Skip to content

An Introduction to the Study of Hinduism

by Guru Prosad Sen

Summary: Three chapters from an introduction to Hinduism published in 1893. The author argues that Hinduism is not a religious organization requiring assent to a creed, and that this explains both its tolerance and its capacity for change. He answers the question “What is Hinduism?” by pointing to what Hindus in a community actually do, and he examines the types of the Hindu family, how they developed, and the changes then taking place. As the source note says, much of the information has historical, sociological and cultural value but does not represent present-day Hinduism.

Hinduism Not a Religious Organization

The popular notion regarding Hinduism is that it is a religious organization, and essentially polytheistic in its character, that is, in other words, to be a Hindu and to remain a Hindu, a man must subscribe to certain articles of religious beliefs common to all Hindus, must acknowledge the authority of some books (Vedas and Shastras), and the supremacy of certain interpreters thereof. According to this popular notion, very generally accepted as correct, without examination of the grounds thereof, the Hindu is an idolater, and no one who does not worship the myriads of Hindu gods and goddesses, 33 crores in number, is not, and cannot be, a Hindu. To a superficial observer the Hindu rises from bed, eats and sleeps, nay, is born, marries and dies with religious rites, and it would almost be rank heresy to say that Hinduism is not a religious organization. Yet nothing can be more erroneous than the popular notion on the subject. Hinduism is not, and has never been a religious organization. It is a pure social system, insisting in those who are Hindus the observance of certain social forms, and not the profession of particular religious beliefs. It has not even a religious creed or a common set of beliefs, nor has it for its guide a particular book, though popularly the Vedas and Shastras are credited with being the books of the Hindus. So far as religious beliefs are concerned, Hinduism embraces within its fold all phases of belief and even of unbeliefs, from the extreme agnosticism of the Nasties and Charbaks, to the popular polytheistic creed of the believers of the myriads of Hindu gods and goddesses. The Hindu Shastras are, to use a Hindu metaphor, a vast ocean, which so far as religion is concerned, the votary, like the Hindu gods of old, has only to churn, to find the nectar of truth, which is exactly suited to the light that is in him. It is perfectly optional with a Hindu to choose from any one of the different religious creeds with which the Shastras abound; he may choose to have a faith and creed, if he wants a creed, or to do without one. He may be an atheist, a deist, a monotheist, or a polytheist, a believer in the Vedas or Shastras, or a sceptic as regards their authority, and his position as a Hindu cannot be questioned by anybody because of his beliefs or unbeliefs so long as he conforms to social rules. This had been the case with Hinduism in all ages, and has not been brought about by the so-called transition state we are now supposed to live in. Extreme shades of beliefs are, and have always been, met with in the Hindu community, nay, even in every Hindu family. Nothing is more common than to find the deism of the Vedantas, the Vaisnavism of Chaitanya, the Sikhism of Guru Nanuk, the phalic worship of the Shaivas in the same family. The father may be a Vaisnav, the mother a Shaiva or a Shakta, the father's brother a Sikh, and the son a deist. The persecutions of Pralddh of the legends, by his father Hirnakashyapa , for professing a faith differing from that of the father, makes the father even now the object of just execration of all the Hindus. They are all tolerant of each other's faith. The Hindu never quarrels with religious beliefs, and he never enquires into the religious belief of his neighbours. Believing as he does that Mukti salvation, is certain to the good and virtuous, whatever his creed, he leaves the highest spiritual concerns of a man to the man himself. The Vijmantra 1 forming the cardinal article of a man's faith, may not even be uttered to one's father and mother. It is a concern of the individual himself, and throughout his life remains a secret between himself and his religious teacher (Guru). It is not even necessary for a Hindu to have a Guru (a religious teacher) if he wishes to dispense with one (and outside Bengal the family Guru, as an institution, scarcely exists), and his religious beliefs or even unbeliefs are then matters which concern him alone. It is not necessary that the Hindu should attend a church or a religious congregation, and it is certainly optional with him to attend any church or religious congregation, — church service, in the sense in which it is generally understood amongst Christians or Mahomedans, does not exist amongst the Hindus. Wherever there is worship, the priest worships, but does not lead the worship; believers attend, but do not know or hear the Mantras that the priest addresses to the object of worship.

The fact that Hinduism is not a religious organization makes it the most tolerant system of all systems in the world, and makes it an essentially progressive system. Changes, transitions, it has always passed through, and evolved out of them something for its own. It takes in and assimilates, it hates to imitate, but it beautifully incorporates and makes new ideas its own by going onward with the impetus generated by these shocks. The earliest known shock of the kind was that imparted by the Buddhists. It was a revolution against the Hinduism of the day, and it brought in new ideas to the spiritual interests of mankind, and the prevailing social system in India. It made a progress which has not been achieved by any other new religious system in India, but it died out, not as is popularly believed, because of Brahminical persecutions, not because Buddhists were bodily expelled from India by force by a Shunker Acharjia , but because the Hindu philosophy had then incorporated with it all that it had to learn from the Buddhists, and because at that stage, so far as the social organization was concerned, the Indian Buddhists chose to get themselves re-admitted in the Hindu social system. The same has been the case with Jainism, Sikhism, Vaisnavism, and the Monotheism of Kabir. The Hindus have incorporated within their system such of the ideas as each of these new religious systems had to impart, and as suited themselves to the genius of the Hindu races and the surrounding circumstances of their position (these are important conditions), and finished off their antagonists by calling them Apna , their own. Take, for instance, the case of Jainism, the oldest of the last mentioned systems. It is essentially un-Hindu. As a religious system it discards the Vedas and Shastras and does not acknowledge the supremacy of the Brahmins. Even now, an orthodox Hindu considers it a sin to visit a temple of Pareshnath . The Brahmins at one time taught, when Jainism assumed an uncompromising attitude, "better to be trampled under foot by a mad elephant than to enter a Jain temple for protection," and the Brahmins of the Hindus still keep themselves aloof from all sorts of social intercourse with the Jain priests. The remnants of the Jains in India are of the Vaisya caste and, as in social matters, the Jains of the day have forgotten, or given up, their hostile and unyielding attitude of the past, and do not object to the Hindu rituals as regards marriage, the Vaisya Jains fully intermarry and otherwise intermix socially with the Vaisyas of Hindu persuasions. Take again the case of the Sikhs. They have been ever deemed by the Hindus as Hindus. Runjit Sinha is taken by all the Hindus to have been the last of the great Hindu princes, and it was currently reported that Dhullip Sinha would be welcome back to India as a Sikh and Hindu. The animus revertendi to Hinduism is all that is required of a man originally a Hindu, and for those who did not originally belong to the Hindu stock, all that is required is the observance of the current Hindu rites. We have not to go far in illustration of our position. Not to refer to the Maimon of the Bombay Presidency, whose position oscillates between Mahomedanism and Hinduism, and whose position it was proposed to determine by an Act of the Supreme Legislature, we may mention the various hill tribes who have joined Hinduism almost within the memory of man. We have said that for one who did not originally belong to the Hindu stock, all that is required is the observance of the current Hindu rites. We use the word current studiously. We will show hereafter how the rites themselves change with the changes of time. It is not, again, that the new convert as a rule is relegated to the lower stratum of Hindu society. Instances prevail in which, according to the exigencies of the case, the position that has been assigned to the convert has been very high. Witness, for instance, the position of the Gayalis, of Gya, originally Buddhistic priests, the Sakaldipi (Singalese)Brahmins, and the Vaisnava Gosains, some of whom in Bengal belong to the Vidya (medical) caste. Its power of assimilation, physical and moral, gives Hinduism a lease of life which has been the wonder of the world in the past, and which will be its wonder for all time to come, unless it correctly understands the Hindu system. That system is essentially an eclectic system, so far as religious beliefs are concerned, and, as we intend to show in a subsequent part of this discussion, in all social matters also. The instances cited above illustrate, we hope, in a marked degree, the position with which we set out, that Hinduism is not a religious organization. The Jains, Sikhs, Vaisnavas, Kaberpanthis, are, to all intents and purposes, Hindus, though the religious creed of each and all, specially that of the Jains and Sikhs, are essentially un-Vedic in origin, and the professors of these religions, though recognised by the other Hindus, as Hindus, do not believe in the authority of the Vedas and Shastras, do not worship the Hindu gods and goddesses, nor acknowledge the supremacy of the Brahmins. If, then, Hinduism is not a religious organization, and the Hindu has the option of choosing for his faith anything from the extreme point of unbelief to belief in a myriad of gods and goddesses, discarding Vedas, Shastras and Brahminical supremacy, what then is it? We will answer the question in the next part of the article.

Notes

  1. The word or words whispered by the Guru to the noviciate at the time of initiation.

Contents

What Is Hinduism?

What is Hinduism? The reply is, that what the Hindus or the major portion of them in a Hindu community do is Hinduism. This may appear to be a truism, it is a truism however, the truth of which ought to be enforced. People, both within and without, discuss the subject as if Hinduism was locked up in some sacred books. The Vedas, the Shastras, the Smrities are regarded as books furnishing guides for the conduct of a Hindu's life, and researches are made in the Vedas and Shastras to understand what Hinduism is. Yet it is a fact, and a fact which cannot be gainsaid, that the Hinduism of the Vedas, nay, of the Shastras, is not the Hinduism of the present day. To even the most superficial reader of the Vedas and Shastras it will appear that changes in almost all the departments of the Hindu's life have been going on from age to age. It is not the scope of this paper to enumerate all these changes, but simply, for the illustration of the definition of Hinduism given above, to indicate that such changes have taken place and even now are taking place. What the Hindus in a Hindu community did, when recorded, became the Vedas of old; what they did at a later age became, when recorded, the Hinduism of the Shastras, and the Shastras that will record the changes of the present day, when those changes we see around us are accepted as accomplished facts, will be the Hinduism of the day. The Shastrakar (complier of the Shastras) of our future, will perhaps, when justifying the departure from the Shastras of the mediaeval ages, and from practices then only existing in the memory of man, appeal to some text of the Veda or of Manu, as a sanction for such departure, perhaps twist the grammatical construction, and interpret a synonym in the light of his own views. Like JimutVahana , of old and revered memory, he will possibly disclaim all opposing views as monstrous and un-Hindu. In this, as we suppose in all social systems, practice precedes theories and codes, and practice is accepted as an accomplished fact when it is carried on by the majority, and very shortly after as part and parcel of the system when it becomes the universal practice. We shall illustrate this by giving a few instances within our own memory. Thirty years ago a Hindu of Bengal (perhaps, of Calcutta excepted) would not be a Hindu, if he were to use onions as a condiment to his dishes, or to take a loaf, or a piece of biscuit; now onions, loaves, and biscuits are no longer prohibited articles of food in many parts of Bengal. Butchered meat is another instance of departure. No one now regards the practice of taking butchered meat as un-Hindu, though many people in Bengal yet scruple to use meat from a butcher's stall. The use of butcher's meat has never been considered un-Hindu in Behar and the other Provinces. Fowls and chickens may yet be regarded as prohibited articles of food in Bengal, but the strong minority who now enjoy dishes of fowl cutlets, soups, roasts, and curries are gaining ground, and will soon become the strong majority, and fowls and chickens will ten years hence, if not in five, come to be Hindu articles of food in Bengal. The Bengali Shastrakar will not have much difficulty in justifying the departure here, as fowls and chickens are not prohibited articles of food in that country of the Hindus, the Maharastra. The caste system even now overlooks taking food cooked by people of an inferior caste, or with them, or even with Mlechas, or Mahommedans. So you can do several things now admittedly un-Hindu without let or hindrance, so long as you do not obtrude your un-Hindu practices ostentatiously to the notice of the community you live in. Changes are thus daily growing, and when the changes suit the genius of the people, they take root and become parts and parcels of Hinduism. This is not simply in matters of articles of food, but in everything around us. Only the stereotyped character, which for good or evil, the Smrities, or that portion of it which is known as the Hindu law in our Courts, has received, by the advent of British government in this country, is calculated to maintain it where it was. The changes in the Smrities themselves, a complete record of which can be easily marked in the controversial portion of the learned codes of Hindu laws, serve to illustrate the position taken above to a very great extent. Take for instance the change, the reform under which the Brahmins came to be subjected to the jurisdiction of the King's Courts, or the Ilbert Reform in the laws of Ancient India. The text of Goutoma provided that "the king is superior to all except Brahmins." The Mitakshara says, that "from the text of Goutoma it must not be inferred that Brahmins are exempted from amercement, for the text is intended for the purpose of generally extolling the Brahminical tribe." It is ordained in the Sutras, ' six things are to be avoided by the King "(acting with respect to Brahmins), "the punishment of flagellation, of imprisonment, of amercement, of banishment, of reprimand, and of expulsion." The author of Mitakshara naively says: "The mere order of priesthood is not sufficient to exempt. That the Brahmins in the text mean persons eminently learned, skilled in worldly affairs, in the Vedas and Vedangas, intuitively wise, well stored with tradition and historical wisdom, continually revolving these subjects in their mind, conforming to them in practice, instructed in the forty-eight ceremonies, devoted to the observance of three-fold and six-fold duties, and versed in legal usages and established rules," or, in other words, such persons from whom the commission of an offence or wrong, or the infraction of a right was impossible. Thus, between the age of Goutoma and that of Vijaneshwara, a great change, affecting the privileges of a special class, must have been slowly and gradually effected, and the Hinduism which Goutoma observed and recorded as rules for the guidance of Hindu kings, as regards Brahminical privileges, was not the Hinduism which Vijaneshwara found extant in his days and justified in his learned disquisition.

Another reform in the Hindu law effected during that period, traces of which are clearly discernible in the disquisition of Vijaneshwara, was almost in the same direction — the encroachment on Brahminical privileges as it existed of old. The ancient doctrine was that the Sabhdsadas (assessors or jurors) of the King's Court were to be Brahmins. The text was — "a king who investigates, together with the chief judge, ministers, domestic priests and assessors at the Court, according to laws, shall attain paradise." Another text enjoined that the persons appointed as assessors or Jurors (Sabhdsadas), "were to be versed in literature, (i.e.,) in the study of philosophy, grammar, &c., and in comprehending the Vedas, acquainted with the laws, (i. e.,) familiar with the sacred code of laws, addicted to truth, i. e., prone to habitual veracity, impartial towards friends and foes, that is divested of enmity, affection, partiality and prejudice." The earlier commentator, Catyana, reads the text "persons versed in literature, &c," as setting forth the qualification of persons to be confined to the Brahminical tribe; but the author of Mitakshara, commenting on the first of these texts remarks, that the use of the conjunction, 'and,' between the words 'priests' and 'assessors,' evidently propounds a distinction between Brahmins, (priests) and assessors. The author, as an additional argument for the interpretation he adopts, says, that, "for the sake of adding popular confidence to the assembly (King's Council) some persons of the commercial class should also be called in to assist." But the most important change in this direction was with reference to the appointment of Chief Judge (Pradvivak). The text expressly enjoined the appointment of a Brahmin. It says, "A Brahmin acquainted with all duties should be appointed and associated with the assessors, by a king who is unable, through want of leisure, to investigate judicial proceedings;" the author of Mitakshara observes that, "if such a Brahmin cannot be found, the king may appoint a Kshatrya , or Vaisya ." It is singular how a turn in the grammatical construction of a text, which, however, was deemed sacred and unalterable, did duty for a change in law, but no grammarian ever thought of giving this turn, until he saw that the changed interpretation was necessitated by the changes which he saw all around. Between the age of Catyana and the age of Vijaneshwara, the author of Mitakshara, said to have been the contemporary of Sankara Acharjia, who is generally credited with the expulsion of Buddhists from India, several centuries had elapsed, and India had witnessed a stupendous revolution, and the Hinduism of the day of Catyana, not in this respect alone, for which we have proofs, but in several other respects, for which the proofs and records are not so clear, was not the Hinduism of the date of Mitakshara. We will see how the changes were brought about. There were no Legislative Councils in Ancient India, and no one in authority who could make or unmake laws. The current theory that Brahmins were lawgivers of the land, does not find any support from the record of the Hindu laws. Even the authors of the codes appeal to the past, and the text writers of the past, for the sanction of what they do enjoin. Their only authority is derived from the correctness with which they interpret the present in the light of the past. Anything that would not accord with the existing facts would, we suppose, carry as much weight with Hindus of their days as the Nava Sanhita of the late Babu Keshub Chandra Sen does with the Hindus of the present day. The growth of Hindu laws was something like the growth of the Common Laws in England, with this difference, that the Hindu laws did comprise a greater variety of subjects affecting the ordinary daily life of a Hindu than the Common Laws of England did with respect to Englishmen. Both have their origin in the growth of usages, their recognition in courts of law, or, as in the case of Hindus, in the assemblies of tribes, and their final codification by learned men; but, as in India, the codifiers (at least the authors of extant treatises) happened to be Brahmins, it is generally assumed that Brahmins were the legislators of the land. Hindu laws, therefore, are Hindu usages codified. Usages again originated in the doings of the Hindus, and when a new usage sprung up to take the place of the old, we may be sure that at the start some one had the boldness to break through the barrier of an established usage, and was branded as the breaker of the laws until the change he adopted, or sought to introduce, was generally accepted, and it took the place of the established usage. Take, for instance, again, the changes that took place between the age of Vijaneshwara and the age of Jimut Vahana. In Bengal, the joint family system had received a rude shock; and it was no longer the patriarchal system of old that prevailed, but the first splitting of families into individual units. Jimut Vahana in his time finds the change accomplished, and establishes the changes as laws, by refuting Mitakshara, and appealing to the past and the text writers of the past; and as an additional argument, establishes the doctrine of factum valet. This doctrine of factum valet prevails throughout India; if not in what are ordinarily called the schools of law, but in every other department of a Hindu's life. The flexibility of this beautiful doctrine enables the Hindu to alter his manners, his customs, his laws, nay, even his religion, to the altered spirit of the age in which he lives. Their surroundings, their education, their circumstances, the infusion of new ideas have always influenced the doings of the Hindus, and the Hinduism of every period. The Bengal Brahmins, even of the age of Ballal Sen, appear to have been as unlike their original stock at Kanouj, as Mr. Bannerji returned from England is from the ordinary Bengali Brahmins of the present date, yet the Kanouj Brahmins never question the Brahminical rank of their caste-men in Bengal: both are Hindus, but the Hinduism of the Kanouj Brahmins is not the Hinduism of the Brahmins of Bengal; and this brings us to our definition of Hinduism once again.

This definition, which we have tried to show accords with established facts in Hindu laws, is that what the Hindus, or the major portion of them in a Hindu community do, is Hinduism. A few words of explanation seem necessary. It is not Hinduism now to go to England, because the few Hindus who go to England are kept out of caste; but supposing in a Hindu community, the Hindus could go to England without losing caste, or supposing even that a strong majority of that community would allow a Hindu who had been to England to be again admitted into caste, going to England would be no longer an un-Hindu practice, so far as that community is concerned. A Hindu, whatever may be the transgressions from Hindu manners he may be guilty of, remains a Hindu so long as he does not lose caste. If he has a dal (party) in the community he lives in, he is a Hindu to all intents and purposes. This community is not the whole body of Hindus, nor all the people of his caste, but a small village circle of people consisting, amongst the higher classes, of Brahmins Vaidyas and Kayesthas in Bengal. This small circle, which usually consists of 300 or 400 families interspersed in two or three neighbouring villages, is called a Somaj, and the people Somajiks. In marriages and shraddhs, for those who can afford it, these are the guests who have to be entertained. If in case of any transgressions from caste rules, the Somajiks do not find any fault with the transgressor, the latter does not lose caste; if some of the Somajiks have their scruples, but others have not, they divide themselves into parties called dals or dal-dalis. Nothing is commoner than to find in many villages in Bengal, the Somajiks split into different factions (dals) over a transgression from an established usage of which some one in the Somaj had been guilty, until the question is finally decided by numbers. If the dal of the breaker of the established usage is strong, the change is as good as accomplished, the contending factions uniting again in time. There are in the same Somaj, or in the same body of Somajiks, nay, even in the same families, men of different views — Conservatives, Liberals and Radicals. The two latter at the present day are the product of English education and the onward influences around. Toleration is the order of the day, and the Conservatives, however they may lament the good old days, cannot help being tolerant, because of the prevalence of liberal ideas, even amongst the younger generation of their own families, or because, as in many cases, when education has made progress, and placed the Liberals in any number in commanding positions, they have to give way to the inevitable.

Much shrewdness, intelligence and tact are required of a leader of a dal and as reformations, to permeate the masses, must begin here, in these units of Hindu communities, a practical reformer can safely carry out many desired reforms by correctly feeling the pulse of his Somajiks. The wise politicians feel the pulse of the nation, the social reformer in Bengal, if he is practical, should feel the pulse of the Somajiks. Many reformers in India have spoiled the cause they advocated, by striving to carry out reforms for which the Somajiks were not prepared; by, in fact, giving too much speed to their Radical coach. Many a reformer — and in India reformers are not reformers, if they are not religious reformers, — has unfortunately marred the cause of reform by treating social reforms as if they were religious reforms. The popular notion is that Hinduism is a complex system, where social usages cannot be separated from religious beliefs. Our reformers cannot rise above this popular notion. They would not separate the domain of beliefs in the supernatural and metaphysical from the every-day common life of man. To them social reforms are not questions of expediency, but cases of conscience. It would be a sin, they say, if knowing early marriages to be mischievous, or, as they call it, wrong, you were to get your children married at an early age. It would be rank hypocrisy, they say, if believing in the equality of men, and knowing that the caste system as it prevails, is not the right thing in all its phases, you were still to be within the pale of caste and not to give it a kick. It would be the height of dissimulation, they say, if not believing or caring for the 33 crores of Hindu gods and goddesses, you were still to pass off as a Hindu. Your life would be a life of contradictions, they say, if while dining on fowl cutlets and mutton chops of an evening, you should sit to supper with your caste-men at Pungti Bhojan at night. The Liberal Indian pleads ' guilty ' to no such charge. In social matters, he believes that what is expedient is right. It would not be right or expedient in his opinion to wage a hopeless war. It would not be expedient to thrust reforms all at once into the old Hindu systems. The wholesale reform of the Brahmo Somaj is too much for the Hindus, and the result has been that the Brahmos have to form themselves into a separate community. If these earnest workers had but contented themselves to work from within, instead of spending their earnestness in uselessly trying to demolish the citadel of prejudices from without, what further changes might not have come on by this time.

The true Liberal Indian on the contrary would, for good or evil, stick to the Hindu system and fight out the cause of reform from within. He knows, or tries to know, how far education has prepared his Somajiks for a desired reform; how far the onward influences have been acting on them, and tentatively introduces, or tries to introduce it in the community in which he lives. There is a struggle nevertheless, but it is the fight of parties, the dald-dah' ) of the Somajiks, and not a fight where the reformer has to go out of the field, fearless and undaunted, no doubt, but nevertheless without achieving a victory. To the cautious general the victory is certain. The educated natives are now, in many parts of the country, the leaders of the Somajiks, and the spread of education gives them a larger and larger share of influence year by year. They are not true to their colors if, knowing or believing that the country is prepared for a reform, they do not give an onward pull. They have no need for preaching and for preachers. Their only agency is the educational movement in the country. The reforms thus introduced are introduced with the concensus of the people. They take root and permeate the social fabric as a whole, and very soon become part and parcel of the Hinduism of the time. In the next paper we will examine what reforms have been already introduced, and what further progress in these directions is possible.

Contents

The Hindu Family

The subject will be treated under the following heads: —

  • I. — A sketch of the development of the Hindu family types— showing that it is not true that the evolution of the types through the intermediate stages has always taken place in the same way, or that the complex types always preceded the simple or individual types.
  • II. — The causes of the growth of the complex types out of the original simple, or individual type. Its effect in rendering Indian civilisation essentially altruistic.
  • III. — The three kinds of types as they actually exist. The word 'joint family,' used to denote the second and the third types, foreign to the Hindu laws.
  • IV. — A comparison of the three kinds of type, showing wherein each is wanting and how they supplement one another, with the conclusion that, unless the Hindus were to substitute a civilisation of a different type, for their own, the three must subsist side by side, one sometimes passing into another, the ultimate aim of all the three being the same.
  • V. — What changes have taken place, and what further changes are needed to perfect the types, and even to make the second and third types live.

I.

It is patent, even on a cursory observation, that certain changes are taking place, at the present day, in the family organisations of the Hindus. The nature of these changes, their causes and effects, and the question of what is required to preserve the structure, will be treated further on; in the meantime we shall begin by trying to show, so far as the imperfect glimpses of Hindu Society which we obtain from ancient records will help us to do so, that such changes have been in progress from the earliest times. This we do, not by way of apology for the present changes, but in order to establish a fact which negatives a position that has hitherto passed almost unchallenged, viz., that the evolution of family types through the intermediate stages has always taken place in the same way, and that the complex types have always preceded the simpler, or individual, types. There is yet another object which we have in view — namely, to show that the second and third types were added owing to the exigencies of our social fabric, and that, unless the Hindu social fabric were to be entirely disintegrated, it would be impossible to revert wholly to the individual type.

The earliest Vedic type of family was the simple, or individual, type, consisting only of the man, his wife and children. It would appear that the sons formed separate households after they had married. The following translation of a hymn in the RigVeda, on the ceremony of marriage, shows that this was the case: —

"May Pushan lead you by the hand from this place. May the two Asvins lead you in a chariot. Go to your (husband's) house, and be the mistress of the house. Be the mistress of all and exercise your authority over all in that house.

"Let children be born unto you, and blessings attend you there. Perform the duties of your household with care. Unite your person with the person of this your husband; exercise your authority in this your house until old age."

"(The bride and bridegroom say): — ' May Prajapati bestow on us children; may Aryaman keep us united till old age.' (Address to the bride) O bride! enter with auspicious signs the house of your husband. Do good to our male servants, and our female servants, and to our cattle,

"' Be your eyes free from anger: minister to the happiness of your husband; do good to our cattle. May your mind be cheerful; and may your beauty be bright. Be the mother of heroic sons, and be devoted to the gods. Do good to our male servants, and our female servants, and to our cattle,' "

In the above passage, the wife is described as transferred from her father's to her own house, to be mistress thereof. Then she is to be the mistress of all and to exercise her authority over all. She is to minister to the happiness of her husband and to be the mother of heroic sons. She is to be devoted to the gods — and to be good to all the domestics, male and female, and to the cattle.

It is true that, later on in the same verse, we come across the following passage (address to the bride): — "May you have influence over your father-in-law, and over your mother-in-law, and be as a queen over your sister-in-law and brother-in-law," but it is preceded by another passage which clearly indicates that these do not form part of the family. The passage runs thus: "O Indra! make this woman (the bride) fortunate, and the mother of worthy sons. Let ten sons be born of her, so that there may be eleven men (in the family), with the husband."

Other passages indicate the same simple family group. The sacred fire was lighted in the house of every householder. The wife prepared the necessary things for sacrifices with pestle and mortar, extracted the soma-juice, and strained it through a woolen strainer and joined the husband in the performance of a sacrifice. We find in one of the hymns, "O ye gods! the married couple who prepare oblations together, who purify the soma-juice and mix it with milk.

"May they obtain food for their eating, and come united to the sacrifice. May they never have to go in quest of food.

"They do not make vain promises of offerings to the gods, nor withhold your praise. They worship you with their best offerings.

"Blest with youthful and adolescent offspring, they acquire gold, and they both attain to a mature age.

"The gods themselves court the worship of such a couple as are fond of sacrifices, and offer grateful food to the gods."

The picture here is of a couple not surrounded by other couples or groups of relations.

The simple rules of inheritance, which we gather from the following verses of the Rig-Veda, point to the same fact, and to the fact that the complex types had not up to that time come into existence.

"The father who has no son honours his son-in-law capable of begetting sons, and goes (i. e., leaves his property) to the son of his daughter. The (sonless) father trusts in his daughter's offspring and lives content.

"A son does not give any of his father's property to a sister. He gives her away to be the wife of a husband. If a father and mother beget both son and daughter, then one (i. e., the son) engages himself in the act and duties of his father, while the other (daughter) receives honour."

Thus, on the death of a man, whatever he left, went to the sons, the daughters being, until they were disposed of in marriage, maintained by the brothers. Failing sons, the property went to the daughter's son, Apparently what is now called a "joint family," had then no existence. There is, of course, no survivorship, nor any rule laid down for the heirship of the brother, or other kinsmen. The property is that of an individual, and not of a corporate body. It descends, under an invariable rule, to the daughter's son; and, so long as he is not born, it is in the hands, not of the daughter, but of the son-in-law, in trust for the daughter's son. There was, of course, not much to give, and these simple rules sufficed. It was not possible that, under the surrounding circumstances of their position, any other type should be in existence, or should then grow up among the Aryans. The struggle for existence had impelled them to come out of their native mountain homes, to a foreign country, where they had to fight for every inch of land with the aborigines. Each man lived for himself, and there was no room for benevolence, or the exercise of altruism. It was the religion of enmity, and not amity, that ruled men in their daily struggles with the non-Aryans, Dasyas (enemies); and not much co-operation, save that of soldiers, fighting side by side with soldiers, either compulsorily or otherwise, was anyhow absolutely necessary. The simple type does not easily change, and we find that it continued long amongst the Aryan Hindus. The sacrificial ceremonies of a post-Vedic period show what type prevailed centuries after the first arrival of the Aryans in India.

Every separate household is indicated by a separate altar; and it was the duty of every householder to have such an altar, with the sacrificial fire on it, as soon as he married, after his period of studentship was over. The ceremony was called the Agni Adhana or the bringing in of the sacred fire. One of the priests chosen for the occasion procured the fire, and set it on the Garhapatya fireplace. Towards sunset, the gods and manes having been invoked, the sacrificer and his wife entered the house, placed the two pieces of wood for the preservation of the fire, brought by the priest, on their laps, and performed certain propitiatory ceremonies. Such, again, is the ceremony of the gift of the cake. The householder is enjoined to observe these ceremonies in all cases.

There is no exception made in the case of a student marrying after his period of studentship was over, when his parents were yet living, a clear indication that he had to start a house of his own as soon as he married, notwithstanding that parents, elder brothers, and the like, were living. He thenceforward came to form a separate household, and had to perform all the duties of a householder.

With a settled state of things, however, and agriculture expanding, a change is indicated — brothers living with brothers, even after the death of the father; but such a state of things appears to have been looked upon with disfavour by the law-codifiers, whose ideal family was the type indicated in the Vedas. Thus Gautama, in one of his Sutras, says, "in partition, there is an increase of spiritual merit," referring, perhaps, to the performances of the duties of a householder in his own household with his wife. The change of type of which we here get an indistinct glimpse, necessitated some rules of partition; but they appear to have been as yet very crude, and not in the form in which they afterwards developed themselves. One of the modes of acquiring property by usage is said to have been the property of re-united co-parceners. The property of a re-united co-parcener going to the co-parcener, and the acquisition of property by a learned co-parcener by his own efforts, as not being liable to partition with his unlearned co-parceners, are indistinctly touched. The co-parceners thus referred to are brothers, as all the Sutras related to co-parcenary property are preceded by a Sutra regarding a brother's succession, wherein we find that the property of not reunited brothers, dying without issue, went to the eldest brother, a verse indicating the fact that the subject of a brother's succession was till then in a nebulous state.

In point of fact, the question of a brother's succession could arise only in very few cases, as there were sixteen kinds of sons, with or without any blood connection with the deceased, the claims of all of whom were recognised, and preceded that of the brother. The family in which the existence of these sixteen kinds of sons was possible, had not surely that kind of decorum in it in which different couples could live together, or in which the so-called 'joint family' of the day could exist as a flourishing type. The brother's right to succession could be again defeated by the widow, by raising a son, or even two sons, to the deceased.

All this points to the conclusion that a change was springing up which was not yet fully recognised or provided for, and was even yet looked on with disfavour.

A full and formal recognition of the growth of a more complex type of family, is not even to be found in the "Manu Sanhita"; but there is evidence to show that, side by side with the ancient simple type, a complex type was generally growing up; and the conservative portion of the community, Brahminical law-codifiers among the rest, were not at all inclined to favour this change. Like Gautama, the codifier in this instance in describing the comparative merit of brothers living together and brothers living separately by themselves, finds in favour of the ancient type, as will be seen from the following verse: —

"Thus they will either remain united, or they will with the view of getting spiritual merit, by the establishment of the five sacrifices in each household, become separated; for in a united state, one alone has to perform the five sacrifices for the household; others do not: so there is special merit in separation."

These five sacrifices, not the Vedic, emphatically called the five great sacrifices according to the Manu Sanhita, were (i) teaching and studying, called a sacrifice to the Supreme God (Brahman); (2) offerings of water to departed spirits; (3) burnt offerings to the minor gods; (4) offerings to ghosts; and (5) an ever-hospitable reception of guests, described as a "sacrifice to men."

Just as we have seen to have been the case at the preceding period, the student is enjoined to finish his studies — the period for the finishing of which appears to have been between 25 and 40 years of age — when he returned home, married and settled down as a householder. The sacrificial ceremonies of old have been replaced by other sacrifices and ceremonies. But the student is still enjoined to light the sacred fire, though this, too, appears no longer to be the universal practice. According to changed custom, if he be thirty, he generally takes for his wife a girl aged 12 years, and, if twenty-four, he can take for his wife even a girl aged only 8 years, though there are indications that girls remain unmarried even to a later age, and sometimes, when of age, marry bridegrooms younger than themselves, who have not yet reached the age of puberty. With the general rule of marriageable ages fixed in the Sanhita, it is clear that the girl-wife could not be fit to take charge of a separate household, and so a changed type of family must have arisen, though of this there is not yet a fuller recognition. It is only laid down in the chapter on Inheritance: — "On the return home of the brothers from foreign countries, after the death of the father, they shall divide his property amongst themselves, if they all wish it: else not."

"If the eldest brother be virtuous, and all like to remain united, the eldest alone shall take the whole property under his charge; the younger brothers shall respect him, as their father, and depend upon the elder brother for their food and raiment." And then follows the verse extolling the merit of partition.

The rule of succession remains unchanged. There is no conception of a corporate existence, or rule of survivorship. The widow takes under an invariable rule, before the father and brothers, as also the daughter; and the succession of all is postponed to the succession of various kinds of sons, still enumerated, though all excepting two are looked on with reprobation, and the widow still has the power of defeating the succession of the brothers effectually for all time, by raising a son to her deceased husband, though this, too, is condemned as not a meritorious custom.

The commentator, writing at a much later date construes this text, as laid down in the Sanhita regarding the raising of sons, as applicable only to those cases where the brother lived separate from his other brothers, as, according to the commentator, widows had no right to the property of the husband where he lived united with his brothers. But the commentary is comparatively modern, and furnishes an instance of how the texts of our laws were interpreted by the commentators in accordance with changed customs. There is no reference of the commentator's note in the Mitakshara, where all the other texts and commentaries are quoted, showing that Syana belonged to a later age than Vijaneshwar.

Even in the text of Yajnyavalka, on which the Mitakshara is expressly based, we find the postponement of the succession of the brothers to the widow and the daughter to be an invariable rule.

In the Vyasa Sanhita, the date of which is fixed by some at such a late date as the conquest of India by the Muhammadans, without, however, any authority, as there are quotations from it in the textbooks admittedly of an earlier date, and which must, at all events, be later in date than the rest of the Sanhitas, we find a fuller recognition of this growing complex family type as a social institution. In the second chapter of Vyasa Sanhita, the duties of a housewife are described. They are much the same as used to prevail, until, of late, in a Hindu household. She is enjoined, after finishing her morning duties, to do obeisance to her father-in-law, mother-in-law, and other elders of the family. In the Manu Sanhita, again, we find that the elder brother should look on the wife of his younger brother as a daughter, and the younger brother should look on the wife of an elder brother as a mother. Thus the complex type was being gradually recognised, and the duties of the several members composing it laid down in consonance with existing usages.

But the fullest recognition of the growing and the existent type, which had very generally taken the place of the older and simpler type, we find in the Mitakshara, in the rule as to the devolution of property which the author, following, of course, existent usages, lays down in his text. The author after describing the various texts regarding a widow's succession, lays down: —

"Therefore the right interpretation is this; when a man who was separated from his co-heirs and not re-united with them, dies, leaving no male issue, his widow (if chaste) takes the estates in the first instance. For partition had been premised; and re-union will be subsequently considered."

Such a qualification to a rule of succession was necessary to suit the changed conditions of Hindu families, the prevalent type which had grown up, and which, bringing, as it did almost a change in domestic relationships, and possibly in the degrees of affection, had already effected a change in the usage as to the devolution of properties. The author of the Mitakshara recognises the change, and tries to reconcile it with the earlier texts. But the rule did not come to be the universal rule in India. The complex type grew up in Bengal, just as in the rest of India; but the growing practice either did not supersede the old invariable rule of succession, or, if it did, was soon abandoned, and the old rule restored.

We have thus laboured to show that, in India, the simpler type of a family — a man, his wife and children— was the earliest, and that the complex type, more than one couple and their children living together in a family, came into existence later on. We have hitherto referred to what (excepting the hymns of the Vedas) would be generally called * Ancient Laws' of India.

The literature of the Hindus gives evidence only of a changed public opinion in favor of the growth of a more complex type. But neither in the "great epics," nor in the succeeding "dramas," does one find the picture of people in homely life living together in a so-called 'joint' family, a kind of negative evidence — and negative evidence is the only kind of evidence we can look for in this matter — that the type, or types, were not yet the prevalent ones. But they give as much prominence to other affections as to conjugal love, and hold them up to public admiration as much as love between man and wife. Sacrifice of self is what each preaches, and this is the solid basis on which the introduction and permanence of a complex type of family was possible. One of the earlier dramas, "Malati Madhava," tries to portray all kinds of affections in a single drama: and it is rather significant that, nevertheless, the ' complex group ' is not there to be found. It is not that the types were not in existence at such a later date; but the educational effect of Hindu Literature was nevertheless necessary to foster their growth and to make them fashionable. The "great epics "teach, by introducing examples drawn from high life; yet it is doubtful whether any of the pictures in them are pictures of a complex family. It is true that, in the "Ramayana," we find the sons of Dasaratha living with him after their marriage and forming the same household with their father and mother; but this was the case of a royal family, and the epic is supposed by some to have been produced at a very much later date. In the "Mahabharata," the hundred sons of Dhritarastra live with him, and Durjodhan, as the eldest born of the blind king, is the chief among them; but there is nothing to indicate that the hundred brothers lived together, further than that they were all princes of the royal family getting maintenance out of the royal treasury. The Pandavs are a type the like of which is not found to have ever existed in India. The Jadavs are mentioned as living together, uncles, nephews, etc. The description, however, implies a clan rather than a family. Here, too, the case is that of a royal race.

In what we have said above, we are aware that we reverse the order in which Sir Henry Maine thought the family types to have originated. His idea is that the original family type was patriarchal and joint; and that the simplest type — that of the man, wife and children — had branched out of it. He refers specially to the Indian village community and Indian joint families as the vestiges of the earliest family type, and we have shown, by reference to the authorities which he recommends as helping in the enquiry, what the rudiments of the social state were before the joint family system came into existence in India.

II.

The questions now are (i): What were the causes, or rather changed conditions, that brought about, and helped the growth of this new complex social type? (2): How did it affect Indian society as a whole, from an industrial and economic point of view, and from a moral and political point of view? (3): What brought about the differentiation of the Bengal type from the same type in the rest of India?

(i) It is clear that the first glimpse we get of the growth of the new type, is at a time when India was changing from a state of militancy to a state of industrialism. The Aryans, who had fully settled in the country, had brought the non-Aryans under their sway. The non-Aryans were no longer the Dasyas, the blacks, the enemies, against whom the thunders of heaven were to be invoked, but a lower class of beings in the social order. The days of compulsory co-operation were gone by, and the days of voluntary co-operation for the peaceful pursuits of life, — foremost amongst them agriculture, — had arrived, (2) This was the beginning; but the fullest development of this type, the growth of which the "Manu Sanhita" vainly tries to resist, is synchronous with a formidable social and religious revolution in India. A new order of things had arisen. The religion in which self was partially predominant, had given place to a religion in which there was a total abnegation of self; it introduced new ideas of humanity, and rules and discipline which swept away many of the ancient landmarks. It also introduced monastic order, the first in India, which, when practised by worldly men, would be socialism in essence. (3) And when this new order was gone, or grown obsolete, it left behind it ideas, the counterpart of which the reactionary conservatism came to claim as its own. Conservatism no longer disfavored the growth of a changed society and a changed type of family. The older family altar, where the sacrificial fire was to be lighted by the family at its start, had long ceased to exist, and, in its place, had grown other modes of worship. The Vedic sacrifices had given place to Pujahs of gods and goddesses in temples not specially intended for a household, or householder; but where a number of people, men and women, forming different and distinct couples, whether living in one family or in different families, might join in worship. Not only temples, but places of pilgrimage, had sprung up in imitation of the new cult, and the idea of incarnation, unknown to the old set of beliefs, had at once riveted the attention of the people. Legends were multiplied, and monastic orders were growing up; and the summum bonum of existence came to mean, not the ego, but the abnegation of the ego. The fullest recognition of the type by our Law Codes dates from this period, in spite of a protesting voice here and there.

So far as its effects on the growth of Indian civilisation were concerned, they can be summed up in a very few words. It rendered Indian civilisation essentially spiritualistic; its materialistic side being no longer in evidence amidst its growing spiritualistic character. Egotism yielded to altruism. The fault was that there was no harmony between the two.

The difference of the Bengal type from that of the rest of India, is in the legal incidents. In Bengal notwithstanding the existence of joint properties between brothers, the property of a deceased brother, dying without sons, goes to the widow and daughter, and daughter's son, and during his lifetime a united brother enjoys the absolute power of disposing of his property in any way he likes, to which, by construction, is added now the power of making a disposition of his property by will. Thus, whereas, in the rest of India, the property of brothers before separation, or after re-union, is a co-parcenary, in Bengal it is not so.

The reason of this difference is not far to seek. The complex type of family grew up here for reasons exactly similar; but in the pursuits which the men followed, there was more need of individual exertion than of co-operation of members of the family. There was less of agriculture, as an exclusive means of livelihood, amongst the upper, i. e., literary classes than in the rest of India. Whether it is cause or effect, the agnatic tie here is less strong. Again, Bengal Proper, though so close to the cradle of Buddhism, does not appear to have ever had the revolution in its midst.

III.

Having shown that the types in India have changed, with surrounding circumstances, from the simple into the complex, as ancient records attest, we now come to the family types as they existed within the memory of man, and which are even now generally existent, notwithstanding the changes that have been going on.

We find three types co-existent. The simplest is that wherein the man, his wife, and young and unmarried children live together, the married sons going into separate establishments with their wives. The second is that in which the man, his wife, and all the children, young and unmarried, and married sons, with their wives and children, live together. The third comprises a number of men and their wives, with the children of all the couples, plus such widows and their children as may have been thrown on their hands by the death of the bread-winners — to whom might be added the aged and the crippled. The first, as an existent type, is the least numerous. It is being brought about by a close imitation of the European types, in some cases in which a similar imitation of European models in other things has taken place. The type was not wanting before in India; only wherever it existed, it was either the work of a step-mother of the type of ' Rani Kakayee ' of the "Ramayana," or of disagreement between mother-in-law and daughter-in-law, of a type differing from the generality of these types in India. Such types of families are reprobated and condemned by the public opinion of Hindu society at large; the man is condemned as weak, hen-pecked, chickenhearted, and the son as undutiful. This type has been so effectually supplanted by the other two types, that a few years ago scarcely a family would have been found to come under it, unless it had originated in a case of the kind adverted to above; and it may be said that the trial of this type, though the most ancient in India, in a true Hindu spirit, without risk or loss of those domestic affections which characterise all Hindu relations, has not yet been made under the changed conditions. It is possible that such trials will come soon. In many parts of India, the sons in government service, in the practice of a profession, live apart, with their wives and children, in a different place from their father's establishment, and it is only occasional visits that they can pay to the family residence. Gradually their numbers are increasing, and the type, growing up under such happier auspices, may perhaps be freed from its present stigma, and be looked on with favour, provided the domestic affections do not cease to exist with separate and remote living, and mutual aid is rendered when such aid is needed.

The second type would be the usual type, even when a complex family type had grown up, where there were no brothers or aged parents of the father living; and, as such, it must always have existed, side by side with the more complex groups. But it is evident, from the actual state of Hindu Society at the present day, that their numbers have been greatly added to, by an increased splitting up of the complex groups of the last type, compared with what formerly used to be the case. We have seen that the "Gutama Sutra" and "Manu Sanhita "refer to partition amongst brothers, and their splitting into separate households as an act of merit. Public opinion in this matter suffered a change later on, and, even within the memory of men now living, division amongst brothers was looked on with disapprobation. But the feeling in Bengal regarding this matter has again undergone a change, and the neighbours have now no opinion to express about it. They think only that the parties interested understand their own affairs best.

In the third group, the men stand to each other in the relation of brothers, cousins, uncles or nephews, or fathers and sons. The widows are probably sisters, sisters-in-law or aunts. The number is sometimes greater and sometimes less; but there is a limit beyond which the agglomeration does not go; especially in Bengal, where the splitting up is almost identical with separation of mess, and separation of dwellings, even in cases of members who have not gone away in search of work. In no case, however, will it be found that the diluted degree of blood relationship amongst the members of the complex family group, extends beyond the fourth degree; and the legal presumption, that, whenever a question of joint or separate familyship arises, whoever raises it, and in whatever degree he may be related to the deceased, the family is to be presumed 'joint' until the contrary is proved, finds no countenance in existing or past types of the Hindu family. Separation comes about naturally, and is as much the rule amongst the Hindus as amongst the other sons of Adam. The fact that the members are related beyond the third degree, might very well be taken as rebutting, primd facie, the presumption that the normal condition of every Hindu family is 'joint,' even if the legal presumption be allowed to exist.

The term 'joint,' with reference to a family, or an agglomeration of persons living together, as contradistinguished from ' separate,' is not of the Hindu law. The Hindu law-lawyers, who were full of verbal subtleties, and with whom every expression was fully weighed, would never have thought of using an expression like this. The use of the expressions ' joint ' and ' separate ' with reference to families, and the legal presumptions about it, are exceedingly modern, and were brought about by the British Courts in India. The Hindu lawyers would have said, if the expression had been used in their presence, we know of Ek-anna bhukta brothers, brothers living in one mess; we know of separated brothers; but how can you predicate of a family, that it is either joint or separate, where families, to be 'families' must always be joint. An anchorite lives by himself and has no family: so men must be with families, or without families; when they live together, they live in families. Men and women living together must form a family. To say that any number of men and women living together is a joint family, and to say that the family comes to be no longer 'joint,' but 'separate,' when they cease to live together, is to suppose that a man and his wife living by themselves, after the others have ceased to live with them, are not joined in a family. The word ' family,' with the idea which it is meant to convey, is entirely European. Its vernacular counterpart, in its present sense, is of exceedingly modern growth; yet one does not exactly understand wherein the idea consists. Has so-and-so a family? You reply, "yes," if he has any children; you reply "no," if he be married and has a wife, but no children. Suppose all these children are married and live in separate establishments of their own, and the man and his wife live by themselves, what would be your answer? And suppose, again, if he, on the death of his first wife, leaving him a number of children, were to marry again, and have children by his second wife, would he not have a family by his first wife, and another by his second? It would, perhaps, be wrong to enquire of a woman whether she has, or has not, a family. The primary idea, if it were to be used in the sense in which it has been translated to India, would, we suppose, be a man in a married state, with his wife living with a number of children, young and unmarried. That is, however, not the sense in which the word 'family' can be made applicable to all Indian types. The only point of contact is that all those who form a family must live together, and in that sense families must always be 'joint,' and it is not correct to predicate of some of them that they are 'joint ' and of others that they are ' separate,' simply because the original number twenty-four in a group living together comes to be divided into eight groups of three each. The three, as forming a family, are still 'joint.' The division of Hindu law is not of the number of men and women, but of rights. There is a joint right of a number of individuals, and there is a division of the sum total of this right into 'individual rights.' They provide for only two kinds of division (vibhaga): division in the lifetime of the father, and division after the death of the father, amongst brothers — indicative of the fact that, even when the complex types had fully developed and had to be provided for, the only case which it was necessary to provide for, was the division amongst brothers, the largest group not then extending any further.

IV.

In what will follow, we shall, therefore, not use the word 'joint family' to distinguish the third, or the more complex type that is now to be found gradually prevalent in India.

We have shown that this type is disintegrating and passing into the second type, if not into the first. "What are the causes?

The primary cause is the contact of Western civilisation with the civilisation that has developed in India, and the changed economic and moral conditions which this contact has introduced and is daily introducing. The genius of the Hindu race, which we have elsewhere said, disdains imitation, will keep them from adopting the Western type as their only unit of social organisation; and as the type, as we have seen, once existed here, and has been found wanting, and replaced by different types— though all this took place in the remotest past — there possibly exist reasons in the constitution of the Hindus and Hindu Society, why this change should not occur. Possibly again, through this contact between the civilisations of the East and West, there will grow the perfected types of the future, and the genius of the Hindus will create them.

Family organisations are the units of society, and ultimately of the political state. But though, perhaps, social organisations, the creation of brute, plus intelligent force, or of any other principle, were originally intended to preserve the units, the units of whatever state of society we may conceive of, can subsist only in subordination to the social aggregate. They are, again, the nursery for those qualities which social aggregates need.

Now, of the three kinds of type which we have described above, the first is more fitted for the development of the conjugal affections, the second for that of the filial affections, and the third, for that of brotherly affection. We do not speak of parental love; it is so natural and so little needs development, that it can exist under all conditions. All these affections need harmonious development. It is true that the development of any one kind of these affections, develops love on the whole, and chastens man. Yet it is possible that, in the development of some one of these affections, the claim of the others might be overlooked. Nowhere, again, is it more true that extremes meet. The best training ground for the conjugal affections might produce, — for little causes, which possibly would not be allowed to grow in shape and form under the other types, — discord and disagreement between man and wife; and unbrotherly hatred, grows in types which are deemed most fitted to develop brotherly love. The first type, again, is individualistic, the second patriarchal, and the third communistic.

The types will have to be further examined under two heads: First, in relation to the question whether free scope for individualism is possible under any of these conditions, and whether it finds a greater check under the last two types than under the first; and secondly, with regard to the subject of individual responsibility.

Now, is it true that any one kind of these organisations is based on individualism, (i. e., where the 'authority of individual, even within such limits as the law imposes, is not checked or controlled by any external authority, or any considerations from inside? In the first of these organisations, which is European, the individual, if he is fit for anything and wishes to be happy, must sacrifice his individualism, in the sense indicated above, to considerations of the limited circle of beings around him. This he will also have to do in the case of the other two kinds of organisation noted above. In the second, the individual father under whose authority all live, must, in order to be happy and to render others happy, sacrifice his individualism to considerations of the ideas, feelings, even the whims and caprices, of the individuals by whom he is surrounded.

In the third type, which is a nearer approximation to the European idea of a ' commune,' with this difference, that, whereas in a commune like that which Fourier thought of, the individuals need not be allied by blood, or by marriage — the kind of organisation, which, as a family group, is common in India, is based on such relationship — the ' karta,' or the head (manager) of the family, whoever he may be, and it is ordinarily seen that the choice devolves on the individual of the group who has the best intelligence and tact, must sacrifice his complete individuality, even including the individual considerations of those of the group with whom he is more intimately connected, for considerations of the ideas, the feelings, and even the idiosyncracies of the larger circle around him.

The difference between the possible limits of individualism under the different types is merely one of degree, not of kind. This sacrifice of individualism, which, in its highest development, comes to be the moral virtue of self-sacrifice, is, therefore, the basis on which family organisations, however simple, must be necessarily based. But, whatever scope these different kinds of organisation present for the development of individualism, individualism everywhere receives a check from the social aggregate. This check is, of course, different in different forms of that aggregate. In India, it is in the first place imposed by the rules and usages of caste over the social units. In Europe conventionalism rules. A large class of people are always found there to be rising against the tyranny of social forms, just as many people here in India, rise every now and then against the usages and rules of caste. In both cases they may revolt against the present, but they will not — we may, in passing, say — shut out the future. It indicates a principle. It means that, as we proceed higher and higher, the units, in whatever form of family organisation they present themselves, must sacrifice their individual isms to considerations of the ideas, thoughts, and even idiosyncracies and prejudices of the social aggregate, in whatever form it exists. In archaic forms there is not a close distinction between what ought to bp the restraints of law, and restraints outside the law, (i. e.), restraints of social forms. Gradually the two are separated in all developed forms, and both grow with the growth of these forms. So while, on one side, "individualism "finds a check imposed upon it by the social forms, it also receives a check, on the other from the growing laws. As matters look, the "coming slavery" will in time be complete.

But individualism checked and restrained is one thing, and the happiness of the individual checked and restrained is another. The object of all sound and reasonable checks must be the increase of human happiness in the aggregate, and so in parts; and any form calculated to diminish this happiness must necessarily be imperfect. If the second and third types are destined to exist, they will only exist in a progressive state of society, where they do not, in any way, restrain individual happiness. We shall show hereafter that this restraint is not at all necessary for their existence.

It must be conceded that, under existing conditions, a sense of individual responsibility does not grow to the same extent under the second and third

7 types, as under the first. They are less favourable for such growth. Perhaps the deficiency is compensated by the fuller growth of responsibility in the head member, and in the growth in him of a certain amount of power to govern his fellow men. There is also a division of work and a nice apprenticeship for those who are to come next. There is also the growth of an honest ambition to take the place of the head member when the time for it comes.

But, with all that, the last two types, especially the third, give rise to a class, called by Englishmen and some English-educated natives, "drones," in derogation of a class of men who will not labour for what they would eat. Their number is fast decreasing under the present economic conditions, and, even where they still exist, they are receiving a kind of treatment on all hands, which is not calculated to foster the further growth of the class. The fact is, public opinion in this matter has, to a great extent, changed. A man would not, under our past standard, have been considered as doing his duty by a dependent of this class, unless he treated him and his, in all respects, as equal to himself and to his own. The same is not the case now.

But there are classes of relations whose claims a Hindu, as long as he remains a Hindu, cannot overlook. There are the aged, the cripple, the helpless widows and orphans of his own kith and kin, with whom, if he has a morsel for himself and his, it must always be his duty to divide. And it is not possible, in the nature of things, unless great violence were to be done to our national feelings, that the first type could long remain as a type of that class, if the duties which the Hindu regards as sacred, were to be attended to. Brothers and sisters of an unripe age might be left orphans by the death of fathers and mothers. Brothers might have left children as orphans, with no widows (mothers) to attend to them. A widowed sister might seek protection under the brother's roof; an aged father and mother might have to be looked after. Unless public opinion in this country were to suffer a tremendous change, a close imitation of foreign modes of rendering assistance in these cases would never commend itself to us. An individual dies, possibly without being able to provide for his immediate environments, with the consoling thought that others will take his place. A brother or a nephew on whose education and support he has spent all his little means, as the best investment for the future, comes to be a successful man of business. What would the public think, what would he himself feel, unless he were a social reprobate, if he were not to take under his wing those from whom he had received assistance in the days of his need. Here the individual type gives way and passes into the other types

So it is impossible to say what, under varying circumstances, the type or types would be. Of course, circumstances tending to weaken responsibility should not exist. Education, a healthy public opinion, appropriate assimilation of ideas drawn from Western civilisation, and consequent changes in the condition of the peculiarly Indian types, should be relied on to bring about this sense of individual responsibility.

In a poor country like India, cheapness is a recommendation in many matters, and in family organisations amongst the rest. In this respect, the third type, excels the other types: and this was one of the reasons why, perhaps, it commended itself to almost universal adoption. It was cheap as regards expenditure of money, as regards expenditure of physical labour, as regards expenditure of mental labour, and it enabled the people included under it to devote their time to the things which most interested them, freeing their minds, as it did, from the almost engrossing cares and anxieties of a household.

It is strange that the first splitting up of the complex family type in this country appears to have been due to the growing poverty of the people. This arose from the fact that the bread-winner in a family, under the abnormal conditions which the complex type had assumed, was, in many cases, a single individual, and it was not cheapness that recommended the split, but a desire on the part of such bread-winner to curtail expenses. It will primarily be a desire for cheapness, again, which, under better conditions and better education, will recommend the second and third types to our people, and perpetuate them as Indian types, . with our abnormal growth of population, and with the consequent ever growing poverty of our people.

V.

But, like many other institutions in this country, the types are undergoing changes, and assuming forms, more suited to present circumstances. It is quite in the order of things that, for the moment, the principle of egoism should appear to have an undue preponderance, and altruism to have lost its hold. A reaction, as in so many other things, is coming on, but the rehabilitation of altruism in the old archaic forms, more in this than, perhaps, in other things, will be found impossible; and a harmonious blending of the two — the assimilation of whatever there is good and beautiful in the form of the West with the types of the East — may ultimately be depended on: The perfected types of our future civilisation will be the forms thus developed.

These perfected types, we hold, are such as are the best fields for the development of all the affections of man and woman, and for their intellectual growth. The types as we have said will differ according to their varying circumstances: they will remain side by side, one sometimes passing into another. But the goal must be the same; the conditions for the development of the individuals, must be the same within such restraints as law or society imposes, and these restraints, we suppose, are ultimately destined to be only such as are calculated to produce the greatest happiness of the greatest number. All other restraints on the growth or happiness of individuals, where they exist, must necessarily come to an end. What are the changes from which we can expect the evolution of the perfected types, with our present type as a basis? Primarily they will be found in what follows.

Nowhere is altruism shown to greater perfection in the complex types than in our women. They do not know what self is. It is the care of the household that engrosses their attention. Everything of the best is for others, and not for the mistress of the house. With servants and maids in number to do her bidding, the woman is a willing drudge from a very early hour of the morning to the latest hour of night; her husband's remonstrance she heeds not; she cannot change her habits; she sits up at night to tend the sick. The slander has been often repeated, that' she is fond of ornaments. The best of the type aims at being the least costly to the family; and certainly she, as a wife, is less costly to. her husband than wives under other types of civilisation. She is content with whatever the family can aiford to give her, equally with the rest. The class has not yet died out. Others amongst the class prized the ornaments, not for their own sake, but as a means to an end. They were held good as a provision against a rainy day. It is the woman who practically manages all the affairs of the household, sweetens the life of all the members of the family, harmonises all interests by universal love, and preserves, by her example, in all respects, the moral tone of the house.

When a disruption comes in a family of complex type, the neighbours say the women are at the bottom of it, and this is for some time currently believed; but the secret comes out; it is the men who are the cause, and not the women, who have warded off the day of disruption as long as they could. The complex type could not exist for a day, if the women did not keep it up.

What, again, could be a better school for the training of the girl wife of India for being a dutiful wife, a dutiful mother, -a dutiful mistress of the household, than the schooling she receives from the mother-in-law. Cases have of late occurred here and there in which the Hindu mother-in-law has been held up as a tyrant to their son's wife. A greater calumny could not be uttered. Every Hindu knows that one of the earliest enquiries made when a girl has to be married is whether there is a mother-in-law; and every one hesitates to pass her in marriage into a family where there is no mother-in-law, unless he is satisfied that there is some one as good amongst the female inmates of the household to take care of her. The mother-in-law, as a general rule, loves the daughter-in-law as a daughter; and the daughter-in-law pays back such love with true filial affection. But the subject of the Hindu family is a sealed chapter to all but the nearest relations; and one or two stray cases that have come of late before the Police Magistracy, of an extremely un-Hindu and obnoxious kind, have, to a certain extent, influenced public opinion. Those amongst the Hindus who were silly enough to join in such cry, must consent to change many of their social institutions all at once, if they conscientiously believe that the mother-in-law is the tyrant she is represented to be.

It is said that our women are not fit companions for our men. Perhaps it tickles the vanity of our young men, who have always a high opinion of themselves, to say so. The case is the reverse. Our men are immeasurably below our women. It would, in many cases, do them good to sit at their feet, and learn from them lessons of virtue and unselfishness. Perhaps the ideal of our women is too high for them to reach. But surely, if they cared for their own happiness in the long run, or the happiness of those around them, nay, of the society in which they live, they would not think of supplanting the present type of woman by one whose idea of a family would be drawn from foreign models; who would not think of a family until their husbands had given them a separate establishment to rule; who would think that the only duty of their husbands was duty to their wives in the first place and their children in the next; who would assert rights in accordance with the rights of women in other countries, and who would be sticklers in etiquette, according to foreign models, based on their second-hand knowledge derived from etiquette books. They would not hanker after a type whose taste for dress and finery would exceed the means of their husbands; who would think it superfine to say that they never knew how to cook, or how to do this or that, — hundreds of domestic duties for which women alone are fitted; nay, what is worse, who would consider it beneath them to do everything for their children. Our girls, our women, must be educated to a higher standard; but that education must be on a national basis. We are by no means in favour of restricting that education in any way. Science, mathematics language and literature are as much for them as for the men; the education which can alone fit them to take in hand the education of the children must be of the highest kind. If some of them are ambitious of obtaining University degrees, there is nothing to be said against it; but what should be jealously guarded against in the higher education of our women, more than in that of our men, is the allowing their minds to be formed in a way in which foreign ideas (especially this of the family type) would alone be adopted. There are few novels, for instance, in the English language, or for the matter of that, in the Bengalee language either, in close imitation thereof, wherein the protraiture is not that of conjugal love alone; other domestic affections scarcely find a place therein. In English novels the pictures are drawn from life; and the family types that are the subjects, are of the sort that prevails in Europe. There is no excuse for their existence in Bengal. Too much of this is sure to make girls disdain our Indian types, and is calculated to render them unhappy under their present conditions.

But what our Indian women want — and this is a subject which should not be overlooked in the education of our girls, — are those graces and female accomplishments which render life — always full of care and anxieties, where misery and happiness are almost equally balanced from day to day, from hour to hour — a little happier. The poetry, the music, the aesthetics, the innocent amusements, the little diversions which take away from our loads of care and morose thoughts, we require under all types, simple or complex.

There were the Pujahs, with their little amusements and their excitements; there were frequent ceremonies connected with birth, with tonsure, with marriages and a hundred other occasions, with amusement for the young and excitement for the old; there were the Britas for the women, prescribed for almost every month. The Dharemghaut, in the end of Bysak, with an expensive finale in the fourth year, when, throughout the month, the lady who performed the Brita, had to provide the best and the choicest food for the whole household, in addition to Brahmins, Gayatis (agnates) and Bundhu (cognates), men living outside the family; the Jamai-sustt, when, in the month of Jait, the sons-in-law of the family were to be presented with the best clothes and choicest food, with flower wreaths, and knickknacks of sorts, engrossing the attention of the ladies of the house for a month previous; the Bhrata-ditya, occurring ordinarily in the month of Kartic, when the thought of all women was to do the like by their brothers. These and a hundred other little things of the kind were taken advantage of by the Hindus for diversion, amusement, excitement, as also for the exercise of affection and devotional feelings . There were Jatras, and Puthi Pat, to the infinite amusement of young and old. Alas! these things do not now amuse! but have we been able to substitute other and more rational amusements in their stead? Judging from what we see, there is something in the observation that, wherever English education has permeated to any extent in India, the people are growing sombre and gloomy. There is no ' go '; no life; no combination of work and play; and, what is worse, there is no rational amusement in the family. Our young men play cards; our young women play cards, each in their separate domains. There is a tennis court outside in some houses; young men, as well as old, sometimes join; but there is no provision whatever for the young women taking any healthy exercise. The duties attended to by their predecessors were of a nature which required bodily labour, and served for exercise, and kept the females in health; these duties are in many cases no longer required of our females, and, unless healthy exercises of some kind are to be substituted, it must tell against their health. Gardening, for the raising of vegetables, or flowers and fruits, was an interesting occupation practised by Hindu ladies. Is there any reason why it should be given up where its practice is possible? Public opinion bans this; public opinion bans music; public opinion bans the mixing of old and young; public opinion bans the presence of the young housewives before their fathers-in-law, and even their talking with the old women of the family. Public opinion, however, is undergoing a healthy change; and though people change with great difficulty in some of these respects, there is hope of alteration for the better.

In many enlightened families, daughters-in-law are treated in all respects as daughters; they are no longer enjoined to keep themselves secluded from the presence of their fathers-in-law, or uncles-in-law, or the brothers and cousins of their husband, except their elder brothers or elder cousins. There is also a bar to the wife appearing before the husband in the presence of the elder male members of the family. If the complex types are to survive under present conditions, these bars, no doubt, will soon cease to exist. Gradually, too, in places where such bars existed before, they are dying out in regard to the ladies taking an occasional airing in carriages with their husbands, fathers, fathers-in-law and brothers. In villages, even in Bengal, women do not live the secluded life which foreigners think they do. They go out very freely in company with the elder female members of the family. Of course, there is no bar to a young female appearing- before her father's relations; and the whole of the village people, though of different castes, are held to be thus related, and her father's intimate friends.

There is no bar to their going to distant places of pilgrimage in company with their male relations. Even railway travelling is doing a good deal to demolish the Purda amongst the Hindus of the upper middle, lower middle and poorer classes. There is scarcely any Purda below a certain rank; though, perhaps — and in this instance again, the example of the upper classes is found catching — the first pretention to gentility consists in making the females of one's family Purdanishins.

But the question of the Purda is likely very soon to adjust itself in the way we have indicated above . There are obstacles, and pretty formidable ones too — we need not enumerate them — to its extending further, at least for many years to come.

The family residences are indexes of the family types of social institutions, and of the kind of happiness prevalent therein. In the Presidency of Bombay and Madras, where no special Purda seclusion is provided, there is only one courtyard in a house. In Bengal there are generally two, sometimes three, and sometimes four. They are ordinarily those of the male and the female apartments. The plan of Indian houses, especially in towns, is changing. There are the courtyards, as of old; but ordinarily the lower storey is used by men as a place of business, and the upper storey by females, as also for sleeping rooms. There are drawing-rooms, both inside and outside, and, in some cases, dining rooms are coming into fashion; while separate suites of apartments are being provided for each married couple. Necessities and regard to convenience will suggest some other changes in the plan of residences as time goes on.

The drawing-room upstairs, where the females of the family ordinarily congregate, is now in most cases furnished with a piano, or a harmonium; and the music, in solo or in concert, practised by the Hindu ladies of the family, as also the sweet vocal music, are indeed becoming charming. The violin and sitar are also instruments to which they are giving attention. They practise drawing, and some of them are growing apt designers of beautiful things. Here, then, should father, mother, sons, daughters-in-law and daughters meet to enjoy their evening. Family billiards, very simple games, cards, draughts, &c., the children giving occasional little performances of their own, with the aid of their immediate elders, might advantageously follow, to enliven the evenings; and an occasional pic-nic outside the house might be given, by way of diversion. The aesthetics of the drawing-room and of the other rooms and their contents, are subjects in regard to which a happy emulation (a feeling which even now exists) should arise between family and family.

But there is a little thing, which, except in houses marked as anglicised, is still to come; — the taking of meals together. The Hindus are a people eminently fitted for domestic enjoyment; and a habit of this kind, which adds to the sweetness of the meal, will not be entirely a novel practice. A Hindu enjoys his meals best when he has a number of children to sit and partake of food out of the same dishes with him; the lady mother, or aunt, or, if they do not happen to exist, the lady wife, with the daughters, sitting by, and keeping up chatty conversation, while they ask you to take a little of this or that, and minister to the enjoyment of the meal in diverse ways. In days of yore, when the grandfathers and fathers of the present generation were young men, it used to be whispered against them, that they, on the sly, sometimes partook of the evening meal with their wives. The practice, then, should be a little extended, and when the barriers we have spoken of are gone, as they are destined to go, this one innovation should come in. No doubt, the females would feel some awkwardness, and it is pretty well known that, in societies where the practice exists, the ladies themselves go half-fed when they sit with the males, and it is the males who, so far as the actual eating is concerned, do their best. This may be a good reason for not introducing the association of males and females at meals: but, perhaps, this disadvantage would be found to be out-weighed by many advantages. For a business man, whose time is fully occupied, the only time which he can give to his family, without detriment to his work, is the time for meals, and perhaps an occasional evening; and while the enjoyment of meals will be added to, by the presence of all the members (male and female), it will keep these business men in the family en courant with the thoughts of those around them.

There are a few other things which must mend, if the complex type is to live. Our young and old appear to have nothing in common between them. The old people hardly ever exchange their thoughts with the young; and this is a great bar to their mutual happiness. The Hindu idea about it is correct enough. The father, when the son is of age, must treat him as a friend; but the Hindu practice is somewhat different. This reserve, in most cases, between the father and sons, has grown by habit into second nature.

Lastly, it is said that the moral atmosphere of our homes is not good for the children. It is a calumny which often goes unchallenged, and every repetition adds to its supposed truth. A better field for the cultivation of the affections which ennoble human nature; a better field for teaching the young to be unselfish, when the children of the bread-winner are treated alike with the rest; a better field for teaching the young to ' do to others as they would be done by ' cannot be conceived. A moral atmosphere of affection and unselfishness pervades the whole structure. What, perhaps, is now vanishing, without a proper substitute taking its place, is an air of devotion and religiousness of faith, from day to day.

We cannot say that, for the better development of the intellect of the children, changes are not required. We want mothers educated both in geography and in history, in the elementary truths of science, and in every-day common affairs of life, to take charge of the early days of our children; females, who can return correct answers to the many questions which the inquisitiveness of children prompts them to ask of their elders.

But the growing sense of individual responsibility must be fully developed if the complex type is to live, and to be perfected as one of the types of the future. Every adult male member must contribute equally to the common family expense, including not only the expense of the common mess, but all the expenses of the children, with that of their education. The practice that has been growing up of recent years in some of the families of complex types, of unequal treatment of the children according to the means of their parents, cannot be sufficiently condemned. It was Unknown even at a time within the memory of man. They should be allowed to live together only under conditions in which the demoralising effects of such unequal treatment cannot exist. It is better that the family should break up, at whatever hardship to individual members, than that such a state of things should be allowed to exist. The contribution for thepurposes noted above being made, each one should retain his savings for his own use. For the individual wants of himself and of his wife, he must look to himself as also to the making of as good a provision for himself, his wife, and his children as he can, consistently with his means. Changes in the complex group in Bengal are taking place in this direction.

The changes have not occurred to the same extent in all parts of India. In places where the causes have been more potent and have operated for a greater length of time, you find greater changes than in others, Bengal has been more affected than the rest of India; and parts of Bengal, nearer the capital, more than other parts. It would be to as little purpose to ask of my countrymen to resist the changes, as to ask them to resist a rising tide. All that we can do, is o see that the solid foundation is not swept away by our unwise resistance. Whenever changes spring up, it behoves every Indian, man and woman, to try to mould and adopt them as fast as they can consistently with the preservation of their existing institutions, — retaining as much of altruism as they can, and admitting individualism and egoism wherever necessary, and thus working out a harmonious whole, the like of which does not yet exist in this world.

Contents


Source

Guru Prosad Sen, An Introduction to the Study of Hinduism. Calcutta: Thacker, Spink and Co., 1893 (printed at the Baptist Mission Press). Chapters I, II and IV are reproduced here. Public domain. Note: Most of the information in this work has historical, sociological and cultural value, but it does not represent present-day Hinduism. This article is from public domain digital sources.

Disclaimer

We have made every effort to reproduce this text faithfully, but we cannot guarantee that it is free of errors. Readers who need accuracy for study or citation should check the original publication. The views and language are those of the author and his time, and e-Scriptures is not responsible for them.

Spelling and style follow the original; obvious scanning and typographical errors have been corrected. This text is believed to be in the public domain in the United States, where this website is operated. Copyright terms differ from country to country, so a text that is free of copyright in the United States may still be protected elsewhere. Readers outside the United States should check the copyright laws of their country before copying, downloading or reusing it; they are responsible for lawful use in their own country. See our Terms of Use.

Our books

Translate This Page

Search This Site