Skip to content

Bhakti Sects of Medieval India

by J. N. Farquhar, from An Outline of the Religious Literature of India (1920)

Summary: Three selections from J. N. Farquhar’s survey of the religious literature of India, in his numbered sections. The first is on the Bhagavata community, the commentary of Sridhara Svami on the Bhagavata Purana and the Maratha bhaktas. The second is on the Vallabhacharyas, the sect that worships Krishna. The third is on Kabir and the sects derived from him. Farquhar’s remarks on the sects are given as he wrote them, from a missionary standpoint.

The Bhagavatas

The Bhagavata Community

§ 356. Probably about A.D. 1400, Sridhara Svami, Mahant of the Sankarite monastery, Govardhana, in Puri, wrote a commentary on the Bhagavata P., the Bhagavata Bhavartha Dipika, which is by far the most famous exposition of the work. He was clearly an excellent scholar, and he must have had access to a very trustworthy tradition. He begins his commentary with the distinct statement that the great Purana was not written by Vopadeva. The fact that this theory was already current proves that Sridhara wrote at a time considerably later than A.D. 1300, when Vopadeva flourished. As the commentary was well known everywhere by the end of the fifteenth century, Sridhara’s floruit may reasonably be placed about A.D. 1400. His interpretation of the Purana is advaitist, since he was a follower of Sankara ; and since the Bhagavata itself tends to be monist, his Dipika is usually regarded as most authoritative.

The Purana was translated into many languages, either completely or partially, during the period. It appeared in Telugu and Bengali in the fifteenth century, in Braj and Persian in the sixteenth, in Marathi and Kanarese about A.D. 1600, in Gujarati and Malayalam in the seventeenth century, and in Hindi in the nineteenth.

A sectarian bhashya on the Vedanta-sutras, which is called the Suka Bhashya, and which purports to be a Bhagavata work, seems to have been written late in this period. Its standpoint is Visishtadvaita, and the texts used to establish the teaching of the bhashya are drawn from the Bhagavata P., Upanishad texts being cited only as subsidiary evidence. The author is called Sukacharya, and is said to have been the founder of the Bhagavata monastery at Talkad in Mysore, but the work is probably pseudonymous. It is a suspicious circumstance that a Bhagavata bhashya should be not advaita but visishtadvaita. Further, no Sukacharya appears in the guruparampara of Talkad, nor yet among the gurus of the Matha of Mulubazil, the only other Bhagavata monastery in Mysore, while the authorities of both monasteries refuse to recognize the Suka Bhashya as a Bhagavata work.1

The Bhagavatas, being both Smartas and devotees of Vishnu, occupied from the first rather an unstable position between the orthodox and the sects, and their acceptance of the Bhagavata P. deepened the difficulty for them. The results are visible in their history. In the Mysore and the Tamil south they are a scattered community possessing very few temples of their own and only a few monasteries. They worship in Sri-Vaishnava temples but distinguish themselves from Sri-Vaishnavas by wearing the ancient sect-mark, a single upright line of cream-coloured gopichandana,2 and by using the Bhagavata mantra.3 Occasionally individual Bhagavatas pass over to the Sri-Vaishnava community. In the Kanarese country on the western coast they still maintain themselves, although greatly outnumbered by Madhvas, and have a number of temples. Throughout these wide areas they still venerate Siva as well as Vishnu, observe Vedic rites, and are recognized as Smartas. They recognize no commentary on the Bhagavata except Sridhara’s. All the other sects dependent on the Bhagavata P. have experienced the same difficulty of maintaining the Vedic position, and most are in consequence now frankly sectarian.

Maratha Bhaktas

§ 357. There seems to have been an interval of quite a century after Jnanesvara before another star of any magnitude arose among the Maratha Bhagavatas. The next notable singer is Namdeva. There is a local tradition to the effect that he and Jnanesvara met at least once, while in the Bhakta-mala they are regarded as master and disciple. In consequence of this Namdeva has usually been placed at the end of the thirteenth, and the beginning of the fourteenth century, but his Marathi is of such a character that Sir Ramakrishna Bhandarkar is inclined to date him a century later.4 Now, a number of his hymns occur in the Sikh Granth, and he is regarded as one of a few bhaktas who, coming just before Ramananda, prepared the way for him. There seems to be sufficient evidence to show that Ramananda flourished in the second and third quarters of the fifteenth century ; so that Namdeva’s floruit would be somewhere about 1400 to 1430. Mr. Balesvar Prasad, who is a most careful student of Hindi literature, gives5 A.D. 1423 as his floruit, which agrees perfectly with the above reasoning and with Sir Ramakrishna’s conjecture. This chronology is finally established by one of Namdeva’s own abhangs, ‘Gone are the saints’,6 which makes it absolutely clear that Jnanesvara and his saintly companions lived long before him. He was a tailor, shimpi by birth and occupation, but he spent his life propagating bhakti in the Maratha country and in the Punjab. In his verse the influence of Islam first appears in the Maratha country. He and those who followed him criticized idolatry with some severity but continued the use of idols. A large body of Marathi hymns are attributed to him, and a considerable number of Hindi hymns appear under his name in the Granth, the whole forming a mass of verse of very high quality. A careful comparison of the two groups would probably throw further light on the man and his life. He was influential in the Punjab as well as in the Maratha country, as is proved by his hymns in the Granth and by a shrine dedicated to his memory and still in use at Ghuman in the Gurdaspur district.7 Another Maratha singer, Trilochan by name, seems to have been a contemporary of Namdeva, but very little is known about him. Three of his Hindi hymns appear in the Granth, but his Marathi hymns, and even his memory, seem to be lost in his native land.

The next leader of eminence among the Maratha bhaktas is Eknath (died 1608), who was a Brahman and lived at Paithan. He is said to have spoken and acted in opposition to caste, and to have suffered for his zeal. But he has been most influential through his Marathi verse translations from the Bhagavata P.8 He left also a collection of twenty-six abhangs called Haripath. In philosophy he was a monist, like Mukundaraj and Jnanesvara.

Tukaram (1608-44) was a petty shopkeeper. He is passionately devoted to Vithoba, and his personal religious life is reflected with great vividness in his moving lines—his longing for God, his humility, his sense of unworthiness, his boundless need, his trust in God, and his appeals and prayers for help. It is his own religious life that occupies his soul; as in most forms of Hinduism, there are but few traces of the passion for winning others. His worship centres in the image of his god. He is conscious of Vithoba’s omnipresence, and his spirituality, and yet somehow the invisible God is identified with the adored image before which the worshipper bends. His hymns are of a very high order, and are probably the largest religious influence in the Maratha country. There is scarcely a theological or philosophical system to be found in his writings, but so far as philosophical thinking may be traced, he tends to be a monist. Sivaji, the man who welded the Maratha race into a strong people, rose to prominence in the last few years of Tukaram’s life, and he sent some of his councillors to beg him to come to court, but Tukaram sent him a few stanzas instead.

Narayana (1608-81), who later took the name of Ram Das, probably under the influence of the Ramanandi movement, was also a poet, but his verse has not laid hold of the people in the same way as Tukaram’s. Yet he exerted great personal influence over Sivaji from 1650 onwards. His poem, Dasabodha, contains much shrewd wisdom, but it is philosophical rather than religious. A small sect, the Ram-dasis still perpetuate his name, wear a sect-mark, and use a secret mantra of their own. The head-quarters are at Sajjangarh, near Satara, where there is the Samadh of Ram Das, a temple to Ram Chandra, and a Ram-dasi monastery. There are many sadhus belonging to the sect.

A Brahman poet, named Sridhara, rose to great fame and popularity during the first quarter of the eighteenth century. His leading works present in stirring Marathi verse the great stories of the Ramayana and the Mahabharata. His influence is not directly religious, except in so far as the stories he reproduces have a religious character.

Mahipati, who flourished later in the same century, gave his strength to writing the lives of devotees and saints.

§ 358. The Bhagavatas of the Marathi country to-day form a popular bhakti movement, the literature of which, apart from the Bhagavata P. itself and Sridhara’s commentary, is all in the vernacular. The god is Vitthal or Vithoba; both these names are merely local variations of Vishnu. The chief centres are Pandharpur, Alandi, and Dehu, but there are numerous shrines throughout the country. In the chief temple of Pandharpur Vitthal wears a curious sort of crown, which the priests say is Siva’s linga; so that the image, standing for both gods, is truly Bhagavata. Vitthal has several consorts installed near him, each in a separate shrine, Rakmabai (i.e. Rukmini), Radha, Satyabhama, and Lakshmi ; but it is noteworthy that Radha takes no place in Marathi literature. Mahadeva, Ganapati. and Surya are also installed ; so that, taking Lakshmi as devi, the five gods are still worshipped there. No Outcaste is admitted to Bhagavata temples in Maharashtra. Namdeva’s head, represented in brass, is placed on the lowest step of the stair which leads up to the gate of the temple; and the shrine of an Outcaste named Chokamela9 is on the opposite side of the street. Monthly and annual pilgrimages are made to the chief sacred places. The pilgrims are called Warkaris. Those who have made the pilgrimage a number of times are allowed to carry a red banner. As they march along, they shout ‘Dnyanoba, Tukaram’, and sing Abhangs. There are also hired singers called Haridasis, who sing Marathi Abhangs and portions of Eknath’s translations from the Bhagavata in the temple of Pandharpur.

One of the best institutions of the movement is called Harikatha, a sort of sermon in song which the leader opens by shouting aloud several times, Jai Rama-Krishna Hari. He then sings a number of hymns and other texts in verse, expounding each in prose. This method of mingled song and exhortation is found in the south also, where the singer is called Bhagavata and the musical sermon is called Kalakshepam.

§ 359. The bhakti movement in Gujarat remains Smarta in general character to the present day. The two chief temples are dedicated to Ranachor Rai, i.e. the king who left the fight, an allusion to the occasion on which, according to the mythology, Krishna left Mathura and came to Dwarka. These two great shrines are at Dwarka and at Daker near Ahmadabad. In both the ritual is still conducted in accordance with Vedic rules.

Contents

The Vallabhacharyas10

§ 372. Vallabha, or Vallabhacharya (1479-1531), a Brahman belonging to the Telugu country and a contemporary of Chaitanya,11 was born in Benares, the son of a member of the Vishnusvami sect. He received a Sanskrit education and wandered about for several years meeting scholars in disputation. Mention is specially made of his vanquishing Smarta scholars at the court of Krishnadeva of Vijayanagar (1509-29). The details of his life are by no means clear nor yet the influences that went to the making of his sect. His relation to the Vishnusvami sect especially requires to be cleared up. There need be no doubt, however, about the teaching of the sect; for there is abundance of literature; but it waits to be studied.

Vallabha called himself an incarnation of the god Agni. He acknowledged no human teacher but said he learnt his system direct from Krishna. Yet it seems absolutely clear that he took over from Nimbarka the theory of Krishna as the eternal Brahman, of Radha as his eternal spouse and of the highest heaven where they sport.

He calls his philosophic system Suddhadvaita, i.e. pure monism, but his monism is certainly not so rigid as Sankara’s. It is called pure monism in contrast with the ‘impure’ monism of Sankara, whose system includes the doctrine of maya and does not lay stress on bhakti. Vallabha acknowledges that men of knowledge may rise to release by means of knowledge, but his way is the way of bhakti. Bhakti is the means, but it is also the end; for bhakti is higher than knowledge ; and the true bhakta will live and sport for ever with Krishna. According to Vallabha, bhakti is given by God: it comes by his grace. The word for grace in the system is pushti. This use of the word is founded on a passage in the Bhagavata P.12 I am assured that the word pushti is never used in the literature as a name for Vallabha practice.

§ 373. The following is an outline of the theology of the sect. Krishna, who is Brahman—reality, intelligence, joy—alone exists. From him there go out, as sparks from fire, the material world, souls, and the antaryamin, or indwelling, god. In souls, which are atomic and identical with Brahman, the balance of the three gunas being upset, the attribute of joy is concealed ; so that they are seen to possess only reality and intelligence as attributes. Released souls rise to Krishna’s heaven, which is far above the heavens of Vishnu, Siva, and Brahma, and there, by the favour of Krishna-Brahman, they attain to the pure condition of his divine nature.

Krishna’s heaven is called Vyapi-Vaikuntha, and in it is a heavenly Vrindavana and glorious forests. From Krishna’s side springs Radha, and from the pores of the skin of Krishna and Radha come millions of gopas and gopis and also cattle and all the denizens of the woods. Krishna and Radha sport eternally in the celestial Vrindavana with their devotees. The loftiest aspiration of a Vallabha is to become a gopi and sport with Krishna in his heaven.

The cult is called seva, service of Krishna. There are eight times of worship daily in each temple.13 The mantra of the sect is Sri Krishna Saranam mama.

§ 374. One extraordinary peculiarity of this sect is the position held in it by Vallabha’s son Vitthalnatha and his descendants. No one can become a guru of the sect, or own one of the temples of the sect, except a descendant of Vitthalnatha in the male line. The pujaris in the temples are paid servants of the guru to whom the temple belongs. Along with this there goes the old Hindu doctrine that the guru is god. Since the faithful Vallabha who is devoted to Krishna ought to dedicate everything to Krishna, and since the guru is Krishna, the highest teaching of the sect leads the faithful bhakta to shower his wealth on his guru. This is the more significant since a large percentage of the rich business class of Western India belong to the sect. Originally, the title given to gurus was acharyas, teachers, but when they became wealthy, they began to live as princes; and since then they have been called Maharajas.

Each Maharaja lives in a house which is also a temple, and in it he has a reception-room next the room in which Krishna is worshipped. Since the guru is Krishna, he must be worshipped as Krishna. This worship is performed in the reception-room, and in many cases the worship of the guru is more elaborate and passionate than the worship of the god. The ritual and the liturgy remind the worshippers of the story of the gopis; and, whether they be men or women, they look forward to becoming gopis and sporting with Krishna in Goloka. In worshipping the Maharaja, women shower their devotion upon him as being actually Krishna, the darling of the gopis. Hence, when the Maharaja is a vicious man, they are in the utmost danger. There has been a great deal of immorality in certain cases. According to my informant, these abuses arose in the eighteenth century. He assures me that there is no basis for them in the literature.

§ 375. In certain cities societies have been formed among Vallabhas which meet from time to time in the Ras-mandali, or circle of holy sport. An equal number of men and women meet and take a meal together, after which there is promiscuous intercourse. The circle gets its name from Krishna’s dalliance (ras-lila) with the gopis, but its methods are copied from the chakra-puja of the left-hand Saktas.

The facts about the Maharajas and the Ras-mandali were made public in a suit for libel which was heard in Bombay in 1862. A full account of it is given in The Sect of the Maharajahs.

Another very remarkable fact in the history of the Vallabhas is the absorption of the Vishnusvami sect. There is no close connexion in doctrine. Vishnusvami’s philosophy is dualistic, and he regards Radha as a woman, Krishna’s mistress at Brindaban. Vallabha’s philosophy is monistic, and he holds Radha to be the eternal spouse of Krishna. Yet for a long time there has been a saying common in North India to the effect that the Vishnusvamis and the Vallabhas are the same, which is true only in the sense that, since most Vishnusvamis have entered the Vallabha fold, there is now no difference between them. The idea that the two sects are one can be traced back to the middle of the seventeenth century, and was probably one of many means employed by the Vallabhas in the process of absorbing the sect. It is usually said that Vallabhas reckon themselves as belonging to the Rudra Sampradaya along with the Vishnusvamis, but that is a mistake.

§ 376. Vallabha wrote a number of scholarly books in Sanskrit, both commentaries and original works, in exposition of his system. There are first three fundamental works :—the Vedanta-sutra-anubhashya, the Subodhini, which is a commentary on the Bhagavata P., and a manual of his doctrine in verse, the Tattva-dipa-nibandha, which is accompanied by a gloss in prose called Prakasa; and then seventeen short poems. The chief of these is the Siddhanta Rahasya, in which he tells how Krishna gave him his revelation. He left nothing in Hindi. Giridharaji and Balakrishna Bhatta are two early leaders whose Suddhadvaita-martanda and Prameyaratnarnava are systematic Sanskrit works of considerable value. Of more recent scholars Gosvami Sri Purushottamaji seems to be the most noteworthy. The Narada Pancharatra, the text of which was published in Calcutta a good many years ago, has thus far proved an enigma, and it will remain such until it is carefully read in the light of the history of the sects. From a superficial glance one might conjecture that it is an old Vaishnava Samhita interpolated or partly re-written, first by Vishnusvamis and then by Vallabhas.

Vallabha had four noteworthy disciples, and his son Vitthalnatha, who succeeded him, had also four; and all the eight lived in the Braj district, i.e. Mathura and Brindaban and the country round, and wrote religious poetry. They were called the Ashta Chhap, literally the Eight Seals, or die-stamps, producing genuine poetic coin. They used the local dialect of Hindi, which is called Braj.14 Hence, since their time all vernacular Krishnaite poetry has been written in Braj. Many other Vallabha singers followed them. By far the greatest of these lyric poets was Sur Das, the blind poet of Agra, who flourished seemingly in the latter half of the sixteenth century. He was a singer of wonderful power. Besides writing Radha-Krishna songs, he reproduced in beautiful verse a large number of episodes and passages from the Bhagavata P.

There was also a far less admirable Vallabha literature in Braj which laid a good deal of stress on the erotic side of the Krishna myths. Perhaps the most prominent are Gokul Nath’s Chaurasi Barta (1551), i.e. eighty-four tales, and the Braj Vilasa (1743) by Braj Basi Das, which is the popular authority for Radha’s life and loves. A long list of these books is given by Growse. Dayaram (1762-1852), one of the greatest of Gujarati poets, was a Vallabha. Much of his verse is erotic.

Contents

Kabir and the Sects Derived from Him

§ 396. Ramananda’s movement provided the Hindu influence which went to the making of Kabir (1440-1518), but Islam also contributed largely. It is possible, but it is not certain, that he was brought up by Muhammadans. It is plain, however, that the mystic Islam of the Sufis laid hold of him, whether he ever lived the Muhammadan life or not. Sufi mysticism has its roots in Muhammad’s experience and teaching, but the leading elements of the system came from two external sources. The first was Neoplatonism, which flowed into Islam through Greek philosophy, Gnosticism, Christian teaching, and Christian asceticism. The other source was Indian thought, but whether it reached the Sufis through Buddhism at a very early date, or through Vedantism later, is not yet clear. The Sufi conception of God tends to be immanental rather than transcendental. He works everywhere but especially in the human heart. It is possible for the humble soul which turns away from the things of sense to find Him, and see Him, and know Him. Many Sufis go so far as to identify self with God, like the thinkers of the Vedanta; and the state of bliss into which they hope to enter after death, called fana, lies very near Hindu thought. It is not quite absorption in God, for it is accompanied by everlasting life in God; yet individuality passes away. In order to reach illumination (gnosis) and union with God (called al-haqq, the Real, the True, sat), it is necessary to walk the path (tariqat), a way of life usually divided into stages. The spirit of this rule of life is to some extent ascetic, and many Sufis have been fakirs, but the great majority have been householders and have earned their bread by labour. The teacher, whether called Shaikh, Pir, or Murshid, has to be obeyed implicitly. The details of Sufi practice are not unlike the methods of Yoga, the purpose being to escape from one’s own individuality and, through illumination, to realize that God is the only reality. This temper of thought goes so far in many Sufis as to induce the idea that revelation and every organized religion belong to unreality. Hence all religions are of equal value, and a Sufi is no longer an orthodox Muslim.

Kabir, then, came into close touch with this system, but it does not seem possible to tell who the teachers were whom he met or which books he read. When the story of Islam in India is written in detail, it may be possible to realize more clearly the influences that went to form him. It seems probable that he lived from A.D. 1440 to 1518. He was a weaver and lived in Benares, and was probably brought up as a Muhammadan. But he became a disciple of Ramananda, and Hindu ideas poured into his mind. There can be no doubt of his relationship to the great leader; for he says in one of his poems, ‘Ramananda illumined me’15 He also mentions Rai Das, the Chamar, as a contemporary. He was brought before the Emperor Sikandar Lodi, who reigned from 1489 to 1517. The student can thus feel here that he is on the firm ground of history. The Emperor banished him from Benares, and he thereafter lived a wandering life, and died at Maghar near Gorakhpur.

§ 397. In the life of Kabir the two religions mingled. The strongest elements of each laid hold of him and formed his thought, the Sufi conviction that all ordinary religions are but forms dictating his general attitude to the two faiths. Hence he was persecuted from both sides, and the Emperor banished him from the centre of Hinduism in the interests of peace. The groundwork of his system of beliefs is Hindu ; for he accepts transmigration and karma, and thus stands within the circle of Indian rather than Islamic thought. A further catalogue of Hindu ideas might be compiled—Brahman, maya, lila, release, detachment, cessation from work, ‘He is I’, the bhedabheda relation, &c.—but most of these coincide or almost coincide with Sufi conceptions ; so that a number of them may be regarded as common ground. On the other hand, he denounces idolatry as foolish, false, and wrong, declares divine incarnation impossible and laughs at the forms of asceticism as silly practices: here Islam rules. Sir George Grierson believes that Christian influence also may be traced in his teaching.16

He was a strict theist, calling God Ram, but recognizing no consort, incarnation, or other divine attendant. He sees God both in nature and in man, and realizes the close relationship between God and man, declaring that man is the same as God and yet distinct from him. His verses refer to God in many shining phrases which touch both the heart and the spirit. The love of God for man finds clear and strong expression in his lines, and he constantly speaks of the rest and peace there is for the man who realizes that love, and the detachment from the things of the world which it brings.

§ 398. Kabir’s poetry is in Hindi,17 and is blunt, unpolished, sometimes even coarse. There is little attempt made to reach literary form. He does not care whether his words are Hindi, Persian, or barbarous, nor whether his sentences are grammatical or not, so long as they strike home. Tagore’s beautiful renderings scarcely reflect the style of the original, though they are not unfaithful as translations. But he was a mystic of great penetration and a poet of considerable power. His best utterances are probably the loftiest work in the Hindi language ; and hundreds of his couplets have laid hold of the common heart of Hindustan.

Large masses of poetry are ascribed to him, but until the whole has been examined critically, it is impossible to tell how much is genuine. About the year 1570 the Bijak, a collection of short poems and utterances, was compiled by one of his followers. Some thirty years later a large number of his hymns and sayings were included in the Sikh Granth.

Besides these, innumerable couplets and witty sayings are currently ascribed to him, and the Kabirpanthis have a considerable literature, much of which they say came from the master, but which, in the main, is clearly of later date.

§ 399. The following is a list of the chief sects which have sprung from his teaching and influence:

1. Kabirpanthis; founder Kabir; about 1470; Benares
2. Sikhs; founder Nanak; 1500; Punjab
3. Dadupanthis; founder Dadu; 1575; Rajputana
4. Lal Dasis; founder Lal Das; 1600; Alwar
5. Satnamis; (founder not given); 1600; Narnol, south of Delhi
6. Baba Lalis; founder Baba Lal; 1625; Dehanpur, near Sirhind
7. Sadhs; founder Birbhan; 1658; near Delhi
8. Charan Dasis; founder Charan Das; 1730; Delhi
9. Siva Narayanis; founder Siva Narayana; 1734; Chandrawar, Ghazipur
10. Garib Dasis; founder Garib Das; 1740; Chudani, Rohtak
11. Ram Sanehis; founder Ram Charan; 1750; Shahapur, Rajputana

A number of common features are traceable in all these groups at the time of their foundation, but the Hinduism which surrounds them presses heavily on them and finds entrance at many points, so that most of the distinctive features tend to become progressively weaker. Four characteristics seem to have been common to them all:

1. God alone is worshipped and idolatry is strictly prohibited: so that Hindu worship is completely abandoned ; and men of any caste may exercise religious functions.

2. The sect is open to all Hindus and to Muslims also.

3. Great stress is laid on the value of the guru.

4. The literature is in vernacular verse.

There were many other ideas which were accepted by all or nearly all at first, but they were not so rigidly held, e.g. the value of the repetition of the name, Ram, the denial of the doctrine of divine incarnation, the rejection of asceticism and begging, and the prohibition of the use of flesh as food, of intoxicating drink and of tobacco. In a few cases infanticide and widow-burning were prohibited. The drift towards Hinduism, however, soon brings in the doctrine of divine incarnation, the worship of gurus, and the formation of an order of Sadhus, who become the divine gurus of the sect ; the rules against flesh, wine, and tobacco are gradually relaxed; the sect tends to become restricted to the clean castes; Hindu mythology, especially the story of Radha, creeps in; and finally idols reappear. In one case obscene rites find an entrance at an early date.

Notes

  1. I am deeply indebted to Mr. R. Narasimhachar, Director of Archaeological Research in Mysore, who, at my request, wrote to Talkad for information with regard to the age of the bhashya, and elicited the facts stated in this sentence.
  2. See § 277.
  3. See § 161.
  4. VS. 92.
  5. SBS. II. 26.
  6. Macnicol, PMS. 41.
  7. Macauliffe, VI. 39.
  8. Parts of these are sung in Sankirtan in the temple at Pandharpur.
  9. He was a Mahar. His poetry survives, and parts of it are very fine.
  10. I have received much help in the understanding of this community from Pandit Magan Lal Sastri of Broach and Poona, who is a sincere Vallabha and also a competent scholar.
  11. But he was not his father-in-law: the two men had the same name, but that is all the basis the story has.
  12. II. x. 4. The lila in Book VI is called Poshana.
  13. Wilson, Works, I. 126 ff.
  14. Grierson, L.H. 20.
  15. Tagore, One Hundred Poems of Kabir, 36.
  16. JRAS. 1918, 156.
  17. The dialect is ‘old Awadhi, the language spoken in West Mirzapur, Allahabad and Audh’, Sir George Grierson, JRAS. 1918, 152.

Contents


Source

J. N. Farquhar, M.A., D.Litt., Oxon., An Outline of the Religious Literature of India. The Religious Quest of India series. London, Edinburgh, Glasgow, New York, Toronto, Melbourne, Cape Town and Bombay: Humphrey Milford, Oxford University Press, 1920. Printed pages 297–302, 312–317 and 331–335. This article is from public domain digital sources.

Disclaimer

We have made every effort to reproduce this text faithfully, but we cannot guarantee that it is free of errors. Readers who need accuracy for study or citation should check the original publication. The views and language are those of the author and his time, and e-Scriptures is not responsible for them.

Spelling and style follow the original; obvious scanning and typographical errors have been corrected. This text is believed to be in the public domain in the United States, where this website is operated. Copyright terms differ from country to country, so a text that is free of copyright in the United States may still be protected elsewhere. Readers outside the United States should check the copyright laws of their country before copying, downloading or reusing it; they are responsible for lawful use in their own country. See our Terms of Use.

The author was a Christian missionary writing in a series for Christian readers, and writes of Indian religion from that standpoint, in the language of his time.

Our books

Translate This Page

Search This Site