Skip to content

In Defence of Hinduism: Shraddha and Hinduism a Scientific Religion

by Annie Besant

Summary: Seven chapters from Annie Besant’s booklet written for Hindu boys, from a Theosophical standpoint. The first two defend the rite of Shraddha, explaining it as help given to those who have passed into the invisible worlds. The other five argue that Hinduism is a scientific religion: they answer the materialist view that thought is a product of the brain, and describe the Hindu teaching on the sheaths or bodies of man and the worlds of matter, with dreams, religious experience, genius and telepathy.

VII. Shraddha

No question is more often asked by Hindu boys than: “What is the use of performing Shraddha? “Why should we perform Shraddha?” The answer to this question may fitly find a place in a series of papers written “In Defence of Hinduism.”

It is well, in the first place, to realise that the custom of helping those who have passed into the invisible worlds is universal. Even savages—the decayed relics of earlier civilisations—have not lost the idea of this duty, and discharge it in their ignorant fashion by burying articles of value and weapons with the corpse, or by slaying with him his favorite horse and dog, that they may follow and serve him on the other side. All civilised peoples fulfil the duty in a more rational and effective way, by suitable ceremonies and prayers accompanied by Mantras, Words of Power.

Among the Zoroastrians, services for the dead are always performed, but the offerings of food, clothes, etc. have become diverted from their earlier purpose; these should be distributed among the people who are still embodied, as they are useless to the disembodied; the old custom is to give alms of food, clothing, useful articles of all sorts, at the service for the disembodied, in loving memory of him, and for the purpose of associating with those who love him many grateful hearts, whose rosy wishes of gratitude and good will may form round him a peaceful and happy atmosphere on the other side.

Among the Buddhists there are ceremonies embodying active help to those passing onwards, and quite lately, among the Shinto-Buddhists of Japan, at a service held for those who died in the war just closed, Admiral Togo addressed the departed ones with love and gratitude, sure that the warm wave of grateful affection would encircle them on the other side of death.

Among the Christians, all but the extreme ‘Protestants’ hold definite services on behalf of the disembodied. In the Greek and Roman Churches, representing Christianity in its oldest and fullest form, ‘masses for the dead’—in their main principles identical with the principle underlying the Shraddha ceremonies—are regularly performed. Words and Signs of Power are employed, and bread, water and wine are the things used. One party in the Church of England, called the High Church party, preserves this venerable and useful custom of praying for the dead, but the other wing, the Low Church party, regards this, and all other ceremonies founded on the knowledge of the invisible worlds, as mere idle superstition. The Non-conformists, who are outside the Established Church, all sympathise with the Low Church, or Protestant, ideas; these ideas are the result of a modern and ignorant reaction against superphysical facts, and this reaction is gradually becoming weaker.

Hinduism, in its Shraddha, is only doing fully, rationally, and in unbroken continuity with the past, that which is done in all religions, but less completely. Unfortunately, too many modern Hindus know as little of the facts underlying their ceremonies as do the adherents of other religions, and so, when intelligent boys ask questions, their elders are unable to answer them, and the boys grow sceptical.

Let us see what are the conditions of a person after death, for if we understand these, we shall be able to understand the reasonableness and the utility of Shraddha.

When a man ‘dies,’ he slips out of the denser part of his physical body, called the annamayakosha, the sheath formed by food. He goes out clothed in his remaining four koshas, and his outermost coating is then the pranamayakosha, the sheath formed of the life-forces; these life-forces act in subtle physical matter, the ethers of science, and hence this sheath is called in English the etheric body, or etheric double. The man does not remain long in this coating, for it belongs to this physical world, and keeps him a prisoner round his old haunts; if his dense physical body be burned, in the good Hindu way, the etheric body breaks up, unless the man tries very hard to keep it together; but if the dense body be buried, the etheric body goes to pieces very slowly, keeping pace with the decay of the dense. When the pranamayakosha is broken up, the man has for his outermost coating the manomayakosha, the sheath formed of mentality —of thoughts, emotions, desires, passions. The matter of this is re-arranged, so that the coarse parts are all on the outside, and these are called the kamarupa, the desire-body; while he is wearing this kamarupa, the man is called a Preta, a departed one, and he lives in Pretaloka, the place of Pretas: ghost would be the nearest English equivalent in popular language, but the word is a bad one, as many silly ideas are connected with it. When this kamarupa is worn out, the finer parts of the manomayakosha make the outermost coating, and the man becomes a Pitri, an ancestor, and lives in Pitriloka, the place of Pitris. After a while this coating decays, and leaves only the finest parts of the manomayakosha, and the man becomes a dweller in Svargaloka, heaven, the happy shining world of the Devas. When he has reached that world, Shraddha can do nothing more for him.

Contents

VIII. Shraddha

When the man puts off his dense physical body, the annamayakosha, it is washed, swathed, and carried away to the burning ghat, the bearers ejaculating: “Rama, Rama, Sita-Rama,” as they carry it along, so maintaining round it the protective vibrations of the holy name. At the ghat, sacred mantras form part of the ceremony, bidding the man go on upon the ancient paths, not lingering near the useless garment he has cast aside; and these mantras, again, fill the air with waves of energy that protect and calm him, and that loosen the clinging pranamayakosha, so that it falls away from him, and leaves him in the manomayakosha, ready for the purificatory process, through which he has now to pass. He is now a Preta, in Pretaloka, and this, if he has not lived a very pure life, is the troublesome and often painful part of his experiences in the world into which he has gone. The Shraddha ceremonies now—the Ekoddishta-Shraddha—are directed to help him through this part of his life; first, by re-arranging the material of the manomayakosha into a form which, by bringing to the surface its coarsest constituents, enables them to be more rapidly eliminated than would otherwise be possible; and secondly, by helping forward the process of elimination. The mantras pray: “May they be purified,” and the vibrations of the mantras in the subtle matter that surrounds us are like waves that wash up against the body of the Preta, washing away the coarser matter, and quickening the disintegration of the Preta form. The water poured out with mantras and magnetised by them, imparts its helpful magnetism to the Preta form, and so, again, helps forwards the desired disintegration. The Preta comes amid his relatives who thus seek to aid him, and is strengthened, comforted, helped by the work and their loving thoughts, and by their will directed to his freeing.

These ceremonies are performed during a year, and are closed by the Sapindikarana, which receives the Preta among the Pitris, dwelling in Pitriloka. Water is poured out with mantras into water-pots filled with water, scents, and sesamum, and the man in the manomayakosha, purified sufficiently to serve as a means of contact with the subtler matter of Pitriloka, enters that brighter world. There too his relatives and friends can aid him, in the further purification of the manomayakosha, till all that cannot enter into Svarga is finally purged away.

The feeding of Brahmanas and the gifts which follow are intended to associate them with the family in this loving service, and the stress is laid upon the fact that they should be learned, because the ignorant, who understand nothing of the after-death conditions, cannot direct aright their thoughts and wills, and so can give but very ineffective help. Hence the Mahabharata enjoins that they only should be invited to such ceremonies as “are versed in the Vedas, the Dharmashastras, the Puranas, the Bhashyas, and the rules of grammar, who follow the standard laid down in the Shastras, versed in the science of emancipation, devoted to truth and to yoga.” “A man of intelligence should examine the Brahmanas invited to a Shraddha.” (Anushasana Parva.)

Such are the ideas underlying the ceremonies of Shraddha, and all occultists know that these ideas are true, and that those who remain on this earth can thus help those who have passed into the next, and can quicken their journey to the svargic world.

Nor should it be forgotten that those who, during their life on earth, have been accustomed to look forward to this assistance after passing through death, are grieved and disappointed if they do not receive the expected help. Never let us forget that our friends in the next world are conscious of our thoughts and feelings, and are affected by them. So shall we not fail to render them due service, and we in turn shall have the help of their willing and loving aid when they are beyond Pretaloka.

Note: Annie Besant (1847–1933) was a leading Theosophist and occultist, not a traditional Hindu teacher. Her account of Shraddha above explains the rites in terms of Theosophical ideas, such as the “etheric double”, the “desire-body” and the “astral” and “mental” bodies, which are not found in the Hindu scriptures and are not the traditional Hindu explanation of the ceremonies. Readers should take it as her own interpretation.

Contents

IX. Hinduism a Scientific Religion

In the great conflict between Science and Religion which has been waged in Europe since the sixteenth century, Religion had been steadily losing ground, until the great spiritual impulse called Theosophy filled the hands of Religion with forgotten truths, and opened the eyes of Science to new realms awaiting conquest. Western Religion—built on books or on councils, as the inevitable result of having, in its early days, chased away its occultists and branded them as heretics—found it difficult to repel the attacks of a Science built on facts and strenuous in the search for truth. The exaltation of faith above knowledge, and the fear of the clear light of reason—which originated in the hatred of the ignorant for the Gnostics, and was strengthened by the hatred of the Moors—undermined Christianity in the minds of the most intelligent; while the bitter memories of stake, rack and prison stimulated men of Science to make the most of every new discovery that could be used against the dogmas of the Christian Churches. Many of these dogmas have crumbled away under the guns of Science; others have been transformed and beautified into transcendental teachings; the books are being, gradually dropped as authorities to be replaced by mystic experiences, and an ever widening liberality has taken the place of the narrowness and exclusiveness of the past.

In these modern days of triumphant intellect, the various Religions of the world are being loudly challenged to justify their continued existence, and to shew that they are worthy to lead the vanguard of thought among the most highly civilised and scientific nations. Christianity has to pass through the fire in western lands: Hinduism, Buddhism, Islam, must pass through the same fire in eastern countries. Religion cannot die, but religions have died and will die; a religion which cannot adapt itself to changing conditions shews, by that very rigidity, that life has departed from it; for the living body is adaptable, and when it ceases to be adaptable it dies. The problem of the near future for each great Religion is: Can it face fearlessly the modern spirit, and shew its power to dominate, shape and guide it, or will it be left behind as a landmark only, as have been left the once mighty religions of Assyria, Egypt and Greece? With the question whether Christianity can adapt itself and remain a living religion, I am not here concerned; it has changed so rapidly during the last half-century that it may be able to live down the story written in blood and fire during fifteen hundred years. The question with which I am here concerned is: Can Hinduism thus adapt itself? can it remain the guiding force in Indian life that it has been during thousands, aye, tens of thousands of years? can it preserve for India, for New India, the India throbbing with fresh vitality and saturated with western thought, all that is really valuable in Old India, the India of the philosopher and the ascetic, of the warrior and the philanthropist? That it can do this, that it can rule the Indian heart and guide the Indian life in the future as in the past, that it can stimulate thought and restrain passion, I profoundly believe. Based on knowledge, it need fear no advance in knowledge; profound in spirituality, the depths of the Spirit find in it deeps answering unto deep; it has nothing to dread, everything to hope, from growth in intellect, from the increasing sway of reason.

Let us see if we can justify these statements from its teachings in the past.

Hinduism was founded and built up by occultists, by men who knew nature in her various manifestations, her subtle worlds as well as her dense. The physical earth, the finer and ever finer worlds beyond, the seven great lokas with their various inhabitants, were all familiar to these highly evolved men, and were described by them as they may still be seen by a man using his subtle body—sukshma sharira—as his vehicle of consciousness. Hence they naturally did not make the mistakes into which men less evolved would inevitably fall. The revelations of geology, for instance, showing that the earth had existed for millions of years, and proving the immense antiquity of the human race, left Hinduism untouched; since, in opposition to the short 6,000 years which the missionaries had sought to impose upon the Hindus as the age of the earth and man, it remained secure in its immense cycles of time, its four yugas of millions of years, its kalpas of 4,320,000,000 years, and its manifestation period of 311,040,000,000,000 years. Even when Lord Kelvin, declared that the sun could only give out heat for a hundred million years, while Hinduism demanded for its shining a kalpa, a Day of Brahma, Hinduism showed no inclination to recast its figures, given by the Adept-Astronomers of the past; and now, with the increase of knowledge, a life-time is given to the sun at least fifty times as long as that assigned to it by Lord Kelvin. Thus has, Hinduism been justified in respect to her vast cycles of time so jeered at by the ignorant. Truly have the tables been turned, in this case, by the increase of knowledge.

Contents

X. Hinduism a Scientific Religion

One of the main contentions of the Science of the last quarter of the nineteenth century was that psychology must be based on physiology, because thought and life were the results of certain arrangements of matter, they were products of physiological conditions. “The brain produces thought as the liver produces bile,” said Karl Vogt. “It appears to me that every rational physiologist, provided he admits such a thing as the genesis of life, is compelled to trace it to a peculiar aggregation of chemical and physical forces” said Virchow. “Life is united not to a special anatomical arrangement of the living body; not to the co-operation of various organs; but to a certain physico-chemical constitution of formless material, to the albuminoid substance which we call sarcode or protoplasm, a nitrogenous carbon-compound in a semifluid state,” said Haeckel. This passage is interesting, as showing three views of the production of life then being discussed; from anatomical arrangement, declared one investigator; from the co-operation of various organs, thought another; no, says Haeckel, life is from neither of these, it is from protoplasm; no one dreamed of arguing that it was a manifestation of Spirit, and linked men to superphysical worlds.

After a long argument, Büchner remarks: “It results from all this that eyes were not bestowed upon us in order that we might see with them, any more than we have received feet in order that we may walk with them. Rather do we see and walk because we have eyes and feet. The function is not the origin, but the result, of the organ.” And again: “The word mind is nothing more than a collective word and a comprehensive expression for the whole of the activities of the brain and its several parts or organs, just as the word respiration, or breathing, is a collective word for the activity of the breathing organs, or the word digestion is a collective word for the activity of the digesting organ.” The brain is, indeed, he says, more important than the other organs, it is “the highest achievement of material combinations,” but the idea of a soul, or Spirit, using the brain is derided. “Psychical activity is nothing more than a motion going on between the cells of the grey matter, caused by an external impression.” “Thought is the result of the complex machinery of that material tissue which we call brain.” “Mental activity is a function of brain-substance.” It is unnecessary to multiply quotations to prove the well-known fact that the whole drift of nineteenth century Science was in the direction of regarding man as a wholly material organism, and Spirit as a mere superstition.

It is obvious that Hinduism is in direct conflict with these conclusions of western Science, and while accepting the facts on which these conclusions are based, it interprets the facts in an entirely different way. To Hinduism there is one eternal Reality, which manifests in time and space under a dual aspect—Sat and Asat, Being and Non-being, Self and Not-Self, Pratyagatma and Mulaprakriti, Ishvara and Maya, Life and Form, Spirit and Matter. Never is this primary ‘pair’ found separated in manifestation, the one presenting itself without the other; known within is the Self, known without is the Not-Self, and the Not-Self depends for its manifestation on its recognition by the Self. In Hinduism, Life is the shaper, the moulder, the artist; matter is the shaped, the moulded, the material. Life is the director, the arranger, the controller; matter the guided, the arrangement, the servant. According to this view, a material organ is shaped by the effort of the life to exercise one of its capacities; the effort to perceive shapes an organ of vision, an eye; the effort to move shapes an organ of locomotion, a leg; the function makes the organ; the organ is the result of the function, not the function the result of the organ, as Büchner contended. Between conceptions so antagonistic as these two, no reconciliation is possible. They start from opposite poles; one or other must be wrong. The question to be decided is: “Which is right?”

This question is being answered by the experiments of Science itself, and with ever increasing force sounds out the reply: “Hinduism is right.” and the best proof that this is the answer of the experiments lies in the changed attitude of the Science of the twentieth century.

The microscopical examination into the minute organisms named Monera—the tiny lumps of protoplasm which are the roots of the animal and vegetable kingdoms, and cannot themselves be called either animals or plants. These have no organs—no mouth, no digestive tract, no lungs, no heart. They are little bits of protoplasm, living creatures, and life’s functions are shown forth, but no function has an organ. The creature needs food—any part of its outer surface acts as a mouth; the part within which is in contact with the ingested food acts as a digestive apparatus. The creature needs air—the whole, surface takes it in, and it spreads through the whole lump. The creature needs the digested matter for assimilation—it filters through the whole and nourishes it. The creature needs to move—any part of the lump can be pushed out to act as a temporary leg, and withdrawn when the motion is accomplished.

As investigations are carried on, it is seen that the continual need for food, and the continual taking of it in, tend to produce a slight depression in the part of the body most used for this purpose, and the depression slowly deepens, and gradually becomes a canal, or tube, through the body, open on the outside, and thus a mouth and a digestive canal appear. And by slow and gradual process, as the life continues to function, other organs are formed: breathing bags appear and evolve into lungs, a pulsating vacuole evolves into a heart, and the extended portions are not withdrawn after use, and so become legs.

What does all this mean? Surely that the life wills to function, and shapes matter to its purpose. Surely that the organ is the result of the function, and not the function the result of the organ. Often and often we see a function expressing itself with difficulty, ere an organ exists fitted for its manifestation. But where can we see an organ without a function, save vestigial organs, the result of past and now discontinued functions? The evidence is clear and overwhelming that, under the pressure of the functioning life, organs for its better functioning are gradually evolved, and that as the Chhandogyopanishat says, the Self, willing to see, to hear, to think, on this plane of gross matter, brings forth in it the eye, the ear, the mind.

Such is the triumphant vindication of the ancient Hindu teaching as to the relation between a function and its organ. The bearing of this on the function of thought and its organ the brain must now be considered.

Contents

XI. Hinduism a Scientific Religion

If it be true that the life, expressing one of its activities, shapes in its enclosing matter an organ, through which that activity is thenceforth more easily and more perfectly exercised; then when we come to study the activity of life which we call thought, and its relation to its organ the brain, we shall be prepared to regard thought as the builder, the producer, of the brain, instead of considering the brain as the producer of thought. We shall expect to find that here, as everywhere else, life has shaped matter, and we should not expect to find here a sudden reversal of the previous methods of nature. As everywhere else the function has preceded the organ, and has shaped and improved it, so here also we shall be prepared to find the same order. And thus, in truth, it is.

The scientific demonstration that thought is not the product of the brain comes from the activities of thought in trance-conditions, and it is significant that Büchner derided mesmerism and hypnotism, as mere frauds and impudent pretences. He saw that if the experiments of hypnotisers were true, the whole foundation of materialism was swept away; and, with a true instinct, he passionately condemned it, and refused all examination of its phenomena. For, in the hypnotic trance, the body is reduced to the lowest condition of vitality; the heart cannot be felt to beat, nor the lungs to rise and fall; the organs of the senses do not answer to impacts, and the man lies in a deep lethargy, insensitive to all that is outside him. The sluggish blood, unoxygenated, scarcely moves in the vessels that supply the brain, and it sinks into the inactivity of coma. Yet, under these conditions, the power of vision, deserting the eye, looks at things that are happening hundreds of miles away; the power of hearing, deserting the ear, listens to voices that are talking at a far distance; the power of memory, so limited in the waking state, gives back all the treasures committed to it during life, even to the events of infancy; the reasoning power becomes more subtle, when the brain is still; the imaginative power becomes more splendid, when deprived of its nervous instrument; every faculty, every power, of thought, instead of vanishing—as they would necessarily do were they brain-products—when the brain is paralysed, arises more vivid, more strong, more far-reaching, when set free from the prison of the brain. Triumphantly, indeed, has science demonstrated the non-dependence of thought on the brain, and the hypnotism that Büchner denounced as charlatanry is now accepted by every educated man. Thus rapidly has knowledge grown during the last quarter of a century.

Along another line, also, is science teaching us that thought produces and modifies the brain. The effect of thought on the brain is to render the cells it uses more complex, more intricate, larger, and we see how rightly Hinduism has taught its votaries that the practices of yoga—the regulation of diet, the steady meditation, fixing of the attention, etc.—are necessary for the safe reception by the brain of the subtle waves which play upon it from another world. The continual connexion found in the West, between the exstasies of the saints and their hysterical nervous conditions, the unbalanced mental states of highly religious people, the instability of the brains of men of genius—all these things have made men, who are sanely balanced, dread the excited manifestations which seemed to threaten the overthrow of reason from her seat. The sweeping down of the powerful and subtle waves of finer matter on the unprepared brain inevitably give rise to hysteria; but the yogi, preparing his brain by meditation, gradually fashions it into an instrument fitted to receive the otherwise shattering vibrations, and thus by thought perfects the thought-instrument, and shapes it to finer purpose. In yoga alone will the western world find the method by which the supernormal may be made normal, and extension of consciousness be gained without danger of insanity.

Contents

XII. Hinduism a Scientific Religion

What is the teaching of Hinduism as regards the constitution of man? Briefly stated it is this: the Jivatma, the living Spirit, takes upon himself sheaths, or material envelopes, or bodies, one after another, each successive envelope being composed of denser matter than its predecessor; each of these envelopes is composed of the matter of one ‘plane,’ or of a portion of a plane, and of these planes there are five, with which man is concerned in present evolution. The ordinary man may be said to be immediately concerned with only three of them, though men of genius, saints and other abnormal persons, come into touch with planes higher than these three.

The densest plane, or world, of matter is called physical, Bhurloka: our earth is composed of the denser parts of the physical matter, and the atmosphere round it of the less dense parts, while the finest parts, the ethers, interpenetrate everything. We have two bodies, or envelopes, made of physical matter, one composed of solids, fluids and gases, and the second of ethers.

The next plane, or world, of matter less dense than the physical, is called Bhuvarloka; sometimes it is called the subtle world, or the astral world; astral means starry, and the matter is more shining than physical matter, and so was said to be like stars. This world also has its solids, liquids, gases and ethers, of which the bodies living in it are composed. We have a body belonging to this world, made of astral matter, and though it behaves like a single body while we are living on the earth, it gradually sorts itself out into two bodies after death; one is the Preta-body, made of the denser parts of astral matter, and the other is the Pitri-body, made of the finer parts.

The third plane, or world, of matter finer than astral, is called Svarga, the heavenly or mental world. It also has its solids, liquids, gases and ethers, of which the bodies of its inhabitants are composed. We have two bodies belonging to this world, made of mental matter; one of them is of the denser parts of mental matter belonging to the ordinary Svarga into which people go; and one is composed of the finer parts, belonging to the Maharloka, a body which is not very active yet, except in great people like geniuses and saints, and with which, therefore, we are not very much concerned here.

Now these three worlds, Bhur, Bhuvar, and Svarga lokas, are all inhabited. Our own earth is clearly inhabited, as we and the numerous people we see, and others out of sight, and all animals, etc., inhabit it. But Bhuvarloka is inhabited quite as much as Bhurloka. All kinds of Devas live there, and Asuras as well; and there are crowds of Pretas there, in the districts named Pretaloka, and crowds of Pitris too, in their land, called Pitriloka; and men and women still living on earth go there while their physical bodies are asleep, but only some are wide-awake there; and there are various other people and creatures there, innumerable multitudes, living their own lives.

The same is true of Svargaloka, except that very few men and women, still living on earth, are able to go there while their bodies are asleep, so not many of them are to be seen; but there are crowds of men and women there, who have come thither from Pitriloka, and are living there happily until their time comes to be reborn into this world, Bhurloka.

Now while we are living here on earth, our astral and mental bodies put us into touch with the astral and mental worlds, Bhuvarloka and Svargaloka, just as our physical bodies put us into touch with the physical world, Bhurloka. And the inhabitants of those worlds can touch and make impressions on our bodies in those worlds, just as the inhabitants of this world can touch and make impressions on our bodies here. The curious mental phenomena, which are just now so much interesting and puzzling European psychologists, who have not had the opportunity, or the inclination, to study Hindu psychology, and the teaching of Hinduism on the material side of man’s constitution, belong largely to these bodies. These teachings reduce into order the chaos of phenomena, assigned to the ‘unconscious’ in man, i.e., to that part of his consciousness which is not in the Jagrata state, his waking consciousness, functioning through the mechanism of his nervous system. Let us look at some groups of these phenomena.

Dreams

These are divisible into: (a) those caused, in the dense physical body, by repetitions in the brain of vibrations set up in waking life; (b) those caused in the etheric physical body, by similar vibrations; (c) those initiated on the astral plane, by (i) passing events or persons with whom the individual is not concerned; (ii) passing events in which the individual is concerned, and communications directly made to him by the inhabitants of that world, human and non-human; (d) those initiated on the mental plane; these are less common, as the physical brain does not easily respond to the vibrations caused on the mental plane.

We shall consider these in order.

(a). These are unimportant, and are generally grotesque, unconnected, the piecing together of fragments of irrelevant and incongruous past experiences, and are without significance. The action of the brain-cells may be started by pressure on a nerve connected with some internal organ, stomach, heart, lungs, etc.; by an overfull or too empty blood-vessel disturbing the brain-supply of blood; by impure blood; by pressure from outside. Any of these, and other causes, may start activity in some brain cells, that will automatically repeat a series of vibrations, or parts of many series, previously experienced.

(b). Characterised by sequence and by a dramatic character, but of no greater importance than those belonging to the dense physical body. The very numerous dreams of a vivid and dramatic character, produced, by outside stimuli, as the dream of a thunderstorm, caused by sprinkling water on the face of the sleeper; the dream of a duel, a battle, or a murder, caused by the firing of a pistol near him; of a trial and execution by slight pressure on the neck; etc. etc. (see Du Prel’s Philosophy of Mysticism for many cases), all these are interesting, as showing the tendency of the etheric portion of the brain to produce pictures, as though it acted as the sensitive plate of a camera; but such dreams have no significance as regards the man himself, though something about his etheric body may be learned from them. These dreams are, of course, remembered on waking, as they belong to the physical body, and the impressions are made in physical matter. But the real man, the Jiva, is not concerned with them, as he is away from his physical bodies during sleep.

Contents

XIII. Hinduism a Scientific Religion

(c) (i.) When the astral body has left the physical, and the latter lies asleep, the astral body, no longer serving as a medium between the Jiva and the physical body, responds readily to the vibrations coming from objects in the astral world, Bhuvarloka, and these bring about changes in consciousness, more or less marked. Just as a man in the physical body may watch a crowd in the street, the movements of the persons therein being in no way connected with himself; as he may see a horse fall, or two dogs fighting, or a procession, or a dead body; so may the man in the astral body see many things around him in the astral world that are not related to himself, and have no significance for him. If he remembers any of these on his return to the physical body, he says he has dreamed of such and such a thing, but the dream has no bearing upon him and his affairs. Often an explanation of such a dream is asked for, and nothing can be said in reply except: “The things were happening, and you saw them.” Such dreams may be very vivid and coherent, very interesting and impressive, but they do not ‘mean anything’ to the spectator. It is otherwise with (ii), in which the spectator is also an actor, in which persons also in the astral world may talk with him, give him information, teachings, warnings, directions, etc., in which he may see things that have not yet happened on the physical plane, or pictures of the past, reflected in astral matter from higher planes, and so on. Memory of any of these on waking would be called a dream, but such dreams are true memories of objective events occurring in another world.

(d.) What is true of dreams that originate on the astral plane is also true of those that originate on the mental, but memory of these is more rarely brought through to the physical plane, the subtler matter of the mental plane making memory more elusive.

When it is remembered that we are constantly clothed in the astral and mental bodies, it will readily be understood that impressions made on these during waking hours, vibrations set up in them by external objects on those planes, or by their inhabitants, will give rise to innumerable impressions, premonitions, warnings, fears, hopes, which, originating away from the physical body, are not intelligible to the reason, working in and limited by that body. Thus the existence of these subtler bodies, related to other worlds, as taught by Hinduism, gives a rational and intelligible explanation of the problems of the ‘unconscious’ in man, that are so puzzling European psychologists.

Religious experiences

In every religion we find that earnest and pious people have occasional experiences in which they become conscious of invisible presences, feel an inrush of peace and joy, are lifted above their normal consciousness, become illuminated with regard to spiritual things. In all these the medium of communication is one or other of the subtler bodies: thus, if the physical and astral bodies be reduced to passivity, the Jiva, in the mental body, becomes conscious on the mental plane, may share the life of Svarga, communicate with the Devas, and feel the bliss of the heavenly worlds. Higher yet may he rise, as in the rapture of the saint the contemplation of the yogi, and all this class of facts becomes intelligible when the Hindu teaching of the constitution of man is understood.

Genius

A genius is a man in whom the karana sharira, the causal body, is active, and its vibrations are sufficiently powerful to impress themselves on the lower vehicles. Its activities are characterised by suddenness, spontaneity, illumination, not by the ordinary mental processes of reasoning. Its light shines out, illuminating the whole field of consciousness, and, like the sun, it justifies itself by shining. Even in ordinary persons there are occasional moments of luminousness and power, in which the man is astonished to find himself ‘rising above himself.’ Truly in such moments it is a gleam of ‘himself’ that shines through the dense matter that normally blinds and cramps him.

Telepathy and cognate phenomena

These are all due to vibrations of the subtler bodies, sending out waves, as in wireless telegraphy, that arouse similar vibrations in bodies they touch, which are capable of reproducing them. By such waves in astral and mental matter thoughts may be communicated, news may be sent, events in a distant land may be known.

When once it is understood that man, by his various bodies, is in touch with many worlds, is affected by them, and in his turn affects them, the chaotic impressions which reach him are reduced to order, and the complete understanding of them is seen to be a matter of an ever-unfolding consciousness and ever-evolving bodies. The disorderly, the miraculous, the fearful, disappear, and all becomes orderly, natural, and interesting. It is Hinduism which offers a guiding hand to science, and gives her the clue by which she may tread safely the labyrinth of the ‘unconscious.’

As the Hindu boy learns, more and more, the splendor of the religion into which he has been born, he will be willing to wait for its further justification, and he will realise that science is approaching, by long continued and patient experiments, that which the Rishis of the past had learned by experiments and training of much longer duration, and that, by the intermediation of this most scientific of the world’s religions, Religion and Science, so long estranged in the West, will again clasp hands.

Note: Annie Besant (1847–1933) was a leading Theosophist and occultist, not a traditional Hindu teacher. In this chapter the Hindu ideas of the sheaths (koshas) and the worlds (lokas) are explained through the Theosophical scheme of “planes” and of “physical”, “etheric”, “astral”, “mental” and “causal” bodies, and the claim that Hinduism was “founded and built up by occultists” and is confirmed by science reflects Theosophical teaching and her own opinion. The scientific views she quotes (Büchner, Haeckel, Lord Kelvin and others) are those of about 1900. Readers should distinguish her presentation from classical Hindu teaching.

Contents


Source

Annie Besant, In Defence of Hinduism: A Booklet written for Hindu Boys. Benares City and London: Theosophical Publishing Society; The Theosophist Office, Adyar, Madras (no year on the title page). Printed at the Tara Printing Works, Benares. Pages used: 31–35, 36–39 and 40–64 (chapters VII–XIII). Some spellings of Sanskrit names have been standardised. This article is from public domain digital sources.

Disclaimer

We have made every effort to reproduce this text faithfully, but we cannot guarantee that it is free of errors. Readers who need accuracy for study or citation should check the original publication. The views and language are those of the author and his time, and e-Scriptures is not responsible for them.

Spelling and style follow the original; obvious scanning and typographical errors have been corrected. This text is believed to be in the public domain in the United States, where this website is operated. Copyright terms differ from country to country, so a text that is free of copyright in the United States may still be protected elsewhere. Readers outside the United States should check the copyright laws of their country before copying, downloading or reusing it; they are responsible for lawful use in their own country. See our Terms of Use.

Our books

Translate This Page

Search This Site