Summary: Three chapters from Melville T. Kennedy’s study of Bengal Vaishnavism. The first two tell the life of Chaitanya, who was born as Visvambhar in Navadvip in 1486: his boyhood and youth, the great change, the beginning of the movement, his farewell to Nadia, his years at Puri, his pilgrimages and his last years. The third describes what Chaitanya gave to the sect: the force of his character, his religious experience and the social consequences of his bhakti. The songs are set as verse.
The Life of Chaitanya: First Period
Visvambhar, tenth child of Jagannath Misra and his wife, Sachi, Vaidic Brahmans of Navadvip, in the Nadia district of Bengal, was born in February of the year 1486. According to popular account, his birth took place during an eclipse of a full moon, a sure omen of future greatness; as was also considered the fact (if such it be) that his birth was delayed considerably beyond the normal time. The father of the child was not a native of the famous city of Navadvip, but had come from Dhakkadakshin, in Sylhet, in order to live near the holy Ganges. The child’s grandfather had migrated from Orissa to Sylhet about 1451, thus the devotion which Orissa has always paid to Chaitanya Deva, claiming him as her own, has a warrant for it.
The parents of the child, Visvambhar, whom we shall call Chaitanya, although this name was not given him until he became a sannyasi,1 gave to the boy a devout Vaishnava upbringing and a wealth of affection. Born the last of eight children, all of whom, save one, had been lost in infancy, he naturally became the idol of the home. The father was a Brahman of religious disposition who had studied in a Navadvip tol. He was a Vaishnava of strict faith and pious life. No meat entered the home; for vegetarianism is a matter of religion to the devout Vaishnava. All the food eaten in the house was first offered to Krishna and then taken as prasada.2 The mother, Sachi Devi, was the daughter of a well-known scholar, Nilambar Chakravarti, who had also come from Sylhet to settle at Navadvip. Thus the boy began life a privileged child, inheriting the peculiar social advantages of Brahman-hood, but blessed far more by birth in a home whose standards were formed by traditions of scholarship and religious piety.
Boyhood and Youth
The boyhood of Chaitanya was evidently that of a very real boy. From the first there was a charm about him which made him a marked child in the neighbourhood. There is evidence of this in the names, Gaur and Gauranga—he of the fair body—epithets of beauty which, given him in childhood, have continued in use to this day. The neighbours also called him Nimai—short-lived—in pitying anticipation, doubtless, of the fate which had overtaken his baby-sisters. About the childhood of this gifted boy there has gathered a cloud of superstitious and miraculous stories, too evidently modelled upon the Puranic stories of the child Krishna. Amidst such a collection of puerile and supernatural exploits as make up the accounts of his early life in the accepted biographies, the real boy is well-nigh lost. We can only conjecture what basis of fact there may have been beneath the legendary.
However, we cannot be far wrong in surmising, that the stories of Krishna-like pranks were not all without foundation. He was evidently a light-hearted child, full of mischief and fun, and possessed of vigour and energy that kept his mother busy.
His schooling was that of the well-born boy in such a famous centre of learning as Navadvip. After a few years in the pathsala—the primary school—he entered, when only eight years of age, the Sanskrit tol conducted by one Gangadas Pandit. It is said that by the time he was ten years of age he had become proficient in Sanskrit grammar and rhetoric, and before he was fifteen was accounted one of the best scholars of Navadvip! Doubtless, considerable allowance must be made here for the enthusiasm of sectarian loyalty. But while discounting much of the tradition that makes him out a youthful prodigy in scholarship, we must believe that he was a very intelligent boy and displayed intellectual keenness beyond the average. He seems to have confined his study largely to grammar, and the logic for which the Navadvip tols had become famous.
When he was still of schoolboy age, his father died. Shortly before this the only other child, an older brother, named Visvarupa, had left the home at the age of sixteen and become a sannyasi. He was never heard from thereafter. Chaitanya was now the sole hope and comfort of his mother. Soon after his father’s death, when the boy was only 14 or 15 years of age, he married and became a householder.3 According to the record, he now set up a tol of his own, receiving pupils in his own house. As this was evidently a common practice among pandits, there is no reason to doubt the statement, although for a lad of his years the picture is rather an incongruous one. The records are also full of the dialectic exploits that now marked his life. If we are to place any reliance upon these stories, it would appear that Chaitanya delighted in disputations and established a great reputation as a formidable antagonist, entering the dialectic lists against all comers.
At this time, according to tradition, he made a fairly extensive scholastic tour in East Bengal, holding disputations and teaching from town to town. He is believed to have gone as far as Dhakkadakshin, in Sylhet, his father’s home. The fact of his having a grandfather and uncles living there makes such a visit entirely probable, but the records of the tour are very scanty. Some doubt is thrown upon these records by the fact that so little evidence of the tour is found in the history of this section. None of the points said to have been visited by Chaitanya have become famous or have been held in honour in the sect, as has been true elsewhere.
While he was absent on this tour his wife died. He was soon re-married, this time to Vishnupriyd, the daughter of a Navadvip pandit, Sanatana Migra. This young girl, so soon to become to all intents and purposes a widow, was destined to hold a place of considerable honour in the future sect.
The characteristics of the young pandit at this time were not such as would indicate the future that was in store. The liveliness of boyhood had developed in the young man into a light-hearted, volatile temperament chiefly concerned with the things of this world. The spirit of the scholastic circles of Navadvip possessed him, and pride of learning seemed his dominant trait. Such triumphs as Chaitanya is reputed to have scored over veteran scholars would not conduce to humility in one so young, and we infer that the quality which later so signally marked the great ascetic was not particularly in evidence in Chaitanya the pandit.
The charm of the boy, however, had not been lost on reaching manhood. Chaitanya was a man of fine presence, with unusually fair skin, lustrous eyes and a mass of hair worn long over the shoulders, according to the fashion of the day. The sacrifice of this adornment, considered so striking an item of masculine beauty, was one of the things that struck the popular imagination with peculiar force at the time of his taking sannyasa.4 His personal charm, his assured social standing as a Brahman, and his distinction as a most promising young scholar in a University city famous for its scholars, made him a marked figure. No wonder the Vaishnava leaders grieved that so promising a son of a Vaishnava household should show so little interest in his father’s faith. Indeed, there was little evidence, outwardly at least, to show that he had any concern for the things that had claimed his brother at so tender an age for the ascetic life.
This was not due to any lack of religious influence. As the son of pious Vaishnava parents, he had known no other: than a religious atmosphere. Direct efforts to influence him, however, were met in a half jesting, half sceptical spirit, that betokened little vital interest, It is recorded that once when a saintly Vaishnava ascetic, named Isvar Puri, tried to win him to a devout life, Chaitanya’s only response was to pick flaws in the grammar of the Sanskrit texts quoted by the sannyasi. This attitude may, indeed, have been partly a mask to hide an undercurrent of feeling suppressed but stirring. Advaitacharya, the leader of the Vaishnavas in Bengal, was a friend of the family and well known in the home. Indeed, it was at his door that the mother of Chaitanya laid the blame for the action of both her sons in becoming sannyasis. Evidently Jagannath Misra’s home was open to all the wandering Vaishnavas who passed in and out of Navadvip, so much so that the boy’s childhood and youth must have harboured many memories of venerated guests. One such ascetic, whom Chaitanya met years afterward in his travels, had a vivid memory of the devout hospitality of that Nadia home. All these influences must have made their impression on the eager young mind of the growing boy, and helped to form the sub-conscious store of latent feeling and aspiration that was to well up so abundantly when the fitting time and occasion should call it forth.
The Great Change
The great transformation in Chaitanya’s life dates from a trip to Gaya, which he undertook about the year 1508, when 21 or 22 years of age, for the purpose of performing his father’s Sraddha5 at this celebrated shrine. Gaya had been a Buddhist sacred place for 2,000 years; it was also a Vaishnava tirtha, or holy spot, as it continues to be at the present day. Here was the famous Vishnupad, the footprint of Vishnu, which was sufficient to make it a centre of pilgrimage for the devout worshippers of Vishnu of whatever sect. To perform the Sraddha at Gaya gave the ceremony peculiar efficacy, which accounts for the pilgrimage of a dutiful son within easy distance of the shrine.
Just what happened at Gaya to work so momentous a change in the young scholar’s life it is difficult to say. The principal factor was a meeting there with the same sannyasi who had earlier sought to influence him religiously, the Madhva ascetic, Isvar Puri. Doubtless the sacred surroundings and the sight of the pilgrims worshipping with simple fervour revived the stored-up memories and impressions of devotion to which we have referred, and aroused in him capacities for religious emotion which had been lying dormant in his nature. The sannyasi now found the opportunity denied him previously, and the result of those days together was the complete turning of the young man from scholastic pursuits and desires to a life of religious devotion. Chaitanya took [svar Puri as his guru, and returned from Gaya a bhakta, i.e. a man devoted in heart and life to the service of Krishna. Evidently there took place here one of those peculiar revolutions in character common to emotional temperaments in all religions, known in Christian terminology as conversion, or, more quaintly, an experience of religion, Of the reality and transforming quality of this experience in Chaitanya’s life there can be no doubt. His whole after life, with its immense influence, is the direct outcome of the change wrought so strangely at Gaya.
On his return to Navadvip the change in him became the talk of the town and the very real concern of his mother. The mystic trances, which were so striking a feature of Chaitanya’s emotional experience, had their beginning now. To his poor mother, already bereft of one son, they were a source of alarm and distress. She had him treated by physicians, believing him on the verge of insanity. The transformation and its causes were eagerly discussed in the daily gatherings of the Vaishnavas. His new spirit was thus reported there:
He is thoroughly changed; he no longer cares to comb his beautiful curling hair; his mother follows him with wistful eyes, but he talks not with ber and cries,‘Oh God,’ and sees visions of him in the clouds; he runs with his hands outstretched and eyes full of tears to catch the Unseen ; despising his soft couch and white bed he sleeps on the bare earth ; he no longer wears his gold chains, ear-rings and lockets, nor the fine krisnakeli cloth of silk with black borders ; he neither takes his bath nor does he eat his usual meals, he no longer worships gods and goddesses, nor does he recite the sacred hymns as prescribed by the Sastras; but weeps and cries, ‘‘Oh God, do not hide your face from me.’
With great hope and joy these devotees welcomed to their midst the one who was to work such wonders amongst them.
Absorption in Bhakti
There now followed a period quite distinct in Chaitanya’s life, which, although brief, was of untold significance for the Vaishnava faith in Bengal. From this time on, his whole life was centred in the Vaishnava group in Navadvip. Absolutely abandoning all scholastic interests and worldly concerns of every sort, he threw himself heart and soul into their life and worship. From the first he seemed to incarnate the very spirit of their devotions. The lord Krishna became the centre of all his thoughts. His energetic, expansive temperament found, in the emotional worship characteristic of the Krishna-bhakti cult, just the sort of medium suited to call forth all the emotional energies of his nature. His attainments and position in Navadvip made him a very desirable accession to the Krishna faith, and these, together with the character of his bhakti, made him the natural leader of the little community.
The chief items in the daily programme of the Vaishnava believers were the gathering for the reading of the scriptures at various homes of the faithful, and the evenings spent in chorus-singing in praise of Krishna.
Chaitanya gave himself whole-heartedly to this musical worship, called kirtan. The courtyard of a certain Srivasa was the centre for the evening devotions. Here, night after night, Chaitanya found an atmosphere so highly emotionalized and a fellowship so congenial and enthusiastic as to arouse him to a high pitch of excitement. This courtyard figures very prominently in the history and hymnology of the sect in Bengal. Chaitanya himself in later days, when a sannyasi residing at Puri, used to speak of it with affection and a trace of homesickness. Although long since swallowed up by the Bhagirathi river, what purports to be this famous courtyard is still the haunt of pious pilgrims at Navadvip.
The kirtan was chorus-singing to the accompaniment of drums and cymbals. The accompanying instruments played no small part in the general results attained. The hole, a long cylindrical-shaped drum with a peculiar detonation, and the sarangi, small brass cymbals, were so invariably associated with the Vaishnava kirtan from the beginning that they have long been looked upon as Vaishnava symbols. The strange power of these instruments to stir the emotions of a devotee is well illustrated in the kirtan. As it progressed, to the stimulus of song and instruments were soon added rhythmical bodily movements and hand-clapping in unison, and, as excitement increased, an abandon of dancing.
The sankirtan, or chanting of hymns by Nimai and his companions, was unlike anything then known. After the instruments had been played in concert for a while, during which the singers composed and concentrated their minds, the chanting of the hymns commences. Nimai, beside himself with bhakti, rises up and begins to dance. His companions, in a moment being as it were electrified by his performance, join Nimai. Nimai dances on with uplifted arms and with eyes turned upwards, and from time to time cries out, “Haribole,” which means, ‘say Hari,’ or simply, ‘‘Bole dole. . . .’ The soul of the kirtan was, of course, Nimai, whose influence awoke profound religious enthusiasm in his companions, who felt themselves immersed, as it were, in a ‘sea of divine bhakti.’ ... Every one present was, in spite of himself, carried away by the torrent of religious excitement.6
Beginning in the evening, the kirtan would increase in volume and emotional intensity as the hours passed. The fervour of excitement, induced by the group acting upon one another, mounting higher and higher, eventually produced all the excesses of hysteria and dementia. It is difficult to conceive of the energy, both physical and emotional, expended in these exercises. Men sang and shouted at the top of their voices hour after hour, dancing and jumping about in ecstatic abandon, until total exhaustion or unconsciousness brought their devotions to an end. In all this display Chaitanya proved himself past-master. Gifted with a fine voice, he never failed to touch the hearts of the devotees by his singing of the love of Radha and Krishna. Then, as the increased volume of song wrought upon his own emotions, he would spring to his feet, and, with arms high above his head, begin to dance in the midst of the singers. This would continue until the perspiration poured in streams from his body and the veins stood out upon his forehead. Often he would fall upon the ground in a stupor as the climax to this wild orgy, and remain thus for a long time. These were believed to be trances in which he entered into full communion with the Beloved of his devotions. Often he would be taken by something very much like an epileptic seizure,7 with frothing at the mouth and rigid body, out of which he would come with crying and tears as though torn away from a beauteous vision. Sometimes at the rendition of a touching song about Radha’s longing he would fall to weeping, and sit or stand transfixed, shedding copious tears, lost to all sense of time or surroundings. Again, as the kirtan rose to a climax he would break away from the circle of weeping, perspiring, dancing devotees, and dash off at top speed in a wild run, until exhaustion or a seizure brought him down. We even read of his climbing trees under the stress of excitement, and of going through all the antics of a madman, raving, and shouting the name of Krishna or Hari incessantly. The translator of the principal biography of Chaitanya, a modern historian and scholar of established reputation, speaks very truly of ‘‘the scenes of ecstasy, tireless exertion in kirtan, madness and miracles, which form the extant history of this period of Chaitanya’s life.’’*
The break with his old life which the Gaya trip had produced was complete and unconditional. From the interests of a proud young scholar, belonging to the aristocracy not only of birth but of learning, with all its sense of superiority and pride of attainment, he had suddenly turned to become a religious devotee of a cult despised by scholars, and marked in their eyes alike by its lack of social standing and the grotesque absurdity of its practices. But the break was not only one of .social connection and outward attachment ; it was a disruption of the very innermost habit and inclination of the mind. This is seen in the clean sweep the new bhakti enthusiasm made of all the intellectual interests of his former life. The scholarly pursuits of a pandit, the atmosphere and habitudes of the tol life, even the zest of the disputant and the relish for the dialectic fray—all these things had passed from his life, as though they had never existed for him. Outside the Vaishnava8 scriptures—principally the Bhagavata Purana and a few Bengali Vaishnava poets—he seems to have read next to nothing after the change.
Beginnings of the Movement
The propagating spirit was strong in the new convert. The kirtan, for instance, became in his hands something more than the fervent worship of a few devotees ; his keen spirit realised its possibilities and he made of it an effective means of spreading the contagion of bhakti. The nightly sessions in the courtyard of Srivasa could not but attract attention. And once within reach of the spell of such a whirlpool of emotionalism, the fate of many an onlooker was sealed. We read, for instance, of a Muhammadan tailor in Srivasa’s house, who could not resist the appeal of this nightly scene, and turned a Vaishnava.
Converts multiplied rapidly, and with each new adherent the wave of enthusiastic bhakti rose higher in the community. Chaitanya’s own personality was the secret of this expanding influence. His was.a magnetic presence, as we shall see from his later experiences. We have already spoken of his beautiful appearance with fair skin and luxuriant hair. Gifted with a noble body and the secret of power over the minds of his fellows, he was possessed not only of emotional capacity to an extraordinary degree, but also of a nature capable of evoking in others similar emotional experiences. Such a gifted personality, suddenly devoting itself with abandon to the ecstasies of a highly emotional religion, could hardly fail to create considerable stir in a quiet community.
The kirtan soon developed into the nagarkirtan, i.e. the processional kirtan.9 Starting from the centre in the familiar courtyard, the Vaishnavas, divided into bands with banners flying, paraded the streets of the town, chanting lustily the Radha-Krishna songs to the accompaniment of drum and cymbal. Thus the fervour and resounding appeal of the kirtan was carried to the very doorway of every home. From being a few devout men worshipping in their own premises, the Vaishnavas now became a public movement, and in the eyes of many a public nuisance.
The fame of the growing movement now made Navadvip a Vaishnava centre, to which gathered men of that faith from every quarter. The most venerable and respected figure in this community of believers was the learned Brahman, Advaitacharya, referred to above, whose home was in Santipur but who spent much of his time in Navadvip. He came of distinguished ancestry, and was a pandit of acknowledged scholarship as well as a man of very devout and pious life. As he was some fifty years Chaitanya’s senior, he was now becoming an old man. We have said that he was a friend of the family, and must have known the boy Nimai quite familiarly. But there developed now a close relationship between the old and the young man, Tradition maintains that the older man saw in the youth an incarnation of Krishna himself. Be that as it may, he clearly recognised the power of -his changed young friend, and, like all others, fell under the spell of his emotional experience. When Chaitanya would lie in one of his numerous trances or swoons, Advaita was often observed to take the dust from the young man’s feet, an act the latter would never permit when conscious.
One of the ascetics who was attracted to Navadvip was a young man nine years Chaitanya’s senior, who was destined to play an important rôle in the development of the sect. His name was Nityananda. He was a Madhva sannyasi, who had travelled throughout India in his wanderings. He was singularly attracted to Chaitanya and the attachment was mutual. For two years preceding Chaitanya’s renunciation of the world, Nityananda lived at the home of Srivasa of the courtyard, and was Chaitanya’s right-hand man in all the activities of the expanding movement.
Another follower of great subsequent fame was added at this time. He was a Vaishnava ascetic, named Haridas—orginally a Muhammadan. Of great humility and piety, he likewise, was drawn to the circle of devoted disciples by the fervent bhakti and irresistible charm of Chaitanya.
These two mendicants became the principals in a house-to-house appeal that Chaitanya now inaugurated, in addition to the kirtan and the street processions at night. Every morning they sallied forth at Chaitanya’s bidding, to sing at every doorway ; instead of receiving the traditional dole of the mendicant they were instructed to ask men to sing the name of Hari and lead holy lives. This is doubtless the origin of the custom, familiar enough in Bengal to-day, of Vaishnava mendicants singing from door to door in the early morning hours soliciting alms. The propagating zeal did not stop with Navadvip, but reached out to neighbouring towns and villages as well. This essentially missionary spirit, that marked the movement in its origin and throughout its best days, is one of the most striking things about it. According to some accounts, a Vaishnava, by name Tapan Misra, was sent to Benares by Chaitanya, to become a resident missionary of the faith in that centre of Siva worship. This man is mentioned as the host of Chaitanya, when the latter visited Benares during his later journeys.
An interesting glimpse of another side of Chaitanya’s life during this period is afforded by the record that he organised and took partin a play. This, of course, was a Krishna yatra10 portraying some portion of the familiar Brindaban stories. Chaitanya took the part of Rukmini, Krishna’s queen, and played the feminine part so well that his own mother, according to account, failed to recognise him. This is not to be thought of, however, as amateur dramatics after the fashion of our own day. It was all a part of the religious expression of the Vaishnava community, and probably was directly in line with the propagandist aim of their other activities.
That the one constructive achievement of Chaitanya’s life—namely, the recovery of Brindaban, the home of Radha, and now the great Vaishnava temple city of North India—was already conceived in his mind at this period, is clear from the fact that he now commissioned some friends to begin the task. The principal disciple chosen for this work was a schoolmate of his youthful days, who later developed into a sannyasi of great learning and piety. He was known as Lokanatha Gosvami.11 In obedience to Chaitanya’s wish, although against his own desires, he left the glowing fellowship at Navadvip, and started out with one companion on the arduous journey upcountry to Brindaban. There he lived his life, never again seeing the beloved form of his companion and master.
This incident is peculiarly revealing, as showing both the quality of the personal devotion Chaitanya inspired in his followers and the spirit which now animated his life. In bidding his friend and disciple goodbye, Chaitanya set the ideal of renunciation clearly before them both: ‘‘Know this, Lokanatha, that neither you nor I are meant to enjoy the pleasures of the world.’
Opposition and the Final Step
Inspite of the popular appeal of Chaitanya’s revival-ism and the success with which it swept large numbers into the Vaishnava ranks in Navadvip, there was still a large and influential section of the population untouched. These were the scholars and pandits, the élite of the city. Indeed, the success of the movement drew them from their attitude of scorn into active opposition. Various means were employed to hinder12 the work. One of the best known incidents in the life of Chaitanya has to do with a form of this opposition. It seems that while singing and preaching in the streets of Navadvip, Nityananda was set upon by two young rajas of the city, who, though of noble family and great wealth, were leading wild and profligate lives. Nityananda received a wound in the face, and was standing with blood flowing down upon his clothes, still urging the drunken men to sing the name of Hari, when Chaitanya arrived. He gently reproved the rajas, and asked why they had not attacked him instead of his beloved friend. The absence of anger and the loving spirit of the two Vaishnava leaders deeply touched the young ruffians; for we read that, overcome with remorse, they became devout and faithful disciples of the new faith.
The sankirtan13 drew the particular wrath of the opposition. When it was transferred from Srivasa’s courtyard to the streets of the city, an appeal was made to the Muhammadan governor to suppress it as a public nuisance. He issued some sort of order against the Vaishnavas, forbidding the uproar they were causing in the streets. In answer to this, tradition has it, Chaitanya organised a monster nagarkirtan, and, dividing his forces into fourteen groups, paraded through the city, finally massing his singers before the Governor’s residence. There the emotional influence emanating from the singing and dancing of hundreds of excited men, led by Chaitanya himself, proved too much for the Moslem magistrate. He was constrained to recognise the spiritual nature of the Vaishnava activities, and, it is alleged, even joined the sankirtan himself !
The opposition continued, however, and the scoffing Brahman scholars yielded no converts to the despised revivalism of Chaitanya. It was the recognition, reluctantly arrived at, of the chasm which intervened between the fervent bhakti of his followers and the scornful self-satisfaction of the scholars that undoubtedly influenced Chaitanya to take the final step. There must have been something more, surely, some deeper spiritual reason, some imperious inner compulsion rising out of his passionate devotion, and driving him on to complete abandonment of everything but the service of Krishna. But of these motives we are not told, the Charitamrita mentioning only his desire to win his fellow townsmen. Declaring his purpose to become a sannyasi, he says,
Then, considering me a sannyasi, they will bow down to me, and in bowing, their guilt will be removed and I shall rouse faith in their purified hearts. Then will these godless men be saved. The desire was strong in Chaitanya’s heart to convert his fellow-pandits. This step was but a final expression of that zealous spirit which had created the movement. As long as he remained a man of Navadvip, one among others, his cause could be but a party; to sever all local ties and become one of that great body of India’s holy men, might give his movement an impetus that should carry it forward over all opposition. With some such expectation, and hoping that his action might be the means of finally touching the hearts and winning the allegiance of those with whom he had once been associated, he at last decided to break life’s dearest ties, and, abandoning everything, to set out upon the way of the homeless wanderer.
17 is just a hint of something of the sort in Cz.BA., 01, iii, are Ch.Ch., 1, xvii, p.131. See also Ck.Bh., Il, xxv, p. 215; I, zai, P- 217, “My taking sannyasa is for saving men.” See also
The Life of Chaitanya: Second Period
Chaitanya’s resolve to abandon the life of a householder was carried into effect secretly at Katwa, a village not far from Navadvip, about the end of the year 1510, when he was 24 years of age. The sannyasi who performed the rite of initiation was an ascetic named Kesava Bharati, who, like Isvar Puri, Chaitanya’s other guru, belonged to the Madhva sect. It seems strange that, for so important a step in his life, Chaitanya should not have sought the guidance of the same teacher who had ushered him into the life of a bhakta. But forms and ceremonies were of little concern to this seeker after God, and it is quite probable that, once the decision was reached, the Vaishnava sannyasi nearest at hand was the best. Although by this act Kesava Bharati became Chaitanya’s sannyasaguru,14 we hear no more of him. Evidently he played no vital part in the spiritual experience culminating in the vow of sannyasa, merely serving as the instrument by which that vow was consummated.
Chaitanya was now a sannyasi of the Bharati order, and his new name was Krishna Chaitanya. Probably the particular order he was joining made no more difference to him than the way in which he became an ascetic. We read in the Charitamrita that, when the great scholar, Vasudeva Sarvabhauma, met the young sannyasi at Puri soon after this, he was disappointed that so gifted a man should have entered an order of sannyasis of lower rank, and proposed to get him admittance into a higher order. A disciple of Chaitanya’s then replied that the master had little concern about the matter and was indifferent as to the relative orders.
Farewell to Nadia
The effect of Chaitanya’s action upon the Vaishnava community at Navadvip was overwhelming. So completely had he been the very life and soul of its activities, that his sudden renunciation of all he had held dear in the community came as a terrible blow, prostrating his followers. He was far more than the leader of a community of believers in Krishna; he had increasingly become the object of their devotion. Many had come to believe him an incarnation of Krishna, and were secretly paying him divine adoration. His personal charm had won the hearts of many outside the Vaishnava community, and his passionate devotion had become an asset of the entire community. There was a sense of common bereavement, therefore, in the loss of the Prabha—the master—from their midst, which was not unshared by those who had been least friendly to his movement.
This grief is found recorded in the literature of the sect. Many of the songs about Chaitanya, which soon came to be written by the hundred, dwelt upon the sorrow of his departure from Navadvip. In the hands of a skilful singer these songs never fail to touch the hearts of a Bengali audience, as the pathos of that deserted home, the bereft wife and mother, and the stricken disciples, is made to live again after four hundred years. The following, by Vasudeva Ghosh, one of the Chaitanya singers, are typical of these songs:
Coming to Sachi’s room, Vishnupriya sits
By the door. Slowly she speaks :
“He was in the sleeping room, but at the night’s end
He fied away. I am thunder-struck.”1516
Mother Sachi, sleepless with thought of Gauranga, arises
At her daughter-in-law’s word, with hair dishevelled
And garments falling. Quickly lighting a lamp,
She searches everywhere— but finds no trace.
Crying “Nimai!” Sachi calls aloud, while
Vishnupriya ‘weeps, beside her in the road,
“Call! Vishnupriya. Call the lord of your life !
While I cry Nimai, Nimai!”
Loudly wail the Nadia folk hearing
Her cry. Of every passer-by she inquires.
- A man advances, ten men accost him :
“Have you seen Gauranga going anywhere?”
Comes the reply, “I saw him running,
Alone, on the way to Kanchannagore.”
Basu says, “Alas, the pity! I fear
Lest my Gauranga Hart shaves his head!”
Why has he taken the danda17 and put on
The coloured cloth? For what has he shaven his head ?
Why with face like the moon does he cry,
“Radha, Radha”? Why leave his native place ?
Srivasa’s ery would melt a stone ; lifeless
Is Gadadhar’s heart ; like a river flow
The scalding tears from Mukunda’s eyes.
From house to house Love goes, enlightening
Each bhakta, but solaced is no one.
Why has he abandoned his wife, and cast off
Her caresses, a burning fire ?
How shall 1 speak of my sorrow—the soul’s
Unutterable pain? The heart breaks
For sight of him. Separation breeds in us all
A restlessness that makes day and night alike.
Basu Ghosh faints.
Very soon after the ceremony at Katwa, Chaitanya, with shaven head and wearing the saffron robe of the sannyasi, started out for Brindaban in a state of emotional excitement. Oblivious of surroundings, as he was, it was a comparatively easy matter for his disciples, by means of a simple ruse, to deceive him as to the route and to bring him to Santipur, where lived the venerable Advaitacharya. .
There in the latter’s home Chaitanya was prevailed upon to remain for a fortnight, holding a sort of farewell reception and a last glorious sankirtan with his friends and followers of Nadia. On receipt of the news they quickly assembled, bringing Chaitanya’s mother with them. Says the Charitamrita:
The Acharya, Sachi and all the bhaktas were full of joy. Every day the Acharya made a great mahotsava By day there was talk with the faithful of Krishna delights ; night after night they celebrated the mahotsava with saikirtan. Sachi, delighted, did the cooking, and the Master with his followers feasted happily . . . Sachi’s bliss increased as she gazed on her son’s face. In feasting him her joy was complete.18
An important decision was made during these days which affected Chaitanya’s whole future life. Before they separated, he yielded to his mother’s entreaties, and promised to make Puri his residence. Overcome by her storm of grief at the sight of his shaven head, Chaitanya promised never to abandon her completely, and left to her decision the whole matter of his residence. It was her suggestion that he should live at Puri in Orissa, whence news of him could be brought to her by pilgrims, and where it would be possible for the faithful at Nadia to visit him now and then. By this act Chaitanya barred himself from active participation in the project nearest his heart, the reclamation of the sacred sites at Brindaban.
The old familiar joys together could not go on without end, as the faithful would have desired. Repeatedly they had persuaded him to tarry a few days longer, but now the sorrowful leave-taking was at hand. Commending the care of the Nadia Vaishnavas to his host, Chaitanya now set out amid the general lamentations of his followers. Four disciples were detailed to accompany him, and with these he turned his face toward Puri.
Introduction to Puri
On his way through Orissa he visited several shrines sought out by pilgrims, and paid his devotions to the deities sacred in Vaishnava legend, not omitting a the festival ly the occasion of a great feast, graced by Saivite shrine or two. As they drew near to Puri the sight of the spire of the temple of Jagannath threw Chaitanya into ecstasies.
Atisight of Jagannath’s temple he became absorbed. Prostrating himself in love, he began to dance. His followers, as though The six-mile journey became a thousand p ne in ne
When they reached the temple Chaitanya’s feeling overcame him completely. He rushed forward in an attempt to embrace the image of Jagannath, and fell in a swoon before it. The custodians of the temple were on the point of beating him to arouse him, thinking him a mad man, when they were prevented by an onlooker. This was no less a personage than a famed Vedantist scholar and logician, Vasudeva Sarvabhauma, who had witnessed the scene with considerable interest. He had the still unconscious body of Chaitanya carried to his own home, where some hours elapsed before he came out of the trance.
This chance meeting in the temple led to the eventual conversion of the Vedantist to the enthusiastic religion preached by Chaitanya. S&arvabhauma, himself a Bengali of Navadvip and the founder of the Navya Nyaya school of logic, which was its chief claim to fame, was drawn to the young sannyasi by his beauty and the evident devotion of his life. The scholar sought first to make him a Vedantist, and then desired, as we have already noted, to introduce him into a higher order of sannyasis than the one in which Chaitanya had been initiated. For seven days the great pandit, who had been especially honoured by Pratapa Rudra, the king of Orissa, instructed the young sannyasi in the Vedanta, but without eliciting any response from him. Rather nettled by his failure to produce any impression on his hearer, Sarvabhauma pressed Chaitanya for his own opinions until the latter finally launched into an exposition of the Vaishnava principles, so diametrically opposed to the Vedanta. ‘The result of this discussion,19 according to the Charitamrita, was Sarvabhauma’s complete conversion to the Krishna-bhakti cult.
The account of this striking episode as given in our authority is enhanced by sectarian and magical elements that obscure the actual facts. We are told that the scholar is finally overwhelmed by a vision of Chaitanya’s deity, in which the young sannyasi reveals himself as Vishnu and Krishna. The record also makes Chaitanya expound pages of abstruse interpretations of the Sastras,20 which is little in keeping with the one consuming passion which had marked his life since his conversion to the life of bhakti. The truth probably is that Sarvabhauma was won to a living interest in bhakti by the powerful appeal of Chaitanya’s rapturous devotion and the charm of his personality. However the change may have been wrought, there is no room for doubt of the fact. The Vedantist pandit became a convert to bhakti, and took the youthful Chaitanya as his guru.
In the Sanskrit drama, Chaitanya-Chandrodaya, by Kavi Karnapura, the verses are given which Sarvabhauma wrote and sent to Chaitanya declaring his newfound faith. They are quoted in the Charitamrita:
The one, ever-ancient, Supreme Being who has taken form as Sri Krishna Chaitanya for the purpose of teaching the knowledge of non-attachment (vairagya vidya) and his own method of devotion (bhaktiyoga), his shelter 1 seek, the ocean of mercy; may, my mind like a bee cling closer and closer to his lotus-feet, Sri Krishna Chaitanya, who is born to restore his bhaktiyoga, destroyed by-time.21 The conversion of this veteran logician was a notable achievement for Chaitanya. Sarvabhauma was one of the most noted scholars of his time and a confirmed Vedantist. For such a man to turn from the pursuits of a life-time and become the disciple of a mere youth is rather uncommon, even in this land of religious devotion.
Sarvabhauma’s confession of faith throws interesting light upon the way in which men thought of Chaitanya. We have said that in Navadvip, among his devoted followers, even before his turning sannyasi, the belief had established itself that he was an incarnation of Krishna. This inclination to render divine homage to Chaitanya is attributed to his followers throughout the record. Considering his arresting personality this is not strange, among the rank and file of his followers. The history of Hinduism bears witness to the ease with which the popular Indian mind tends to explain unusually gifted and forceful religious personalities in terms of incarnation. We should expect this to a certain extent. But in the case of Sarvabhauma, we are dealing with a mind far above the ordinary. If in his confession we have a genuine document, and there is no reason to doubt it, it carries valuable confirmation of the powerful impression created by Chaitanya on the minds of his contemporaries, even at the beginning of his life
The Long Pilgrimage
After several months spent in Puri, Chaitanya started southward on a journey, ostensibly to search for his brother, but really to visit the shrines of the south. The record of this tour through southern and western India consists largely of descriptions of Chaitanya’s devotions at the various temples visited, and their effect upon the temple crowds. Miraculous incidents are frequently narrated, and a sectarian desire to enhance the wonder of his name is more in evidence than the effort to produce a clear and straightforward account of the pilgrimage. Many of the well-known temples of the present day appear in the record, the absence of others being due to the fact that they date from a later period. Not all of the places mentioned can be exactly identified. The record as it is given in the chief biography is confessedly not an accurate account kept during the pilgrimage, but represents the recollections of Chaitanya and his companion secured from them by his disciples afterward. In general, however, it is possible to trace the route followed.
Leaving Puri, Chaitanya visited the shrine of the Karmavatara,22 at Sri-Kurman, in the Telugu country, near Chicacole, and the temple of Narasimha,23 at Jiyad, near Narasapatnam Road, 46 miles south of Waltair. At Rajamundry, on the Godavari river, he bathed at a spot associated with the Buddha, and had a notable encounter with a high official. This was a gifted and pious man, Ramananda Ray by name, who was Governor of Rajamundry under the king of Orissa, and a devout and scholarly Vaishnava. In him Chaitanya discovered a kindred spirit, and the two were drawn to each other by instant attraction. Sarvabhauma had whetted Chaitanya’s interest by his praises of this unusual official, so that when the governor and the sannyasi met at the bathing ghat on the river bank, a remarkable scene ensued. The narrative thus describes it :
The Master knew at first sight that it was Ramananda Ray. His mind sprang forth to meet him, but restraining himself, he remained seated. Ramananda Ray, seeing the sannyasi, came forward. Chaitanya was lustrous like a hundred suns in the saffron cloth, his body handsome and well built, his eyes like the lotus. Ramananda was wonder-struck as he gazed, and approaching, he prostrated himself in lowly obeisance. The Master rose and said, “Stand up and cry ‘Krishna, Krishna.’” In his heart the Master was thirsting to embrace him, still he asked, “You are Ramananda Ray, are you not24” “Yes,” Ramananda answered, “Iam a low Sudra, a slave.” Then the Master clasped him tightly to him as spontaneous love arose in both alike ; in excess of feeling, Master and slave became unconscious. The two fell on the ground in each other’s embrace, stupefied, perspiring, weeping, trembling, with hair on end, colourless; from the mouth of each, thickly muttered, was heard “Krishna !”*
Truly here was a meeting of devotees worthy even of Chaitanya’s remarkable standards of emotion!
One of the most celebrated chapters in the Charitamrita is the account of the converse between these two as they sat on the banks of the Godavari. The theme was bhakti—Krishnabhakti—and the types, stages, qualities and passions of the love developed by the devotee in his adoration of the Lord. The peculiar tenets of the Bengal Vaishnavas are here set forth with a theological relish and precision that suggests more of the systematic theologian than the eager dialogue between two devotees. However that be, the two men became warmly attached to each other, and found unfailing delight in each other’s piety. Thus was added another to the circle of able men who came to look upon Chaitanya as their guru, and who remained faithful disciples all their lives. Among the very few works which Chaitanya had read to him daily in later years was a Sanskrit drama by this Ramananda Ray.
After this refreshing experience, Chaitanya proceeded on his way. He touched at shrines near Bezwada, and others about Cuddapah, visited various sacred sites in the Arcot district, and came to Conjeeveram, where he paid his devotions at Saivite as well as Vaishnava shrines. Chingleput, Chidambaram, the Cauvery river, Kumbakonam, the Tanjore neighbourhood, and the Srirangam temple near Trichnopoly were all visited. At Srirangam he spent four months consorting with Sri-Vaishnava Brahmans. From there he proceeded to the temple city of Madura, touching several points on the way, thence to Ramnad and the ancient shrine at Rameswaram. Returning to Madura, he then sought out many sites in the Tinnevelly district and came across to Trivandrum, visiting all the sacred places in the region of the extreme south. Through Travancore and Malabar he made his way up the west coast into the present Mysore State, where he visited the famous Sringeri matha25 founded by Sankaracharya. Continuing through the Kanarese country he came to Udipi, famous as the home of Madhva, founder of the system called by his name. The image of Krishna there had been installed by Madhva himself. Here Chaitanya spent many days, worshipping at this shrine and dis-coursing with the Madhvas over the essential Vaishnava doctrines. Pushing on up the coast he came to Kolhapur, and then to Pandharpur, the great centre of Vaishnava devotion in the Maratha country. Here he was rejoiced to meet a disciple of a guru of the same order as his own gurus, an ascetic who had been in Navadvip and had grateful memories of the pious hospitality of Chaitanya’s own parents. Going on from Pandharpur, he went north beyond Bombay as far as the Narbada river, and then turned and struck directly across central India, across what is now Hyderabad, following the Godavari and its tributaries until he came within the jurisdiction of the Governor of Rajamundry once more. After renewing his delightful converse with Ramananda Ray for several days, he returned to Puri amid the general rejoicing of his disciples after some twenty months of wandering.
Experiences by the Way
A certain catholicity is evident in Chaitanya’s pilgrim quest in keeping with his unconcern for orthodox rules of worship. He did not confine himself to Vaishnava shrines alone, but seems to have visited all the holy places wherever he was, regardless of their sectarian connections. Such, for instance, was his visit to the Sringeri matha of Sankaracharya, the greatest, of all names associated with that advaita26 philosophy which to the orthodox Vaishnava is anathema. Even the orthodox Charitamrita mentions repeatedly his visits to Siva shrines. It does not say more, but it is evident that to one of Chaitanya’s extreme sensibility the mere sight of any object to which people were making obeisance would stir in his breast those emotions of praise which for him constituted the heart of worship.
Two Vaishnava works, evidently new to Chaitanya, were discovered by him on this tour. He had copies made of each and brought them back with the utmost care, carrying them, the biographer says, ‘‘like two precious jewels.’ These works were the Brahma Samhita and the Krishnakarnamrita. Chaitanya spoke of these finds in superlative terms, and they were undoubtedly of great influence in the development of his thought. For this reason the account of these manuscripts is of very real interest. The Brahma Samhita was found in Travancore. It is known in Bengal only in fragmentary form, and it is not clear from what sect it sprang. It exalts the infinite glory and forms of Govinda (one of the names given to Krishna), which would seem to mark it as Nimbarkite, but nothing definite can be said about it. The Krishnakarnamrita was written by a Travancore Brahman, named Lilaguka Bilvamangala. Chaitanya found it at Pandharpur. It is believed to be a Vishnusvami work, because its teaching agrees with what little is known of Vishnusvami’s doctrinal point of view. The influence of these works on Chaitanya is reflected in the saying among his followers, to the effect that he founded his religion on the Karnamrita and his theology on the Brahma Samhita. It is significant also, that the theological work of the greatest theologians of the movement is founded upon the latter. It is clearly a mistake, however, to think that Chaitanya’s religious experience is based upon either of these works, for, as we have seen, that came to flower in the days of Navadvip, before he dreamed of being a sannyasi or had ever heard of these writings. The sources of his religious experience are clearly the Radha-Krishna songs of Jayadeva, Vidyapati and Chandi Das. What gave these new discoveries their hold upon him was that in them he found the passionate theme of the poets treated in definite works of devotion, with a background of theological interpretation which was probably quite new to him. We may say, then, that the finding of these works probably deepened and clarified his vivid experience, and marked the beginning of a definite theological interest. Whatever system Chaitanya bequeathed to his followers had its origin in the stimulus received from these manuscripts.
As we have indicated, the contagious effect of Chaitanya’s fervent devotions in shrine after shrine is the main theme and interest of the narrative. Wherever he went, this lover of Krishna sought to inspire men with the same bhakti which filled his own life to overflowing. Unfortunately, the record is so exaggerated as to appear grotesque at times. Were we to take it literally, we should have to believe the whole of south India converted to emotional faith in Krishna by the mere sight and sound of Chaitanya. Here, for example, is a typical passage:
As before, those who caught sight of him on the road, and the inhabitants of the villages he entered, all became Vaishnavas and cried, “Krishna, Hari.” These, spreading the movement to other villages, made them Vaishnava also. There were many kinds of people in the south : some wise, some religious, innumerable godless ; these all, through the Master’s influence, turned from their own creeds and became Vaishnava. Among the Vaishnavas, almost, all were worshippers of Rama, some being Madhvas, and some Sri Vaishnavas. At sight of the Mahaprabhu27 these all became worshippers of Krishna and sang his name.28 Equally irresistible was the might of his argumentation:
There were logicians, mimamsakas,29 Vedantists, and followers of the Samkhya, Patanjali,30 Smriti, Purana and the Vedas. They were all bold to uphold their own scriptures, but the Master, having pointed out their defects, demolished all their opinions ; everywhere he established Vaishnava doctrine and none could refute his conclusions. Defeated, they accepted the Master’s creed, and thus he made the whole south Vaishnava.’
One incident reveals (all unconsciously) a touch of broad humour. <A Buddhist professor, supported by a group of disciples, undertook to vanquish Chaitanya one day. But he proved himself more than their equal, and left them no philosophic foot on which to stand. Humiliated and smarting under their defeat, the Buddhists sought by a low stratagem to accomplish what their philosophy had failed to do. They offered a plate of unclean rice to Chaitanya, representing it to be prasada from a shrine of Vishnu. Before he could taste it a great bird swooped down and carried off the rice, plate and all. But as he rose the plate slipped out of his talons, caught the luckless professor squarely on the skull, neatly cleaving it. The unhappy disciples now clamoured for forgiveness and succour at Chaitanya’s feet, acknowledging his divinity. At his command they began to sing and shout the name Krishna in the ear of the senseless professor, whereupon he straightway rose up and joined in the shout, thus showing himself, we are to infer, a truly converted Vaishnava.31
After sufficiently discounting the exaggerations and the sectarian bias of our authority, we can arrive at a reasonable surmise as to the actual facts. There is nothing in the after history of the sect to indicate any following whatever in the south If there were any such wholesale conversion of communities it was a purely ephemeral thing, leaving nothing to show for it in later years. The truth these extravagant claims really seek to convey is that everywhere Chaitanya went crowds were deeply impressed by his evident devotion. Nowhere in the world are the common people so quick to render homage to religious sanctity as in-India. Chaitanya combined with the traditional sanctity of the sannyasi the powers of a gifted revivalist. The effect was tremendous. It is easy to believe that whole villages were stirred by the passionate intensity of his emotions, and, while under the spell, joined enthusiastically in his devotions. But this is very far from saying that these same villagers were changed from their various sectarian beliefs and practices into faithful Vaishnavas of the Chaitanya cult.
There were definite results from Chaitanya’s travels, however, that were not ephemeral. His devotion did leave a permanent impress on the Vaishnavism of the south land. It does not seem too much to say that his personal influence effected a general stimulation of Vaishnava sects wherever he went. In the Kanarese country, for example, we find that he is credited with helping to bring in a Vaishnava revival, the mendicant singers who popularised Krishna worship having received their inspiration, in part at least, from him.32
Joys of Bhakti in Puri
During the two years of Chaitanya’s absence from Puri, interest in him seems to have become quite general among the leading personages connected with the temple. This was doubtless a result of the prestige which the new type of religion gained through Sarvabhauma’s conversion. Returning to Puri after his extended travels, Chaitanya met with a rapturous welcome from the little group of his disciples, and also found the leading men of Puri assembled with Sarvabhauma, eager to pay him honour.
Another distinguished citizen of Puri who was consumed with desire to see the strange young sannyasi was no less a personage than Pratapa Rudra, the king of Orissa himself. He was a man of devout tendencies, whose natural interests led him to honour the scholar, Sarvabhauma, and to seek a man like Rama-nanda Ray for prime minister. Hearing of Chaitanya through these disciples, the king wished to meet him and acquaint himself at first hand with the strange power which, in so youthful a devotee, had proved more than sufficient to master the veteran scholar and the accomplished officer of State. The king’s desire, however, met an obstacle in Chaitanya himself. The ideals of the ascetic life were ever dear to him, although for its rules, oftentimes, he seemed little concerned. Since, for the true ascetic, kings were banned, Chaitanya would not consent to see Pratapa Rudra, and it was only through a ruse that the king won his way into the presence and acknowledged discipleship of the Nadia saint.
Upon the return of Chaitanya, his disciples despatched a messenger to Navadvip, in Bengal, bearing the joyful tidings to his mother and to the community of the faithful. In their eagerness to see Chaitanya, the Bengal Vaishnavas now organised the first of those annual pilgrimages to Puri that came to mean so much to the disciples in Bengal. Two hundred of them came to Puri at the time of the car festival of Jagannath, and spent a considerable period in Chaitanya’s company, in delightful fellowship and daily worship in the temple. A great deal of space in the biographies is taken in describing the welcome of the Bengal pilgrims, and the various joyful events of their stay. Their vociferous entrance into the city was watched by the king from the roof of the palace. The chanting of the Bengali songs by two hundred lusty throats, together with the joyful abandon of the pilgrims as they neared the presence of Chaitanya, filled the king with amazement; nor did the sight lessen his own desire to see the object of so much devotion.
One of the exploits of these days was the cleansing of a temple by Chaitanya and the Bengal pilgrims, in preparation for the car festival. This lowly act, assuming as they did for the time being the status of sweepers, was done as an act of devotion. On the day of the great festival, when the car of Jagannath conveys the image of the god from the main temple to another temple at some distance, Chaitanya with his followers performed great feats of sankirtan. This is the greatest day of the year at Puri, with huge crowds in attendance. The Vaishnavas were divided into seven bands, and performed continuous kirtan, encircling the car as it advanced. Chaitanya, in a perfect transport of emotion, went from one band to another, stimulating his followers to greater ecstasies.
With a roar the Master danced violently, whirling about in a circle like a fire-brand, till the very earth, with ocean and mountains, trembled at his tread. Stupefaction, perspiration, horripilation, tears, trembling, pallor, helplessness of all sorts, pride, exultation, humility—all these were seen. Stumbling he fell to the ground, and rolled there like a golden mountain.
In the midst of the wild dance a strange delirium came upon the Master. At the same moment all eight kinds of sd/#vé& emotion were stirred within him. His hair stood on end, with flesh and skin all bristly like a Simul tree full of thorns. People were struck with fear to see such clashing of his teeth, thinking they would surely fall out. From his whole body ran sweat mixed with blood, while with choked voice he stammered incoherently. His tears fell like water from a fountain until the bystanders were wet. The beauty of his fair-complexioned body was now like saffron, now like the lustre of the mallika bloom. At one moment he seemed stupefied, the next he rolled on the ground ; now his hands and feet were motionless like dried sticks, again he lay prone on the ground almost bereft of breath. Seeing this the disciples were weak with fear. At times water fell from eyes and nose, and froth from his mouth, just as a stream of nectar flows from the arc of the moon. .. .
As he gazed at the lotus-face of Jagannath—its beautiful eyes sparkling in the sunlight, its garland, cloth, ornaments and perfumes— there welled up in the Master’s heart an ocean of delight. A storm of frenzy seized him there, and waves of feeling arose in him in mad delight. Like to an army was the warfare of his varied emotions. . . .
All hearts and minds were attracted by the sight, and the Master’s love-nectar bedewed the minds of all. All the attendants of Jagannath, the king and his officials, pilgrims, the Puri residents, all alike were amazed at the sight of the Master’s dance and love. Love to Krishna flooded the hearts of all.?
It is not strange that when the great car reached its destination, Chaitanya and his companions were exhausted with their exertions, and lay ‘‘overcome with love,’ as the biographer puts it.
After four months had elapsed Chaitanya sent the Bengal pilgrims home, expressly commissioning33
Advaitacharya and Nityananda to preach the religion of bhakti in Bengal, even to the lowest castes. For three years this annual migration took place, Chaitanya’s life at Puri otherwise being an uneventful round of daily worship at the temple.
The Brindaban Pilgrimage
From the very beginning of his absorption in Vaishnavism, Chaitanya had cherished an ardent desire to see Brindaban, the holy city of Krishna-worshippers. His first thought on becoming a sannyasi was to make this pilgrimage, but, as we have seen, the guile of his followers defeated this plan. Each year at Puri he had planned to make the journey, but was induced to postpone his departure from season to season, at the urgent entreaty of King Pratapa and the growing company of his disciples and admirers.
Now, after the departure of his Bengali disciples after their third annual visit, two years after his return from the southern tour, Chaitanya set out for Brindaban. He left Puri accompanied by a large band of disciples, and under the escort of royal officers despatched by the king to insure his safety and comfort. At the king’s command every river crossed in his kingdom was marked by a pillar set up at the ford, in order that the spot might henceforth be observed as a tirtha, a sacred place. Special provision for the welfare of the disciples was made along the route, and quantities of pri a were sent on from Puri to feed the whole company for several days.
In this manner he was brought into Bengal, and from there on his course was attended by crowds of his countrymen as far as a village named Ramkeli, near Gaur, the ancient capital in north Bengal. en route he stopped at Santipur, near Navadvip, and here rejoiced his mother by a visit. It is characteristic that he begged at her feet for permission to make the Brindaban pilgrimage. At Ramkeli two remarkable men entered his discipleship of whom we shall hear more later. They were two brothers, Sakar Mallik and Dabir Khas by name, high officials in the Muhammadan court at Gaur. They had been Maratha Brahmans of princely descent, whose’ancestors had migrated to Bengal. These two had risen to influence and great wealth in the Moslem service, and had themselves adopted the faith of Islam. It would seem that they were spiritually unsatisfied, for, when Chaitanya reached their part of the country, they sought him out and were immediately drawn to him. They became his followers, and from that time secretly sought means of abandoning their worldly eminence for the ascetic life. Under the names Ripa and Sanatana, given them by Chaitanya, these men were destined to play a leading part in the movement. Of this meeting Chaitanya says :*
With great difficulty I came to Ramkeli village, where two brothers came to me, Rupa and Sanatana by name. They were kings among bhaktas, objects of Krishna’s mercy, prime minister and governor by profession, of the highest proficiency in knowledge, devotion and wisdom, and yet counting themselves lowly as the grass. The sight of this humility would melt a stone. I was pleased and said to them, “Although of high station, count yourselves very lowly, ere long Krishna will release you.” Speaking thus I bade them farewell, when on my going, Sanatana spoke a riddle: ‘‘Accompanied by a million men, is this the right way to go to Brindaban34’
Aroused by this frank criticism from his new disciple, Chaitanya concluded that such a popular procession from village to village, ‘like a travelling showman,’ as he himself put it, was hardly the sort of pilgrimage to be expected of a humble mendicant.
Upon the conclusion of the rainy season, he sated He therefore gave up his plan and returned to Pur
out once more, but this time he stole away secretly with one Brahman follower and sought out unfrequented ways. At Benares he stopped for ten days with two Bengali disciples, but his presence made little impression on this centre of Siva-worship and Vedantism. The jibe of the leading Vedantist, to the effect that Chaitanya was only a trader in emotionalism and would find no market in Benares for his wares, seemed to have stated the truth.35 On reaching the sacred Yamuna river (the modern Jumna) he dashed headlong into it in ecstasy, and had to be rescued by his companion. This occurred repeatedly. ‘“‘On the way to Mathura, wherever he halted, he made the people dance to Krishna’s loved name.’”’ At Mathura, which is associated with Brindaban in the sacred legends of Vaishnavism, Chaitanya visited all the holy sites and bathed at the twenty-four different ghats.
All the while, as he approached the scenes of Krishna’s exploits, his emotions grew in intensity, until his companion became fearful of the result. Even the neck of a peacock was sufficient toe send him into a swoon, the dark colours reminding him of Krishna. Qn catching sight of Govardhan hill, near Brindaban, he was so affected that he threw himself on the ground, clasping the very rocks in frenzy. Finding two shallow pools in a rice field he bathed in them rapturously, thinking them the pool where Krishna dallied with Radha in the water. In this manner he visited all the holy sites round about Brindaban, as far as they were discovered. At this time there was nothing of the modern Brindaban; even the sites of sacred history and legend had been lost and forgotten. However, Chaitanya’s Nadia friend and disciple, Lokanatha, had been living here for some years now ; and at the period of this visit other disciples were there, although the record makes no mention of their presence. During these days, Chaitanya lived in such a continuous state of emotional excitement that he was practically unaccountable for himself.
Finally, after another experience of fishing his master senseless out of the water of the Yamuna, the Brahman companion decided that a change of scene was advisable. Chaitanya was persuaded to start for Prayaga (Allahabad), but he was so overcome at the thought of leaving Brindaban that he became unconscious and was carried away in that condition.
As they travelled along the Ganges, Chaitanya’s emotions nearly cost him the lives of his followers, although, as it turned out, the final result was a group of new disciples. While resting one day in a shady spot, the sight of a herd of cows filled his mind with a flood of thoughts about the scenes of Krishna’s exploits. Suddenly a cowherd began to play upon the flute, and Chaitanya immediately went into a swoon, foaming at the mouth and giving every appearance of being at death’s door. Unfortunately, at this moment a troop of Pathans happened upon the scene, and promptly concluded that they had found a band of robbers and their drugged victim. The hapless disciples were bound, and might have had short shrift, had Chaitanya not revived and commenced to dance joyously with uplifted hands, chanting the name of Hari. The Pathans now realised the character of the sannyasi, and, in great awe at his devotion, quickly released the disciples, but accused them of poisoning Chaitanya. He readily explained the situation, and then entered into a religious discussion with one of the Pathans who was something of a holy man himself. The Moslems tried to win Chaitanya to the faith of Islam, but in the end they themselves turned Vaishnava and became disciples of Chaitanya. They were known thereafter as the Pathan Vaishnavas. One of them, according to the account, a young prince named Bijuli Khan, became an ascetic widely known for his sanctity.
From Brindaban they came to Prayaga where Chaitanya spent several days at the Kumbha mela, the great bathing festival. Here he was joined by one of the two new disciples from the Moslem court in Bengal, whom we have described. This man, Ripa, had relinquished his post, rid himself of all his3637 wealth except sufficient for his family’s welfare, and then gone in search of Chaitanya. Another interesting visit at this point was from Vallabhacharya, the founder of the Vaishnava sect of that name. At Benares Ripa’s brother, Sanatana, arrived. He had been thrown into prison by the Sultan of Bengal, to prevent him from leaving his service, but had escaped and left everything for the sake of Chaitanya. On these two men, according to the record, Chaitanya spent much time, teaching them the doctrines of the bhakti cult. Six long chapters of the principal book of the Charitamrita are devoted to detailed theological exposition, which he is represented as teaching the two brothers. They were commissioned to settle at Brindaban and spend their lives as recluses, searching out the forgotten sites sacred to the Krishna faith and teaching its doctrines by word and pen.
During this stay in Benares, Chaitanya came into more successful contact with the Brahman pandits than before. The most striking result of this was the conversion to Vaishnavism of Prakasananda Sarasvati, the leading Vedanta scholar of the city. When Chaitanya had first come to Benares, this pandit had scoffed at him in these terms:
I have heard of a sannyasi in the country of Gaur, a sentimentalist, one of Kesava Bharati’s disciples, and a deceiver. Chaitanya is his name. With his sentimental crowd he goes dancing from place to place and village to village, and all who see him in his ecstasy, call him god. His bewitching art is such that all are charmed at sight of him. The great scholar, Sarvabhauma Bhattacharya has gone mad after Chaitanya,I hear. He is only a sannyasi in name; much more a great magician! His sentimentality will not sell at Kasi.’ Listen to the Vedanta ; don’t go to him. With that wild man is destruction in both
This is the man who now surrendered to the sentimentality he had denounced. He was a recruit worthy to rank with Sarvabhauma; and his conversion to the bhakti cult is an added commentary upon the remarkable power possessed by Chaitanya to touch and move the hearts of men.38
From Benares the return to Puri was made by unfrequented ways, with one attendant only.
The Last Years at Puri
Chaitanya never again left Puri. Although in commissioning his followers to settle and preach at Brindaban, he repeatedly expressed the wish that such could have been his own lot, yet it is clear that he accepted his mother’s word as determining his residence for life at Puri. Having once visited the sacred sites, he gave himself to a life of worship at Puri, and left to his disciples the great work he had hoped to do himself.
The remaining seventeen or eighteen years of his life were uneventful. With a chosen few about him he settled down to the routine of life in the temple city. Each year the Bengal contingent spent several months at Puri, which served to break the monotony somewhat. But, apart from the occasional visits of scholar ascetics and disciples, the even tenor of Chaitanya’s life as a recluse was unbroken. There is singularly little in the record with which to fill out the story of these last years. Small incidents, and descriptions of Chaitanya’s emotions make up the narrative. He was constantly attended by a small group of disciples, who read and sang to him much of the day and superintended all the details of the daily worship, bathing, etc. As the years went on, Chaitanya became increasingly incapable of caring for himself. The extreme emotional demands made upon his nervous system for so many years could not but result in growing instability and disorder. No human organism could stand the strain put upon it by Chaitanya’s experiences. Although there is no satisfactory record of the last days, what there is indicates a state of nervous disorder characterised by stupor, trances and wild outbursts of frenzied delirium, showing only too clearly the approaching utter collapse of a mind and body strained to the break-
The end of the saint is unknown. His principal biographers have drawn a veil over the death of their master. Legends there are of his disappearance in temple and image, but of the fact there is no certainty.
One of the less reliable of the biographies—the Chaitanya Mangala, by Jayananda—gives the date of his death as July, 1534, and attributes it to a wound in the foot, which brought on fever resulting in death. This may be the fact. However, the common supposition that the end came by drowning in the ocean during one of his fits of ecstasy has a great deal of probability in its favour, considering the many times Chaitanya was rescued from just such a death. The body was probably buried in the temple by the priests, and the miraculous tales that arose, of the mester’s disappearance in various images, were doubtless created and encouraged by them for purposes of revenue.39
Chaitanya’s Contribution to the Sect
Ir will be helpful at this point, before we pass on to consider the development of the sect, to gather up and enumerate those influences which made Chaitanya’s distinctive contribution to the movement which bears his name. We shall not attempt to determine exactly or exhaustively the full extent of that contribution ; but we can indicate at least the main lines of influence, and thus gain a clearer understanding of his relation to the sect.
The Impress of His Character and Personality
In the potent influences emanating from Chaitanya’s personality we have already seen the real origin of the sect. The materials, indeed, were not of his making; they had existed for generations in Bengal in the persons of Vaishnava adherents. But his was the spirit that took these elements of a common faith and fused them in the fire of his own burning devotion, until they came out a new creation—a living movement full of his own energy. Others took and organised what the master spirit had evolved, and gave it a form by which to perpetuate itself. But nothing in all the subsequent years of the movement has been able to efface the stamp put upon it in its origin by the personality of Chaitanya.
The marks of that initial influence are to be seen in various ways. It is clearly evident, first, in the leadership with which the movement started. We have seen how it was Chaitanya’s magnetism that drew to himself and his cause strong men who gave themselves to its faith and fortune. Such were the Brindaban Gosvamis, who created the theology of the sect with such outstanding power. Such were the Vedantist scholar, Vasudeva Sarvabhauma, Ramananda Ray, the minister of state, and the powerful king, Pratapa Rudra himself, whose adherence to Chaitanya gave the movement standing throughout Orissa. Such an one was Nitya-nanda, sannyasi and devotee of another sect, until he came under the master influence that fired his mind and set him at the task that has made his name a power in Bengal ever since.
The influence of Chaitanya is further seen in the fact that the greatest development of the sect followed the lines of his own deepest interests. The zealous spirit which carried it throughout Bengal and Orissa within two generations of his death was no other than the spirit which he infused into the little group of followers in Nadia. Similarly, it was his fixed idea about Brindaban and his earnestness in inspiring others with his own vision, that gave that great chapter to the history of the sect. Had it not been for his enthusiasm on the subject of the recovery of the sacred sites, it is hardly likely that Bengal Vaishnavism would have had any connection whatsoever with the modern development of Brindaban.
The Vaishnava character is still another fact in evidence of Chaitanya’s influence. A certain type has characterised the best spirits of the sect all through the years. Its standard is the character of Chaitanya himself, whose outstanding qualities were humility, passion for God, joyousness and devotion. There are a few Sanskrit Slokas which are quoted in the chief biography as Chaitanya’s own writing.40 The best known of these, oft quoted by Vaishnavas, is to this effect :
Humbler than the grass, more patient than a tree, honouring others yet without honour oneself—such a one is ever worthy to take the name of Hari. This bears the hall-mark of Chaitanya’s spirit and may well be his own verse. The inculcation of this spirit of humility has marked the sect at all times. The common use by a large number of Vaishnava writers of the term Das (servant) instead of their own names, thus effectually obliterating their own individualities, is an illustration of the reality of this teaching and its practice.41 With the other distinctive traits of the Vaishnava character as well, it is true to say that they have been cultivated after the likeness of the character of Chaitanya.
Finally, Chaitanya’s influence is manifested in the persistence of the most characteristic feature of the sect. It is precisely the same to-day as that which sprang up in that spontaneous outpouring of song in the Navadvip courtyard under the magic touch of the young Gauranga. The sankirtan was the natural expression of that group. So it remains to-day the natural expression of any Vaishnava gathering. Indeed, a gathering of Vaishnavas without the sankirtan is unthinkable. It would not be itself. The plaintive refrain, the swinging chorus, the shouting, the clangor of the familiar drum and cymbal, the swaying bodies and uplifted hands, who does not connect these things with Chaitanya Vaishnavism as surely as the kneeling figure on the Calcutta office jaun42 at sunset is associated with
The Power or His Religious Experience
The emotional fervour, which required for its expression the strenuous exertions of Chaitanya’s sankirtan and dance, was a new element in Vaishnavism, at least in north India
This statement is true in spite of the fact that the Bhagavata Purana has much to say about singing praises to Krishna. It is not asserted that Chaitanya created the kirtan, for it was known long before his day. It is true to say, however, that he transformed it. None of the other sects based upon the Bhagavata Purana developed anything comparable to the Nadia outburst. We may rightly speak of it, therefore, as a new contribution to bhakti; and its continuance in the sect after Chaitanya marked off the Bengal Vaishnavas as possessing a distinct characteristic. The possession of emotional capacities like Chaitanya’s would have marked a man in any sect, but enlisted in the service of a faith like the bhakti cult, the result could hardly fail to be extraordinary. Here lay the secret of its great appeal to the heart of the common people. Chaitanya wrought upon their feelings until the contagion of his own fervent bhakti swept them off their feet. As the Bengalis are a people in whom the emotional element is strong, this type of appeal was peculiarly fitted to evoke a popular response. It was this aroused emotional power of the group, finding vent through the Kirtan in its various forms, that became so effective a propagandist agency. Thus the very power of the movement to propagate itself lay in the immense vitality of Chaitanya’s religious experience.
A further evidence of the effect of his experience is seen in the new spirit which he imparted to asceticism. He brought into it an element of joy ousness that lit up the sombre and forbidding aspect that Indian asceticism usually wears. The lyric strain that was such an ineradicable element in Chaitanya’s devotion, and the emotions of his heart so easily stirred to overflowing— these endowments of a generous nature could not be changed or subdued by the assumption of the yellow robe and the mendicant’s bowl. To the end of the day Chaitanya remained a minstrel of Hari, with a song in his heart and the lilt of it ever upon his lips. How far this spirit was perpetuated in the ascetic order of the sect, among the vairagis,43 it is not possible to say. But it is easy to believe that a real measure of the same spirit has characterised these men down through the years. Certainly song appears to be their chief characteristic to-day, even in their degradation, and the ever-present ektara,44 and the even cruder gopiyantra, simple instruments of one string, remain as humble symbols of the lyric quality that was the glory of their master’s life.
Another effect of his religious experience upon the sect is a most interesting and important one. This has to do with the way in which Chaitanya’s whole life soon came to be the norm by which the songs about Radha and Krishna were interpreted. This will be dealt with when we come to the literature of the sect. Suffice it here to say that, as the years went by, men saw with increasing clearness that Chaitanya’s life was a drama of the eternal longing of the human soul for the Infinite. This was also the interpretation that came to be put upon the Brindaban legends, whereby the too-evident sensuousness of the poetry glorifying Krishna’s amours was sought to be transmuted into a spiritual allegory of the divine love. So it came about quite naturally that the life of the master was used to illustrate and interpret the literature of the movement. This is the meaning of the Gaurachandrika, an invocation to Chaitanya, which is invariably sung at the beginning of kirtan. The singer sings the story of some incident in the life of Chaitanya revealing his passion for Krishna, and this provides the key for the proper understanding of the Radha-Krishna songs which follow.
Social Consequences or His Bhakti
It is hardly accurate to write of Chaitanya in terms of social reform, or to credit him with a revolutionary social vision. Indeed, it is difficult to come at the truth in describing his influence in this respect, for his life and teaching had manifold social effects which lend plausibility to the assertions sometimes made about the social reformation wrought by him. It seems perfectly clear, however, that Chaitanya was not concerned with the reform of Hindu society. His sole interest was religion, and it is only as his religious experience, and that engendered by him among others, came into conflict with the Hindu social system that he can be called a social reformer. His social reform, so-called, was only a by-product of his bhakti.
The social consequences of his religious experience came from the catholicity of his bhakti. He recognised no limits whatever to be set to this absorbing experience, and the participation of men in it. Such breadth of view was vastly disturbing to orthodox Hinduism. That all men could find a place in common religious worship and be counted as equal in the attitude of devotion, was startling and revolutionary. Indeed, many sayings are attributed to Chaitanya which seem to transcend the caste system altogether, although the authenticity of all such teaching is not certain by any means. This attitude, on the other hand, is balanced by clear evidence of social orthodoxy. When we come to the study of this phase of Chaitanya’s teaching, we shall see that he did not consistently set himself against the caste system.
It is perfectly clear, however, that he went far beyond the customs and ideas of his time in the direction of a brotherhood of bhakti. He accepted converts from Islam freely, and one of the earliest of his disciples was a Muhammadan faqir,’ Haridas by name, who attained to great sanctity in the sect and was buried by Chaitanya’s own hands at Puri. We have already seen how the two disciples, Ripa and Sanatana, who were raised to the highest positions of honour as scholars of the sect, were utterly outcasted from Hindu society as renegade converts to Islam when Chaitanya met them. He repeatedly proclaimed his bhakti as being accessible to the lowest classes of Hindu society. In short, it may be said that he had courage to preach a message of religious freedom which made a place for all in its cult of loving devotion. Naturally, this gave his movement a tremendous appeal to the hearts of the common people. To this day the
2? Ascetic, corresponding to the sadhu or vairagi of Hinduism. humble people of Bengal sing such songs as Dr, Sen heard among the sweepers in Tipperah, the burden of which was, ‘‘Come, and see the god-man who does not believe in caste.45
However, it is a question, which is the more striking, the opening of the portals of bhakti to all castes, or the sheer simplicity of the requirements of the new faith. Nothing was demanded of men but what they could give; high and low, rich and poor, without rite or ceremony, all alike were swept in on the wings of song. The one requisite was the chanting of the sacred name. It was a religious worship in which the humblest, the most ignorant, and the poorest of all could join. This simplification of religion was an achievement which had its social reverberations also, for it boded ill for the vested priestly interests. It was an emancipation of the common man from ecclesiastical tyranny, that would have been a social as well as a religious triumph could it have persisted. Temple-worship remained, of course. It was ingrained in Vaishnavism, and occupied a very large place in the practice of Chaitanya and of his followers. Butin the flowering of the movement, in the enthusiastic days in Navadvip, the heart of it, certainly, was the sankirtan. It was the essential and for the time being it seems to have been all-sufficient. These things must ever stand to Chaitanya’s credit. In the midst of a priest-ridden, caste-bound society, this man, by the expansive power of his own emotional experience, was led to inaugurate a popular religious movement which for a time freed the commonalty of men from the ancient thraldom of the law book and the priest, and led them into a common fellowship of devotion.
The full consequences of this teaching form part of the history of the sect. It is probable that Chaitanya neither foresaw them nor was in full sympathy with the steps taken by some of his followers in carrying out the logical implications of his own teaching.’ But it does not detract from the significance of those implications that he failed to recognise them himself. They were the elements that gave the movement its note of liberating power in its best days. Even in its later days of deterioration, this note has never entirely departed from the sect.
1In his latest book, Chaitanya and His Age, Dr. Sen argues eloquently for the view that Chaitanya himself was the guiding spirit in all the social measures undertaken by Nityananda in Bengal. ‘Nityananda was appointed by him to stay in Bengal with the sole charge of social reformation ; Chaitanya had found the caste system eating into the vitals of our social fabric, and he and his followers were determined to root out the evil from the land’ (pp. 278-79). “Thus we see that he was behind the great machinery of social reformation set on foot, guided and controlled by him at every stage of the advancement of the cause of Vaishnavism in this great province ” (p. 287). With the utmost admiration for Dr. Sen’s great learning, and deep feeling for Chaitanya, 1 am persuaded that this is a misreading of the story, and that the view set forth in the text comes nearer to the truth. Evidence for this point of view will be given in succeeding chapters.
Notes
- An ascetic who has renounced all connection with the world.
- The food offered to the idol ina temple. It is afterward distri- buted among and eagerly received by the worshippers.
- Owing to the fact of his father-in-law’s name being Vallabha- charya, it has been stated in various English works that Chaitanya was son-in-law to the founder of the Vallabhacharyas; and, because of this fact, a relationship has been traced between the two sects. This is pure fiction, as Chaitanya’s father-in-law was a Nadia house- holder, while the founder of the Vallabhacharyas was not only from the Deccan, but was a contemporary of Chaitanya himself.
- Renunciation of the world to become a wandering mendicant, the last of the four stages of life prescribed for the Brahman.
- A ceremonial offering to the spirit of the departed, a relic of ancestor worship. ? Religious teacher and guide, necessary for every earnest Hindu, at least of the sects. He receives initiation from the guru, and Teverences him as God.
- Gauranga, Vol. 1, p. 124.
- It is interesting that Chaitanya himself, in later Gays, described his trances as due to epileptic fits, See, for instance, C4.Ch., xviii, p. 326,
- Sarkar, Chaitanya’s Life and Teachings, 2nd Edn., xi-xii. This is an English translation of the middle section of the Chattanyq
- Literally town-praise, i.e. the chorus of song and praise carried into the streets and turned into a procession,
- A primitive sort of dramatic performance without a stage.
- Gosvami, literally “‘ cow-lord,” is a word whose original meaning and reference are not clear.
- has come to be used as a title in the Vaishnava sects. Among Chaitanyas it denotes an authoritative religious teacher, one who, in theory at least, is descended from one of the original disciples of Chaitanya.
- Same as kirtan. Ca.M., Ul, p. 85.
- The one who initiates a disciple into the life of a sannyasi, as compared with the guru who gives diksha, or initiation into the sectarian faith.
- Ch.Ch., II, vi, p. 183. Cf. Ch.Bh., IH, 3, p. 244.
- From the collection of Vasudeva’s poems in the Bangiya Sahitya Parishat, Calcutta.
- The staff of a sannyasi.
- Grand festival. Usualk
- Ch.Ch., II, v, p. 180. Cf. Ch.Bh., IIL, 2, p. 240,
- Sastra is the name given the law-books in verse, such as the code of Manu, the Manava Dharmasastra. From this it has come to mean the sacred scriptures generally.
- Ch.Ch., II, v, p. 194, Cf, also Ch.Bh., IIL, 3, p. 246,
- The Tortoise, the second of the traditional ten incarnations of Vishnu.
- The Man-lion, the fourth incarnation of Vishnu,
- Ch.Ch., II, viii, pp. 202-3,
- Monastery. The Bengali term commonly used is aé/rd.
- Non-dualism. An absolute monism, conceiving the individual soul as identical with Brahman.
- The great master, commonly used of Chaitanya. Ch.Ch., I, ix, p. 223.
- Students of the Karma Mimarsa, the first of the six orthodox systems of philosophy.
- The author of the Yoga system.
- Ch.Ch., II, ix, p. 225.
- Ch.Ch., II, ix, p. 225.
- Rice, History of Kanarese Literature, pp. 12, 59. Also Farquhar, 0.2.L./., p. 303. Another interesting piece of evidence points to definite influence in the Maratha country which links the famous Tukarima with Chaitanya. Tukarama, who was born more than a century after Chaitanya, refers in one of his abhangs (No. 80, p. 31, The Poems of Tukéréma, Vol. 1, edited by J. Nelson Fraser ; see also note on p. 404) to three Krishna-worshippers as his teachers. These men were Raba Chaitanya, Kesava Chaitanya and Raghava Chaitanya, and are referred to as followers of the Bengal saint. The fact that all three bear this name would seem to lend weight to the supposition that Chaitanya left behind him in the Maratha country an influence that did not die away.
- Ch.Ch., II, xiii, pp. 268-72.
- Ch.Ch., 11, xvi, p. 306.
- See below p. 49,
- Ch.Ch., II, xviii, pp. 325-26. Considering the tenacity with which Moslems cling to their faith, this story on the face of it seems open to doubt. But it has had a wide currency, and evidently had some basis in fact. Dr. Sen, in his University lectures (C.C., p. 282), accepts the story as it stands.
- This festival, of very great sanctity, is marked by a huge gathering of ascetics. It is held at the confluence of the Ganges and the Jumna rivers, at Allahabad, once every 12 years.
- Ch.Ch., II, xvii, p. 312.
- See C.H.A., p. 259, for a discussion of this point. See also a discussion of the various theories in Si Gauranga, by Bhudhar ry ret ad Bharati, p. 488. This is a useful life of Chaitanya
- Ch.Ch., TH, xx, pp. 598-600.
- BLL, p. 570,
- Enclosed carriage with a flat top,
- From vairagya, absence of passion,
- See illustration facing p. 215.
- H.B.L.L., p. 462. Very definite qualifications of the social freedom preached by Chaitanya require to be considered. For a fuller discussion of this social teaching see p. 118.
Source
Melville T. Kennedy, M.A., The Chaitanya Movement: A Study of the Vaishnavism of Bengal. The Religious Life of India series. Calcutta: Association Press (Y.M.C.A.), 5 Russell Street; London, New York, Toronto, Melbourne, Bombay, Madras and Calcutta: Humphrey Milford, Oxford University Press, 1925. Chapters II, III and IV. This article is from public domain digital sources.
Disclaimer
We have made every effort to reproduce this text faithfully, but we cannot guarantee that it is free of errors. Readers who need accuracy for study or citation should check the original publication. The views and language are those of the author and his time, and e-Scriptures is not responsible for them.
Spelling and style follow the original; obvious scanning and typographical errors have been corrected. This text is believed to be in the public domain in the United States, where this website is operated. Copyright terms differ from country to country, so a text that is free of copyright in the United States may still be protected elsewhere. Readers outside the United States should check the copyright laws of their country before copying, downloading or reusing it; they are responsible for lawful use in their own country. See our Terms of Use.
The author was a Christian missionary writing in a series for Christian readers, and writes of Indian religion from that standpoint, in the language of his time.