Summary: Two lectures from Sri Ananda Acharya’s introduction to Hindu philosophy (1917). The first sets out how the ancient Indian thinkers approached philosophy, covering the meaning of darsana, the six systems, the Buddha’s teaching on Nirvana, and the contrast between Indian and European philosophers. The second presents Sankara’s monistic Advaita Vedanta, covering the Absolute and the cosmos, the life of Yoga, the states of Turiya and Samvit, and the doctrine of Avidya, or error.
Lecture I: General View-Points of Ancient Indian Philosophers
The meaning of the word Darsana — The six systems of Indian philosophy — The Buddha’s teaching regarding Nirvāna — European chronology — Contrast between Indian and European philosophers.
India has been justly regarded as the home of philosophy and religion. From the earliest times Indian thinkers have felt the necessity of basing religion upon philosophy, and of building society upon religion. In order to illustrate the fact that philosophy has been the dominant factor in the history of India, I will begin by telling you a little fairy tale.
There was once an Indian prince who was wandering among the mountains when he met a great sage, who told him that he would have to pass through many misfortunes and would suffer much trouble in the future. The prince asked the sage if he could not help him so that he might be spared these terrible misfortunes, whereupon the sage gave him three things: a milk-white leaf, a silver-white bee, and a bee of golden hue, and told him that as long as he kept these three together in a safe place, he would be preserved from all danger. The prince took the three gifts to his mother and explained to her their magic properties, whereupon she caused a room to be built of stone under a lake, and there in a steel box she placed the three treasures.
In the course of time the sage’s words were fulfilled, and although the prince passed through many dangers, his life was preserved.
It is in the same way that the life of the Hindus is preserved through the possession of three things: philosophy, morality, and religion. The milk-white leaf represents morality, the silver-white bee stands for religion, and the bee of golden hue symbolises philosophy. All through the history of India we find that these three have been regarded as sacred and treasured as the precious talisman that was to preserve the nation through all the vicissitudes of its history.
As you all know, India has passed through many changes during the last few centuries, but there are probably no people in the world who had been subjected to so much pressure from outside, and have yet managed to escape from the degenerate influence which is usually the result of contact with less civilised races. Thus we see that the ideals of a holy life have been preserved in spite of the absence of a national government to safeguard the essentials of Hindu life and religion.
Far away from the sun-baked plains, the busy towns, and quiet villages, there lived a brotherhood of teachers who matured their philosophy in the solitude of the mountains and in the depths of the forests for the purpose of guiding humanity. These teachers, who were known by the name of Sannyāsins, were, and still are, the real legislators, governors, and guides of the Indian people. These Sannyāsins, trained in the science of self-knowledge and self-control, and renouncing the ordinary pursuits of life, wander all over the country, live among the people, and teach them to live the life of righteousness.
It would take too long to give an exhaustive account of the influence exerted by Indian philosophy on Indian life; I will only touch on a few points. To begin with, it is extremely important that I should explain the meaning of some technical terms of philosophy for which there are no English words which exactly correspond.
The word “Darsana” is generally used as synonymous with “philosophy,” and is derived from the Sanscrit root dris which means “to see.” If we trace the origin of the word, we find that the first and most ancient meaning is “seeing with the eyes.” The second meaning is “perceiving with the different senses,” perceiving, that is, with the sense of seeing, sense of hearing, sense of smelling, sense of feeling, and sense of tasting. Darsana, therefore, includes all that we feel and all that we perceive with the external senses through our minds. The third development of the word is “seeing with the Divine eye,” that is, the eye which is opened through meditation and purity of life, by which means the soul is brought into touch with the Highest. Thus the three meanings of the word Darsana are: seeing with the senses, seeing with the mind, and seeing with the Divine eye, which last you may call intuition.
The third meaning is the most important one to be remembered, as it marks off Indian philosophy from the philosophies of the rest of the world by presupposing that the soul is the ultimate Reality, and that its substance as well as its form is to be described by the word intuition (Sākshi Svarupa). Some philosophers appear to think that consciousness is an attribute or faculty of the soul which is independent of the senses; others again think that consciousness is independent of the senses as well as of the reasoning powers, and is the intermediate link between soul and thought activity; but the Vedānta teaches that soul is pure intuition.
There are at least sixteen different schools of philosophy in India, but of these only the six principal systems are generally recognised. The first and oldest of them is the Sāmkhya, the founder of which was Kapila. Kapila is regarded as the father of Indian philosophy because, although philosophy in the sense of Darsana was known to the Rishis even before his time, he was the first to place it on a rational basis.
Now let us turn to the meaning of the word Sāmkhya. Sāmkhya means that which can be numbered, classified, grouped. Kapila called his system the numbering system, but of course it had nothing to do with arithmetic. It was so called because he classified material phenomena under twenty-four heads, or principles. The other meaning of the word Sāmkhya is Ātmānātmāviveka, which means the discrimination of soul from nature, spirit from matter. The reason for separating or differentiating the soul from matter is that we are conscious within ourselves of a principle, i.e. self-consciousness, which is quite different from the rest of the universe. You are aware within yourself of your own existence; I am conscious within myself of my own existence, and, going deeper still, I find that I am conscious of my own existence as the witness or seer of the thoughts and feelings that pass within the mind and body, within which the soul appears to dwell. As the thoughts and feelings of each one of us differ from the thoughts and feelings of others, Kapila assumed the existence of a plurality of independent souls, each of which is fundamentally different from every other. He also assumed the existence of a world of matter independent of the world of souls.
The object of the Sāmkhya is to realise the distinction between matter and spirit, so that the latter can emancipate itself from the bondage of the former; thus Sāmkhya teaches us how to see the spirit which lies encased in matter, therefore it is called a Darsana because it invites us to see the glory of the spirit as it is in itself.
The second system of Indian philosophy was founded by Patanjali and is called the Yoga. The Yoga Darsana is not an independent Darsana, but has arisen out of the Sāmkhya and may be said to supplement it. The word Yoga means “self-concentration with a view to see the soul as it looks when it is abstracted from mind and matter.”
Patanjali says in his Yoga Sāstra that when the soul is freed from distraction, ignorance, and doubt, it stands face to face with God and is blessed with the vision of the All-holy. Thus it is quite clear that the object of the Yoga Darsana is to teach us how the eye of the soul may be opened so that we can see our God, through whose grace we are able to escape the miseries that are due to ignorance. The fruit of God-vision is perfection. Man can only be saved by Yoga, that is by the conscious union of finite souls with the Infinite through the clear recognition on the part of the former of the essential kinship of both. This recognition may be obtained in various ways, either by dedicating all the fruits of our work to God — this way is called the Karma Yoga — or by the absolute surrender of all our hopes and aspirations, and our self also, to God, in the belief that His grace is our highest good. This is called Bhakti Yoga, or the realisation of God through love and devotion. The highest form of Yoga is called Jnāna Yoga, in which the finite soul does not see itself except as infilled by, and identical with, the Absolute God.
The third system of Indian philosophy is called the Nyāya which was delivered by Gotama. He taught that the highest aim of human life was to attain to a right understanding of God, soul, and nature. The word Nyāya means standard, or universal principle. This Gotama lived long before Gautama the Buddha and was the inventor of Hindu logic, physics, and metaphysics.
The fourth system is called the Vaishesika and is also based upon Gotama’s Nyāya; it is, in fact, one of the great divisions of the latter. It teaches that Liberation is the reward of Divine knowledge.
The last two, the fifth and sixth systems of Indian philosophy, are called the Mimāmsā and the Vedānta, taught respectively by Jaimini and Vyāsa. Mimāmsā means profound thought, reflection, and is concerned chiefly with the correct interpretation of Vedic ritual and text, while the Vedānta deals with the inquiry into the nature of the Absolute Spirit. The object of the Vedānta is to discern the highest truth that is revealed in the consciousness of humanity, and thereby to attain the Highest Goal of existence.
Now I will briefly refer to some of the subjects treated of in the different Darsanas, and this will enable you to form an idea of the scope and object of Hindu philosophy. They are as follows:
- The origin and constitution of the universe.
- The nature of knowledge and its instruments (such as mind, etc.).
- The discrimination of the soul and its immortality.
- The future state of the soul and its wanderings.
- The cause of our embodied existence.
- The cause of pleasure and pain.
- Moral law (Karma).
- Bondage and Liberation.
- Personal God and the Absolute, or the Impersonal God.
One aim inspires the whole body of Hindu Darsanas, and that is Liberation — Mukti.
“As the waters of the ocean have only one taste, which is salt, so the Darsanas have only one aim, which is Liberation.”
Man wants to be liberated, to be free — free from the imperfections of his own nature — physical, intellectual, moral, and spiritual. This aspiration is seated deep down in the very nature of our spiritual consciousness, and finds eloquent expression in the songs of the Upanishads and in the aphorisms of the Darsanas. To attain to freedom means to be holy and wise and perfect, as God is perfect, wise, and holy. Different philosophers have interpreted freedom in different ways; for instance, Kapila says that freedom means the realisation of the independence of the spirit from the material principle in which it finds itself entangled. This state of perfection means complete freedom from the vicissitudes of terrestrial existence, but this may be taken in two ways: first, that the soul may be completely extinguished, just as the flame of a candle is extinguished; or that the soul may return to God from Whom it arose. The former teaching has been attributed to the Buddha, while the latter emanates from the Vedānta. I cannot enter into a discussion as to whether the Buddha meant by Nirvāna the complete extinction of the soul, for the Buddha preferred to be silent on questions relating to the finality of things, and, as often happens, his followers interpreted the sayings of the master according to their own favourite views! I can only say that my personal opinion on the subject of the Buddhist doctrine of Nirvāna is that the Buddha meant, not the extinction of the immortal spirit, but of the lower ego which is the seat of all selfishness and imperfection. That this is so seems probable from what he said on one occasion when he took some dry leaves into the hollow of his hand, and asked his disciple Ānanda to tell him whether there were any other leaves besides these, to which Ānanda replied:
“The leaves of autumn are falling on all sides, and there are more of them than can be numbered.”
Then the Buddha said: “In like manner I have given you a handful of truths, but besides these there are many thousands of other truths, more than can be numbered.”
The Buddha was of opinion that man must be taught to be moral first, then he will see the greater truths for himself. The Vedāntic conception of the soul is based upon the essential unity of the soul and Brahman. The Vedāntin holds that the idea of an individual soul existing apart from the Absolute is mistaken logic. Man thinks that he is cut off from the Infinite because of his ignorance. Liberation means the passing away for ever of this illusory sense of finiteness, and realising the eternal nature of the Soul.
All philosophical speculation can be traced in the Rig Veda, which is the oldest of all the Vedas; there we find such passages as the following:
“The poets and prophets discover God in their hearts. Beyond light and darkness, there He shines in His wonderful Majesty.”
The entire Vedic literature is filled with references to the existence of a God, and man’s need to realise Him. The Upanishads, of which at the present time there are only 108 in number, are full of the loftiest poetry with regard to the immortality of the soul, the Creator of this universe, and the final liberation of man through the knowledge of “the God who dwells in the cavity of the heart.” All the philosophical speculations of the world can be traced to the Upanishads, which are an inexhaustible storehouse of scientific and philosophic ideas.
The next body of literature are the Sutras, or aphorisms: all the Darsanas are written in this form, and it is quite impossible to understand them without commentaries. These were written much later. The interpretation is in the hands of Brahmanas and Sannyāsins; the Brahmanas teach the lay pupils, and the Sannyāsins teach those who renounce the pursuits of mundane life and devote themselves exclusively to the realisation of the Absolute Brahman.
It is exceedingly difficult, if not impossible, to settle the chronological order in which these different systems were given to the world. European scholars have a tendency to fix the age of Sanscrit literature at a much later date than we do in India, basing their conclusions on very superficial evidence. For instance, Wilson based his conclusions concerning the date of the Mudrā-Rākhasa from a passage which runs as follows: “... being troubled by the barbarians”; he said that this drama was composed between the eleventh and twelfth centuries A.D., for no other reason than that India was invaded by the Mahomedans at that time; but the word Mlechchha refers to all non-Indians, and we know that Alexander the Great invaded India in the fourth century B.C., and that after Alexander’s time India was repeatedly invaded by Bactrian Greeks and Scythians. But Wilson gives no reason why Mudrā-Rākhasa should not belong to the Alexandrian period. Again, Max Müller thinks that the Vedas were composed between 1500 and 1000 B.C., and he refers the Sutra literature to a period extending from 600 to 200 B.C., although there is hardly a single scrap of evidence to substantiate this view. We shall therefore leave the question of dates alone. It is certain that in very ancient times the real authors of the Vedas taught them to their pupils, by whom they were afterwards handed down to successive generations, when the teachings contained in them came to be widely diffused. In later ages, these were reduced to writing and divided into different systems according to the subject matter, each being ascribed to the celebrated Rishi through whom it was believed to have been revealed.
With regard to Indian philosophy, it is impossible to apply what is known as the ideal method, or for the matter of that the chronological method either, in tracing the development of the Darsanas. It is tolerably certain that none of the six teachers whom I mentioned actually wrote the Sutras which pass under their name. Kapila, Kanāda, Gotama, Jaimini, Patanjali, and Vyāsa taught these Darsanas to their pupils in systematic form, and many centuries after their death the Sutras were written; but these great Rishis were not the originators, they were the conveyers of the Darsanas. It will be seen, therefore, that these Darsanas passed through two stages in the course of their development, viz. the oral and the written stage, the former being of course the more ancient.
European historians and antiquarians firmly believe that their ancestors were savages and that they are far more enlightened than their forefathers, but we in India believe exactly the opposite. We think that our ancestors were gods and Rishis, endowed with superhuman wisdom and holiness, and that we Indians of the present day are their unworthy descendants. The illusion of European historians consists in judging our history from a knowledge of their own past. I should like to remind them that the law which they deduce from a study of the history of Europe after the fall of the Roman Empire cannot be held to account for the civilisations of ancient Egypt, Greece, Persia, India; and China. In those countries civilisation, instead of developing, has degenerated, while in Europe civilisation has progressed from very unpromising beginnings. India looks back, while Europe looks forward to the Golden Age.
It is not every one who is called to the study of the Darsanas; there are certain mental, moral, and spiritual qualifications that are necessary, the first and most important being that the student should have fulfilled all his duties towards the world; among which are included, not only civic and household duties, but all the observances required of him towards the manes of his forefathers, as well as the offering of sacrifices to the deities who preside over nature. Next, he must be able to control his senses, his mind and intellect. He must cultivate what is called one-pointedness, not allowing his mind to wander; he must be ready to forgive every injury that may be inflicted on him; and he must be able to see God in all. When a man possesses all these qualifications, then he is allowed to study philosophy. Yet it must not be supposed that the mass of the people are kept in ignorance, for as in Europe there are only a few experts who devote themselves to the higher branches of science, such as mechanics, chemistry, medicine, etc., so in India it is only the few who may devote themselves to the study of the Darsanas, while to the populace philosophy is taught through the medium of religion, mythology, and parables. The drama, art, and poetry of India are all pervaded by this teaching.
In India the ideal of education is very high, and consequently its realisation implies a process coeval with the progress of the soul through infinite time. As the summit of human perfection cannot be attained within the brief span of a single life, and as society is composed of individuals, each differing from the other in taste, inclination, capacity, and attainment, education was arranged in such a way that all classes of men and women, from the best and brightest minds to the most commonplace, should be afforded opportunities for receiving instruction.
The Rishis recognised that a fundamental contradiction exists between the requirements of our spiritual and our earthly life, and that this can only be overcome by making the latter subservient to the former. From this originated the institution of Āsrams and castes. The Āsrams are the stages of life for receiving the education suited to each; for instance, the first period of a man’s life ought to be devoted to the acquirement of knowledge; the next should be devoted to the performance of the duties incidental to social life; the third period should be devoted to the acquisition of truths which lie at the root of all things, such as the nature of God, the state of the soul after death, etc., and the fourth period should be devoted to the realisation of the Highest; but during this last period of life men who have passed through this training are expected to give the fruits of their experience to the rising generation.
European philosophy does not concern itself either with the foundation of religion or that of morality. The people, no less than the Church, never expected guidance from the philosopher in matters relating to the supersensuous. But in India the teachers of the six systems of philosophy are also the teachers of religion and morality. Religious life was never divorced from philosophical contemplation, nor was the culture of the Darsanas viewed with suspicion by religious people. The secret of the harmony between Dārsanikas and Dhārmikas (philosophers and religious men) is that the former started with the assumption that the Vedas were revealed to man by God. No Dārsanika every questioned this supreme fact, hence the happy blending of faith with reason, which is conspicuously absent in the history of the development of European philosophy.
The Indian Dārsanika starts his inquiry with a searching examination of the position of man, including both his psychology and his surroundings; he finds that although man is happy to a certain degree, he is not supremely so, that his lot is a mixed one, while he continually longs for an unmixed state of blessedness. The investigation into the cause of suffering leads the Indian philosopher to the conclusion that all pain is due to our confusion of the immaterial spirit with the material body, and his final teaching is that man can — by means of knowledge, and knowledge alone (Jnāna) — become, not only the master of his fate, but that he can isolate himself completely from the onslaught of all evils, including death, even in this life. Hindu philosophers teach that the soul is a spiritual, conscious substance, perfect and universal, neither liable to birth, death, or pain, but that, owing to the power of a mysterious agency, sometimes called Avidyā, ignorance, and sometimes Aviveka, non-discrimination, or Mithyā Jnāna, false knowledge, souls are tied to subtile bodies and are made to pass through pain and pleasure, birth and death. Souls suffer Samsāra, or repeated births, owing to non-discrimination of the real from the unreal, i.e. the confusion of the Immortal Soul with the perishable aspects of personality. All works born out of this primitive non-discrimination, whether mental or physical, moral or immoral, are reproductive, i.e. they go on multiplying until they are counteracted and destroyed by true knowledge. Therefore the highest aim of man is to attain to perfection and freedom through the destruction of all Karma (works). Karma can only be destroyed by the complete annihilation of ignorance, non-discrimination, and false knowledge.
It is extremely difficult to picture in the mind’s eye the state of freedom which the Indian philosopher has in view. It must be remembered that he believes that all that we call suffering, disease, and death, is, in the last analysis, a state of feeling which does not correspond with reality. When Jnāna1 arises, all the apparitions which are called up by our imagination and feeling will vanish away and nothing will remain except the Absolute I AM. This is called the highest stage, from the summit of which body, mind, and the whole universe will appear as mere shadows.
Although this idea of Mukti, or liberation of the finite spirit through the knowledge of its infinite nature, is foreign to European philosophers, it must be said that, both in the Bible and in the writings of early Christian mystics, the belief in the attainment of one-ness with God through love is frequently to be met with. Again, although the idea of the infinite movement of the finite spirit in accordance with the law of moral retribution has not found any place in the discussions of European philosophers, it does not seem to have been unfamiliar to the author of the Gospel according to St. John.
Bibliography
- Sarvadarsana Samgraha, p. 85.
- Buddha, by H. Oldenberg, pp. 263–285.
- Dhammapada, pp. 427–445.
- Samyuttaka Nikāya.
- Malinda Panha.
- Rig Veda.
- Mr. Dhruva’s paper, “On the Age of the Veda.”
- Mr. Tilak’s “Arctic Home of the Āryas” and “The Orion.”
Notes
- Jnāna is the intuition which arises through the development of the cognitive faculties.
Lecture V: Monism: The Absolute and the Cosmos
Psychological foundation of Advaita philosophy of Sankara — State of subconsciousness — Progressive Yoga life — Turiya and Samvit — Avidyā, the doctrine of error — Discipleship.
Sri Sankara Āchārya’s exposition of the Vedānta proceeds on strict Advaita, or monistic lines; it is an exposition which is unsurpassed in the history of philosophy. No philosopher, either in ancient or in modern times, has ever risen to such high altitudes to survey pure spirit; yet he cannot be called the founder of Advaita Vedānta, for he only carried on the glorious traditions of his master and spiritual father, Sri Govinda Āchārya, who was in turn the spiritual son of Sri Gaudapāda Āchārya, the writer of an excellent commentary on some of the most abstruse of the Upanishads. The age in which these three philosophers flourished is not exactly known, but it can safely be said to have been not later than the eighth century A.D.
Sankara based his teaching on the ancient texts of the Upanishads, and his interpretation was guided by a transcendental sense of value which was at once critical and constructive. He mercilessly exposed the fallacies of Kapila’s realism and the nihilism of the Buddha’s teaching. The blemishes in the systems taught by Patanjali and Gotama were also pointed out by him; but although his tone was extremely critical, Sankara’s philosophy is far from being destructive, for he established philosophical thought on the surest of all foundations, viz. on the transcendental identity of experience with existence, chit and sat.
Hence arises the great difficulty of comprehending the logic of his dialectical procedure, for a thorough familiarity with the Vedas and the different Darsanas is a pre-requisite for the student who aspires to the study of Sankara’s Advaita. Moreover, the abstruse nature of his writings may be appreciated from the fact that the superstructure of his metaphysics was built upon the psychical experience of the fourth degree (Turiya), and that the truths taught in his work were meant for the instruction of those who, being born in the fourth caste (Brahman), had, by pure and holy living, made themselves eligible for the fourth order (Yati); and lastly, the ideal which he preached could only bear fruit and become actual to those who had the fourth purpose of life (Moksha) in view, and who were on the threshold of realising the fourth and last perfection (nirvikalpa Samādhi). The Advaita ideal is to be followed by those who have renounced all desires for worldly prosperity, who live only for truth, and whose one object in life is liberation.
But let not this discourage any one from the study of Sankara, for whatever may be your position in the world of religion and philosophy, you all desire to be emancipated from error and saved by a knowledge of truth which can give permanent peace and happiness. The seeds of knowledge sown now will bear fruit in the fulness of time.
Let us examine some of the salient features of the Advaita philosophy of Sankara. The promise of Advaita-knowledge lies embedded in our nightly experience of deep sleep (Susupti), and its fulfilment in the experience of unconditioned ecstasy (Samādhi). It would be impossible to understand the Advaita philosophy unless we were able to discover its psychological foundation in the depths of our own nature. Consider the changes that take place within the mind every twenty-four hours: in the day-time we are awake and active; at night we go to sleep. Sometimes we dream, at other times we enjoy a dreamless sleep; thus it happens that every day we pass through the three states of waking, dreaming, and dreamlessness, yet we hardly stop to think over these three states of our own bodies and minds, although the entire range of existence and experience lies confined within the limits of the two parallel states of waking and sleeping. What is life but waking? What is death but sleep? Yet we feel that our real existence is beyond wakefulness and sleep, beyond life and death. Why is this? In waking we are conscious of the ego and of the world; the ego remains unchanged while the world changes. By the term “world” I mean the sensations that come to the mind through the senses, the eyes, ears, nose, taste, and touch. These sensations are continually changing: first we see light, then perhaps we hear sound, after that we experience smell, etc. It is the ego which perceives these changes; the ego is also acting. When we desire to talk or walk, it is the ego which puts forth activity and thereby moves the organs and limbs — hands, feet, tongue, etc.
One of the functions of the ego is knowing, while the other is acting. In waking life the ego knows and does, therefore we may say that self-consciousness is the central fact of waking experience, in which the ego clearly distinguishes its individuality from the individuality of other egos. For instance, I am distinct and separate from you; you can never obliterate the distinctive mark of your own individuality from that of a friend, a son, or a neighbour. “I,” “you,” “he” are personal pronouns which express this ineffaceable distinction between different individuals. In the waking state self-consciousness implies the consciousness of personality and not that of the pure Self. This personality is really a series or group of attributes; i.e. it includes the mental attributes which you have inherited from your ancestors, as well as those which are acquired. You may be kind, energetic, and temperate; you may be a father in relation to one individual, brother in relation to another, and so on. Personality is a consciousness of disposition, social position, etc., and all these revolve around the centre called “I”; but what this “I” is, apart from personality, is a mystery. Another characteristic of the content of the waking consciousness is the uniformity of the outer world. In the waking state time is measurable, space is measurable, and there is a nexus between one event and another, which is called the causal tie; for instance, there is a relation between rain and harvest. This knowledge, which we derive from the measurableness of time, space and causality, constitutes our conception of the uniformity of nature; therefore we may sum up the contents of our wakeful consciousness as follows:
(1) Knowledge of our own character, disposition, etc.
(2) Knowledge of the character, disposition, etc., of others, e.g. men and animals.
(3) Knowledge of the uniformity of space, time, and causality.
Does the waking consciousness give us the knowledge of the true nature of this self? It is difficult to answer; let us say that it gives us direct knowledge of our own character, etc., and of the character and disposition of others, together with an indirect knowledge of the “I” or self. I say “indirect knowledge,” because we really do not know the exact nature of the “I,” although we have good reason for supposing that behind and below my thoughts and feelings there is “something” which forms, so to speak, the ground or foundation of my character and disposition, whether waking or dreaming.
Let us now analyse dream-consciousness. It is very difficult to say what happens during the interval between the beginning of sleep and the beginning of dream. It may be that our dreams begin in a more or less hazy way from the moment when drowsiness first overcomes us. In an advanced stage of sleep our dream-images become sufficiently clear and distinct to impress themselves on the memory so that on awaking we are able to recall them. If we compare the content of waking consciousness with that of dream consciousness, we shall find that as a general rule dream-consciousness contains all the elements of waking consciousness, only vastly transformed. For instance, in many cases there is a marked change of personality; the character, age, rank, temperament, and disposition of the dreamer changes in the wildest way. A poor housemaid dreams that she has become the Queen of Persia, a brave warrior dreams that he runs away at the first sign of danger, and a man dreams that he is an angel. Time, space, and causality take on a new rôle; events appear to take place in a few moments which would in reality occupy many months, maybe years. There is a case recorded of a man who dreamed he was wandering about in the wilderness. After walking for several days in the jungle, he found his way out and entered a small village where he lived in the house of a rich man, fell in love with the daughter and married her. They lived happily together for many years, during which time seven boys and seven girls were born to them; then their happiness was marred by a severe famine, in consequence of which food became very scarce and the whole family had to leave the village. While the man with his wife and children were fording a stream, down came a strong current of water from the mountains and swept them all away, with the exception of the man himself, who with great difficulty swam across and was thrown against the river bank. He got up and dried himself in the sun, but just when he was thinking of going on to the nearest village, a huge tiger attacked him. Frightened by the animal, he yelled for help, and was awakened by the sound of his own voice. All this took place in an inconceivably short time.
In dream, time creeps like a snail or gallops like a war-horse. In dream, we cannot measure time in the same way as we do in waking, we cannot divide it into hours, minutes, etc. Space also undergoes a great transformation, and distance is no longer the same in dream as in the waking state; similarly the idea of causality changes. Dream-consciousness transforms all our notions concerning nature’s laws, and no happenings, however grotesque, cause any surprise to the dreamer. The world of dream has laws and expectations of its own, quite apart from those of the waking world. Thus we see that the experience of dream is unverified by the experience of waking. The images of dream appear to the dreamer as real; he only believes them to be unreal on waking, but it never occurs to the dreamer that the sights and sounds which he experiences on waking are unreal, for waking gives the lie to dream experience, but not conversely. In one sense dream-life is a narrowing down of consciousness, but in another sense it reveals the vast possibilities of a widening of the function and sphere of consciousness. Dream shuts us within a sphere in which the ego is unable to take part or influence other egos, or the world of matter. The dreamer is not an ethical personage, for he is not master of his own will or conduct. Dream shows the power of the ego to create time, space, and causality. In waking we are the creatures of time, but in dreaming we create a new time from whose tyranny there is no escape except by waking. Thus the ego destroys time and space, and evolves a new time and a new space out of its own Karma — only to become once more a prisoner. Its newly acquired freedom from the meshes of the outer world is devoured by the monster of the world within.
Advancing from the magic house of dream to the field of dreamlessness, we find a complete change of scene. Dreamlessness is a unique experience; it is a state of intense passivity, peace, and silence. We cannot say that the ego did not exist in the dreamless state, for on waking it recollects that it slept soundly and peacefully; neither can it be said that the ego was unconscious at that moment, because the memory was actively recording the absence of any phenomenal experience, and that is why the dreamer says on waking, “I did not dream.” Dreamlessness is therefore the consciousness of negation, but it cannot be said that the entire field of consciousness was empty of all content, because there was, at the moment, a consciousness of rest, quiet, and delight. It is an experience in which the function of the ego changes. It no longer feels the pressure from the world of other egos or from the world of sights and sounds. It fails to objectify itself, and thus forgets its relation to the world and society; it is no longer a subject, because the dreamless ego is unconscious of its mental and moral attributes. During deep sleep kings no longer remember that they are kings, the sinner forgets his sin and the saint his holiness. In one way only the dreamless ego retains its subjective character, viz. it is conscious of the experience of restful joy due to the temporary cessation of all brain activity. The light of consciousness is turned back upon itself, and in its own light it sees the surrounding gloom of nothingness.
It may seem to you that this third, or dreamless state, is the last state of the ego; but that is not the case. Beyond this there is another state, known to the Rishis by the name of Turiya, which is called the fourth or last state of the soul. There are no words to express the idea of the Turiya state. It may be called the transcendental state of the soul because it transcends, or goes beyond the three states of wakefulness, dream, and dreamlessness. It is, in fact, not a state but the very ground, essence, and substance of consciousness, upon which, as I pointed out at the beginning of my lecture this evening, rests the Advaita philosophy of Sankara. It is exceedingly difficult to draw a line of demarcation between the third and fourth state of sound sleep. The Turiya is the point where consciousness becomes identical with existence and the circle of thought coincides with the circle of reality; hence it would be impossible to describe it by any symbol, quality, or attribute. The soul sees itself, and its individuality ceases, it becomes universal, one with God. Not personal God, determined by the conditions of an evolutionary world system, but the impersonal, absolute God, called in Vedānta, Brahman.
Imagine for a moment the absolute non-existence of this vast world of sight and sound. What remains after the starry universe is destroyed? A vast space. Then imagine this space to be devoid of ether and of the subtile seeds of creation. Perfect stillness reigns supreme over the ocean of universal space, beginningless and endless. What supports it? It is self-supported, self-dependent, lifeless, motionless, soundless, colourless. From this analogy you can conceive the state of the soul in Turiya. The soul in Turiya does not see, yet is not blind; does not hear, yet is not deaf; does not reason, yet is not irrational; does not exist, yet is not non-existent; it goes beyond the bounds of space, time, idea, feeling, thought, and reality. The Rishi describes it in his mystical language as “neither inwardly conscious nor outwardly conscious, neither conscious both inwardly and outwardly, nor is it massive consciousness, neither conscious nor unconscious, what none can see, nor apprehend, nor understand, without mark, unthinkable, past definition, nought but self-conscious alone that ends all evolution, peaceful, good and non-dual. This is the Self, this must be known.”1
Every time that we enjoy deep sleep we touch the sphere of our eternal glory. The rhythm of nature throws us on to the timeless shores of immortality. The soul plays with herself, free and joyous, on the fields of her own glory, and there the music of the spheres is hushed into the beauty of silence. Leaving her harp, the muse enters into the lotus-chamber of the heart of contemplation.
This Turiya, or the absolute Self, of which we half unconsciously obtain a glimpse in deep sleep, driven thence by the necessity of the body’s mechanism, must be realised in Yoga, or religious meditation and ecstasy. I say “unconsciously,” because we rise out of profound sleep without knowing that we were blessed with the beatific vision of the Self-Divine. Sleep is an avenue of unconscious self-knowledge; Yoga is the avenue of intensely conscious self-knowledge. It is for this reason that I said the promise of Advaita lies embedded in the psychology of deep sleep and its fulfilment in the experience of Samādhi. As Turiya is the fourth state of the soul, so Samādhi is the fourth stage of Sādhana, or religious aspiration and effort. The first stage of religious life is dispassion (Vairāgya), or the conscious effort of the soul to shake off the influence of matter and the acquired disposition to delight in the pleasures of the body. The second stage is discrimination (Viveka), or the intellectual realisation that the Self-Divine is the only Reality and the only Truth, all else mere nothing. The third stage is called Absorption (Dhyāna), or the continuous dwelling of the mind on the glory and substance of the Self-Divine. The fourth and last stage of religious life is Samādhi, or the realisation of oneness with the Divine in pure consciousness and perfect freedom. The four states of our psychic life, viz. (1) waking, in which we are conscious of the outward universe; (2) dreaming, in which we are conscious of the inward universe; (3) dreamlessness, in which we are unconscious of the inward and outward universe; and (4) Turiya, in which we are self-conscious in the absolute sense, — these four states correspond to the four stages of the Yoga life of the religious aspirant, viz. (1) conquest of the objective world of sense and emotion, (2) conquest of the subjective world of intellect and reason, (3) conquest of the subtile world in which the first two lie in seed form, and (4) freedom in the identity of Self with God.
In our analysis of the states of waking, dream, and dreamlessness, we discovered that the self does not know itself although it knows the other. By “other” I mean the object or presentation in consciousness. In waking, the self knows the physical; in dreaming, the mental world; and in dreamlessness, the absence of the presentation itself. In all the three states it stands watching, witnessing the play of fancies, desires, and images in the mind. This watchful, witnessing self is called Samvit. Whether we are ill or well, at work or play, asleep or awake, this “inner witness” never loses sight of our thoughts and actions. This Samvit is quite wide awake when the physical brain is stunned, or during what is popularly known as unconsciousness, trance, or fainting. From the moment of birth to the moment of death, through the rough and smooth experiences of life, Samvit remains the same — self-luminous, self-active, self-regulating. Hence it is reasonable to assume that it is independent of brain and body, and therefore independent of what we call life and death. The Samvit is like the flame of a candle, burning and illumining perpetually, its brightness undiminished by that which envelops it. Try however hard you may, you cannot put out the light of your own consciousness. If you extinguish it in one sphere, that same moment it is sure to shine in another sphere, like the sun which sets in the western, to rise again in the eastern sky, undiminished in glory and effulgence. The scenes in the theatre change, the actors come and go, but the illuminating lamp burns all the while.
One of the most remarkable characteristics of the first three psychical states is the unknowability of the real “I.” In waking we become acquainted with the stream of consciousness — not with the bed or the basin of the stream. This stream of consciousness consists of a surface-current and an under-current; the former is the sensation-continuum of auditory, visual, tactual, olfactory, and gustatory sensations, while the latter is the ideal continuum of motives, feelings, and thoughts. The sensation-continuum, when projected into the vacuum of space, produces pictures of the fixed and stable world, and when projected into time, produces the world of movement. The mind creates this dual world by projecting this sensation-continuum on to the screen of time and space. The ideal-continuum is also a superimposition of the ego of interests and feelings relating to the preservation of our bodily life. In a way we seem to be aware of these two, the sensation-continuum and the ideal-continuum, the surface-current and the under-current of the stream of consciousness. But we know nothing of the self on which and within which our thoughts move and the space in which the physical world hangs. To use a familiar illustration: when you witness a play in a cinema theatre, you cannot see the machine or the man (while you sit among the audience), neither can you see the background upon which the images of men and women, railways and steamships, are moving. Similarly, in waking and in dreaming we are ignorant of the soul, i.e. the subjective substratum, on which the mind rests. What happens in the dreamless state? Just what happens in the cinema theatre when the machine stops and the lights in the auditorium are extinguished. You are surrounded on all sides by darkness and feel that you only are there, by yourself, alone. The ignorance of the waking and dreaming states takes a massive form and prevents the soul from knowing anything outside the knowledge of its own identity.
This brings us to the consideration of the doctrine of error (Avidyā). Knowledge and error are as inevitably combined as light and darkness. If you ask me, What is error? I will reply by asking a counter question, What is darkness? It is only possible to define darkness by negatives. Similarly error can only be defined by saying that it is the want of knowledge. In fact, the word knowledge has only a relative sense, for it implies error; for this reason the Vedānta says that Avidyā is perpetual. This doctrine of error, or nescience, is the keynote to Vedānta epistemology. I will try to explain it as clearly as I can. When you say, “I know,” you imply at the same time that “I do not know.” This sounds paradoxical, but it is true. For instance, when you say, “This is the sky,” you mean that the blue vault overhead is called sky and that it looks blue. This is all you know; but you do not know of what the thing called “sky” is composed, nor how old it is; you do not know its length and breadth, nor who made it, nor do you know the many other qualities which it may possess. Similarly with all the things of this earth; there are always certain attributes, or aspects, which remain unknown to our intellects. This our body, so near to us — do we profess to understand its nature, its working, and the laws which govern its origin, growth, and decay? The wisest among our scientists is ignorant of the mystery of life. We know a little, but there is a great deal which we do not know. Avidyā is not the negation of knowledge, it is the negative element present in knowledge. For instance, we sometimes say we are certain that we do not know such and such a thing; just as in mathematics one presupposes “zero,” so in Vedānta, Vidyā (knowledge) presupposes Avidyā (error). The function of Avidyā is to offer a perpetual opposition to Vidyā, but such is the beautiful economy of our inner nature that Vidyā is continually overcoming Avidyā, and the reign of knowledge is ever expanding.
If we inquire into the origin of error we shall not arrive at any answer. Whence this error that accompanies us all our lives? Why this error at all? Will it ever end? We cannot deny that our intellects are at every step shadowed by the fear of error; our forgetfulness, our tendency to exaggerate, our liability to deception, all these come under the term Avidyā. In theology, Avidyā appears as “sin,” or “original sin.” In ethics, Avidyā goes under the name of “evil” or “immorality.” In æsthetics, Avidyā is called “ugliness” or “the unbeautiful”; in logic, Avidyā is fallacy; in metaphysics, Avidyā is called phenomenon; in practical life, Avidyā touches us in the guise of pain, disappointment, sorrow, and misery. When a friend misunderstands your language, it is because his mind is clouded by Avidyā, or because Avidyā prevents you from using the right words.
Our very notions of “life” and “death,” of “right” and “wrong,” of “pleasant” and “unpleasant” are the products of Avidyā. There is no absolute standard in the world of Avidyā; one Avidyā makes man think that he is the lord of creation, but wait and see how another Avidyā appears in the form of an infinitesimally small insect, a microbe of typhus, which humiliates him to death. Great nations of warriors who conquered the world have been blotted out of existence by insects and microbes. What is all this but the magic of Avidyā? Who can understand the growth of man from the protoplasm? Waking is no less Avidyā than dreaming. Man becomes a philosopher only when he understands his inability to understand.
Is Avidyā real or unreal? In other words, is an illusion real or unreal? This question may be illustrated by an example. We all say, “The sky is blue,” but we know it is an optical illusion; the sky has no colour. Again we say, “The sky meets the earth at the horizon.” This also is an illusion; the sky appears like an arch but is not so. These two attributes of the sky, viz. blueness and curve, are not real and do not exist at all, and yet we seem to think that they are real. If we abstract or take away these two seeming attributes from the sky, what remains? Nothing but the vast space signified by the name “sky.” This example shows the true function of Avidyā, viz. it makes the unreal appear as real, the non-existent appear as existent; blueness and curve do not exist in the sky, but Avidyā conjures them up and holds them before our vision. At the same time there can be no illusion without a real substratum; the substratum of sky is necessary in order to produce the illusion of blue colour and curve; if there were no sky, there could not have been the appearance of blueness and curve. Just try to think of these two attributes as existing without a sky to support them; you cannot think in that way. Take another example. When ski-ing on the snow-clad hills of Norway, I have often seen a figure on the distant hill-top. My first impression suggested that it was a bear, but as I proceeded it seemed to resemble a man; when I began ascending, I discovered that it was only a tree. First the idea of a bear frightened me; next the idea of meeting a fellow-traveller consoled me; and lastly, when I discovered that it was a tree, I laughed at myself. These illusions illustrate the nature of the working of Avidyā; it makes the unreal appear as real and superimposes illusory images upon a real thing. In the first example the blue colour rested upon the sky, and in the second example the illusory image of a man rested upon the tree. Many other examples of illusory perception may be cited, but this general rule will hold good in each case.
The same Avidyā is at work within our minds, but it is not so evident as in the case of sense perception. But when we practise introspection, we soon find that Avidyā is lurking in our minds also. For instance, our belief in our own ego is a belief in point. We all believe that each one of us possesses a separate ego, each one imagines that he is engaged in some work, that he is enjoying or suffering. If I am asked where I see the working of Avidyā here, I reply that it is Avidyā which makes each one feel as though he or she were an enjoyer of pleasures, a doer of deeds, or a sufferer of pain. It is Avidyā that makes us feel awake, or asleep, or dreaming. These illusory states are superimposed upon the universal, unchangeable, eternal “I” which is the real “Self,” of which we have a glimpse in Turiya. Illusion does not last long; it vanishes from the mind as soon as discovered, although it may continue to have an objective existence for others. One of the great tests of illusion is that it changes: those who have studied physical science see the blueness of the sky just as those do to whom the illusion has not been pointed out, but for them it has no existential value. The proof that the real eternal “I” is quite distinct from the narrow individual “I” consists in the constant change to which the latter is liable. We know that sometimes we feel very happy and say to ourselves, “I am enjoying life!” Again, at other times, we feel miserable, and say to ourselves, “I am unhappy.” Or again, at other moments, a feeling of peace comes over us. Which of these is the real “I” The happy “I,” the unhappy “I,” or the peaceful “I” Then, again, sometimes we are awake and active, at other times we are asleep and passive. Which is the real “I,” the wakeful “I,” or the sleeping “I”? Sometimes we are clever, sometimes bright, and sometimes dull; which is the real “I,” the dull “I,” the bright “I,” or the clever “I” There is a clear line of demarcation between the changeless “I” which stands at the back, and the changing “TI” which acts, enjoys and suffers, wakes, sleeps and dreams. This changing “I” is the illusory offspring of Avidyā, and the changeless “I” is the eternal Self, the Ātman, the Brahman.
Just as on pure space the two attributes of colour and curve are superimposed by Avidyā, so on the pure consciousness of Brahman are superimposed the attributes of enjoyment and suffering, activity and passivity, thought and will, life and death, by Avidyā. And just as we discover from our physical science that real space is without colour and without form, so from our knowledge derived from the Guru and the Vedānta we discover that the real and true Self is birthless and deathless and changeless, neither enjoys nor suffers, but is One, identical with Itself, universal and eternal.
Avidyā makes us believe that we are many, in reality the Self is One — one vast, indivisible, limitless consciousness, appearing as separate centres of consciousness in each individual. The very idea that we are individuals is an illusion, for what is the essence of individuality? Consciousness. How can consciousness be bounded by space and time, body and mind? The proof of this is sought in our experience of the Turiya, when not a shadow of individuality lingers within the field of consciousness. The belief that you are embodied is only a habit of thought, fostered by ignorance; the real self which reveals itself in Turiya has no body, is neither old nor young, neither ill nor in health, neither poor nor rich, but is the self identical with the Self.
The whole of experience extending from the waking to the dreamless state is Avidyā’s field of operation. At this point it may perhaps be asked, Is the whole of life a mere illusion? To this question I shall not attempt to give a definite answer.
There was once a King who devoted himself to the study of the Vedānta, and being persuaded that this life had no real existence and was therefore valueless, he spent all his time in meditation and neglected his Queen and the affairs of state. One day, noticing her royal husband’s indifference, the Queen inquired whether anything had occurred to keep the King away from those whom he loved so dearly. To this the King replied that nothing had occurred except that all the world appeared to him a mere nothing, an illusion. “The kingdom is a phantom,” he said. Then the Queen asked:
“Is all that we see an illusion?”
“Yes,” he replied.
“Are our children also an illusion?” she asked.
“Yes.”
“Am I an illusion?”
“Yes.”
“Then is not the King himself an illusion?”
At this he hesitated before replying, and the Queen, perceiving his embarrassment, said, “Are there not some illusions which are useful? And if so, would it not be as well to act as though they were real for the time being?”
Then the King, recognising his mistake, was obliged to acknowledge that the Queen was right.
By this it will be seen that all is not illusion, for according to the Vedāntic theory, error implies truth, illusion implies reality. The unreal life, which is true for all time, floats mysteriously upon the real life, which is true for all eternity. For the time being this unreal life of action is to be taken for a fact — a sort of provisional hypothesis having a pragmatical value. But all the events of life are facts of illusion. Our social endeavours, our government, our wars, our peace, our morals, our literature and science, are facts within Avidyā. They are unreal — when we rise above them and behold our own reality. Just as in dream we see images and for the moment believe them to be real, but when we awake from sleep we realise that we have been dreaming; similarly, as long as we lead the life of ignorance we take all things to be real, but when we awake in Yoga Samādhi we realise that the things of sense are mere shadows, and the pains that we suffer, the crosses that we bear, appear as nothing when the soul enters into the Kingdom of God.
If it is asked, “Is the soul unreal? For if the three states of waking, dreaming, and dreamlessness are illusory productions, then why does it not follow that even the idea of a soul is erroneous?” I reply that if you think that the soul is somewhere located in the body, or that it is conditioned by time, space, and mental modifications, then it is an erroneous belief. The idea that souls are many, that they suffer or enjoy, that they are born and die, or that they possess bodies, is called in Sanscrit Jiva bhava. Avidyā is responsible for this Jiva bhava, or the notion of being an individual. Avidyā superimposes this Jiva bhava upon Brahman — the eternal consciousness of God. Avidyā has the power to make the eternal, imperishable Brahman look as though he were mortal, having a body and liable to the accidents of earthly life. Just as the sky, though in reality without shape and colour, appears to us as having a curved shape and a blue colour, so the universal Brahman appears to us, i.e. to our Avidyā-tainted minds, as Jiva. But as by studying science we learn that the sky is a vast, illimitable space, without shape or colour, so by studying the Vedas we learn that Brahman is the One Eternal Truth and Bliss of existence.
Our fundamental position is that existence is knowledge. Avidyā consists in thinking of non-existence as existence. Reality co-exists with eternity. All that we perceive exists in time and space. Whenever we think that a thing exists, we think it has been caused by something else; in other words, we cannot think of a thing as causeless. This kind of thinking is Avidyā-thinking, therefore our physical organism is the product of Avidyā-thought. The physical organism exists as long as our judgment is fettered by Avidyā. More than that: even when ignorance is dispelled by Vedāntic knowledge, the body of the Yogi continues to live, just as when we are told by our professors that the sky is without shape and colour we continue to see curved space and blue colour in the sky, for the momentum of Avidyā lasts for some time after disillusionment. We all know that the physical body is ephemeral and that it will die, yet we are still anxious to preserve it. But even after the death of the physical body there is no escape from Avidyā; as in sleep the ego dreams nonsensical dreams, so after death the ego goes on believing in its own individuality.
As the ego (Jiva) wanders helplessly from waking to dreamland, and from dreamland to the quiet valley of deep sleep, so the soul, overcome by Avidyā, wanders helplessly from existence to existence, from experience to experience. The memories of pain and pleasure, experienced in past lives, continue to unfold themselves in the actuality of embodied existence. Can we resist our inclination to work and our inclination to rest? No, we are quite helpless, we eat and sleep because we cannot do otherwise. Similarly we are born and we shall pass away, because we have no control over the creative and destructive powers of Karma. We are the creatures of our desires, the creatures of heredity, of the civilisation of our age and environment. In a word, we are the slaves of illusion.
This doctrine of Avidyā sounds very hopeless. It seems to rob us of our dignity, of our glory, of our wisdom, and of our independence; yet it cannot be denied that the doctrine exposes rather ruthlessly the faulty structure of our psychical being. Life is not as beautiful as it looks. Open a book on medicine and observe the number of diseases to which the body is liable, it will then seem a miracle that we are still alive. Read history and take note of the woful mistakes committed by men.
It is not my object to preach pessimism, but it cannot be denied that nature affords little encouragement for optimism. The business of philosophy is to interpret experience. Man wants Truth, and where are we to find supreme truth, that truth which alone can save us? The Vedānta says, “Look within.”
Human experience is a mixture of good and evil, light and shadow; beyond this lies the true Self, identical with God, which is the “non-imperceptible” (aparoksha) principle of consciousness. The reason why the true Self is called “non-imperceptible” is because it is neither perceived not yet unperceived; pure consciousness is the ground of perceiving the ego and the non-ego, both of which are the twin offspring of Avidyā. We have to reach the Self, the knowledge of which will free us from the experiences of waking, dream, and dreamlessness. Knowledge alone can save. Not knowledge in the philosophic or scientific sense, but the knowledge of our oneness with God which is Mukti, or Liberation.
If the knowledge of the true Self brings liberation from the net of cosmic error, it must be proved that such knowledge is possible. How can we know the Ātman (the Self-Divine) who is free from all subjective and objective attributes? For knowledge implies a division of the sphere of consciousness into subject, which knows, and object, which is known. If we know Brahman He will become an object for us. To this objection it may be replied that in all knowing processes there is a third factor which is neither the subject nor the object; this is called the Witness (Sākshi). This Sākshi is only an impersonal presence, unconcerned in the cognitive activity of the subject. What is called “subject” is the determinate, or maker, of object. We know that the subject is sometimes attentive and sometimes inattentive, sometimes interested and sometimes indifferent. Hence the subject may be said to be in an inalienable relation of attention and interest with the object. But such is not the case with what is called the Sākshi, or the Witness, which is not a faculty nor a mode of thought, but consciousness pure and simple. Moreover the Sākshi is distinguished from the subject by its non-individual character. The Sākshi is identical with itself, whereas the subject, even in the same person, always changes. Now the subject is a thinker of plans, at other times the doer of deeds; but the Sākshi is always the witness standing behind, existing by its own reality and shining by its own brilliance. In sorrow and joy, in work and play, the witness stands within. There is another point which it is necessary to emphasise. The Sākshi is universal because it is common to all. I cannot say that the Sākshi in me is different from the Sākshi in you. My subjective character is different from your subjective character, but the Sākshi is the same in all.
The reality of the Sākshi revealed in introspection supplies us with the keynote to liberation. It may be that we are not all sufficiently introspective to realise what is meant by Sākshi; but every one who has a desire to attain to the highest truth of life and eternity may realise it if he is willing to take the trouble (or “make the Tapasyā” or “Sādhana,” as we say in India) necessary to its realisation. The preparation necessary for initiation into cosmic consciousness involves the realisation of the nothingness of all that we see. The lights and shadows of existence are to be separated from pure existence itself; for the mind is constantly weaving the warp and woof of the cosmos. Each fancy that flits across the horizon of the mind is the seed of a future world. Desire, which rises like a perpetual spring from the unknown depths of the ego, nourishes this seed and helps to germinate it, and this seedling becomes the tree of life. Our bodies contain some immortal elements which scientists call cells, which are now acknowledged to possess a germinal consciousness. These cells have kept alive the species of all vegetable and animal organisms. In the same way, Avidyā keeps alive the seeds of desire in the store-room of the Kārana-sarira (the soul in its ultimate form). Hence issues the stream of transmigratory life, and hence proceed all our troubles and disappointments. We all want to know what we are, but the knowledge of our true being cannot come from outside, from philosophy, from religion, or from science. It is always with us, within our reach, within the reach of thought. Every act of perception contains within itself the eternity of Being. It is the essence of our enjoyment of art, music, and poetry. It is the root of our love for God and pity for man. It is the fact of the existence of God and humanity in one. It is consciousness, it is existence, it is joy. We have a faint experience of it in Turiya, and we have a vivid experience of it in Samādhi.
In order to attain to the consciousness of the Supreme Self, the disciple must approach a teacher versed in Brahma-Wisdom. To be a worthy disciple it is necessary to possess four qualifications, viz. (1) a discriminative intellect, (2) controlled will, (3) purified emotions, and (4) a longing for liberation. Without devotion to Brahman, progress is not possible.
I will endeavour to explain in what these four qualifications consist.
(1) The disciple should constantly meditate on Brahman as the only Truth to be attained, and all else as untruth.
(2) He is then to train his will. The will is to be directed, not towards the appropriation of what is agreeable to the senses and desires, but towards the realisation of the highest knowledge. He is to desire nought of earth or of heaven, but the very soul of Brahman. This means the renunciation of all work.
(3) Renunciation of work will conduce to the quieting of the emotions. Thus he will cease to desire name, fame, or worldly happiness; he will learn to uproot from his heart all passions; in a word, he will turn his eyes for ever from the phenomenal and psychical world. This will help him to practise forgiveness, equanimity, and same-sightedness.
(4) He will then be able to uproot the very idea of the ego; for the notion of this “I,” this narrow, mean self, is the greatest stumbling-block to the attainment of Divine Wisdom.
When the disciple becomes free from the pride of rank, birth, and ego, he learns to value the teachings of his Guru. Gradually his inner eye opens and he gets an insight into the secret of the eternal Consciousness, and then only he obtains a foretaste of liberation. That is so grand, so sublime, so wonderful an experience, that the disciple cannot help longing to be emancipated from the bondage of this Avidyā state. The consciousness of the Absolute is the crown and glory of religious consciousness; here we are to seek for peace, for beauty, and for truth. The dream of life ends and the soul awakes to its eternity, conscious of a surpassing restfulness, born of the very Being of Truth.
Bibliography
- Advaita Brahma Siddhi, by Sadānandayati.
- Svārājya Siddhi.
- Suresvar Āchārya’s Vritti.
- Nirvāna Shathak of Sankara.
- Vedāntasāra.
- Pratyabijnādarsana.
- Purusha Sukta (Rig Veda).
- Apyaya Dikshita’s Vedāntakalpataru Parimal.
- Vedānta Paribhāsa.
- Madhab Āchārya’s monograph on Sankara.
Notes
- Māndukya Upanishad, 7.
Source
Sri Ananda Acharya, Brahmadarsanam or Intuition of the Absolute: Being an Introduction to the Study of Hindu Philosophy. New York: The Macmillan Company, 1917. Lecture I, “General View-Points of Ancient Indian Philosophers,” and Lecture V, “Monism: The Absolute and the Cosmos.” Some passages have been omitted and the spelling of some Sanskrit terms has been standardised. This article is from public domain digital sources.
Disclaimer
We have made every effort to reproduce this text faithfully, but we cannot guarantee that it is free of errors. Readers who need accuracy for study or citation should check the original publication. The views and language are those of the author and his time, and e-Scriptures is not responsible for them.
Spelling and style follow the original; obvious scanning and typographical errors have been corrected. This text is believed to be in the public domain in the United States, where this website is operated. Copyright terms differ from country to country, so a text that is free of copyright in the United States may still be protected elsewhere. Readers outside the United States should check the copyright laws of their country before copying, downloading or reusing it; they are responsible for lawful use in their own country. See our Terms of Use.