Summary: Three sections of the chapter on metaphysics in Jaini’s Outlines of Jainism. The first explains substance (dravya), its attributes and its modifications, and why a substance is uncreated and indestructible although its conditions arise and perish. The second takes the six substances in turn: the soul, matter, dharma and adharma (the principles of motion and of rest), space and time. The third treats the five astikayas, the magnitudes that occupy space, with the same substances described again from that point of view. The footnotes follow.
III. Substance and Attributes
Let us see what we mean by dravya, which is the generic name for soul, matter, time, and space, and the principles of motion and stationariness. A dravya exists in its own nature, and has its own attributes and modifications (7). It has what is technically called satta. This satta connotes three accidents: utpada, coming into existence, or origination; vyaya, going out of existence, or perishing; and dhrauvya, continuous sameness of existence, or continuance. The utpada and vyaya relate to modifications (paryaya) of substances; dhrauvya relates to its inner nature, to its essential attributes. Soul-dravya exists, or has satta, which means that the soul exists with its soul-ness, and with its qualities and modifications. These qualities may refer to its essential nature, e.g. that the soul has consciousness; or to its transitory condition, to its paryaya, e.g. that the soul of Mahavira is the most white of all (see lesyas below, pp. 45–7). The soul’s satta, in the utpada and vyaya aspects, relates to its embodied condition in samsara. It comes into existence and goes out of it, as A or B. But as soul itself, it has continuous existence throughout time: it is the same soul now as when it animated the body called A or B. Before our birth, in our life and after death, until our highest evolution, the soul remains the same individual. This is the dhrauvya aspect of the soul’s satta.
The important matter is this: birth or death (utpada and vyaya) are of a condition of a dravya. The dravya is uncreated and indestructible; its essential qualities remain the same (dhrauvya); it is only its paryaya, or condition, that can, and does, change. And it is logically necessary from the first position taken up by Jainism: namely, that substances and attributes are distinguishable, but not distinct. The attributes are not all fixed; they come and go (utpada, vyaya); but the substance remains (dhrauvya).
As to the threefold consideration under substance, attribute, and condition or modification, in the light of satta substance is dhrauvya, the modification or condition is utpada and vyaya, and the attributes are partly one and partly the other. Substance, even in its dhrauvya aspect, is only a sum-total of eternally existing attributes, e.g., the soul is consciousness, matter is non-consciousness, and space is the capacity of giving place to substances. Thus the attributes of consciousness, etc., are dhrauvya. But the conditions of substances are also the sum-total of attributes which attach to the substances and then leave them. The soul in the condition called A had certain attributes as A, e.g., name, size, colour, nationality, character, religious tendency, scholarship, etc.; all these attributes attached to it at some time, at its birth or after, and then ceased at its death. These attributes come under the utpada and vyaya of the condition or modification of the soul called A. The other dravyas, besides soul, may in the same way be considered with reference to satta and with reference to substance, modification, and attributes (8–9). Let us deal with the six separately.
IV. The Six Substances
The Soul
This is the only knowing substance; its essential characteristic is consciousness. The other substances, matter, time, space, and principles of motion and stationariness, are devoid of consciousness (10). I know, the table does not know; the pen with which I am writing is not conscious of my using it or of its existence. The month and date of my writing are not conscious, nor are the principles or forces which make it possible for me to stand up or sit down. Matter, time, dharma and adharma, and space are devoid of consciousness. But of these, matter, soul, and time are innumerable; whereas dharma and adharma and space are only one each.
Matter (11)
That which has not consciousness, but can be touched, tasted, seen, and smelled is matter. Things enjoyable by the senses, the five senses themselves, the body, the mind, the karmas, and all other material objects are called pudgala, or matter. This will be dealt with more fully under astikayas, or magnitudes.
Of course material objects are innumerable.
Dharma (12)
This is devoid of taste, touch, smell, sound, and colour, and is conterminous with the universe (loka). It is the principle of motion; the accompanying circumstance or cause which makes motion possible, like water to moving fish. The water is a passive condition or circumstance of the movement of a fish, i.e. it is indifferent or passive (udasina) and not active or solicitous (preraka) cause. The water cannot compel a fish at rest to move; but, if the fish wants to move, water is then the necessary help to its motion. Dharma cannot make soul or matter move; but, if they are to move, they cannot do so without the presence of dharma. Hence it is that at the end of the loka or universe, there being no dharma, the soul which, urged by its natural tendency to move upward, has risen to the siddha-sila, or the place of liberated souls, attains perfect rest. It cannot move, because there is not the necessary motion-element, dharma.
Dharma is one only, like adharma and space, and unlike soul, matter, and time, which are innumerable.
Adharma (13)
This is the opposite of dharma, equally coeval and conterminous with the universe. It is also an indifferent or passive cause of stationariness; like the earth to falling bodies. Its nature and substance are the same as those of dharma. It is immaterial, and one.
Space (14)
This is what gives to all souls and to all other substances their places in the universe.
Like dharma and adharma, space is one only.
Space includes our universe and beyond. The universe is loka, and the beyond is aloka. The five substances, dharma, adharma, soul, matter, and time, are found in the universe only.
Time (15–18)
That which is the cause or circumstance of the modification of soul and other dravyas is time: it is immaterial, and is the necessary element in our dealings with other dravyas. It is without taste, colour, smell, or touch. It has only its own attributes, and the peculiar attribute of helping the modification of the other substances. Like the souls and matter, it is innumerable.
The two divisions of time into avasarpini and utsarpini eras, and the six ages of each, have been noticed above in the Introduction. In practice time is divided as follows:—
samaya is the unit of time; its measure is the time taken by a unit of matter in going from one unit of space to the next unit of space with slow motion.
nimisha, time taken in raising the eyelid. It consists of innumerable samayas.
kashtha = 15 nimishas.
kala = 20 kashthas.
nali or ghati = 20 kalas and a little over.
muhurta = 2 ghatis.
ahoratra (day and night) = 30 muhurtas.
masa (month) = 30 days.
ritu = 2 months.
ayana = 6 months or 3 ritus.
samvatsara (year) = 2 ayanas (16).
V. The Five Astikayas (Magnitudes) (19–32)
Jaina philosophy really starts with a perfect division of the universe into living and non-living existences, jiva and ajiva. But the contents of this division are arranged and considered in two more ways. Ajiva being sub-classified into matter, space, time, dharma, and adharma; we get the six dravyas, substances, of Jainism. These six are then considered as having or not having constituent parts (pradesas). From this point of view time is the only continuous substance which does not consist of many pradesas, like our bodies. A pradesa is an infinitesimal unit of space; kaya (or body) is the technical name given to a thing which has pradesas. Time has only one pradesa: therefore time has not kaya, is not an astikaya, or a magnitude. The other five are astikayas (19–21). These astikayas are uncreated; they have the quality of satta or the characteristic of modifying their condition and continuing their substratum (utpada, vyaya, and dhrauvya) (22). They are also the constituent elements of the Universe (24). They are called astikayas, because they have satta and are therefore asti; and because they have many pradesas and are therefore kaya (20). Dharma and adharma have innumerable pradesas (units of space). Matter has pradesas which may be numerable, innumerable, or infinite. Thus, a molecule (or skandha) may be numbered as to its atoms. But some masses cannot be numbered as to their atoms, e.g. a mountain. Some other skandhas may contain an infinite number of atoms, as an ocean, the world. Space has infinite pradesas. But the soul has innumerable pradesas (22–3).
The soul, space, dharma, and adharma are immaterial (amurtika), unbreakable, and cannot be said to have parts. The soul has great elasticity: it can expand, if need be, and fill the whole universe. But its pradesas cannot be divided.
The Soul (5, 30–1)
The soul, we remember, is either liberated (siddha) or mundane. The mundane soul is in combination with karmic matter. We are not perfect: we can improve. These two facts are the cogent indications of the capacity of the human soul to evolve. Evidently it is in an impure state, and the cause of impurity is not far to seek: the gross body speaks for the demand of dead matter on the living man. What, then, is the pure soul? Every soul is potentially pure. Matter is only a cruel parasite, an unclean veil. The soul is ever all-perfect, all-powerful. By ignorance it identifies itself with matter, and hence all its troubles and degradation. In its pure condition it has four enjoyments: those of perfect perception, perfect knowledge, infinite power, and infinite bliss.
In the impure state nine properties of the soul may be mentioned—
1. It lived in the past, is living now, and shall live for ever.
2. It has perception and knowledge.
3. It is immaterial, i.e. has no touch, taste, smell, or colour.
4. It is the only responsible agent of all its actions.
5. It completely fills the body which it occupies, e.g. that of an ant or an elephant (30–1).
6. It enjoys the fruits of all its karmas.
7. It wanders in samsara.
8. It can become in its perfect condition siddha.
9. It goes upward.
The cause of its impurity being karmic matter, the nine qualities may, more or less, be derived as consequences of this eternal combination of life and lifelessness. The soul is a dravya; therefore, like every other dravya, it is eternal. Its peculiar attributes are perception and knowledge. It is, of course, different from karma, or matter; therefore it must be immaterial. It has identified itself with matter; therefore it assumes a body, which it must fit. It is responsible for its karmas, because it has the power to get rid of them all. It must reap the harvest of all seeds that it has sown; and therefore must remain in the field of samsara, or cycle of existences. And still all these evils are self-assumed; and in its pure condition the soul is siddha (5).
To get at even a working conception of our innermost nature is as difficult to-day as when the philosopher taught his pupils, “Know thyself.” After all, there is a good deal of truth in the saying “After me the deluge”. Nothing can interest me, unless it directly or indirectly relates to me, to the “I”. This “I” is for me the centre of all life and of all theories and ideals of life.
In the Introduction (p. xvii) we have seen the first great question of philosophy and theology to be: “What am I? What is this soul?” The duality of matter and life is evident, except perhaps to the extreme monism of materialism or idealism, which, in Hume’s phrase, may be said to be “subversive of all speculation”. Thus the soul is this life only when identified with a particular individuality. Jainism here steps in to elaborate the characteristics of this spiritual man within the man of flesh.
In every man, every living being, a demand for happiness and aversion to pain or trouble is the first universal feature of life. Jainism seizes this as the most important characteristic of soul. It seeks happiness. It seeks this, because it has it not. To science soul or life is only a mysterious something that lurks behind the marvel of matter. To Jainism and to all religions this is an incomplete account of reality: the soul is as real as matter itself. The body is rough and gross: it is fit only for the struggle with its own kin—matter. The soul is subtle and refined, not meant for struggle with matter: it is what feels pain and pleasure. The senses and the mind bear messages to it. It is the entity between which and the phenomena of life the body is the visible link. It is the something which still feels discontented when the body and even the mind have found all that they want. It is a more inner principle of life than even mind. It is that which has the instinct of peace and bliss. Despite all our pangs and sorrows we still hope for the best. This unkillable hope is the faintest index to the eternal bliss which is an ever-present characteristic of soul. The hurry and competition of life soon tire us. This is due neither to laziness nor to love of weakness. It is only the germ of compassion which is the soul of man. It is the pursuit of peace, of undisturbable tranquillity, that is a great feature of the soul in its pure condition. The peace and bliss are the twin goals aimed at by the soul. They cannot be everlasting, unless based on deep, detailed, and well-digested knowledge. Perception and conviction are conditions of perfect knowledge. Thus perception, knowledge, peace, and bliss are the great characteristics of soul. In combination they imply an enormous power in the fully evolved soul. Thus we come once more to the Infinite Quaternary (ananta-chatushtaya) of Jainism. (Theology, p. 1 supra.)
The doctrine of soul is not in the Jaina view a mere matter of faith, it is a matter of observation and common-sense. If people shut their eyes to the noonday sun and go on asking: “Where is the sun, we can’t see it. There is no sun,” there is no remedy; they cannot see the light. By shutting one’s eyes to facts, or explaining them away, if they oppose our pet theory or scepticism, we cannot kill facts, although truth is shut out, in part or wholly. I try to make this clear, as Jainism cannot be properly understood and followed, unless we believe in a soul and clearly realize our belief and analyse in details the meaning thereof.
Matter (Pudgala) (11, 25–9)
Wedded to the soul is the great lifeless substance of matter. Whereas the soul’s qualities are life, consciousness, knowledge, perception, peace, bliss, and power, matter has for its characteristics lifelessness (6), touch, taste, smell, and colour (25).
The distinction of matter into atoms (anu) and molecules (skandha) has been known to Jainism for centuries. “In an atom there is only one pradesa (or unit of space)”: so says the Dravyasamgraha-gatha 26 (27). But, as atoms unite, they become a molecule. The finest kind of matter is that of the karmas, forming the karmic body, which always attends the soul and is the last to be discarded before the entry into the region of liberated souls. A group of karmic atoms is technically called a karma-vargana (28).
Science recognizes three conditions of matter: solid, liquid, and gaseous. Jainism recognizes six conditions—
1. Gross-gross, or very gross matter (= solid), e.g. a mountain, a pillar of iron, etc. This class of matter, when divided, cannot be united without the use of a third something;
2. Gross (= liquid), e.g. water, oil, etc. On division this can be united without the intervention of a third thing;
3. Gross-fine, e.g. shade, sunshine. It is interesting to compare this with the corpuscular theory of light in Western physics, before it was replaced by the modern wave-theory of Huygens. It is matter which looks gross or tangible, but cannot be grasped;
4. Fine-gross, e.g. fragrance, sound, sweetness, etc.; the distinction between this and gross-fine being that gross-fine is more gross than fine, because it can be seen as light, shade, etc.; whereas fine-gross cannot be seen, although its origin may be gross. The gases of science would be fine-gross. Fine-gross includes all things that may be perceived by the senses of touch, taste, smell, or sound;
5. Fine: matter capable of becoming karmic matter. It cannot be perceived by the senses (28);
6. Fine-fine: still finer molecules, in the karmic body, which is the finest. Fine-fine matter has for its atoms the combination of two or more ultimate atoms (paramanu). (According to some it is the ultimate atom itself.)
Space (Akasa) (14)
Things in the universe occupy each some place. That which gives things their places is space.
Space has two divisions: (1) the universe (loka), (2) the non-universe or the beyond (aloka).
In the universe all the six dravyas (magnitudes and substances), soul, matter, space, time, principles of motion and stationariness, find their places. In the aloka there is only endless space.
In the universe also, which is in the form of a human body standing akimbo, there is only a small portion of space occupied by living beings. Of these, again, only a small part form the miserable and active mankind, which inhabits the madhya-loka. (See under Cosmology, Appendix II.)
Principles of Motion (Dharma) and Stationariness (Adharma) (12–13, 32)
This and the next substance are the greatest peculiarity of Jainism. There is no other system, religious or speculative, which has anything corresponding to the Jaina dharma and adharma. These must be considered in some little detail.
The term dharma is used in many senses. In Indian philosophy it meant “property”, “quality”, “characteristic”, and in theology “duty”, specially religious duty, and thus religion itself. In modern times it popularly means “religion”, and sometimes the “highest duty” of a man or a community. Originally it meant “rule”, “law” also, as in dharma-sastras, “law-books”; but now this use is obsolete, except in that phrase. Dharma is also used as equivalent to piety; a dharmatman is a man who is pious, good, benevolent. Further, dharma means meritorious deeds; as so-and-so has done a work of dharma, e.g. by feeding or clothing the poor, by building a temple, etc., etc.
This variety of uses has had a confusing effect upon all. Jaina philosophy has suffered especially. The technical and peculiar sense in which dharma and adharma are employed in Jaina metaphysics is sometimes entirely missed, even by leading Orientalists: e.g., in Dr. Guérinot’s excellent Essai de Bibliographie Jaina, at pp. xvii and xviii, we read: “D’autre part l’ajiva, qui se subdivise en cinq espèces:
1° Le dharma, la loi religieuse, le mérite, la droite conduite.
2° L’adharma, ou principe contraire au précédent, soit le démérite, le péché.”
The universe is divided into jiva and ajiva. “Ajiva is subdivided into five species: (1) dharma, religious law, merit, right conduct; (2) adharma, or the principle contrary to the preceding, say, demerit, sin.”
Here the meaning of the terms dharma and adharma in Jaina philosophy is quite misconceived. The popular and modern connotation of the terms is certainly most misleading. These facts are significant. Why should the Jairas adopt such misleading terms for their peculiar doctrines? If the term dharma had been fixed as signifying even law or merit when the Jaina doctrine arose, it is impossible to see why Jainism should adopt it as meaning the principle of motion. A better suggestion is that dharma, in its technical Jaina sense, must have been used before the meaning of it as law and merit was fixed. This is another indication of both the great antiquity and genuineness of the Jaina system, and must be added to Professor Jacobi’s classical lines of evidence set forth in the Introduction.
To come to the usage of the two terms, an ancient text says: “dharma is devoid of taste, colour, smell, sound, and touch, is conterminous with loka (the universe), is unbreakable or indivisible, is all-pervading by its nature, and has innumerable pradesas (or units of space)” (12).
It is well to remember that astikaya, = magnitude, does not mean material something. There are five astikayas—matter, time, space, dharma, and adharma. And of these only one, pudgala, is matter, i.e. capable of touch, taste, smell, and colour (25). All the other astikayas are devoid of these four distinguishing attributes of matter. The five astikayas, or along with jiva (soul) the six dravyas, all exist eternally. They cannot be destroyed; they were never created. They are independent of one another, except of course that in a sort of neighbourly contact or conflict they keep the universe going. They are not ignorant of the principle of division of labour. Matter goes to struggle with the unwary or infatuated soul; time times the conflict; space makes possible the arena; dharma helps the combatants to struggle on; and adharma assists them when they are inclined to rest. This is the whole struggle for existence. This is the genesis, the evolution, and the destiny of the universe. It cannot be changed, it cannot be stopped. The soul seeks to act, to move itself or matter, and dharma, which is omnipresent in the universe, is ever-ready to assist it to move itself or its adversary matter. If the soul seeks to cease moving, or matter loses its grip and drops down inactive in the form of a matured and fallen-off karma, there is adharma to help the soul and matter to cease work and to be in a condition of stationariness. Accordingly dharma-dravya is eternal, indestructible, the essential circumstance for all moving bodies, and itself the product of the activity of none (12).
It is noticeable, too, that the most important magnitudes and substances are two: soul and matter. The other four are a sort of setting to these two. Space and time are the necessary conditions to make the drama visible to knowledge; dharma and adharma are the necessary conditions of its continuance in its endless vicissitudes, merit and demerit, high and low, happiness and misery, as far as disturbance and tranquillity. Of course, dharma and adharma are in their nature and modus operandi the same (13). It is the same sword in the hand of a devoted soldier or a fanatic rebel.
Finally, dharma and adharma are everywhere in the universe. Beyond the universe they are not: there is only empty space, extending on all sides in its undisturbed, eternal void and eternal unchangeableness.
Source
Jagmanderlal Jaini, Outlines of Jainism, edited with a preliminary note by F. W. Thomas. Cambridge: at the University Press, 1916. Chapter II, Metaphysics, sections III–V. This article is from public domain digital sources.
Disclaimer
We have made every effort to reproduce this text faithfully, but we cannot guarantee that it is free of errors. Readers who need accuracy for study or citation should check the original publication. The views and language are those of the author and his time, and e-Scriptures is not responsible for them.
Spelling and style follow the original; obvious scanning and typographical errors have been corrected. This text is believed to be in the public domain in the United States, where this website is operated. Copyright terms differ from country to country, so a text that is free of copyright in the United States may still be protected elsewhere. Readers outside the United States should check the copyright laws of their country before copying, downloading or reusing it; they are responsible for lawful use in their own country. See our Terms of Use.