body of angels and denizens of hell; aharaka, the special body emanating from a saint to resolve his doubts; taijasa, or magnetic body; karmana, or karmic body.
These five bodies are distributed as follows: a man has the physical, magnetic, and karmic bodies; an angel has the angelic, magnetic, and karmic bodies.
This accounts for four, the remaining aharaka being a special body manifested in a saint temporarily and for a special purpose.
Now the five kinds of knowledge may be considered thus in relation to the five kinds of bodies:—
Man with his physical body acquires sense-knowledge and study-knowledge. Also with his physical body he acquires, e.g. by means of austerities, knowledge of the remote. With his magnetic body he acquires knowledge of the thoughts and feelings of others. It is literally sympathy, on the analogy of symphony between chords or strings in music, which are tuned exactly alike. If a man’s magnetic body is in the same tune with another’s, the thoughts and feelings of the one will meet with a ready response in the other. It is everyday observation that a mother or a devoted wife anticipates and exactly realizes the needs or wishes of her beloved children or husband. With his karmic body the man acquires full knowledge. And it must be remembered always, that acquisition of knowledge means the removal of knowledge-obscuring karmas, the gradual demolition of the karmic body. The matter of the other bodies acts simply like the workman employed to demolish the karmic structure; as soon as his work is accomplished, he is automatically dismissed. So, as soon as the bondage of karma is severed, the physical and angelic bodies fall off, and the magnetic and karmic bodies await their definite final dissolution before the eternal soul is set free in moksha.
To take the five kinds of knowledge in detail—
Mati-jnana, or sense-knowledge, is also called smriti, samjna, chinta, abhinibodha. It is acquired (1) by means of the five senses, (2) by means of the mind.
It is divided into four parts—
1. Avagraha, perception, taking up the object of knowledge by the senses. It is also called alochana, grahana, or avadharana.
2. Iha, the readiness to know more of the things perceived. It is also called uha, tarka, pariksha, vicarana, or jijnasa.
3. Apaya, finding out the perfection or otherwise (samyakta or asamyakta) of a thing. It is also called apayaya, apagama, apanoda, apavyadha, apeta, apagata, apaviddha, or apanutta.
4. Dharana, retaining the detailed reality of a thing. It is also called pratipatti, avadharana, avasthana, nischaya, avagama, or avabodha.
To illustrate: I see the nurse and boy going along outside: this is avagraha. I wish to know more about them: this is iha. I go and make inquiries about them, and know all kinds of details about their ages, family, etc.: this is apaya. I grasp the full significance and characteristics of the details which I have gathered: this is dharana.
Each of the above four classes of sense-knowledge has twelve sub-classes: bahu, much; bahuvidha, manifold; kshipra, quickly; anisrita, without the help of symbols or signs; anukta, without being taught; dhruva, steady; alpa, less; alpavidha, in few ways: akshipra, slowly; nisrita, with help of signs; ukta, taught; adhruva, not steady.
Thus mati-jnana is 4 × 12 = 48 kinds; and, as each kind may be acquired by five senses or the mind, in all it is of 48 × 6 = 288 kinds.
Again, the above distinctions apply to sense-knowledge with reference to artha, the object itself. With reference to vyanjana, or [intermediating] sensation, sense-knowledge is of only one kind, the avagraha (or perception) kind. This is never manifested in the case of the eye or the mind. Therefore it can only be of 4 × 12 (the twelve classes above referred to) = 48 kinds.
Thus the total kinds of sense-knowledge are 288 + 48 = 336.
Sruta-jnana, or study-knowledge, is of two kinds—scriptural and non-scriptural. The scriptural means knowledge derived from the study of the Jaina Scriptures, i.e. the Twelve Angas (see Appendix V). Non-scriptural is knowledge that is derived from outside the Angas.
Avadhi-jnana, or knowledge of the remote, is of two kinds: (1) innate, as in the case of angels in Heaven or fallen ones in Hell; (2) acquired, by the precipitation or annihilation of karmic matter. The former is called bhava-pratyaya, and the latter kshayopasama-nimittaka. This latter is acquired by men and animals, and is of six kinds—
1. Ananugamika, limited to a particular locality, i.e. outside those limits the man loses this faculty.
2. Anugamika, not limited to any locality.
3. Hiyamana, knowledge of the remote, comprehending innumerable worlds, seas, continents, etc., becomes less and less, till it reaches the minimum.
4. Vardhamanaka, acquired from very slight beginnings; it goes on increasing. It is the converse of hiyamana.
5. Anavasthita, unsteady, so that it fluctuates according to circumstances.
6. Avasthita, never leaving the possessor in the locality where it is acquired and retained by him even in another form of existence.
(For these see Tattvartha-sutra, ch. i, 21–3.)
Manahparyaya, or mind-reading knowledge, is of two kinds—
1. Riju-mati: this arises from the straightforwardness of man’s mind, speech, and body, and consists in discerning and knowing the forms of thoughts in other’s minds.
2. Vipula-mati: by this the finest karmic activity in the minds of others can be read.
The distinction between the two kinds is this: (1) vipula-mati is finer and purer than riju-mati; (2) vipula-mati cannot be lost, whereas the possessor of the riju-mati mind-reading power may lose it.
Mind-reading knowledge is distinguished from far knowledge as follows—
1. Mind-reading knowledge is purer and more refined than far-reading knowledge.
2. Mind-reading knowledge is confined to the locality where men live. Far knowledge is not so limited, and may be extended to the whole universe.
3. Mind-reading can be acquired only by men, and also only by samyamins, i.e. men of control. Far knowledge can be acquired by all souls in all conditions of existence.
4. By mind-reading we can know all forms of thought, etc., even their minutest modifications. By far knowledge we can know forms with only a few of their modifications.
From this point of view sense- and study-knowledge applies to all substances, but only in some of their modifications. Far-knowledge applies to coloured substances, but not to all their modifications. Mind-reading applies to all coloured objects, even in their infinitesimal parts. (See Tattvartha-sutra, 25–7.)
Full Knowledge
Kevala-jnana, full or pure or perfect knowledge, applies to all things and to all their modifications. It is, in fact, a characteristic of the soul entirely liberated from the bondage of matter.
To conclude, a soul can have one, two, three, or four kinds of knowledge at one and the same time. If one kind, it must be perfect knowledge; if two kinds, it is the sense- and the study-knowledge; if three kinds, it is the sense- and the study- and the past-knowledge; if four kinds, it is all except perfect knowledge (73).
Source
Jagmanderlal Jaini, Outlines of Jainism, edited with a preliminary note by F. W. Thomas. Cambridge: at the University Press, 1916. Chapter II, Metaphysics, section XV, part B. This article is from public domain digital sources.
Disclaimer
We have made every effort to reproduce this text faithfully, but we cannot guarantee that it is free of errors. Readers who need accuracy for study or citation should check the original publication. The views and language are those of the author and his time, and e-Scriptures is not responsible for them.
Spelling and style follow the original; obvious scanning and typographical errors have been corrected. This text is believed to be in the public domain in the United States, where this website is operated. Copyright terms differ from country to country, so a text that is free of copyright in the United States may still be protected elsewhere. Readers outside the United States should check the copyright laws of their country before copying, downloading or reusing it; they are responsible for lawful use in their own country. See our Terms of Use.