Summary: The last of three pages from the appendix on Jaina logic in Jaini’s Outlines of Jainism. It explains syad-vada, the distinctive doctrine of Jaina logic, which looks at a thing from many sides (anekanta) and uses the example of two knights who saw different sides of a shield. It sets out the seven classes of statement, each beginning with syad (from a certain point of view), with a rose as the example, and then gives the Jaina syllogism. A closing note names the Jaina works on logic.
Syād-vāda
The great and distinctive doctrine of Jaina logic is the syād-vāda. Its chief merit is the anekānta, or many-sided view of logic. This, it would be seen at once, is most necessary in order to acquire full knowledge about anything. It is a corrective of the fallacy into which fell the two knights who saw the different sides of the shield. Tom Smith, for example, may be a father with reference to his son Willy Smith, and he may be a son with reference to his father John Smith. Now it is a fact that Tom Smith is a son and father at one and the same time; and still some may declare it impossible for a man to be a father and a son simultaneously. This fallacy is not quite so obvious in other cases, and is a fruitful source of much misunderstanding. Two seemingly contrary statements may be found to be both true, if we take the trouble of finding out the two points of view from which the statements are made. Seven classes of points of view are noted. They are:
1. syād asti: A is. A rose is.
2. syān nāsti: A is not. A rose is not, from the point of view of a clock;
3. syād asti nāsti: A is and is not. A rose is and is not, as in 1 and 2;
4. syād avaktavya: from a certain point of view it is impossible to describe A; e.g. from the point of view of integral calculus it may be difficult to describe a rose;
5. syād asti cha avaktavya: A is, and it is impossible to describe A. This is a combination of 1 and 4;
6. syān nāsti cha avaktavya: A is not, and it is impossible to describe A. This is a combination of 2 and 4;
7. syād asti cha nāsti cha avaktavya: A is and A is not, and it is impossible to describe A. This is a combination of 1, 2, and 4.
From these seven modes of expression the system derives also its second name: sapta-bhaṅgī, ‘sevenfold system of logic.’
Syllogism
The Jaina syllogism, like that of Gautama’s Nyāya, but unlike the syllogism of Aristotelian logic, consists of five propositions. To take an elementary example:
Man is mortal.
John is a man.
∴ John is mortal.
The Jaina logician would argue thus.
Jack died, Fox died, Herbert died, and so did William;
Jack, Fox, Herbert, and William are truly universal types of man.
∴ All men die.
John is a man.
∴ John will die.
It seems wasteful to have five propositions in a syllogism, when three would do. But really the great merit of Jaina logic is to combine the inductive and deductive methods, and so by its very method more or less to answer in anticipation the criticism that logic is a barren kind of intellectual gymnastics, and to a certain extent also that logic is merely formal and has nothing at all to do with the matter of the argument.
[Note.—As authorities for this chapter we may cite the Tattvārthādhigama-sūtra of Umā-svati, the Pramāṇa-naya-tattvālokālaṃkāra of Vādideva Sūri, the Syād-vāda-mañjarī of Malli-shena, the Parīkshā-mukha of Māṇikya-nandin, and the Nyāya-bindu of Siddha-sena Divā-kara, edited with English translation by Professor Satischandra Vidyābhūshaṇa, also the English work by Mr. Jhaveri cited in the Preliminary Note.]
Source
Jagmanderlal Jaini, Outlines of Jainism, edited with a preliminary note by F. W. Thomas. Cambridge: at the University Press, 1916. Appendix I, Jaina Logic (printed pages 116–118, last part). This article is from public domain digital sources.
Disclaimer
We have made every effort to reproduce this text faithfully, but we cannot guarantee that it is free of errors. Readers who need accuracy for study or citation should check the original publication. The views and language are those of the author and his time, and e-Scriptures is not responsible for them.
Spelling and style follow the original; obvious scanning and typographical errors have been corrected. This text is believed to be in the public domain in the United States, where this website is operated. Copyright terms differ from country to country, so a text that is free of copyright in the United States may still be protected elsewhere. Readers outside the United States should check the copyright laws of their country before copying, downloading or reusing it; they are responsible for lawful use in their own country. See our Terms of Use.